I think a good type of treatment for this would be body cameras and mikes which a therapist could review with a patient and provide them with rational explanations.
Significantly, it's often the doctors who are believed to be behind the surveillance. So I think your proposal is unlikely to work.
With that being said, I've known a fair number of varying degrees of paranoid people.
I suspect this tactic would oftentimes just play into, indulge, and validate their paranoia.
Though you've been downvoted, the structure of your seemingly casual observation is validated by some of the most renown psychoanalytic and philosophical thinkers of the 20th and 21st centuries. (In the US, psychoanalysis is largely repudiated as a therapeutic pathway for severe mental illness such as paranoid schizophrenia. However, philosophy and psychoanalytic thinking can provide occasionally valuable insights into the nature of human psychology, each capable of being productive and provocative in equal measure.)
In _Jacques Lacan's Four Discourses_ (Lacan has been referred to as the "French Freud"), Slavoj Zizek asks readers to
> Recall, again, Lacan's outrageous statements that, even if what a jealous husband claims about his wife (that she sleeps around with other men) is all true, his jealousy is still pathological. [0]
This is probably a misattribution by Zizek (or a conflation) since Sigmund Freud makes the comparison in the _Standard Edition_ (XVIII, 226).
> Freud suggests that a jealous husband who is obsessed with the idea that his wife is cheating on him can be described as paranoid even if it turns out that his wife is cheating on him. [1]
Without question, the priapic over-concern with the possibility of spousal infidelity is characteristic of masculinist psychoanalytic discourse. However, the kernel of truth in this is that one's internal representation is separate from reality, however closely the two may match. In other words, paranoia is pathological (belief in gang-stalking) even if it is matched by a dysfunctional reality (CIA surveillance) and this can be seen in the opposite case of a naive subject who neither suspects nor fears being surveilled despite being surveilled in reality (e.g. a psychologically healthy subject who is targeted by state surveillance).
In short, paranoid fantasies may in fact be matched by reality, but that does not make the paranoid fantasies any less paranoid. Conversely, blissful ignorance may be contradicted by reality, but that does not necessarily make the subject any less blissful.
(As a bonus, the paragraph from which the Zizek quote is drawn continues in its next sentence to explain how anti-Semitism draws upon psychopathological thinking to validate its ideological end. In other words, anti-Semitism for Zizek is structurally/phenomenologically identical to paranoia.)
[0] http://www.lacan.com/zizfour.htm
[1] http://bit.ly/1WKHjQ7 (I hope links using URL shorteners are not contra HN etiquette.)
EDIT: Spelling.
Something similar can be seen in depression. I've gone through multiple periods of depression, and I noticed quite a difference in quality between them. While it can probably not be generalized, I noticed that the stronger, more vivid and often shorter periods of depression often least matched reality in hindsight, whereas the dragging, nagging, longer periods of depression often felt justified even in hindsight. Even now, for example, I don't feel that my perspective has fundamentally changed since my last long period of depression; I just don't feel bad about it.
The fact that I felt bad about a situation that other people don't feel bad about was what made me 'someone dealing with depression', not the objective facts of my life.
Realizing this, combined with buddhist thought and practice, has made it easier for me to deal with depression, social anxiety (which often includes quite a bit of paranoia), and my changing moods in general.
That just means the therapist has been got to and is now One of Them.
These claims seem like they would be pretty easy to verify with some recording equipment.
However, they can be very reassuring after an episode has subsided.
The person recording clearly believes he's captured evidence of spys tracking him, yet the footage seems to show an ordinary trip to the subway with fellow pedestrians minding their own business. And there seem to be many other videos along those same lines.
I was thinking of some of the more testable claims made in the article. For instance, the person who claimed that their behavior was being mimicked.
Believing your mind is playing tricks on you is really the last ditch effort at rationalizing something for most people. They don't come to that conclusion easily without some sort of history or practice doing so.
I used to howl at the early SNL -- well, when they were "on"; individual skits were always hit and miss. Over subsequent "generations", it came to the point where I could no longer watch it.
I've ended up feeling similar about a significant portion of mainstream "comedy" films.
Eventually, I realized: It used to be, even when the portrayals were sometimes a bit vicious, that we, the audience, guided by the writers and actors, were laughing with them.
That changed: Now, much of comedy is taking grossly stereotypical portrayals and laughing at them.
Laughing with, we acknowledge our... weaknesses, flaws, strengths, human-ness, and bond through shared laughter over them. Defuse the discomfort and tension.
Laughing at, we define and separate into groups: "Us" versus "them". And those laughing, as the "us", bond through the process of excluding the "them".
Society's never been easy. But this part of it -- emblematic, for me -- has turned into a nastier place, in the U.S. media.
[1] http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=26b_1315119865
[2] http://ultimateclassicrock.com/joe-cocker-john-belushi/
[3] http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/tv/showtracker/la-et-st...
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/27/us/politics/donald-trump-s...
It's renewed my faith in comedy.
Edit:I was thinking of the Murray/Belushi days and don't know why I thought Farley was around the same time
I can imagine kids online would eat these folks up without realizing what they're doing.
Do mental health professionals recommend that paranoid people take breaks from the internet?
I like to debate online. I try to do it in the most respectful way possible. After reading this story, I imagine that a paranoid person could perceive disagreement as an attack.
Food for thought for me. Thanks for sharing your experience.
I find it odd and a bit ironic that the moment we identify someone who could benefit most from something like mindfulness can be a time when they're most likely to reject it. Perhaps this is the struggle of psychology and education in a nutshell. It's most useful when the student seeks it out.
