News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by js8 on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:00AM (#11690443)
A more interesting question would be why software programs, or databases, age and die. At some point, their own size and complexity will make them hard to change, and they will be left to slowly die.

When I was younger, I wanted to live forever. But now I came to believe that dying is actually good, for a similar reasons. As we age and learn, we become experts at many things, but at the cost of flexibility and speed of learning (this is actually expressed in myelin coating of synapses). So we need to have next generation of people starting from scratch, questioning everything, otherwise we would be stuck with the old ways of doing things.

So perhaps aging and death is an evolutionary adaptation, to changing conditions in our environment.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by fnbr on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:10AM (#11690506)
You're right, of course. However, I am extremely selfish, and while I agree with you, I can't help but think "yes, but not me."

Society might need death, but I still want to live forever.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by _yosefk on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:41AM (#11690657)
I'm selfish enough, but I'm not sure how enjoyable it would be once I reach 130, not to mention 1300, on the theory that even if much of the physical aging problem is solved, much of the mental aging problem will remain, and the same things making me increasingly mentally inflexible will make it all increasingly less fun.

I also think death is treated too seriously by people believing they're just a bunch of atoms but still thinking of themselves as an entity meaningfully separate from the rest of the world.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by zanny on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:47AM (#11690690)
We have had successful cryonic restoration of brain tissue in rabbits? I believe, and have also had successful brain transplants of mice.

I easily figure in the next 100 years we will accept cloning as a replacement for death. Simply duplicate the body, and transfer the brain, maybe throw in some extra gray matter to replenish what is lost through aging. Of course "throw in some extra gray matter" sells the complexity a bit short, but we are definitely on track to accomplish it.

I anticipate never having a 130 year old body. I would just replace mine with a genetically enhanced one at 60, and start over from ~15 (or honestly whatever the earliest age to insert a brain is). Almost anyone should be able to raise the money in ~30 years to pay to have another clone grown.

And from there you can iterate a few generations on first generation tech until we can manipulate the living brain into being able to learn like you are five again, hopefully without the negative side effects present in current brains of that capacity.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by WaltPurvis on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:45PM (#11692381)
> in the next 100 years we will accept cloning as a replacement for death. Simply duplicate the body, and transfer the brain

Cloning isn't the same thing as "Simply duplicat[ing] the body."

Cloning creates an embryo which turns into a human infant. Then you have to wait 18 years for it to mature before you can transfer the brain.

There's an insurmountable moral barrier to raising a fully conscious child to adulthood and then killing it so you can have its body.

Some commenters down-thread have suggested removing the infant's brain and raising it, without consciousness, in a vat of some sort.

Aside from the obvious difficulty and huge expense of maintaining a fantastical life-supporting "vat" for 18 years, it just simply wouldn't work.

Human beings require social interaction, and consciousness, to survive. An infant deprived of social interaction and environmental stimulation, and the consciousness to experience it obviously, would die. Animals also require physical interaction; our bones and muscles and senses can't develop properly in a vat, so you'd end up with, at best, a pathetic excuse for a body, totally unable to function in any way you'd enjoy, if your clone survived at all (which it wouldn't).

In short, this idea is both morally appalling and biologically ridiculous.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by wyager on Friday May 13, 2016 @09:13PM (#11694147)
The human body does not literally require social interaction to continue operating. That's just silly.

There are also ways to maintain muscles without normal exercise. Direct electro-stimulation is an easy approach.

There is no physical reason you couldn't grow a body without a brain. It's an engineering challenge.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by WaltPurvis on Saturday May 14, 2016 @10:42AM (#11696295)
>The human body does not literally require social interaction to continue operating. That's just silly.

I wasn't talking about you. I was talking about whether a human infant missing most of its brain and deprived of all social interaction, environmental stimulation, and physical activity would thrive and mature normally. It would not.

(Also, just for the record, there are things which aren't possible to do, no matter how many awesome engineers you have.)

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by wyager on Saturday May 14, 2016 @04:07PM (#11697825)
Obviously a body with no brain wouldn't do great. That's why you put the a brain in before you start using the body.

