News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by rtpg on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:39AM (#11868935)
What problems do flying cars solve? I know it looks cool but is there some huge thing that would get solved with this?
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by uptown on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:55AM (#11869016)
Cars and trucks are relegated to the 2d grid of streets. They consume an inordinate amount of space, and require that all travel occur in series down a road. When an accident occurs, this disrupts the flow of traffic down that path, and also frequently disrupts the flow of surrounding roads as drivers seek alternate routes around the problem. Roads wear down over time, and require maintenance to repair. Salt and chemicals placed on roads to melt ice and snow can have adverse impacts on the local water tables and have other negative ecological impacts.

Air-travel doesn't have those same constraints. Travel could be more point-to-point. An accident by one or two aircraft doesn't need to inhibit the travel of all other crafts flying in the general vicinity. Air space, while regulated and crowded in some urban areas, is largely under-utilized and expansive. It's also not a space that is shared with foot traffic, so pedestrians could reclaim some of the space currently allocated to roads since the volume of vehicular traffic would likely drop.

That's not to say that personal air travel doesn't introduce an entire set of new problems and challenges - it absolutely does, but there are many problems that cars and roads cause which air-travel avoids by-design.

Think of air-travel in the context of this cartoon:

http://greatergreaterwashington.org/post/24948/to-a-pedestri...

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by drzaiusapelord on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:56AM (#11869378)
This doesn't solve the parking problem. Sure, you get to work a bit faster but now you need to put that thing down. In a downtown area where there's a major price premium for parking. Getting to work in 10 minutes instead of 30 is going to be attractive and that'll raise parking demand, but there's only going to be so much parking available. Tearing down profitable office buildings to make flying car parking lots will be cost prohibitive and I doubt Joe Officeworker is interested in a $500+ a month flying car space.

Its also worth mentioning that none of these proposed designs are vtol, so you'll need a real runway to land or take off.

Worse, how do you leave the massive underground parking lot? Drive to the street then somewhere you can safely lift off? Now you have to wait to taxi to the proper runway or lift off zone or whatever these things will ultimately be allowed to use. Double worse, now we're less invested in solutions that actually work and don't require massive parking spaces like public trans via light rail, e-bikes, traditional bikes, etc.

There's a reason why the personal plane never took off. I'm pretty bearish about the flying car concept, even if all the technical and regulatory issues are easily solved (hint: they wont be) there's still pricing and safety issues on top of the parking problem. Oh and 9/11 is fresh in everyone's minds. Can you imagine anyone approving these things flying near the skyscrapers we work in? I suspect that if that these things catch on, they'll be like the Concorde. A toy for rich people in a hurry but with so many strict regulations and limitations that it'll ultimately be infeasible in the long run.

If Page and Google have shown anything, they're poor futurists outside of the information realm. When it comes to hardware, they're batting very poorly. They let Valve and Oculus take the VR crown, they let Musk take space tourism and electric cars, they let Jobs take the first mass market smartphone, let Amazon take the e-book crown, etc.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by uptown on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:17AM (#11869511)
"Tearing down profitable office buildings to make flying car parking lots will be cost prohibitive and I doubt Joe Officeworker is interested in a $500 a month flying car space."

Rooftops have been used for ages as landing pads for helicopters. I don't see why you couldn't do the same for these. And the article mentions adoption of the uber-model of non-ownership, so it's not like you'd need a parking lot of these sitting idly at the workplace for end-of-day. They'd come and go on-demand.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by drzaiusapelord on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:18AM (#11869520)
My rooftop is full of HVAC equipment and my building is 28 stories high. Even if it was engineered to hold that much weight and redone to make it safe for landing a vtol plane, we're looking at what? 3 or 4 spaces at most in a building that holds over 2,000 people.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by joosters on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:23AM (#11869542)
A helicopter pad on a rooftop can generally only hold one helicopter. Where would the other people in the office park? Besides, hardly any of these flying car designs take off & land vertically.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by _audakel on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:37AM (#11869626)
You could have the tesla self park / pick up feature. It drops you off and then Flys off some here where there is much space. Then you just call it back when you ready to leave.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by rileyteige on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:50PM (#11871023)
Sounds like a lot of wasted energy if that thing has to fly any reasonable distance.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Nav_Panel on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:28AM (#11869570)
> This doesn't solve the parking problem. Sure, you get to work a bit faster but now you need to put that thing down. In a downtown area where there's a major price premium for parking.

What I envision instead is an extension of the office park concept, but suddenly there's no traffic congestion. You could have massive suburban/exurban growth and still have incredibly short commutes -- employees fly to their offices and park on the grounds.

