News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Nokinside on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:48AM (#11868982)
Helicopters and small planes already exist. We might have autonomous helicopters and small planes in the future, but flying car concept is flawed and not because it's hard to build one.

- Preflight checks and flight safety. Larry should first build normal small aircraft that can do without constant manual checks before flight. This is actually good subgoal to work with even without flying cars in mind. Reliable infrastructure that checks and calibrates instruments so reliably that you don't need manual checks would be revolution in aerospace. Just walking from your car into your future Cessna-Android and flying off would be sci-fi for aviators.

- Energy consumption. No matter how energy efficient the engines are, hovering and short takeoffs use lots of energy. Flying with small wings with little lift is equivalent to driving monster trucks in full power. You don't want flying becoming everyday phenomenon until we have abundance of carbon free energy.

- Noise and safety regulations, aviation regulations over urban areas. Flying cars are not happening in the suburbs or anyone where lots of people live. In the meantime try to get new helicopter landing sites approved in your neighborhood. If you have to take car to your flying car hangar, just have a small plane instead. Or walk to a buss station.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by outworlder on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:49AM (#11870177)
> Preflight checks and flight safety. Larry should first build normal small aircraft that can do without constant manual checks before flight.

Omg, this. The amount of checks required for any sort of aircraft is ridiculous. A lot of it involves button pushing and checking status. This could be automated.

For instance, for a cessna 150:

STARTING ENGINE Mixture – RICH Carb heat – COLD Prime – AS REQUIRED Master switch -- ON Beacon Light – ON Throttle – OPEN 1/8” Prop Area – CLEAR Ignition – START Oil Pressure – CHK Radio – ON/SET Transponder – ON / STBY Wing Flaps – UP Mixture – LEAN 1 INCH READY TO TAXI

Most of these things could be set automatically.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by handedness on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:08PM (#11870712)
The examples you gave take no more than 30 seconds. Sure, FADEC can eliminate most of them, but they're quick.

Other examples–checking the oil, the tank sumps, the intake, the tires, the flap tracks, the rudder bolt(s), the wing tips, the tailwheel springs, etc.–are the stuff that software largely can't replace, and are the more time-consuming part of taking off.

Put another way, the latest fighter jets and commercial heavies still have significant visual preflights.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jfoutz on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:21PM (#11873129)
Could cameras at various points of the plane could identify when things are not perfect? Computer vision has limits, but identifying leaks, ripples on a surface that should be smooth, and rivet discoloration seem pretty feasible. Granted, I'm not a pilot, and i've never done a walk around.

I can't figure out how you'd check the tips of the wings, but the leading edges should be visible from up by the nose. Similarly, the trailing edges from the tail.

It's also easy to be extra cautious. bias to 0 false positives. Sure it will detect problems that turn out to be dirt or poor lighting or something, but one visual check seems faster than 20 (or however many are necessary).

in a controlled environment like that, you could require stuff to be painted computer vision friendly colors. Even more, i'd bet oil reflects differently than metal under different lighting. internal stuff could be lit up with IR or some other part of the spectrum for easy detection.

I dunno. seems like perhaps a few pounds of electronics.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by outworlder on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:29PM (#11870872)
> The examples you gave take no more than 30 seconds. Sure, FADEC can eliminate most of them, but they're quick.

Sure. Maybe I shouldn't have picked the engine section as the example.

In the context of this thread, way more than that is needed.

> Put another way, the latest fighter jets and commercial heavies still have significant visual preflights.

And that is fine. The stakes are high, the plane itself is much more complex and placed in high demand, plus they can hire staff.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by 6stringmerc on Thursday June 09, 2016 @02:36PM (#11871393)
The "staff" you mention that does the walk-around of the major commercial airliner is/are also the person(s) who will be piloting the plane, IIRC.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by parfe on Thursday June 09, 2016 @03:12PM (#11871575)
I just flew on an a320 and watched the plane taxi to the gate. Someone on the ground crew in an orange vest walked around the plane and did a visual inspection using a flashlight. At no point did someone from the flight crew leave the plane.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by 6stringmerc on Thursday June 09, 2016 @04:53PM (#11872300)
Curious as to what airline and at what airport? Usually pre-flight is before the plane taxis "from" the gate not when it arrives "at" the gate.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by parfe on Thursday June 09, 2016 @06:51PM (#11872969)
Are you referring to only the first flight of the day?

A plane lands, taxis to the gate. Passengers disembark, the plane gets cleaned and refueled, people on the ground checked it out, new passengers board (me), and it taxis from the gate. At no point did the pilots leave the airplane to "walk-around".

