Today I read a story about a car getting tickets for $100k [0], one of the tickets was for being in a "hazardous and dilapidated condition", broken headlights and cracked windows. I'm currently living in Rome, Italy - the traffic wardens would have a field day here, basically every car has some sort of damage from an incident.
Don't even get me started about HOA rules...
But if my neighbor miswires a light switch and it starts a fire that burns my house down because they're close together, that would suck. In that situation, I would have wanted a say in whether my neighbor chose to do that themselves or hire someone who knows what they're doing.
I'm living in a house that is filled with small jobs that seemed like they were done by someone who didn't know what they were doing. Lots of scrap lumber, mis-matching parts, electrical re-wires that just didn't work, etc. I'm glad I don't need a permit to fix some of that myself, but I would've loved to stop this guy before he did these things.
Or if someone's half-assery endangered otherwise innocent lives. Note: not necessarily crying "save the children!" "Innocent" as in "couldn't influence decision to get someone who knows what they're doing".
I don't have numbers, but I would be fairly confident in a guess that many, many more houses burn down because of a combination of open flames and carelessness, than do because of low-level DIY electrical work.
Using matches to light a stove or fireplace is so common that we've as a society decided to not place restrictions on that activity because the cost outweighs the benefit.
However, doing electrical work on your house is not quite as common and the result of your work will stay with the house and possibly affect future owners. Added to that the work is generally hidden or not obvious and future owners may not know about your substandard work.
Yeah it's a totally arbitrary line, but either we license nothing or we just pick somewhere to draw it.
My original comment was because in the UK most of this stuff isn't licensed* - even installing a gas stove doesn't need a license, which I'd argue is a lot easier to screw up than a light switch.
There are 'regulations' on how things should be done, but these are merely guidelines in most cases - you won't have any issues with the authorities when trying to sell your house or with insurers if it's not up to scratch. It would be interesting to see how accidents caused by this compare in the UK and US.
On the other hand two things we do strictly regulate are 'listed' buildings and the removal of trees in your garden.
*I think the same is true for most of Europe.
EDIT: What's the emoji for "my tone is sincere, I'm misunderstanding what he's saying you downvoting heathens?" ( =
I'm more or less in the same boat, but leaning towards "not licensing."
Here's how I look at it: in your scenario, would licensing have really prevented any of that from happening? It might give us grounds to sue for damages, but I don't think it would deter idiots from doing what idiots are going to do. Seems more likely to hinder conscious people who can be bothered to look up "the right way" to do something in the first place.
In industrial cases though I absolutely see the need for licensing where safety is concerned - I don't want an untrained person working on the aircraft that's about to transport me across 3000 miles of land mass.
The distinction I would make is a matter of scale and significance I suppose.
Scale feels like a good metric for this. Like, if you're a builder making a lot of houses get a permit. If you're a homeowner fixing your own stuff, you're okay. Maybe education? Like, "You're buying a house! Have a free handyman course on us!" or something?
Yep, that seems like a reasonable compromise to me.
When I commented about this previously though, I was told it reflected strong union etc. rules in Australia.
In practice, in the US, lots of people do some amount of their home repairs including electrical. I'm sure, in many cases, that work is theoretically supposed to be done by a licensed electrician, plumber, etc.
No, you can't. And it's not a matter of "sometimes you can't trust people to do the job right", it's that more times than not an amateur will cut corners, or more accurately, won't know enough to even know that they're cutting corners. For example, my wife and I bought a VW Westfalia camper van a few months ago. After 35 years it's been through a few owners. I wouldn't let any of the previous owners anywhere near my house wiring. Stuff works, but it's half-assed in a lot of places. Twist two wires together, cover it in tape. I'm a solder-and-shrink-tubing guy myself, but c'mon, at least use a Scotchlock or something.
I've owned houses with outlets that had no ground because the person that put the outlets in couldn't be bothered, so they snipped the ground wire so that it was out of the way. Yeah, you plug stuff in and it would work, but would you trust the culprit to wire your house? And so on, and so on.
The summary is, I've seen enough half-assed work over the years (and some of it from "professionals" that people paid money for) that I do not trust people to use their own judgement. Do I think a license should be required to install a light switch? That's a different question. Are you going to trust the person that took a database class a few years ago to "use their own judgement as to whether they can do it sensibly or not" when it comes time to write the backend for your contact management system? I'll bet you they'd eventually deliver something that mostly works. Do you want to maintain it?
Individually, yes, you can expect people to act in their best interest. When doing things for others, not so much. Look at the #ventyourrent movement for examples of the way people are being treated in pursuit of profit -- not high rents, but the sheer number of landlords that either fail to maintain, or negligently maintain their properties in a way that puts tenants at risk.
The US has a serious problem with licensing and regulation, but that also seems to be a product of their litigious culture as a whole.
In a condo building though, I don't know how you can get around an HOA.
Condos pretty much have to have an association to manage them. You typically own the interior of the unit. The association owns the exterior and the land.
Which is exactly what I will do, because though I've been doing wiring of various sorts at a smaller scale since the '70s, I very much want someone double checking my plans and work. And this makes sense in many ways, e.g. there's about a foot separating my and my neighbor's garages, and while more between our houses, if mine were to catch fire, the fire department would have to earn their pay to keep it from catching on fire.
And echoing others, yeah, all people, pro and diy types, most certainly cannot be entirely trusted to do it right.
You might enjoy the long-running series of photo galleries called "Home Inspection Nightmares" on the "This Old House" site: http://www.thisoldhouse.com/toh/info/0,,20211283,00.html
But even though government intervention tried to cut risks, or to ban offensive activities, they still exist. Look at how many "hairdressers" from "Pakistan" are in the west, or how much "slavery" still exist although its illegal. Banning alcohol made it go into the underground route and made Capones rich.
