Does it sound ridiculous? Yeah. Professional investors complain about people whose only qualification to invest is their bank account. They do realize they are investors right?
Well a dollar is a dollar, it doesn't have a brand. The scary thing to professional investors isn't dumb money and large valuations per se. It's the competition that gets the best deals just because it offers more money. How ironic.
To take a more nuanced opinion, I don't think the distinct is between dumb and smart money, but between branded and unbranded money. There is in fact somewhat of a "brand" for a dollar. If A16Z invests in you, their dollars have some built-in, unwritten-but-real future bonus in the professional VC circus that will pile onto your next deal. Some nobody can offer the same deal on paper today as A16Z, but it won't guarantee that brand-name pile on in a later investment. The question is, how often does the A16Z actually pay off in that future-bonus way, or how many VC firms actually provide a meaningful bonus in that way?
If the "Emirati home office" just offers more money up front, the branded dollar's future brand bonus is less valuable in comparison. This helps explain a firm like A16Z's increasingly generous (and preposterous) first investments. Increasing competition, not "dumb money," has negated a valuable competitive advantage American VC firms once had.
The weird thing about dumb money, unfortunately, is that it can act with
fiendish intelligence, insisting on stipulations that guarantee returns at
the expense of founders, employees and other investors.200 of what is supposed to be a rare phenomenon.
When the NYT starts talking about it you know the structure of the bubble is weak. Stories like this only popped up in the months before the housing crash. Prior to that all the stories were all about what a great investment real estate is.
Bubbles are odd things though, it could keep going until there are 400 unicorns, but I doubt it.
The NYT (together with all media) has been saying there's a bubble for years. They've written nearly 200 articles about this bubble between 2008 and 2015.
For example: http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2010/12/03/a-silicon-bubble-show...
There will always be naysayers. Plenty of people thought the notion of Facebook being worth even $50bn was ludicrous.
Bubbles exist, but so does growth. It's all but impossible to differentiate the two until after the fact.
That being said, we probably are in something of a bubble.
Dumb money is a hedge-funder who’s jealous of a V.C. Dumb money is sovereign wealth. Dumb money is an Emirati home office. Dumb money is a Facebook millionaire in a Maserati who wants to look like a player. Dumb money wants to get in on tech because it’s a box to check off. Dumb money isn’t in it for the long run. Dumb money doesn’t actually care about the technology. Dumb money doesn’t create value.