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jeffcore on Thursday June 09, 2016 @03:39PM (#11871760)
This is typically what happens during our hot seat evolutions in the Navy, as well. As Aircrew, I'm more concerned about performing my own walkaround if any maintenance had been performed between flights and/or it's the aircraft's first flight that day.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by cpncrunch on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:17PM (#11870347)
With modern FADEC engines, all of this is automated (from what I read...I've never actually flown anything with FADEC).
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jeiting on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:56PM (#11870624)
The recent diesel installs with FADEC that Redbird has been doing in 172s have a one button run up: You just hold the breaks and hit a button and the FADEC does the run up and checks all parameters and gives you a go/no-go.

FADEC - Full Authority Digital Engine Control

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Natsu on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:50PM (#11871022)
And here I thought it was 'Automatic', but I haven't dealt with a FADEC since I wrote avionics test scripts almost 20 years ago.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by rorosaurus on Thursday June 09, 2016 @06:13PM (#11872774)
Very interesting. Do you know how this system handles eventual sensor failure?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by serge2k on Thursday June 09, 2016 @02:24PM (#11871293)
Everything you set automatically is now more complicated.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jackhack on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:22AM (#11869538)
>>In the meantime try to get new helicopter landing sites approved in your neighborhood.

Which takes us right back to the noise issue which needs to be solved, first. 'Till then, no way.

Helicopters (nicknamed 'choppers' for good reason) buzzing over neighborhoods aren't exactly the average homeowner's dream. The "whapwhapwhapwhap" of a helicopter overhead, reverberating through a home, is just as desirable as open-pipe Harley Davidson motorbikes or roaring hotrods. That is to say, it's not.

Other than a crash, I can't think of a surer way to put people off from air traffic than noise.

(edit: grammatical typo: than->as)

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by JDDunn9 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:19AM (#11869969)
I don't think cities have the ability to regulate helicopters. Airspace is regulated by the FAA, which pre-empts the states from regulating them further. I remember reading an article about some city where helicopter noise had become a problem and they couldn't do much about it. Although I suppose with enough complaints the FAA might change their rules.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by arebop on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:40AM (#11870113)
Surely they can regulate use of land. What good is your helicopter without a helipad?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by run4yourlives2 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:44PM (#11870974)
Airspace is regulated federally in most countries, but what you can build on the ground is almost always local in regulation.

You might be allowed to fly overhead without he city being able to do much about it, but you won't be able to land or take off.

(And to be honest, if the city complains to the federal regulators regarding noise, they almost always listen - almost every airport in a town has strict noise-reducing approach patterns for this reason already.)

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by nsxwolf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:29PM (#11870439)
Increase the amount of helicopter-style traffic by 10x, and eventually congress will make the FAA enact new regulations.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Gravityloss on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:43AM (#11869684)
IMO fenestron equipped helicopters are significantly more pleasant to listen to. There's no sharp slapping from the tail rotor.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by narrator on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:29PM (#11870874)
You forgot the big one: Most small aircraft cannot fly in bad weather. If it's raining, windy, or even cloudy these things are going to be grounded if the pilot doesn't have an instrument rating.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by rileyteige on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:34PM (#11870907)
Not to mention icing conditions!
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by SpikeDad on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:40PM (#11884690)
Not to mention how little skill that a big percentage of people have just driving cars. Can't even get people to follow the speed limit - fat chance you'd get them to follow aviation regulations.

Most people in cars that make mistakes end up in a crash but don't die. Everyone in a portable flying device that makes a mistake will die.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by the_watcher on Thursday June 09, 2016 @04:01PM (#11871920)
Sure, but that's not a reason to just punt on trying to build a flying car. Larry Page has the money to invest both in stuff he thinks will change the world (which he does both independently and at Alphabet) as well as in things he just wants to exist.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by mtgx on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:41PM (#11872605)
They can be automatically disabled for when there's bad weather.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by SpikeDad on Saturday June 11, 2016 @02:42PM (#11884699)
Hahaha. The function of my flying car is controlled by - Meteorology? Now that's funny. I have respect for meteorologist (heck - for me it was either that or computer science) but even today local forecasting is not reliable enough to base the functionality of devices upon.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by nibnib on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:23AM (#11875005)
That rules out selling any in large parts of the world then.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by sievebrain on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:04AM (#11869071)
Your first point makes sense, but if the flying cars are fully electric then I'm not sure how much of the work to make existing small aircraft totally reliable would be applicable to such a different machine.

I guess that leads on to the question of, why not start by making an electric self-maintaining self-flying Cessna?

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Nokinside on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:23AM (#11869171)
Energy density of jet fuel and gasoline is something like 45-46 MJ/kg. All rechargeable lithium-whatever batteries have less than MJ/kg.

