News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by guimarin on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:14PM (#11789071)
3.) I'll take that position. Tax repatriation holiday please!

Money is only useful at a macro scale if it's in motion. These cash reserves are worthless if they just accumulate. Better to take them back into the US, and be distributed as dividends to shareholders or through buy backs than to leave them.

If that money could be invested internationally it would, and so basically the mere fact that the money is sitting idle in the bahamas is a huge vote of no-confidence in the other economies of the world. Every once and a while you used to see the big companies buy stupid expensive office space in London and other European/asian cities that were experiencing real estate growth. We see that less now probably because they are already well allocated in that asset class.

Now you may be thinking, well if it's better to take the money home then leave it sitting there for a decade, consider the following. If you repatriate the money and pay anywhere near the 35% corporate tax rate to do so you have to invest it in the US for at least 5 years with a 10% rate of return before you get back to what you had held internationally. Outside the fact that this is basically impossible to do with hundreds of billions of dollars... Absolutely no quarterly venture (wall street) is going to be allowed to do that, they will be sued into oblivion by their shareholders just for trying. Especially since the US regularly holds repatriation holidays. The only tenable long-term solution to this problem is to not tax corporate earnings from overseas. Tax them through individuals later, but not the corps. Otherwise Apple could exist in one form or another for 100 years with 100s billions of dollars just sitting overseas. Of course people who don't understand economics will argue that this is defrauding the US gov't of legitimate tax revenue, but my argument is the US is not the jurisdiction in which this money was earned, so it should see none of it.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by mdorazio on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:45PM (#11789275)
I think you missed the point of my #3. This is like the underpants gnomes in South Park: Step 1: Tax-free repatriation Step 2: ???? Step 3: Economic pizza party

What is step 2 here? Is there any actual evidence that repatriated funds would go back to productive things in the US economy? When we had a tax holiday in 2004, it was a complete failure for jobs and development [1], and only helped shareholders and executives. Is that really what we want? For that matter, is there even a guarantee that companies would distribute all the money back to shareholders in a way that would lead to personal income tax?

Your argument that the money is not being spent overseas implies lack of confidence in other economies is exactly what I'm saying - there is no productive use of those funds available, or else the holders would already be spending it. I would personally much rather some portion of that money go back to the government for expenditure directly on public projects than have all of it go who knows where when it gets repatriated.

I and may other people opposed to tax-free repatriation are perfectly aware of the economics and simply disagree with you on desired outcomes. My opinion is that if you don't want to pay US taxes, don't do business in the US. If you want the benefits of the US labor force, infrastructure, education, legal and military protection, etc. then you should be willing to pay taxes to enjoy those benefits. What other countries do or do not do is irrelevant, as are the desires of necessarily selfish investors. I also disagree that tax-free repatriation is the only long-term solution available - it's just the one you personally like the most. For example, there's nothing stopping Congress from enacting laws to tax stockpiled funds.

[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240529702036331045766237...

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by drumdance on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:42PM (#11789591)
If they repatriate the cash, the company can

a) pay dividends, which are taxed on the recipient

b) buy back shares, generating a capital gain for the seller, which is taxed

c) park it in a bank, which boosts reserves and indirectly stimulates the economy

d) make alternative investments such as corporate venture capital, real estate etc

I personally think there should be no corporate income tax. Instead, taxes should be paid by citizens when the money hits their personal bank account.

Yes, there would be opportunities for evasion by people incorporating themselves. No, I don't know what the ultimate solution to that is.

BUT... right now there is an army of accountants and lawyers who are able to charge companies like Apple exorbitant fees because the potential tax savings is so huge. If you have a $100 million tax liability, using accounting tricks to lower that liability by $20 million justifies paying a lot of lawyers.

If those gains were distributed instead of taxed at the corporate level, suddenly those lawyers will find they have to service a thousand, probably tens of thousands of customers to realize the same payoff they get from one big customer. That changes the economics of tax evasion considerably.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by mdorazio on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:35PM (#11789823)
Thank you for laying out the likely outcomes. My issue is two-fold: 1) we're basically saying "I guess 15% (dividend and long term cap gains tax) at most (probably less) is good enough" instead of the 35% they would normally pay, which just generally seems like bad thinking to me when it comes to setting policy, rather than finding a different solution. And 2) I'm not aware of any evidence that b, c, and d are likely to have a positive outcome for the US as a whole rather than for individuals. (b) assumes that capital gains will be realized and taxed within a short-term time frame, (c) assumes that banks are actually in need of reserves, which I don't believe is true [1], and (d) assumes that alternate investments would actually be pursued that aren't being funded right now, which I'm also not sure is true to any significant extent (ex. Google already has Tech Stars and spends mountains of cash on real estate)

