News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by spot on Thursday May 19, 2016 @06:56PM (#11734501)
from the post:

> Schools in the US are now buying more Chromebooks than all other devices combined -- and in Q1 of this year, Chromebooks topped Macs in overall shipments to become the #2 most popular PC operating system in the US*.

that's pretty amazing actually. congrats to google & the chromebook team!

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jalami on Thursday May 19, 2016 @11:01PM (#11735326)
Congrats on the adoption, although I still don't think it's moving our public institutions in the right direction. It's really just moving a lot more kids into a walled garden. I know Google has been in hot water for collecting student data recently and has since taken steps to fix it. That's their primary business model though. "Anonymizing" promises always follow and then it's a trust game again.

I can see a future where a mandatory Google account follows you up the grades. Educational software is released exclusively in Google's Play store. Assignments and homework are handed in with Google Drive and Google Docs.

Sure this is great for Google, but I think our public institutions suffer from such a third-party centrality. I remember at UW-Madison, it was annoying having to pay for a semester long subscription to whatever the professor decided was a good cms for the class, but at least the costs were explicit and there wasn't a monopoly player in the field that everyone had to use. IMHO, Google is more interested in getting people into the garden than it is in selling hardware or fostering education.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by groovypuppy on Friday May 20, 2016 @12:01AM (#11735469)
"I can see a future where a mandatory Google account follows you up the grades. Educational software is released exclusively in Google's Play store. Assignments and homework are handed in with Google Drive and Google Docs."

This is not the future. This is now. At the school district where I volunteer as a computer instructor, all the first graders already have a Google account that will follow them throughout their grades. In fact their user names include the year they are expected to graduate. They are teaching first graders how to use Google docs. Editing a Google doc is their first big lesson. I see them as walled in, but from their perspective the Google ecosystem is all there is to the internet.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by aedron on Friday May 20, 2016 @03:12AM (#11736029)
Same thing here, only they are using Microsoft's cloud stuff for MS Office. These cloud suites are just too convenient not to use, and as long as there is no open and free alternative, it seems schools are stuck choosing between one of the oligopolists.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by danieldk on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:18AM (#11735683)
They took a page from Microsoft's playbook. They know that you have to capture the next generation in schools.

I agree with your worries. But it also tells that other parties in the market have utterly failed to compete. iPads used to get traction, but are more expensive, and Apple doesn't provide a complete ecosystem like Google Apps for Education. Microsoft has been sleeping, they have all the pieces but wanted to push Windows as-is. The open source solutions require you to hire some sysadmins, while Google Apps did exactly the opposite: it cut out some personnel that used to maintain the infrastructure.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by kuschku on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:11AM (#11736467)
> The open source solutions require you to hire some sysadmins

That is rarely an issue, though – even my German (combined middle and high) school had a dedicated sysadmin and two teachers teaching computer science who had a PhD in compsci.

Developing custom systems, running them, etc comes a lot cheaper longterm than going into vendor lock-in (especially with privacy laws, where even looking at Google can cost you millions)

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jalami on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:05AM (#11737093)
I think it's fair to say that nothing will be as convenient as a single centralized body controlling all the data management, client software/hardware and services under one roof. Nothing, not ever. So its not really an incompetent market so much as an incompetent or lethargic school system willing to make deep present and future concessions for a one click solution. The complete package is the problem, not the solution. You can't provide a modular and open ecosystem of small, single-concern pieces of software and hardware that rivals the single-provider model. When a single-provider model becomes entrenched, it's near impossible for those modular offerings to take root as they won't interop with the defacto Google, by design. Our education system now has a MAINFRAME.

For all the mud Microsoft gets, their ecosystem was pretty modular because that was their business model. They're locking it down and becoming more cloudy every day, but for a long while, Microsoft didn't care what you ran, didn't explicitly track your usage and worked with a wide variety of disparate multi-vendor software. I'm not saying Windows is where we should have been nor that it wasn't a lock-in of a sort, but we're not really better off now. Apple iPads were less open than Windows, but had consistent hardware. Now Google has achieved the complete solution.