>(Also, just for the record, there are things which aren't possible to do, no matter how many awesome engineers you have.)

Yes, like break the laws of physics. Nothing proposed here does that.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Grishnakh on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:25PM (#11691763)
I can't imagine why you would need a cloned body. With the level of technology needed to make that work, you should just be able to rejuvenate the one you already have. The body is already self-repairing, the problem is that the aging process makes this mechanism faulty. That can be fixed. If your cells can easily grow and multiply from a zygote into a mature adult, there's no reason you can't fix the flaws which prevent total rejuvenation. It might require nanites though. But that still sounds easier than a brain transplant and then manipulating the brain to learn like a 5yo again.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by zanny on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:15PM (#11692584)
The later is surely science fiction, but brain transplants - which really, are just figuring out how to perfectly reconnect spinal tissue, which while incredibly hard is not something completely fictional since we have already done it in very reduced test cases (and we know that stem cells are likely going go give us an easy way eventually to just regrow the gaps in the spinal column) are not nearly as far out as nanites of the sophistication to modify organic cells are right now.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by antisthenes on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:27AM (#11690933)
What about the ethical issue of clones? Will clones be raised in vats without ever achieving consciousness?

If you have to raise your clone by yourself as another human being, who's to say which one of you deserves to keep living?

It all sounds so very nice in theory, but the reality might be that only the very rich and the elite will be able to afford to undergo such procedures, mainly because of the secrecy needed to essentially grow sacrificial human beings to maturity.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Bluestrike2 on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:30PM (#11691810)
Well, preferably you wouldn't be growing conscious clones. Ideally, you'd sabotage the brain's development so as to prevent consciousness from developing in the first place (keep the hindbrain, chuck the rest so to speak) or come up with a way to artificially control vital functions.

But don't worry. There are lots of other ethical concerns to focus on after you get rid of the conscious clone problem.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by zo1 on Friday May 13, 2016 @05:15PM (#11693286)
"Well, preferably you wouldn't be growing conscious clones. Ideally, you'd sabotage the brain's development so as to prevent consciousness from developing in the first place"

Arguably, if you're at that level of sophisticated biological manipulation, you're probably better-off simply growing the organs/replacement-parts/cells by themselves.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by wlievens on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:01PM (#11691577)
Affording rejuvenation would be paid for by your pension, because you wouldn't need that anymore.

Read the Commonwealth Saga by Peter F Hamilton

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by johnmaguire2013 on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:05AM (#11690785)
How does this affect overpopulation?
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by seren on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:29AM (#11690949)
Read a SF novel recently [0] where the rejuvenation treatment that you take periodically to extend your life indefinitely also makes you sterile temporarily. If you chose to have children (which is socially frowned upon), you must stop taking the treatment forever.

Not sure that we would be able to implement such a rationale solution, but at least it was pretty logical. The novel is essentially about the other grim decisions you have to take to have a constant population.

[0] This was in a book with multiple short stories from Paolo Bacigalupi. I believe this is Pump Six and Other Stories. Most of the novel are rather pessimistic, but at the same times sounds plausible enough to happen. I also recommend The Wind Up Girl from the same author.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by rsync on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11692328)
"Society might need death, but I still want to live forever."

This occurs in cell populations - the programmed self-death of cells (apoptosis) becomes corrupted and the individual cell acts selfishly (relative to the organism) and stays alive.

We have a word for this phenomenon and that word is "cancer".

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by abandonliberty on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:58PM (#11692463)
I enjoyed this metaphor even though it's a bit misleading.

Suspension of apoptosis is necessary, but not sufficient, for cancer. We have plenty of non-cancerous cells that rarely or never undergo apoptosis such as neurons or stem.

The implication that immortality = cancer does not follow.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by restalis on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:14PM (#11692572)
"The implication that immortality = cancer does not follow."

Indeed, cellular immortality may be cancer when it gets against apoptosis and it's just a natural thing when not. Cancer as well comprises a wider range of anomalous cellular developments that most often does not turn off the apoptosis. The metaphor however was about selfishness, on individual organism and cell level.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by developer2 on Saturday May 14, 2016 @07:39AM (#11695655)
>> Society might need death, but I still want to live forever.