The decline of western civilization is happening right now.
http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/06/22/155596305/episo...
A recent ruling negated the requirement:
http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/08/09/158498244/its-n...
So part of the ruling negating the requirement took into consideration that braiding had none of the associated threats to public health and safety. This sounds like things working as they should with regards to overreaching. It's a shame she had to shut down and sue, but the right call was made by the judge.
This person happened to be able to get the Institute for Justice behind her. Most lower class people do not. They simply get squeezed out, and a la Bastiat we never see them.
As for hair dyes, as long as you can buy these things in regular stores, and people generally not getting hurt by them, why would the specific act of putting it in your hair be so dangerous that special government licencing would be required?
It's easy for a bunch of high-achieving people to imagine that these requirements are all great and easy to follow, but there are people in this world who are never going to finish college but still know how to cut hair or cook food or arrange flowers for other people. These people seldom have any significant lobbying voice and when they are choked out you don't see them. You just have some honest person trying to provide honest labor and being told "no" by the nobility.
The people passing these licensure requirements should stop and think really hard about what it's like for a person of little means but with genuine interest to comply with them, and only make the requirements the minimum necessary to satisfy public safety.
I'm okay with that. A hair stylist shouldn't need to complete a cosmetology degree, as in that NPR story. But I would very much* like for them to have taken a test that, at some point, at least asks them if they're aware that you can spread certain diseases if you're not careful about what you do.
But when you set up in business the people paying you money need to know you're not incompetant and that you're not going to cause them chemical burns.
Some of the chemicals - (EG sodium hydroxide) - can be pretty harsh.
(I'm not sure the expensive US method of regulating hair dressers is correct, but it's not totally stupid to regulate people putting sodium hydroxide on your head)
Teenagers have bought sodium hydroxide and hydrogen peroxide and heaven know what other nasty chemicals and plastered it in their own and their friends hair at home for decades, and there's no epidemic of permanent disfigurement from chemical burns (if there was, we'd have people up in arms over these chemicals being sold freely).
In other words, the putative argument for requiring hair dressers licenses is solving a theoretical problem.
Before you start doing business with someone, spend a few seconds evaluating the place. Maybe get a recommendation. If it's busy, that's a lot of other people vouching for it, it's probably at least OK. If it's a repurposed lemonade stand in a back alley, it's probably not (even in a jurisdiction that requires licenses!). It's really just basic common sense.
Yeah, that is some requirement you made up. Just because you want your stylist to be regulated should have no bearing on me. Please keep your laws off my body.
I trust the average person to give safe haircuts 100/100 times.
If the hairdresser is noticeably disturbed or drugged, I'll be moving on. I can leave at any point in the process if I feel I am in danger.
Out of curiosity, I searched for haircut related deaths and they were all customers killing the hairdresser because they were upset about how they looked. Based on the actual danger, I would suggest licensing someone to receive a haircut may be the more effective method of increasing haircut safety.
It's easy to imagine that my kid wants to be a barber and so I could front the money for him to do whatever licensure requirements there are. But it's really hard for some poor person to hop through those same hoops, when all they are trying to do is earn an honest living by offering services for which people will give them money.
A lot of "well what's the harm in requiring hairdressers to take 100 hours of classes" are things which strictly benefit the middle- and upper-class (they aren't really going to notice paying 50 cents more for a haircut), but could really put the screws to the lower-class.
In my experience, it's a very lower-middle or lower socioeconomic status profession. The licensure requirements certainly haven't meant (in my experience) that we're limiting the field to wealthy people.
It probably could be better/easier, but again, given all the chemicals that get combined, the pace at which they work, and the sharp instruments, I don't think 2.5 weeks of fulltime training is unreasonable.
But if you're very lucky, the chemicals will kill the lice, and you'll be too worried about your new disease to be concerned about your hair!
"Hair stylists work with extremely sharp implements extremely close to major blood vessels."
Which implies something more than a knick on the skin that the injured customer then refuses to treat resulting in an infection.
1) Dyes/bleaches/etc. are often extremely dangerous industrial (as in, cannot be purchased easily at home) chemicals that used wrong could easily cause severe burns or at best an inhalation hazard.
2) Without properly cleaning cutting tools (scissors, clippers, razors, etc.) you run a high risk of spreading disease. With hair and nails the concern is often fungal, but if the last guy who got a buzz cut had lice you're in for a bad time if nobody cleans the clippers.
These are the crazy assholes, after all, that shut down businesses that do nothing but cornrow braiding for lack of licenses.
As for "the spread of disease", they aren't back-alley abdominal surgeons. The only disease that runs any real risk of being spread are lice... and there's no need to license that. Licenses don't help prevent that. Nor does anyone need 1400 hours of training to know how to identify them, or how to clean combs and brushes.
Sloppy people with licenses will still spread them, careful/clean people without licenses will never spread them. Enforce health codes instead of insisting on licenses that just put large barriers of entry in front of people trying to make a living.
Existing groups use licensing to shut out newcomers. They are largely anti-competitive, and anti-capitalistic.
The other is where unlicensed activities results in people dying. The outrage from such events often ends up with "license the people", so that Bad Things can't happen.
That's arguably a better approach, for mechanics, nuclear power technicians, etc. Perhaps even hairdressers, who work with toxic chemicals and need to know basic safety.
For me, the "health and safety" requirements make sense. Anything outside of that is typically anti-competitive, and likely rent-seeking.