I think a large part of it is the framework v. libraries argument all over again in a different package. I think we're on the swing back now where we want to trust providers a lot more than after the corporate IBM fallout. With everyone getting their music from Spotify, movies from Netflix, games from Steam, analytics from GA, chat from Slack, books from Kindle, etc. Schools are asking, why not us too? For a lot of people, schools aren't something you can just decide not to sign the EULA and walk away from though.

These chromebooks are just cheap thin clients for Google services. They're some of the most locked down devices on the market, but thanks to the internet being decentralized by nature and Google seeming like the door to the internet, their centralization doesn't seem so scary. They interop with little else and hold no data, even printing hits their servers first before your school's printer.

Here's to hoping for a swing-back.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by simula67 on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:27AM (#11735708)
> Google is more interested in getting people into the garden than it is in selling hardware or fostering education

All for-profit companies are interested in turning a profit. No company would be interested in fostering education, no matter what they say. The question is whether their profit motives are harmful to the education.

The larger point here is about the dangers of the cloud. Google could chose not to allow you access to your own data. It can hand it over to the government. A hacker can break into your data and impersonate you remotely, even if you went off the grid. If they become a monopoly, they can jack up their prices and you would have no recourse. They could offer you crappy service and you will have to swallow it.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jalami on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:11AM (#11736928)
I agree with you. Their cloud is really the danger in this relationship. Educators should use products and services whose business model doesn't hamper their ability to remain in control of their students' education. I didn't mean to come off as saying Google isn't sincere and another company with similar offerings would be. It's business.

I think it will get beyond individual school/department lock-in though. Steam, for example, hasn't simply locked-in consumers to their purchases and made it difficult to transition away. Developers are often locked in because they rely on Steam for match-making, piracy-busting, cloud saving, achievements apis, server-hosting, modding support, etc. etc. All of this offloaded centralization is easier than doing it yourself and more like the console's devs are used to. If you want a AAA PC game, you're more than likely going to get it exclusively on Steam.

Android is already there, many/most of the apps require Google's services for even mainline functionality and definitely for consumer discovery. Google education could be next if it gets adopted like Google Analytics as the de-facto api, educators would have no choice in the matter. All good products use Google's apis for everything.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by rpdillon on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:06PM (#11741895)
I'm limited to only my experience in the U.S. public school system (and two universities, one private, one public) but education itself seems to be a walled garden. Curricula are set by policy, not by the instructor. Textbooks are pre-determined, and largely non-negotiable. Many classes mandate all sorts of closed software, sometimes begrudgingly allowing Octave in place of Matlab, for example. Many CS courses mandate a particular language, proprietary or not. And it's nothing new; when I was growing up, it was Apple ][ machines in every classroom. Even in my master's program, the layout templates for the thesis were provided assuming I was using Word. I had to parse them and mirror them into LaTeX so I could use the tools of my choice.

I understand and agree with your concerns, but choice has never been a staple of the education system I've encountered. Perhaps it is different elsewhere.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by userbinator on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:37PM (#11735255)
I hate to be the contrarian one in a thread full of Google fans, but I'd consider this trend of schools flocking to locked-down and largely cloud-dependent computing devices to be pretty freaking scary. Start them young, get them accustomed to and comfortable with the idea of some huge company having great knowledge of and control over their online lives... it's a great business plan, but one that I would certainly object to my kids participating in.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by Adaptive on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:50PM (#11735292)
I understand this concern. I've helped deploy chromebooks and linux based laptops and pcs at my daughters school. I am pro open source and would love to see lots of digging into understanding the systems. However I am also in favor of chromebooks. Here's why:

The alternative to chromebooks isn't a glorious world of non-locked down non-cloud dependent machines. It's a world of poorly managed, crappy windows boxes. A world where students pass around USB keys. A world that is at least as locked down as a chromebook but much less secure and in many ways less flexible.

Chromebooks, as locked down and hermetically sealed as they are as an ecosystem, are great for one simple reason: they free up time and resources. I'd rather see a fleet of chromebooks that are dead simple to manage and deploy and then take all that extra time and money and spend it on equipment a linux or osx or whatever based lab full of machines students can hack on and learn to code on and hook up to actuators or whatever they want to do.