I've never understood people who say they'd like to live forever. It just doesn't make any sense to me. The oddest thing is to listen to someone who talks about how it is - not probably or hopefully - going to happen in their lifetime. I once had an acquaintance who spoke of it so seriously that it was religious; he honestly believed (possibly still does) that he will not die.

You have the ones who are so absolutely terrified of death that they desperately grip onto the concept of immortality; a science fiction replacement for an afterlife or reincarnation they do not believe in. (Tangent: Why do so many people reject the idea of open casket funerals. Death is just too horrible to even observe, let alone having to reconcile that it will one day happen to them? "Think of the children" is a common argument, which is bullshit; perhaps such a large number of adults are so fearful exactly because they were never exposed to it.)

You have people who use the idea as a fantasy that someday they will do all the things they want to do, but don't have the time, money, or motivation to do today. This category is depressing, because I don't understand how someone can believe that an extended future would magically fix whatever is holding them back right now.

Then there are those who treat our species like a special little snowflake in the universe. That somehow being sentient with a consciousness is intrinsically deserving of cheating death - self-righteousness at the species level. That science can solve any problem, and not only will it be possible, but that it unequivocally should be done. "I think, therefore I am, and should forever be".

tldr; Death is, at least presently, inevitable. Get over it.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Faint on Sunday May 15, 2016 @07:22AM (#11700484)
I'm not afraid death. I wish to see, participate in, and develop the (if possible, far) future.

And yeah, I dream of the day I could do more far reaching stuff than what I do to pay the rent.

I see 2 pragmatic reasons for aging: enabling faster biological evolution, and escaping the lower performance/plasticity of older brain. We are at the brink of usefully being able to engineer human DNA and germ line. Once we get there (possibly not in my lifetime) - to the extent brain plasticity/performance can be kept up (and improved) - I see little reason for death through aging.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by stcredzero on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:38PM (#11691865)
Society might need death, but I still want to live forever.

Anyone who is sufficiently math literate should know that they're very unlikely to live forever. If there's some finite chance you're going to die each year, as you consider longer theoretical lifespans, the probability you'll die gets so close to 1, it's basically a certainty. Anyone who is sufficiently science literate should know that thermodynamics and the heat death of the universe precludes anyone living forever.

All that said, if you offered me a life-span boost to 250, 1000, or a million years, I'd take it!

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by dropit_sphere on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:57PM (#11692451)
"Even 500 would be pretty nice."
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by lawpoop on Sunday May 15, 2016 @12:58PM (#11701636)
I think that once all the people of my generation are dead, and all the people I can relate to, who had the same formative experiences I had are gone, I won't want to live much longer.

I think even if we engineer away death, you will still have the psychological structure from the "formative years" -- adolescence to early adulthood-- that sort of fundamentally make you personality-wise.

The songs and movies that gave you emotional experiences, the events that happened, etc. For me and my cohort it would be groups like Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Beck, and movies like Reality Bites and Pulp Fiction. These were the things that spoke to us as we were becoming adults.

It's not that those groups or movies mean much to me nowadays, but I feel that, socially, I am a peer with someone who lived through those years at the same age I did. It's not simply that we share the same cultural references, nor is it just that we happen to be the same age. I think rather that we were formed by the same events at that age and time.

If I live to be 230, I might feel somewhat disconnected from a 200-year-old, even as the age difference becomes relatively smaller and smaller, because that offset of 30 years made for a completely different formative experience. I'd still want to be friends with people who _get_ me.

My grandpa lived into his 90s. It got to the point where the children of his peers were dying. His main thing to do was read the obits and note how he knew that person. He had lots of family and friends, but no one could relate to his stories of old sports games, WWII, etc. etc. He was in good health and will mentally alert, but after my grandma died, it was just a matter of time. He died of a blood infection, no illness or anything.

