News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Grain of Salt by hbhakhra on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:39AM (#11874814)
"Recently, a Model S was in a very high speed accident in Germany that caused it to fly 82 feet through the air, an event that would likely be fatal in vehicles not designed to the level of safety of a Tesla. All five occupants were able to exit the vehicle under their own power and had no life-threatening injuries."

That is a pretty impressive feat for a car. Also, the voluntary recalls are an interesting case because to me they did something positive in doing a recall before any injury happened. When the news of the recall broke though, people were complaining about the recalls. Part of the problem is that any announcement by Tesla makes the news round while a similar recall by Toyota or anther company, that would affect many more people, wouldn't get a tenth of the attention.

Re:A Grain of Salt by zubspace on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:01AM (#11874921)
Recent discussion regarding the german accident with pictures in the submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11650967

The cabin looks still intact and the outcome would would probably be different, if there was an engine in the front of the car. Still I believe those 5 peoples were very, very lucky. In my opinion this is just PR. You'd probably find examples like this for all car manufacturers.

Re:A Grain of Salt by Vik1ng on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:32AM (#11875041)
Re:A Grain of Salt by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:40AM (#11875249)
> dog in the backseat

Now that is impressive. The safety systems are all designed for humans and yet a dog in the backseat, who could probably not be properly secured, survived.

Re:A Grain of Salt by Xylakant on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:40AM (#11875642)
A dog can be fairly well secured on the backseat. A proper harness and a short leash that clips gets attached to the seat belt works perfectly fine.
Re:A Grain of Salt by hangonhn on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:01PM (#11879021)
Actually, not really. Subaru sponsored tests on these harnesses, and nearly all of them failed, except for one:

http://www.sosubaru.com/dog-safety-harness.htm

Dog safety harnesses don't get anywhere near the scrutiny seat belts do.

Re:A Grain of Salt by dwyerm on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:17PM (#11880554)
This looks like thinly veiled marketing, preying on the unreasonable lengths that dog owners will go through and the expenses they will incur for their animals...

...and yet I see those little dog test-dummies and I want to shove money through my screen despite the fact that I don't even own a dog.

Humans are silly...

Re:A Grain of Salt by outworlder on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:37AM (#11877111)
We do this whenever our dog is in the car. This is nowhere near as good as what we have for human passengers. One of the reasons is that dogs hate to be restrained. So there's a leash. In case of a frontal collision, this would prevent her from flying out of the window.

In the case of the car itself flying, and possibly tumbling on impact, I don't think the odds would be that good, as the dog would likely impact against hard surfaces. Or other passengers. That's maybe the least of the problems though, if the car's structural integrity is compromised...

Re:A Grain of Salt by wldcordeiro on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:50PM (#11877730)
Yeah, plus the leash (if it's a neck one especially) could end up causing harm to the dog.
Re:A Grain of Salt by outworlder on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:55PM (#11881150)
oh yes, please don't ever restrain a dog with a neck leash in a car. It's better to have the dog fly off the car and take their chances, than to risk a broken neck.

I bought a new harness, with the largest contact area I could find, specifically for car usage.

Re:A Grain of Salt by nerfhammer on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:18PM (#11879664)
How big was the dog?

Serious question. Smaller animals have less momentum and are more robust to a large deceleration.

Re:A Grain of Salt by PinguTS on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:36AM (#11875437)
Sorry, but this part of the blog article is completely PR BS.

This car was speeding but not "very high speed". The car crashed into a field. This is flat. Every other comparable car like Mercedes E class, Audi A6, Volvo S60, … would have provided the same level of safety.

Here the original reporting with images: http://www.tz.de/muenchen/region/schwerer-unfall-icking-18-j...

Re:A Grain of Salt by mkesper on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:10AM (#11875537)
The last image here shows why this car flew: http://electrek.co/2016/05/06/tesla-model-s-crash-large-crum...
Re:A Grain of Salt by eridius on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:47PM (#11878878)
Yes, into a field. From the air. It literally flew through the air and crashed down onto the ground. Doesn't matter that it was a field, the ground is still the ground, and if there was an engine in the car the passengers probably would have been killed. But you make it sounds like it merely drove off the road and into a field.
Re:A Grain of Salt by Mchl on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:36AM (#11875630)
What exactly is the difference between 'speeding' and 'very high speed'?
Re:A Grain of Salt by PinguTS on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:05AM (#11875748)
Speeding = you are to fast according to the allowed speed

High speed = anything above 130 km/h (about 80 mph; because that is the recommend speed on an Autobahn)

Very high speed = anything above 250 km/h (about 155 mph; because that is where normally the limiter kicks in)

Just, yesterday morning I drove my self at about 200 km/h (124 mph) because I was in hurry, because I had some unexpected road-construction work before.

