News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Friday May 27, 2016 @05:59PM (#11789343)
3% * 10 years = 30%, wait 20 years and well you get the idea. The point is by keeping large foreign holdings you simply gain an ever larger tax burden until you need to bring money back to pay it off. After all foerein holdings are not a problem the problem is the unlimited tax dodge until tax holiday.

Also, the ability for companies to have subsidiary's as separate entity's is all down to law and can change at any time. US courts regularly https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by charlesdm on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:13PM (#11789418)
Only if this money yields 0% in the meantime. Even with a 3% tax, it's probably still better to reinvest through your offshore entity than to repatriate.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by beefield on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:03PM (#11789686)
Most western interest rates are very close to zero or even below. I guess that in Zimbabwe you would get reasonable nominal interest rates but there are some other issues that make it uninteresting for most investors.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by firebones on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:22AM (#11790962)
Yes, peg that kind of AMT to inflation.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by thaumasiotes on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:11PM (#11789405)
3% * 10 years is 26%, not 30%. And later payments are better than earlier payments even when they're numerically equal.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Friday May 27, 2016 @09:03PM (#11790146)
That's assuming zero interest. 3% ROI + 3% tax over 20 years...

Also, the idea is an AMT tax if you pay 3 million in US taxes and keep 100 million untaxed offshore that's no additional taxes. Next year if you add another 100 million (200m total) your US taxes also increase by another 3 million. So you might as well bring back enough that you would have paid 3 million in extra taxes so 200m - 3/.35 = 191.4m off shore and 8.6m brought back. After a few years your foreign untaxed accounts stop growing as you bring back as much as your making.

Same basic math would also apply with 5% or 1% AMT tax rate, the difference is how large the foreign reserves get.

PS: Ok, now the downside. It's really hard to parse though untaxed profits of subsidiary's. But, companies like Google are going to stick with legal methods of dodging taxes.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by thaumasiotes on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:41AM (#11790720)
3% tax every year for 20 years is 46%. It doesn't matter what interest rate you get on your holdings; that tax reduces your worth 20 years down the line by 46%.

> the idea is an AMT tax if you pay 3 million in US taxes and keep 100 million untaxed offshore that's no additional taxes. Next year if you add another 100 million (200m total) your US taxes also increase by another 3 million. So you might as well bring back enough that you would have paid 3 million in extra taxes so 200m - 3/.35 = 191.4m off shore and 8.6m brought back.

I'm not following you. Suppose every year my goal is to minimize the taxes I pay that year. What benefit do I see from repatriating those $8.6M?

Scenario A: I have $200M offshore and pay a 3% offshore-holdings penalty of $6M. Taxes are $6M.

Scenario B: I have $191.4M offshore on which I pay a 3% offshore-holdings penalty of $5,742,000. I repatriate $8.6M on which I pay a 35% repatriation penalty of $3,010,000. My total taxes in this scenario are $8,752,000, which I notice is more than $6,000,000. What did I gain?

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Retric on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:03AM (#11791854)
It's an AMT, so for Scenario B: the AMT is 5,742,000 which is a minimum and not added to anything. AKA You pay that or other taxes if your other tax bill is higher.

You repatriate 8.6M which leads to tax of: 3,010,000. 3,010,000 < 5,742,000 you pay 5,742,000. Which is less than 6 million. (This assumes you have zero tax bill for US operations.)

Also, paying this does not decrease your future tax bill next year in any way. So if your interest rate is zero you pull money back this year. The idea is to penalize behaviors designed to reduce taxes.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by zht on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:03PM (#11789687)
why is 3% for 10 years 26%?
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by Nullabillity on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:14PM (#11789732)
You're thinking 3% of the original amount, rather than 3% of the remaining amount. If you pay 3% then 97% remains. 0.97^10≃0.74, meaning that you've lost 26%.