90% of computer management in a school is dealing with day to day "can't print / how to load a document / etc". I've seen this completely evaporate at my daughter's school after rolling out chromebooks. It's amazing.

So bring on chromebooks as locked down, easy to manage dedicated "get homework done" devices and free up time and money (because man are they cheap) to teach programming and hardware and everything else in a real computer lab.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by soyiuz on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:48AM (#11735762)
I also want to point out that Chromebooks can easily be turned into Linux machines with Crouton. They are not locked down in that sense.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jalami on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:31AM (#11737226)
It's not really easy depending on who you ask and running Crouton isn't really making it a linux box in this way as you're just running on top of ChromeOS with most of the hardware integration still handled by ChromeOS.

No school would endorse this because I'm sure crouton isn't in their support package. Doing it 'right' often implies opening the case, voiding your warranty, removing the write-protect screw, flashing away ChromeOS with a third party build of SeaBios, installing an unsupported Linux OS on the hardware and praying drivers exist in the mainline kernel for your device, then making due without any of the ChromeOS cloud-goodies your device was given from Google. Not really SOP for organizations buying in bulk with warranties.

I do it because I like small, cheap computers running Linux well and thankfully ChromeOS is Linux-y, but for most people, this is still very locked down. Even being able to unlock ChromeOS devices is probably more a side-effect than a willful desire from Google to be open.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by stephenr on Friday May 20, 2016 @12:33AM (#11735558)
> poorly managed, crappy windows boxes

> at least as locked down as a chromebook but much less secure

I fucking loathe windows, but Lucy, you've some 'splainin to do. How is a Windows PC "at least as locked down" as a Chromebook?

Remember that "locked down" in the case of a chromebook doesn't mean "the administrator has decided what apps you can run and who can use it", it means "the fundamental design of the operating system means it can only ever run browser based apps, and it's inherently reliant on Google's infrastructure to work".

If Microsoft shut up shop tomorrow, the billions of Windows PCs in the world would have a security issue, sure, but they wouldn't stop fucking working.

> So bring on chromebooks as locked down, easy to manage dedicated "into to being a google user" devices

Fixed that for you.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by piyush_soni on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:46AM (#11735751)
I don't know what's inherently so bad about "being a google user". It's mostly paranoia. If the only hypothetical disadvantage you're thinking about it is "Google might shut down one day", then you're not thinking about a very near future. If the TV channels shut down tomorrow, your TVs effectively stop working too, you still buy them. There are hundreds of such devices out there, which you buy because it's pretty evident the company is not shutting down tomorrow. On the other hand, even if Google shuts down, a lot of things on your Chromebook will keep on working offline, especially with the advent of Android apps now.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by stephenr on Friday May 20, 2016 @02:07AM (#11735819)
> I don't know what's inherently so bad about "being a google user".

Having every facet of your digital life mined for personal data, for the sake of a mega-corp's bottom line?

> If the only hypothetical disadvantage you're thinking about it is "Google might shut down one day"

Not at all. Its actually more likely "Google might stop supporting X, Y or Z that you depend on".. They, you know, have a history of doing that.

However, let's play along anyway.

> If the TV channels shut down tomorrow, your TVs effectively stop working too, you still buy them.

No. Just. No. I literally don't remember the last time I watched broadcast television (hotels excepted), even when I lived in a country where I could understand what was being said on the broadcast channels. In our last house 1 of 2 TV's was connected to a satellite receiver for when my father in law was in the house. We moved 3-4 months ago. No satellite dish hooked up yet. No terrestrial aerial.

> There are hundreds of such devices out there, which you buy because it's pretty evident the company is not shutting down tomorrow.

I do? Would you care to enlighten me about these devices I apparently buy?

> On the other hand, even if Google shuts down, a lot of things on your Chromebook will keep on working offline

Are you kidding me? In offline-mode, you can't even edit your calendar on a Chromebook.

You're also not thinking about things like e.g. users on the system. It's inherently dependent on Google - you can't just add a local account like you can with a regular computer, you have to be online, with the person sitting there next to you, so they can sign in with their own google account.

