a) pay dividends, which are taxed on the recipient
b) buy back shares, generating a capital gain for the seller, which is taxed
c) park it in a bank, which boosts reserves and indirectly stimulates the economy
d) make alternative investments such as corporate venture capital, real estate etc
I personally think there should be no corporate income tax. Instead, taxes should be paid by citizens when the money hits their personal bank account.
Yes, there would be opportunities for evasion by people incorporating themselves. No, I don't know what the ultimate solution to that is.
BUT... right now there is an army of accountants and lawyers who are able to charge companies like Apple exorbitant fees because the potential tax savings is so huge. If you have a $100 million tax liability, using accounting tricks to lower that liability by $20 million justifies paying a lot of lawyers.
If those gains were distributed instead of taxed at the corporate level, suddenly those lawyers will find they have to service a thousand, probably tens of thousands of customers to realize the same payoff they get from one big customer. That changes the economics of tax evasion considerably.
I have never heard of this. Anything I can read or Google about this?
The do business in the US and they pay taxes on the business they do in the US. The US tax laws are absurd on this issue.
> there's nothing stopping Congress from enacting laws to tax stockpiled funds.
I am sure that would be help up in the courts for so long it would never see the light of day.
They setup a subsidiary in a offshore tax heaven, transfer their patents and intellectual property to offshore tax heaven, and then route the profits from US company to their offshore subsidiary with transfer pricing tricks.
Some of these companies claim that their headquarters are in Switzerland, Ireland or Cayman Islands. But in reality they are nothing more than a PO box and bank account.
And I agree with you that we're unlikely to see meaningful forced taxation anytime soon based on the current political climate, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try.
Isn't a large fraction of the US (40% or more?) shareholders? I am one, and I'm certainly not a member of the business elite.
Why should you allow tax free repatriation of money that's largely accrued abroad as a result of choosing not to invest locally and avoiding taxes on profits with IP trickery. The only reason I can see that the demos has to allow such repatriation is if trickle-down theory weren't false.
What is step 2 here? Is there any actual evidence that repatriated funds would go back to productive things in the US economy? When we had a tax holiday in 2004, it was a complete failure for jobs and development [1], and only helped shareholders and executives. Is that really what we want? For that matter, is there even a guarantee that companies would distribute all the money back to shareholders in a way that would lead to personal income tax?
Your argument that the money is not being spent overseas implies lack of confidence in other economies is exactly what I'm saying - there is no productive use of those funds available, or else the holders would already be spending it. I would personally much rather some portion of that money go back to the government for expenditure directly on public projects than have all of it go who knows where when it gets repatriated.
I and may other people opposed to tax-free repatriation are perfectly aware of the economics and simply disagree with you on desired outcomes. My opinion is that if you don't want to pay US taxes, don't do business in the US. If you want the benefits of the US labor force, infrastructure, education, legal and military protection, etc. then you should be willing to pay taxes to enjoy those benefits. What other countries do or do not do is irrelevant, as are the desires of necessarily selfish investors. I also disagree that tax-free repatriation is the only long-term solution available - it's just the one you personally like the most. For example, there's nothing stopping Congress from enacting laws to tax stockpiled funds.
[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240529702036331045766237...