[1] https://twitter.com/dallasfed/status/433408941947494400

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by SilasX on Friday May 27, 2016 @08:50PM (#11790120)
That "15 percent" dividend tax is on top of venture returns that are taxed at 35%. It's like if people were saying you have it easy because you only pay 5% taxes, without mentioning that you have to pay regular income/FICA taxes, before it hits your bank account, and the 5% attaches the second you start to spend it.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by solotronics on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:54AM (#11790934)
Maybe the whole point is to force corporate profits out of the country, thus giving US companies a motive to purchase assets or companies in other places. The US dollar is different in that it is a reserve currency so there are forces in play here that do not make sense unless you take reserve status into account. I think it is advantageous to keep USD outside the US because it can then circulate in other countries further cementing its position as a reserve currency, its a feedback loop.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by brianwawok on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:59PM (#11794451)
> I think it is advantageous to keep USD outside the US because it can then circulate in other countries further cementing its position as a reserve currency, its a feedback loop.

I have never heard of this. Anything I can read or Google about this?

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by sigzero on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:52PM (#11789314)
>My opinion is that if you don't want to pay US taxes, don't do business in the US.

The do business in the US and they pay taxes on the business they do in the US. The US tax laws are absurd on this issue.

> there's nothing stopping Congress from enacting laws to tax stockpiled funds.

I am sure that would be help up in the courts for so long it would never see the light of day.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by RealGeek on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:44AM (#11790602)
The problem is not that they aren't paying taxes on their foreign income. They are evading taxes even on the income earned in US.

They setup a subsidiary in a offshore tax heaven, transfer their patents and intellectual property to offshore tax heaven, and then route the profits from US company to their offshore subsidiary with transfer pricing tricks.

Some of these companies claim that their headquarters are in Switzerland, Ireland or Cayman Islands. But in reality they are nothing more than a PO box and bank account.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WildUtah on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:43PM (#11792511)
Countries with territorial systems have to monitor transfer pricing scams. The US actually ends up with much less revenue because it doesn't care as much about internal pricing abuse.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by mdorazio on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:10PM (#11789402)
Absurd why? Just because you disagree with the policy doesn't make it stupid. Personally, I think the US tax laws are perfectly reasonable in intent on the issue, they're just poor on execution which results in the situation we currently have. I think we could both agree that a large chunk of the "business" being done abroad by many tech companies is fabricated nonsense based on shuffling IP around, building shell companies, and other tricks that have nothing to do with where money is actually generated in reality. The big losers here are small businesses that don't have the option to play tax avoidance games, not giant companies with multi-billion dollar profits year over year.

And I agree with you that we're unlikely to see meaningful forced taxation anytime soon based on the current political climate, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by brisance on Friday May 27, 2016 @11:36PM (#11790484)
How is its execution considered "poor"? Do you have any idea how difficult it is for an American to open a non-American bank account outside of America due to FATCA?
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by walshemj on Saturday May 28, 2016 @07:12AM (#11791254)
If your an American in the UK Banks wont touch you with a barge pole and you are effectively excluded from things like ISA's
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by mac01021 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:14AM (#11790952)
> and only helped shareholders and executives

Isn't a large fraction of the US (40% or more?) shareholders? I am one, and I'm certainly not a member of the business elite.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:04AM (#11791020)
Indeed a large fraction which doubtless correlates with the wealthiest. Dropping taxes means greater wealth disparity is built in - the poor get poorer because they can't afford to invest.

Why should you allow tax free repatriation of money that's largely accrued abroad as a result of choosing not to invest locally and avoiding taxes on profits with IP trickery. The only reason I can see that the demos has to allow such repatriation is if trickle-down theory weren't false.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by tracker1 on Monday May 30, 2016 @03:45AM (#11800117)
Personally, I'd just assume get rid of corporate taxes, instead taxing at transaction or trade level, and also eliminate corporate person-hood (legally speaking). Top this off with policies that allow for regulatory capture of unutilized or long-term under-utilized corporate assets.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by skybrian on Friday May 27, 2016 @09:58PM (#11790281)
On the other hand, money that's just sitting there doesn't harm anything either; it has no effect until it's used. And at the macro scale there's no shortage of U.S. dollars. If creating more money is all that's needed to boost the economy, the Fed can easily do it.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by zanny on Friday May 27, 2016 @10:14PM (#11790309)
Money that stops circulating has a tangible market impact, especially billions of dollars tied up in corporate treasure chests. Stalled money slows the velocity of the economy and effectively shrinks the monetary base. One of the hallmarks of post gold-standard fiat economic planning is to push monetary velocity as high as it can manage through many means because you get more market growth the faster money changes hands and circulates.

IE, the capital market could get richer, or it could get faster, and in either case absolute money moved increases. The former is often hard to do, since you either need to print money without causing inflation or cause the money to appreciate against goods into a strong dollar, and both have negative side effects going faster doesn't really have until you are going too fast and realize you have to slow down.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by skybrian on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:15PM (#11792401)
Not buying it. Removing money from circulation and adding money to circulation should cancel out.