This was an 18 year old girl, who just had her driving license (18 is the minimum legal age for driving here in Germany; 17 with governed driving by an adult)

Here an comparable accident who lifted for 40m (131ft) and crashed in a field with some rollover and it does not look that different from that Tesla accident: http://www.swp.de/heidenheim/lokales/polizeibericht/Auto-lan...

BTW: Are there any international news on how the safety cell of this BMW protected this 51 year old guy?

Re:A Grain of Salt by sambe on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:58AM (#11876010)
The gap between speeding and high speed is only 10mph or so but very high speed is nearly double? I don't think that's a reasonable definition. Most people rarely or never go over about 110ish? That would be my definition of very high speed. Even on the Autobahn - where presumably there are sections where a greater proportion of the population have done higher speeds - the rest of the world's perception and the kinetic energy doesn't decrease.
Re:A Grain of Salt by true_religion on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:33PM (#11878756)
It's not an ordered system where speeding < high speed < very high speed.

You can be going at high speed, but not speeding because you are not breaking any law about going 'too fast'.

On the other hand, you can be speeding at 20mph because you are inside a public garage and the limit was actually 5mph.

Re:A Grain of Salt by clamprecht on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:51AM (#11875977)
How would you classify Formula 1 cars' speeds? (320 km/h or 200 mph)
Re:A Grain of Salt by MikeTLive on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:49AM (#11877219)
plaid?
Re:A Grain of Salt by extropy on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:09AM (#11876078)
Racing speed?
Re:A Grain of Salt by darklajid on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:35AM (#11876627)
According to the pictures / reports this car was driving on a normal road, not the Autobahn.

Outside of cities you're limited to 100km/h (or less ofc - but 100km/h is the maximum you'll get if we ignore rare cases with 4+ lane roads and a solid barrier in the middle → 120km/h). Speeding means that you drive reckless and/or cross the (low-ish) legal limit and/or the limit that common sense dictates.

"Very high speeds" over here refer to the Autobahn and I'd be quite hesitant to label anything below 180km/h as "very high speed".

Just so that you can chuckle a bit: My company car (A3 SportBack quattro 2.0, 110kw) was returned this week. Due to rather .. special circumstances I'm currently driving a Toyota Prius Plugin Hybrid instead. I reached 190km/h on todays morning commute a couple of times (late, after most commuters - very low traffic).

Re:A Grain of Salt by jnky on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:54AM (#11876767)
> Outside of cities you're limited to 100km/h (or less ofc - but 100km/h is the maximum you'll get if we ignore rare cases with 4+ lane roads and a solid barrier in the middle 120km/h

That's not quite correct. The speed limit is generally 100 km/h outside of cities, except when there are either two lanes (or more) per direction and a line between the two different directions or if there are less than two lanes per direction, but there is a sold barrier between them. In those cases there is no speed limit, just like on the Autobahn.

Re:A Grain of Salt by darklajid on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:26AM (#11877030)
Thanks a lot. I learned something new today, after driving for nearly 20 years. That was suprising..

That said: The road in question certainly wasn't one of these - it looks like a random road between tiny "cities" (villages?). So 100km/h or less seems quite right here.

Re:A Grain of Salt by thomersch_ on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:51AM (#11875686)
In Germany those two things are distinct. 250 km/h is very high speed but not necessarily speeding.
Re:A Grain of Salt by Too on Saturday June 11, 2016 @04:50AM (#11882710)
Here is a video of a similar crash, probably not driving as fast but still doesn't look very dramatic too me. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KqIZiASGa0g
Re:A Grain of Salt by frostymarvelous on Saturday June 11, 2016 @08:14AM (#11883176)
I doubt it's claiming Tesla cars are safer than every other car. It was just to highlight that their cars are very safe.

How is that PR BS when it actually happened?

