News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by distances on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @06:36AM (#11861272)
In Finland this is solved by it not being possible to avoid state pension. You can collect your additional stash, but if you're getting a salary, you will be paying to the pension fund.

Yes, women live longer, but in general have a bit smaller pension due to their time off the workforce because of motherhood, and (still) slightly lower salary levels. I don't consider this unfairness towards men any significant issue.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by wueiued on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @09:35AM (#11862159)
I wrote "for the same contribution". If women pays equal money, she will get more from system, because she lives extra seven years.

Plus children are counted as a bonus for state pension. So you do not lose pension for spending three years home with kid. (men would)

We also have compulsory state pension system. It does not stop people from opting out.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by distances on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @09:50AM (#11862235)
> We also have compulsory state pension system. It does not stop people from opting out.

This doesn't sound like compulsory, right?

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by wueiued on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:10AM (#11862357)
You can always leave to other country, or minimize your contributions with creative accounting.

Also very common is to build your own house by yourself DIY style. It is significantly cheaper because you do not have to pay taxes from work you do for yourself.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by facetube on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:22AM (#11862436)
The United States taxes its citizens' income worldwide, at least above a certain income threshold, and from my understanding requires yearly filing regardless. IMO it's unlikely that simply moving to a different country would allow you to dodge a federal mandatory pension (provided it happened in the US).
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by kevinpet on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @11:34AM (#11862915)
Social security is the United States' federal mandatory pension, and it does not generally apply to foreign income (unless in a country that also has a mandatory pension with which the US has a tax treaty).

https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/soci...

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by benjohnson on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @12:24PM (#11863381)
Oddly enough, you can opt out of the Social Security - some employees of government agencies don't have to contribute and some religions are also exempt.

Personally, I feel that anybody should be able to permanently opt-out if desired.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by facetube on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @02:38PM (#11864484)
I worked for one of those organizations in the past, which seems to have skewed my view quite a bit. Thanks for the corrections.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by maxerickson on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:30AM (#11862487)
Social security has an awful lot in common with a federal mandatory pension. If anything, it would probably be easier to opt out of a pension system (where pension implies that the individual benefit is more fully funded by the individual payments).

People that can show they are making payments into a similar program elsewhere often don't have to make social security payments.

https://www.ssa.gov/international/agreements_overview.html

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by Chris2048 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @07:04AM (#11861382)
> time off the workforce because of motherhood, and (still) slightly lower salary levels

This has nothing to do with life-expectancy though, so isn't relevant.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by distances on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @09:22AM (#11862083)
Well, I don't see the whole point of life expectancy and pensions relevant. Pension or payments definitely should not be balanced according to statistical life expectancy per gender.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by _benedict on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:50AM (#11862604)
Not even privately purchased annuities? Otherwise you may have just discovered why many people don't buy them; they are a suboptimal purchase for men, if the ungendered life-expectancy is used.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by distances on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @12:12PM (#11863252)
No, not talking about the private ones, but rather the compulsory state-driven pension system that is in place in most of the Europe.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by Chris2048 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:55AM (#11862631)
Pensions, much like life-insurance, should probably factor it in, which would include other things too (weight, smoking).
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by caseymarquis on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @06:48AM (#11861314)
That's an excellent point. It actually helps balance existing inequality. Maybe not 'ideal', but fairly practical.
Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by Chris2048 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @07:20AM (#11861454)
No! You don't balance unrelated, uncorrelated things.

Do we now abandon efforts to reduce gender roles, or pay-gap differences because that would upset the balance. Are women who don't become mothers owed a greater pension?

Refusing to fix one problem, due to some illusion of karma is ridiculous. Should we also abandon cancer-cures out of concern for those who are short-lived by other causes?

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by hermannj314 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:07PM (#11863755)
Can you elaborate? Why is it wrong to base individual pensions payments on individual contributions? I'm not following.

Are you just saying it wrong to lump people into two different groups arbitrarily? Like we don't base social payments on two arbitrary cohorts like "people over/under 68 inches of height", so why would we base it on gender?

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by Chris2048 on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @01:23PM (#11863880)
The original poster was implying that other inequalities wrt gender "balanced out" the equality wrt pensions and lifespan. I was rejecting arbitrarily linking two unrelated things (problems), and consider them as cancelling each other out.

The poster also stated "In Finland this is solved by it not being possible to avoid state pension" so this isn't basing individual pensions on individual contributions, because much like life insurance, and individual pension would adjust for life-expectancy, whereas I believe the Finnish system is a flat rate wrt gender (this is what I inferred?).

The point about arbitrary groupings is a good one, but it will fall on deaf ears in places like the US, where established groupings have high political importance.

Re:Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday June 08, 2016 @10:12AM (#11862374)
The existing inequality caused by not working as much and choosing lower paying fields? You can bet if men benefitted from this instead it would be considered institutional sexism that would be targeted and dismantled.