Folks who work downtown should probably live in the city/commuter suburbs and would be better served by other types of transit such as rail. I doubt this type of vehicle would even be allowed in a dense urban area. Flying cars in Manhattan sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by marssaxman on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:12AM (#11869897)
Wait, now - you want to exacerbate sprawl and worsen suburban inefficiency, and this is supposed to be a benefit? I think you have just convinced me that personal flying vehicles are a terrible idea to be opposed at all costs.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by Nav_Panel on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:53AM (#11870204)
I'm not saying this view is a positive thing, it's merely what I imagine will happen if personal flying vehicles become affordable, based on past trends and our political environment. I would personally prefer more investment in public transit and dense urbanity, which isn't even really possible due to overly restrictive zoning laws.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by marssaxman on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:50PM (#11873965)
Ah, sounds like we are much in agreement then.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by drzaiusapelord on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:48AM (#11869713)
Except its the dense urban areas with the serious traffic and the kinds of people with the disposable income to consider a $300,000 vehicle who are probably going to be the main buyers here.

I think suburban people probably aren't as motivated and if this stuff can't handle skyscrapers then the concept is pretty much dead outside of recreational usage.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by chris11 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @01:18PM (#11870782)
I'm actually currently working on projects related to traffic management systems for UAS. I'd say that currently air travel is much more complicated than street travel. And there is a lot of research and engineering that needs to be done before we can safely handle large amounts of UAS traffic.

For one, UAS take up more space than cars. Sure they can be smaller, but operators/systems need more space to safely fly. Two, we don't have systems in place to handle large amounts of traffic. Traffic on roads is much simpler. You have well defined routes, and you have well-defined regulations to safely handle adverse driving situations. UAS do not currently have systems that can automatically handle large amounts of traffic or adverse flying conditions. Plus the autonomous systems are currently not quite up to a human pilot's ability to fly. There may be some very advanced autonomous flight systems, but there isn't anything that could handle the amount of traffic comparable to current street traffic.

I think this is definitely an exciting time for autonomous flight. But I also think we are just really starting to get around to solving the problems caused by UAS. I don't know if it's fair to compare large amounts of UAS traffic to street traffic. I think the state of UAS traffic management is closer to the state of street traffic 100 or so years ago. UAS safety systems and airspace regulations definitely aren't sophisticated.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by knodi123 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:28AM (#11869571)
> An accident by one or two aircraft doesn't need to inhibit the travel of all other crafts flying in the general vicinity

lol, an accident by one or two aircraft might not immediately inhibit the travel of nearby crafts, but it will certainly cause a legal storm that will eventually inhibit it!

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by skrause on Thursday June 09, 2016 @05:42PM (#11872619)
Bicycles also solve all the problems you listed.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by uptown on Thursday June 09, 2016 @06:15PM (#11872784)
Bicycles are a great alternative for many commuters but they can't match the range that cars or planes can provide for most cyclists.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by EA on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:08AM (#11869096)
I work around dozens of pilots. Most of them used to own, co-own, share, or lease a plane. Only a few of them actually have a plane they could go fly right now.

Maintenance, upkeep, costs, and regulations are obvious reasons why some would be deterred from owning and using a private plane.

But most everyone of the pilots said, if you want to go to the beach, in general, the best way to get there is a 6 to 8-hour drive in a minivan. The faster you go in the plane, the faster you burn fuel, and the more likely you'll have to land to refuel. Even if you don't refuel, loading, landing, unpacking, and rental cars are all unpleasant time sucks at a small airport in a small plane which saves you maybe 2 or 3 hours on your commute.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by bmj on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:37AM (#11869263)
This squares with my experience. The folks I know that travel by small plane do so because they enjoy flying, not because it offers any real benefits over driving.

These folks are also not lacking for disposable income.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by 6stringmerc on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:41AM (#11869658)
One quick look at the "estimated" price tags for the flying cars in the article - $280,000 & $400,000 as examples - should be enough to reveal how stupid the idea is at the core.

For $400,000 I could get a decent shape used Beechcraft Bonanza and a 2 year old Corvette or BMW M-class sedan. Both of which would out-perform the Flying Car in either respect. Easily.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by base698 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:38PM (#11870513)
Mostly true. For me I go a lot of places that are a 2 hour plane ride followed by a 2 hour car ride. In those cases it's faster to just fly directly where I want to go, and avoid the car portion. Most places have smaller airports a lot closer to a rural destination. Of course, if you only go to larger cities, this is never an issue.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by robotresearcher on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:47AM (#11874528)
Float plane. Tie up at your dock.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by adwf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:50AM (#11868991)
There are a number of potential issues they solve:

1) Efficiency. A flying car can theoretically take a straight line to its destination instead of having to follow a complex road layout. It might be less efficient to fly per minute, but if you're flying less minutes, it could be a net gain.

2) Reduce congestion. How much fuel in a car is burnt in traffic? With flying cars, congestion will largely be a thing of the past, you have effectively unlimited road just by changing altitude.

3) Reduce urban sprawl. You can get rid of a lot of the roads that plaster the countryside. There will still need to be some obviously. But less.

4) Reduce national infrastructure costs. As above, you get rid of the roads, you don't need to maintain them anymore.

5) Convenience. You don't need a driveway or garage on your house when you can land on the roof ;)

All in all there are quite a few decent reasons for it. Just depends on whether you can beat that efficiency level.

It would be interesting to see if anyone has done calculations factoring in the cost savings from reducing sprawl and the miles of road that are maintained each year.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by daveguy on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:01AM (#11869403)
> 1) Efficiency.