Re:A Grain of Salt by FreeFull on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:49AM (#11874856)
One thing that helps Tesla cars out in comparison to most other cars is that there is no engine in the front, so it's all just a huge crumple zone.
Re:A Grain of Salt by creshal on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:07AM (#11875147)
Why? Motors can be part of a crumple zone, too. Look at e.g. the Smart – its engine gets pulverized in heavier crashes, and absorbs lots of the impact energy.
Re:A Grain of Salt by zelos on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:35AM (#11875237)
Presumably there are mechanical (heat, pressure, shock etc.) limits to how you build an engine that limit what you can do to improve safety? As light and small as modern engines are, they're still a big lump of iron/steel/aluminium.
Re:A Grain of Salt by creshal on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:11AM (#11875353)
Sure, but how is an empty space better at absorbing impact energy than that?
Re:A Grain of Salt by codeduck on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:40AM (#11875444)
Placing an engine in that empty space means that there is less space available for the car's crumple zones to deform before the engine intrudes into the passenger safety cell.

A tesla can have its entire front concertina'd down to nothing without anything entering the safety cell. A front-engined normal car cannot do this; typically 50 to 60% of the length of the front of the car is engine. While external parts of the engine may crumple, the cylinder head and main section of the engine by necessity need to be milled from solid metal; These will not crumple, they will be pushed into the safety cell if the collision is energetic enough.

Re:A Grain of Salt by ssmoot on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:21AM (#11875831)
In addition to the engine going under the vehicle (even at fairly low speed crashes; just watch NHSTA videos on YouTube), the front motor in a Model S is more dense and weighs about the same as a 4 cylinder engine, transmission and accessories. I'm gonna call that a wash until I see evidence to the contrary.

Straight on collisions aren't even the toughest ones to pass. It's the small offset tests that really seem to give manufacturers a hard time. And no engine there.

Re:A Grain of Salt by jacquesm on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:04AM (#11875516)
In modern cars the design is such that the engine is pushed under the car if there is enough energy in the collision.
Re:A Grain of Salt by agumonkey on Friday June 10, 2016 @07:30AM (#11875604)
Well the engine doesn't compress smoothly, it mostly translates into the cabin with high probability of partially crushing the people on the front seat. I believe Tesla layout just makes it 'easy' to let the frame dissipate energy internally by bending much more than any other ICE based cars.
Re:A Grain of Salt by slaxman on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:56AM (#11875494)
You want the front of the car to absrob the energy. When it crumples, it absorbs the energry and lesser energy is transferred to the passengers. The Engine is tough and will not crumple. It will thus not absorb the energy but transfer it to the passengers.
Re:A Grain of Salt by ssmoot on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:18PM (#11879665)
So I just checked out some crash videos on YouTube. The Model S appears to have a surprisingly small crumple zone.

That's just my layman's perspective, but take a look and see if you don't agree. The front readily collapses, but just past the center-point of the wheels (presumably about where the motor area starts) it's a brick wall and the whole 2+ ton vehicle just stops in it's tracks.

Compare that to Volvo crash tests, especially the Euro NCAP Small Offset. The front fender of the Volvo disintegrates, but then the wheel actually flys off and the front of the cabin even appears to absorb some energy. It looks like a much softer landing. The interior shots are even more impressive with less deformation and a lot more padding with a lot less slack in the airbags.

Taking a look at the XC90, it's probably no surprise then that it achieves significantly higher ratings, despite having a 4-cylinder ICE in the engine bay. (see http://www.euroncap.com/en/results/volvo/xc90/20976 and http://www.euroncap.com/en/results/tesla/model-s/7897)

I didn't run across any Model S tests where it looked like that long hood was actually doing much for it since it appears to hit some sort of impenetrably stiff wall halfway through. You can look at the crash test video during a Musk demonstration and see the same thing. There's some sort of structural member there in front of the motor that just doesn't seem to give way.

BTW, it actually appears the Honda Accord mentioned is slightly safer (except for pedestrians) despite the tested model being 5 years older.

The Model S is no doubt a very safe vehicle overall. But it's not the second coming, and Musk's talk of crumple zones appears to be more Marketing than Truth (and the ratings bear that out).