Also, that's not really what happens when a corporation has a lot of cash because it's not really cash. The money is still invested, but in safe investments like government bonds. The cash is then still circulating.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:34PM (#11789205)
Tax holiday's are a terrible waste. Just tax foreign holdings at say 3% per year as an AMT and suddenly all that money starts flowing again.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by guimarin on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:41PM (#11789246)
I don't see why I would pay 35% of my holdings to avoid having to pay 3%.

Also your plan is impossible because it's not Apple or Facebook or Google the US listed entities that own this money, it's independent country specific subsidiaries. The US Gov't has no territorial claim on their asset reserves. The fact that the big companies report the money as their own is a GAAP sleight of hand that everyone knows already understands both sides of in the marketplace.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:59PM (#11789343)
3% * 10 years = 30%, wait 20 years and well you get the idea. The point is by keeping large foreign holdings you simply gain an ever larger tax burden until you need to bring money back to pay it off. After all foerein holdings are not a problem the problem is the unlimited tax dodge until tax holiday.

Also, the ability for companies to have subsidiary's as separate entity's is all down to law and can change at any time. US courts regularly https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by charlesdm on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:13PM (#11789418)
Only if this money yields 0% in the meantime. Even with a 3% tax, it's probably still better to reinvest through your offshore entity than to repatriate.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by beefield on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:03PM (#11789686)
Most western interest rates are very close to zero or even below. I guess that in Zimbabwe you would get reasonable nominal interest rates but there are some other issues that make it uninteresting for most investors.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by firebones on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:22AM (#11790962)
Yes, peg that kind of AMT to inflation.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by thaumasiotes on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:11PM (#11789405)
3% * 10 years is 26%, not 30%. And later payments are better than earlier payments even when they're numerically equal.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Friday May 27, 2016 @09:03PM (#11790146)
That's assuming zero interest. 3% ROI + 3% tax over 20 years...

Also, the idea is an AMT tax if you pay 3 million in US taxes and keep 100 million untaxed offshore that's no additional taxes. Next year if you add another 100 million (200m total) your US taxes also increase by another 3 million. So you might as well bring back enough that you would have paid 3 million in extra taxes so 200m - 3/.35 = 191.4m off shore and 8.6m brought back. After a few years your foreign untaxed accounts stop growing as you bring back as much as your making.

Same basic math would also apply with 5% or 1% AMT tax rate, the difference is how large the foreign reserves get.

PS: Ok, now the downside. It's really hard to parse though untaxed profits of subsidiary's. But, companies like Google are going to stick with legal methods of dodging taxes.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by thaumasiotes on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:41AM (#11790720)
3% tax every year for 20 years is 46%. It doesn't matter what interest rate you get on your holdings; that tax reduces your worth 20 years down the line by 46%.

> the idea is an AMT tax if you pay 3 million in US taxes and keep 100 million untaxed offshore that's no additional taxes. Next year if you add another 100 million (200m total) your US taxes also increase by another 3 million. So you might as well bring back enough that you would have paid 3 million in extra taxes so 200m - 3/.35 = 191.4m off shore and 8.6m brought back.

I'm not following you. Suppose every year my goal is to minimize the taxes I pay that year. What benefit do I see from repatriating those $8.6M?

Scenario A: I have $200M offshore and pay a 3% offshore-holdings penalty of $6M. Taxes are $6M.

Scenario B: I have $191.4M offshore on which I pay a 3% offshore-holdings penalty of $5,742,000. I repatriate $8.6M on which I pay a 35% repatriation penalty of $3,010,000. My total taxes in this scenario are $8,752,000, which I notice is more than $6,000,000. What did I gain?

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:03AM (#11791854)
It's an AMT, so for Scenario B: the AMT is 5,742,000 which is a minimum and not added to anything. AKA You pay that or other taxes if your other tax bill is higher.

You repatriate 8.6M which leads to tax of: 3,010,000. 3,010,000 < 5,742,000 you pay 5,742,000. Which is less than 6 million. (This assumes you have zero tax bill for US operations.)

Also, paying this does not decrease your future tax bill next year in any way. So if your interest rate is zero you pull money back this year. The idea is to penalize behaviors designed to reduce taxes.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by zht on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:03PM (#11789687)
why is 3% for 10 years 26%?
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Nullabillity on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:14PM (#11789732)
You're thinking 3% of the original amount, rather than 3% of the remaining amount. If you pay 3% then 97% remains. 0.97^10≃0.74, meaning that you've lost 26%.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:49PM (#11792537)
> Just tax foreign holdings at say 3% per year as an AMT and suddenly all that money starts flowing again.

Now you have one of two problems. If the 3% goes against only cash and not other assets then it's completely ineffective, because they can just hold the money in whatever type of assets aren't included. But if it does include all foreign assets then US companies can no longer do business in foreign countries, because they won't be competitive with local companies that don't have to pay the same recurring tax on the plant and equipment and other business assets needed to operate there.