I expect it will always be more efficient to roll an object on wheels than to keep an object lifted under power and moving forward at the same time. Rolling friction is not very high. This and safety are major reasons we don't have flying cars today. Prop planes are in the sub 20 mpg range and jets are in the gallons per mile.

>2) Reduce congestion

I think that autonomous cars (on the ground) will solve this a lot faster than flying cars.

> 3) Reduce urban sprawl.

This is just incorrect. The roads are not what causes urban sprawl and the roads are not the only negative impact. Urban sprawl happened for two reasons: "white flight" and easy transportation. This does nothing for one and makes the other easier.

> 4) Reduce national infrastructure costs.

This would be a very long term benefit after ubiquity of flying cars:cars as cars:trains now. I don't think it will ever get there because of point 1). Personal flight consumes more energy than personal rolling.

>5) convenience.

True. Although houses would have to have heli landing pads installed making it more of a rich toy item. Not to mention noise. Also, autonomous rolling vehicles will solve this too. Is going to your roof more convenient than going to your driveway?

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by adwf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:17AM (#11869506)
You have to take into account more than just the pure physical efficiency of rolling cars vs. flying. There is the practical efficiency too.

When I drive my car to work, I have to take a big dogleg out to the motorway, sit in traffic for 5 minutes to join, then drive down the motorway which is winding between the towns but mostly going the right direction, then take another big dogleg off + traffic, and finally I'm at my destination. I wouldn't be surprised if I'd driven the equivalent of 2-3 times the straight line distance.

Normal efficiency calcs focus on the gallons part, a flying car would reduce the miles.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by kuschku on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:35PM (#11870486)
Or one could increase the density of where you live, and build a transit network.

The metro also usually goes in straight lines.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by adwf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @02:35PM (#11871372)
Yes, but much like a motorway, it's someone else's straight line, not mine. I still have to get to a station and then get to my destination afterwards, which could involve a lot of walking. Not to mention that not everybody wants to live in high density housing, it has a whole set of unwelcome problems of its own.

Personally speaking I love dense living and walking everywhere, but it's not for everyone.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by daveguy on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:17AM (#11869944)
That's a good point. Although the VTOL aspect is still very energy consumptive.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by outworlder on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:07PM (#11870301)
> 1) Efficiency. A flying car can theoretically take a straight line to its destination instead of having to follow a complex road layout. It might be less efficient to fly per minute, but if you're flying less minutes, it could be a net gain.

Theoretically. That fact that standard commercial flights don't do that should be a red flag. Commercial flights follow pre-designated airways.

Smaller aircraft in unregulated airspace aren't that constrained. But that's because there's too few of them.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by dekhn on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:43AM (#11869299)
The efficiency argument doesn't work: moving up against gravity will always be more expensive.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jonnycowboy on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:55AM (#11869368)
There are always tradeoffs... airplanes move more or less at a steady speed, and are much more aerodynamic than cars, which spent quite a bit of time stuck in traffic. Thus in many cases planes are more efficient than cars (despite needing to lift).
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by dekhn on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:06AM (#11869853)
Airplanes have to go faster than the stall speed. Stall speed is typically ~60mph or more, and air resistance goes up as the square of the speed (times the aerodynamc cross section). Airplanes aren't really that much more aerodynamic than modern cars.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by adwf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:07AM (#11869450)
Not necessarily. If a car is twice as efficient, but has to travel three times as far because of the windy road system, the flying car will have it beat in a straight line.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by knodi123 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:32AM (#11869589)
> travel three times as far because of the windy road system,

Ironic choice of words. The winding road system adds distance to your commute, but a windy airspace adds air-miles to your commute.

That is, a flying car doesn't travel through the same amount of air when going 1 ground mile in different directions.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by adwf on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:46AM (#11869699)
Haha, completely unintentional. Very good point though.

Personally I don't think flying cars will take off (ha, done it again...) for quite some time, if only for risk reasons. Think about just how many car accidents there are every day, now imagine every accident ending with a 100m death plunge from the sky. I just can't see it going mainstream for a long time.

Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by dekhn on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:50AM (#11869734)
I think you'll need to adjust that from "three times", to "90 times" for the physics and math to work.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jessriedel on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:56AM (#11869023)
You can go faster and in a straighter line, and -- given good communication between autonomous vehicles -- there is essentially no limit to traffic throughput. Also, you don't have to build as many roads, which are expensive and take up lots of valuable land.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by RankingMember on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:01AM (#11869059)
This is true at least until we become so overpopulated that we're living in Jetson's-style sky-houses.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by jessriedel on Thursday June 09, 2016 @04:35PM (#11872174)
Would that we have those problems :)
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by vintermann on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:46AM (#11868971)
They can probably go in a straighter line to wherever they're headed.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by eumoria on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:54AM (#11869008)
Also being able to add layers atop one another as traffic increases.
Re:Larry Page’s startups working on flying cars by nix0n on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:19AM (#11869149)
Larry Page has a lot of money, and a reputation for building the future. People will say, "Hey this smartphone is okay, but where's my flying car?"