Turboprops are efficient and reliable. They have good power-to-weight ratio. Currently electric motors are good only for things like gliders that need relatively little power.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by prplhaz4 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:33AM (#11869238)
This link (recently on HN) provides an interesting analysis of the options: http://spectrum.ieee.org/aerospace/aviation/how-i-designed-a...

It seems like a fuel cell could be a viable option in the not-too-distant future, but still comes with a good number of trade-offs...

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jp555 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:23AM (#11869540)
If self-flying taxi average flight times are 15 min, does this matter?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jacquesm on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:20AM (#11869970)
It does if you want to operate your self-flying taxi in an economically sound manner. All the time that it is on the ground it is not making money. Which means you'll be charging it when the number of requested rides is low, so you'll need to make a number (possibly quite a large number) of 15 minute rides before you get to recharge.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by gohrt on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:20PM (#11870797)
15 minute flight, 15 minute back to depot, 5 minute battery swap, charge batteries at the depot.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by lettergram on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:29AM (#11870036)
Blimps would also be viable. You can significantly reduce the required energy to get them to move
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by outworlder on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:56AM (#11870224)
I love blimps. Even more so the semi-rigid ones. We can even get some of them solar powered now.

However, have we solved all the mooring requirements? I can't envision blimps used by individuals until they can self-moor or something.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by lettergram on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:20PM (#11877501)
You could hold the hydrogen or helium as liquid prior and post use. There's a bunch of stuff we would have to figure out to make it work, but it doesn't seem entirely impractical.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by sievebrain on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:54AM (#11869770)
Yes, I know, jet fuel is one of the most energy dense things out there. But the article talks endlessly about electric power being the key to a self flying car, so I assumed the whole discussion was contingent on that being practical.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by ams6110 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:36PM (#11870925)
Flying cars, of course, are ridiculous.

Best sentence in the article.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Shivetya on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:47AM (#11870166)
So lets get silly here; granted I wanted a flying car ever since seeing a Spinner in Blade Runner.

Deploy a balloon above the vehicle when not under power which reuses the helium when not moving beyond a set speed. Pretty sure it can be an airfoil in itself and compact enough to sit above the craft. When transitioning to full on flight it can be partially deflated to reduce its air resistance but still retain the shape needed for lift. Plus why do these air cars need such high speeds when flying?

Since I am not a wiz at these things I am not sure how much balloon you need to compensate sufficiently for the vehicle weight. You don't need to compensate all of it, just enough so that when all power fails you don't hit the ground beyond the means of the occupants to survive. With modern electronics losing power at altitude should allow a glide landing.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by gambiting on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:51PM (#11870587)
To "reuse" the helium it would need to compress it again - and that uses a lot of energy. Not to mention that you would need a lot of helium, and helium, almost like hydrogen, has a tendency to escape from its containers so you need really heavy lead bottles to store even a few litres. It's not impossible, but it does not seem practical in any way.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by nradov on Thursday June 09, 2016 @04:24PM (#11872094)
Helium is typically stored in steel or aluminum pressure vessels. Not lead. Lead is heavier and more expensive, and it's soft enough that attaching valves can be problematic.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Natsu on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:47PM (#11870992)
They could do some kind of drone and do all the safety checks regularly before dispatching them, perhaps. Then the people doing the checks only need to be at the site. Maybe also allow remote control that can take over in emergencies and keep a few pilots around for that.

That said, convenient landing spots may not exist for many trips, so I have no idea what a good use case would be for this kind of thing.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by stcredzero on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:49PM (#11872647)
No matter how energy efficient the engines are, hovering and short takeoffs use lots of energy.

What about electric vehicles with beamed power? The "heavy lifting" for a small electric aircraft could be done at the airport using beamed power, freeing up weight and increasing the effective range of the aircraft.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by tempestn on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:05AM (#11874945)
Rather than beamed power, how about some sort of ground vehicle that launches the aircraft (or pushes it up to a given speed and then releases)?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by stcredzero on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:07PM (#11877844)
The ground footprint for VTOL vehicles using beamed power is a lot smaller. Even a vertical accelerator built up the side of a skyscraper would have a larger footprint and higher costs.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:55PM (#11872677)
The question is, how much power would be needed. It screams "military-grade futuristic microwave weapon" to me.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by stcredzero on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:51AM (#11874372)
LASER!
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by TeMPOraL on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:06AM (#11874735)
Probably even worse / more dangerous.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by stcredzero on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:04PM (#11877823)
But it sounds cooler!
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by the_watcher on Thursday June 09, 2016 @04:00PM (#11871908)
> Noise and safety regulations, aviation regulations over urban areas.