> especially with the advent of Android apps now

Right, because apps designed to work on a mobile phone, which generally has it's own data connection independent of whether wifi is available or not, will just naturally assume they need to work offline. Good luck with that.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by piyush_soni on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:27AM (#11736520)
All the places where you have taken "you" literally as yourself, I didn't mean that. I meant people in general.

And I wrote "a lot", not "all" the things will keep on working Chromebook (in an hypothetical situation Google shuts down).

> Right, because apps designed to work on a mobile phone, which generally has it's own data connection independent of whether wifi is available or not, will just naturally assume they need to work offline. Good luck with that.

Yes, the same mobile phones which also have an airplane mode.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by imtringued on Friday May 20, 2016 @04:51AM (#11736381)
The only problem with "data mining" is the government, not corporations. The corporations use that data to only do one single thing: give you personalised ads.

However the government could pass new laws and prosecute you for things you have done 20 years ago on the internet.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by DanBC on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:18AM (#11736489)
That's a particular viewpoint that isn't shared by, for example, Europe, where my data is mine, and a corporation gets to use it with my permission. They need to tell me that they gather it, and why they gather it, and what they do with it, and they have to only keep it for as long as necessary.

There are protections for me if a corporation sells my data without my permission or misuses my data.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by beefield on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:20AM (#11736504)
Is there something stopping these corporations to do anything else with the data? I can imagine recruiters willing to pay on some educational information/analysis. I can also imagine corporations selling credit rating information based on the data on the individuals they have. And these were after thinking about 25 seconds of possible valuable use cases on data.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by kuschku on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:14AM (#11736477)
Have you missed out on the past few years of news?

Facebook has admitted to having manipulated which articles showed up in your news stream, and in which order, to test if they could manipulate the mood of their users.

There was even a discussion about it on here.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by dzamo_norton on Friday May 20, 2016 @10:57PM (#11742981)
You draw a clean divide but be wary of things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by discordance on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:30AM (#11736764)
> Its actually more likely "Google might stop supporting X, Y or Z that you depend on".. They, you know, have a history of doing that.

For example, Google Reader.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by millstone on Friday May 20, 2016 @02:53AM (#11735968)
There are some particularly concerning scenarios:

1. Google collects and stores information about my children, and it is released (by accident or otherwise)

2. Google profits off my childrens' education, has financial incentives not aligned with those of my family

but mostly I just think it's really fucking creepy for an advertising broker to be building up a profile of a first grade child, and I think maybe schools shouldn't become reliant on an ad company to help deliver education.

To assuage my concerns, Chromebooks should be usable without creating a Google ID. Or maybe the whole school should have a single ID used by all students.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by userbinator on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:22AM (#11736942)
A world where students pass around USB keys.

That's a good thing, if your alternative is "upload files to a third-party server that might not even be in the same state and download them onto a machine sitting a few feet away. I don't believe the "security" argument either; for a long time schools have configured machines with software such that they don't persist changes across reboots, and that easily gets rid of any infection or unwanted changes.

free up time and money (because man are they cheap) to teach programming

That just widens the gap between users and programmers, and leads to the odd phenomenon of people coming out of "learn to code" classes knowing how to open an IDE and write and run code, but are otherwise still mostly computer-illiterate because they skipped the "implicit education" of dealing with the issues arising from normal computer usage. The problem is that the demographic between "normal user" and "coder", the "power users", has disappeared.

in a real computer lab.

Students should be using a "real computer" for everything they do, not just in special classes, as otherwise it leads to a situation where they perceive programming as something special for "approved" circumstances, and not merely a skill a "power user" can use to improve their productivity. It's somewhat reminiscent of http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by Bombthecat on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:08AM (#11735657)
Apple was basically in the same position and they lost it to google.

Someday there will be something better and people will switch.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by zepto on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:11AM (#11735666)
Chromebooks aren't better - they are just cheap and familiar looking. Google has done nobody a service except themselves.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by danieldk on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:25AM (#11735705)
It's not just about Chromebooks, it's the Chromebook in combination with Google Apps for Education which provides Google Mail, Hangouts, Google Docs, and an electronic course environment:

https://www.google.com/edu/products/productivity-tools/class...