That "Tesla Model S breaks roof test" for example? Not the strongest. Not even at the time of testing. Here's the current generation XC90's results for example: http://www.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/vehicle/v/volvo/xc90-4-door.... Over 10 tons. The previous generation was off about a ton. As far as I can figure out both figures are greater than the Model S's despite the fan-faire.

Re:A Grain of Salt by creshal on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:57AM (#11875498)
And as I already mentioned before, this is simply not true, you can make engines that crumple extremely well.
Re:A Grain of Salt by robbiemitchell on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:48AM (#11876279)
It might be possible, but is it common? Is a Honda Accord going to crumple politely?
Re:A Grain of Salt by CompelTechnic on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:11AM (#11875780)
Could you provide some evidence/ examples?
Re:A Grain of Salt by creshal on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:41AM (#11875932)
https://youtu.be/mnI-LiKCtuE?t=265

Seems I remembered it the wrong way round – it was the Corsa that held up and crumpled well enough to not have significant intrusion even at 110 km/h (70 mph).

Re:A Grain of Salt by jads on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:25PM (#11878037)
This isn't really evidence that it's possible to make an engine that can crumple. In fact, quite the opposite.

This particular Corsa B (93-2000) was a 1.4i (1.4L engine) - the physical dimensions of the engine are extremely small[1], and there is a lot of empty space in the engine bay that isn't taken up by the main engine block (excluding various plastics, wiring, etc - actual metal). I don't think it's so much the case that this engine "could crumple", rather that there was a lot of space for the front to crumple into, before there was none left and the engine was then pushed into the cabin.

Engine blocks are, well, blocks of metal. They're not going to crumple in any meaningful way.

[1]: http://iheartautos.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/engine-b...

Re:A Grain of Salt by jsight on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:55AM (#11876782)
There was no engine in the front of that car.
Re:A Grain of Salt by varjag on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:17PM (#11880549)
This is untrue. ICEs are designed to be dimensionally stable and withstand a lot of mechanical stress due to operation.
Re:A Grain of Salt by specialist on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:19AM (#11876963)
Re:A Grain of Salt by DanBC on Friday June 10, 2016 @06:41AM (#11875446)
When empty space gets pushed into the cabin it doesn't amputate legs. When an engine gets pushed into the cabin it might amputate legs.
Re:A Grain of Salt by kerryfalk on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:09AM (#11876080)
This isn't what happens, though. As others have mentioned, the engine ends up under the car.
Re:A Grain of Salt by whyenot on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:22AM (#11876147)
The engine in a Smart is in back, behind the occupants. In general, the most important crumple zone of a car is in the front.
Re:A Grain of Salt by brohee on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:44AM (#11876672)
The motor is behind the driver on a Smart car...
Re:A Grain of Salt by awesomerobot on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:18AM (#11876506)
Yes, but it's just generally the laws of physics. If you have 600lbs of metal in front of you there's a lot more energy that has to go somewhere (the cabin).
Re:A Grain of Salt by Too on Saturday June 11, 2016 @05:05AM (#11882749)
Having weight in front of you will help to push away the object you are colliding with, rather than having the same weight under you or behind you. That inertial energy is not relevant to what enters the cabin.
Re:A Grain of Salt by awesomerobot on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @07:30AM (#11901248)
The forward inertia of the engine isn't the problem if you're hitting a wall (though it is in a head-on collision), the cabin area is much squishier than an engine — so if the car is stopped from the front fast enough the cabin will enter the engine. More crumple zone and less engine is better for the inertia behind the engine (the passengers).
Re:A Grain of Salt by tempestn on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:19PM (#11879673)
Or, (under the car).
Re:A Grain of Salt by pedrocr on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:00AM (#11874914)
The four wheel drive models do have an electric motor in the front as well but since it's small most of that benefit should still be there.
Re:A Grain of Salt by hermannj314 on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:51PM (#11879475)
I enjoy the irony of using an anecdote to imply something meaningful about a car's safety in the same article that decries the use of an anecdote to imply something meaningful about a car's quality.

In total, a good response from Tesla.

Re:A Grain of Salt by narag on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:12PM (#11877419)
That is a pretty impressive feat for a car

Long ago I was a passenger in a similar accident with a VW Golf that looked very much like this one after the dance. We walked out, just a little scratched and a lot scared.

The jump distance itself is not impressive, I've seen longer without consecuence.