Did you read the entire article? An entire section was devoted to how the rise of electric engines addresses the noise issue, as well as some of the safety issues by removing the bomb (internal combustion engine) from the vehicle.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by ohazi on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:48AM (#11877204)
> into your future Cessna-Android and flying off

Dear god, please don't let Android anywhere near my airplane instruments and flight controls. It's like the exact opposite of a real-time system - practically guaranteed to hang and crash.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by kordless on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:39AM (#11869637)
The primary problem with flying things is that they currently rely on atmospheric lift. Loss of lift equals death of occupants and vehicle.

It's only when we transition to alternate means of lift that flying will be "safe" for public consumption and operation.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by tim333 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:49PM (#11871009)
Lots of people fly currently and there is seldom fatal loss of lift.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by cpncrunch on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#11870361)
There are safety measures such as autorotation and airframe parachutes that can safely land the aircraft after an engine failure.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by alphapapa on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:21PM (#11870382)
And what happens when a Cessna parachutes onto the roof of your house? Onto the middle of a busy street? etc. If we were all using flying cars, this would become a regular occurrence. It's just not practical at that scale.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by skj on Thursday June 09, 2016 @03:47PM (#11871820)
What happens when a car veers off the road into your living room?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by alphapapa on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:15PM (#11879140)
Most roads don't point at people's living rooms. Now and then I see a house at the top of a T intersection, and I can't imagine living there. I used to drive down a country road that had nice houses a few feet from a curve in the road, so any car that didn't make the turn would hit the house. I would never live there, either.

But imagine hundreds or thousands of small aircraft flying over your house every day, driven by non-pilots, maintained like automobiles. I wouldn't want to live there, either.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by PhasmaFelis on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:56PM (#11872679)
The basic design of roads and their surroundings mean that an out-of-control car is relatively unlikely to collide with a building, as opposed to another car, a utility pole, a divider/barrier, etc. Conversely, an aircraft falling over a built-up area is very likely to encounter a building, and even if it lands in a road, it's going to be harder for moving cars to spot and avoid than an out-of-control car would be.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:54PM (#11872669)
Probably much less damage, because a typical car in the city is going much slower than a typical plane falling from the sky, and kinetic energy goes with square of velocity...
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by cpncrunch on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:30PM (#11873699)
A plane (with BRS parachute) falls at 10-20mph, according to BRS's website. Typically a small plane will weigh about 2000-3000lb.

A car in the city will be going at about 30mph, and will weigh about 4000lb.

There are news stories here regularly of cars driving into storefronts. Generally when I hear a story about a Cirrus activating their parachute, it lands on empty space and doesn't do any damage.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by tempestn on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:09AM (#11874961)
Any reason you couldn't add steering controls to an emergency parachute, just like skydivers use? Not manually pulled, but with some small emergency actuators? Basically you'd just need the ability to pull down corners of the parachute, right?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by cpncrunch on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:30PM (#11877581)
If the engine is still operating, you might be able to steer:

https://www.cirruspilots.org/copa/safety_programs/b/pull_ear...

(although obviously most of the times you would want to use the chute is because the engine has died!)

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by alphapapa on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:21PM (#11879196)
Maybe. But if you're making an emergency landing in a populated area, there is generally no safe place to land. Parachute or not, you're probably going to land on or in the middle of something, and injury or property damage is almost certain.

Whereas, if my car breaks down on the street...

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by alphapapa on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:17PM (#11879156)
Drop a 3,000 lb aircraft on a roof at 20 mph, and I think it will break through the roof.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by cpncrunch on Friday June 10, 2016 @04:15PM (#11879638)
Maybe not:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MythBusters_(2014_season)#Pian...

a 1400lb piano dropped from 50ft (40mph at impact) won't break through a roof.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by alphapapa on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @03:56AM (#11944173)
Uh, yes it did. Did you read what you cited?

> A baby grand piano weighing 1,400 pounds (640 kg) pierced its legs through the roof but was unable to fully break through.

I consider the legs breaking through to be "breaking through the roof."

Then:

> Calling the myth busted, the team loaded another upright piano with enough sand to reach a total weight of 2,600 pounds (1,200 kg), much more than a full-size grand piano, then dropped it from 75 feet (23 m) above the roof. This time, the piano did smash a hole in the roof and landed on the floor.

Since we've been talking about a heavier aircraft, anyway, I hardly think this Mythbusters experiment proves anything here. As much as I enjoy watching the show, it's not a scientific study of how roofs are affected by heavy objects falling on them. There are a variety of factors to consider, including design, materials, condition, etc.

And finally, even if it didn't pierce the roof in any way, when it slid off the roof, it would land on something, damaging or injuring it.

The bottom line is that you don't want aircraft falling on your house.