There is no "social contract" anymore. So yeah, every poor bastard for themself.
We have to get over our need to punish, and start to count the dollars, realize that they can improve and save lives, and start rehabilitating. We can't do that when we have pathological cases mixed in with petty criminals, passionate "one-timers" and the like.
By the same token, we can't stop mass shootings when our standard treatment for schizophrenics without money is, "Find a nice streetcorner buddy." Most will die miserably, but of course a few will snap.
From my own personal observations, I am certain these drugs do a lot of damage.
I've managed to get my girlfriend stabilized with supplements and some safe drugs, and got her into a smaller system to manage her court-ordered treatment. Her new court-ordered psychiatric nurse initially wanted to keep her on the antipsychotic injection, but there was a bureaucratic snafu (pre-authorization) and the injection wore off. After the drugs had lapsed for a month, the psychiatric nurse decided that it wasn't actually necessary.
Robert Whitaker, author of Anatomy of an Epidemic, [1] has looked into the practices of the mental health industry, and makes the case that the standard treatments make people's mental health worse.
It seems pretty obvious that they hurt more than they help, but for many people, the alternative to a lifetime of constant, horrible spiritual anaesthesia is occasional bouts of explosive delusions which lead to behavior that's dangerous to the patient and to others.
Which would you chose?
The reality is a lot more complicated. For some people these drugs help. For others it makes things worse. For yet others it's somewhere in between. And measuring the results accurately is incredibly difficult due to the difficulty of objectively determining someone else's cognitive state. Which is difficult enough even when it's something comparatively straightforward, when there are layers of mental illness, trauma, and complex drug interactions at play it becomes a herculean effort. And one that the medical establishment generally lacks the resources and commitment to follow through on. Some people are lucky enough to have loved ones or family members around who can accurately judge what's "normal" and what isn't in someone else's behavior and also put in the effort to find what treatments help or not and maybe shepherd someone to improved health. Many other people only have a few minutes spent on their care and most of their treatment comes out of a generic manual which might as well be a flow chart of "if X prescribe Y". This isn't helped by the widespread stigma, misunderstanding, and misinformation about mental illness that permeates society.
Right now our approach to these issues is like trying to tune a malfunctioning jet engine without any knowledge of how it works and experimenting via trial and error by dumping liquid oxygen or coal dust into the intake. The fact that some people are helped leads us to the incorrect conclusion that we actually know what we're doing instead of just occasionally getting incredibly lucky.
That's a good analogy.
I was talking to someone recently, and realized that the "antipsychotics" are essentially speed-governors for people. It's better to fix the actual problem with a car than arbitrarily limiting its top speed. Another analogy is that these drugs are like under-clocking your CPU so it doesn't overheat, instead of replacing the broken fan.
My girlfriend screwed up her brain's metabolism by self-treating her depression with alcohol and stimulants. When the alcohol went away, she became rather psychotic. Her mother (whom she was living with) called the crisis team, and the hospital didn't help things by treating her with antipsychotics, when they should have used coconut oil, nutritional supplements and some of the more useful prescriptions.
My observation is that the practitioners who treated my girlfriend weren't concerned about the behaviors that created the condition (self-medicating depression with alcohol & the street pharmacy), they just prescribed medication in the hope that it would help with the presenting symptom ("psychosis").
She'd stabilize after a few weeks in the mental hospital. When released, she would resume her efforts to treat her own depression, and would shortly end up back in the mental hospital.
My girlfriend got much better when I obtained the supplements and safe drugs that help with the actual causes of her mental exhaustion.
But I don't have her on lockdown, and I can't force her to consistently take what clearly benefits her, nor keep her away from the professionals' bad prescriptions (SSRI's and benzodiazepines) that create more problems for her.
However, having bipolar can cause a susceptibility to psychotic incidents and requires different treatments than depression.
Anyway, it seems like much of the medical establishment is still in a very archaic mindset when it comes to treating mental illnesses that involve the potential for violence. Actual quality of life is irrelevant as long as you reduce the likelihood of someone getting physically hurt in the future. Meanwhile, we still use incredibly antiquated drugs like thorazine which are questionably effective and have a mind-numbing list of side effects. Yet the drug companies don't do a whole lot of research on efficacy, safety, or on new drugs because there just isn't much money in it.
All her psychotic incidents were self-induced with substances. Whatever label gets applied, I suspect one of the root causes of her condition is a dysfunctional pituitary gland. This should be easily treatable, but none of the professionals care.
> Meanwhile, we still use incredibly antiquated drugs like thorazine which are questionably effective and have a mind-numbing list of side effects.
Indeed, "mind-numbing" is certainly on the all these drugs' lists of side effects.
> Yet the drug companies don't do a whole lot of research on efficacy, safety, or on new drugs because there just isn't much money in it.
The newest "antipsychotics" are rather expensive, and one of the best-selling drugs in the world right now is Abilify. There is no financial incentive to research using nutrients and old generic drugs to eliminate the conditions that give rise to psychiatric symptoms.
That's what made me think of bipolar, because that's a thing that happens, there's a greater susceptibility to certain triggers.
Also where the money is as well (vs. Psychiatry).
Please remember that these kinds of communities have sprung up in the context of the ongoing stigma of mental illness, and the limitations of present medications for psychosis (most have unpleasant side-effects). Other contributors are a mistrust of authority, and the always-complicated balance between individual liberties and involuntary treatment.
Finally, a plea for some compassion. Many of these people live a deeply tormented life, and feel like they can't trust anyone. It's a hard existence for both them and their families. It might seem like a humorous phenomenon, but there's a lot of suffering here.