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jfoster on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:46AM (#11735753)
They're cheaper and still good enough. They're popular because that combination is closer to what is desired by the market.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by KWD on Friday May 20, 2016 @09:04AM (#11737415)
I would say they are better at fulfilling this particular role. A Chromebook meets and exceeds requirements for a computer for many, and with the benefit of low maintenance (it just works), so why would they need what Apple offers.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by sotojuan on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:43PM (#11735274)
To be fair most of these schools probably already have iPads anyway. My mom's school gave out iPads and MacBooks to teachers and classrooms like crazy.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by Mahn on Thursday May 19, 2016 @08:51PM (#11734962)
Anecdotal, but when our app got featured on the Chrome Web Store, we saw "clusters" of people coming from single IPs and running Chrome OS, which we would later find out to be US high-schools; for us that was pretty interesting, the realization that a lot of students in the US actively run Chrome OS, we certainly didn't plan for it.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by danso on Thursday May 19, 2016 @07:23PM (#11734631)
Pretty heartening too...for awhile, I was worried that computerized education would be limited to tablets.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by AckSyn on Thursday May 19, 2016 @08:12PM (#11734835)
Tablets aren't really a problem when it comes to education. It's only a shift in how we do computing vs what we do it in.

They've built tablets. We (developers) need to build the software that does more than consume our time, but allow us to create the content for others. Sadly, it's not there yet, but in time it will be. I don't doubt the computing capacity is there for a company to create a 3D modeling program for a tablet that's either touch driven, or a combo that includes a mouse and/or keyboard. There are already suites out there for image manipulation, music and video creation etc.

If I could purchase a tablet and then a full (3D) CAD or other modeling software for it, I'd drop the money in a heartbeat.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by om42 on Thursday May 19, 2016 @08:27PM (#11734884)
I don't really do much CAD but have lots of friends who do. Wouldn't you end up needing a keyboard and a mouse to be productive CADing on the tablet? Which would defeat the form factor of the tablet. There does seem to be a market for CADing on tablets as seen in Onshape. But I have never seen any of my friends use it (Mechanical engineering students and industry tends to favor SOLIDWORKS and sometimes CREO)
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by AckSyn on Thursday May 19, 2016 @09:02PM (#11734999)
If the design of the CAD software were designed around the usage of a touch screen, and I don't think one would have to be constrained to require its use. I'm not saying they'd have to use the on-screen keyboard but build the interface to work well with a touch screen using what's already established in most programs (pinch, twist, tap and drag an item off a pallet or adjust its size etc).
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by jimjimjim on Thursday May 19, 2016 @09:33PM (#11735094)
I've spent a bit of time working on an imaging application (not CAD but building plans) and whenever desktops vs tablets comes up everybody eventually realizes just how huge their fingers are and the meeting moves on to another topic.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by euyyn on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:23PM (#11735224)
I thought the iPad had pens like the Surface?
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by stephenr on Friday May 20, 2016 @12:34AM (#11735561)
Right, its much better if computerised education is limited to browser based applications.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by simula67 on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:16AM (#11735678)
You realize the article is about Android apps coming to Chrome OS, right ?
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by stephenr on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:28AM (#11735710)
You realise that every single school/education department that chose to use Chromebooks did so knowing that they would not run anything but web apps, right?

Additionally, this announcement of a future release lists very specific models of Chromebooks that will support Android apps. Honestly, Android (and Google's management of the situation) has a fucking terrible track record when it comes to support and updates for devices.

Lastly - if you think that apps designed to run on a smartphone and later frankenstein'd onto a low cost laptop form-factor with a browser-as-the-os tagline, I think you should prepare to be surprised.

Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by groundCode on Friday May 20, 2016 @02:29AM (#11735879)
Interesting. Does that mean they have relaxed their t&c on how old you have to be to get a google account? I seem to remember a few years back google deleted an email account that some parents had set up for their child to email their grandparents.
Re:Play Store and Android Apps Coming to Chromebooks by zepto on Friday May 20, 2016 @01:15AM (#11735674)
Since iPads oursell macs by a significant margin this is just a typical distorted comparison by IDC.