So even if we can undo aging and death, we still might need to address the developmental process-- tweak it in some direction. Either have eternal formation, or re-formations-- something.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by ci5er on Friday May 13, 2016 @12:39PM (#11691405)
Cells that think like you do - we call 'cancer'.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by akvadrako on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:29PM (#11692257)
Maybe you can have it both ways. There is a good chance we live in some form of a multiverse and our experience depends on self locating uncertainty. The effect of this is big world immortality; we each live forever from our own perspective. There isn't scientific consensus on this yet, but my research and the simple logic behind it has convinced me enough to take it into account in my planning.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by arcameron on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:32PM (#11692281)
Can you elaborate on this please?
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by SpaceCadetJones on Friday May 13, 2016 @04:56PM (#11693194)
I'm probably getting this wrong since I haven't looked into it, but I think they're talking about the idea of an infinite number of universes that contain the totality of all that is possible. When one dies, they only cease to exist in that universe, but continue to exist in others.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by accounthere on Friday May 13, 2016 @12:56PM (#11691533)
I think it's fine if some people get to live as long as they want. Not all of us desire it and not all of us would make good use of it. The people that do it can then decide to stop whatever is helping them stay alive when they no longer want to. I see no downsides to this.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by crusso on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:31AM (#11690960)
Society doesn't "need" death.

It isn't a great leap to think that if we learn to alter our bodies at the nano/genetic level that we can handle our own evolution.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by eagsalazar2 on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:37PM (#11691860)
This is idealistic in the extreme. I think it could be easily argued that for our own sake and that of the environment we live in, humans could use more natural attrition, not less.

If we get to a point where large portions of our population are no longer oppressed or in poverty, where horrendous wars are largely a thing of the past, and we are already managing our population and environment in a healthy way -- then I'll be in your camp but right now we're doing exactly none of those things so, uh, no way getting rid of death is a good idea IMO.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by crusso on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:14PM (#11692576)
humans could use more natural attrition

What's your evidence that more attrition will create a greater society? If anything, greater longevity of people would allow for the accrual of more knowledge and wisdom. Living longer gives you a better long-term perspective. Give people a direct reason to care about what the environment will be like 150 years from now and maybe they'll care more about the CO2 they're putting out.

but right now

None of this is right now. We're right at the infancy of genetic manipulation. Even with the accelerating rate of technology growth, we won't understand our biology at a genetic level enough to be able to manipulate it in an everyday way for at least 50 to 150 years.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by rsync on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:51PM (#11692419)
"So we need to have next generation of people starting from scratch, questioning everything, otherwise we would be stuck with the old ways of doing things."

This is a very important concept - and one I would like to help illustrate with a thought experiment:

Think of the most liberal, progressive thinker[1] you can from the 19th century. I don't know ... Karl Marx ? Tolstoy ? Lincoln ? Whomever ...

Now, hold that thought ... and think of the most reactionary, "conservative", bigoted, old-fashioned public figure you can ... Mike Huckabee, perhaps ?

I will now suggest that Mike Huckabee, in almost every imaginable measure, is more progressive and liberal than (whomever you chose in step one). Mike Huckabees wife has worn pants. Mike Huckabee has spoken to a divorced woman in public. Mike Huckabee has probably used birth control.[2]

See how fast that happened ? In less than 200 years, the political window has shifted far enough that the most reactionary, right wing member in 2016 is more liberal and more progressive than the most liberal and progressive figures from the prior period.

How will that work if people from 200 (or 300 or 400) years ago are not only still around, but presumably well funded with vast stores of capital ?

[1] let's limit it to very well known, universally recognized figures...

[2] Ok, I'm not sure about that one, but you get the point ...

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by dropit_sphere on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:55PM (#11692436)
The neoreactionaries flip it the other way; they would shove this thought experiment in the faces of "conservatives" and say, "Haven't you, by any reasonable measure, failed utterly and completely in achieving any of your political goals? Do you have any reason to believe this will change in the future?"
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by reasonattlm on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:17AM (#11690534)
The evolution of aging is an arms race to the bottom. Very few species can succeed without aging once any competitors evolve aging, and this happened very early on. Here is thinking on "we age because the world changes." Of course what is great for evolutionary success has nothing to do with what is great for the individual, and the two should not be confused.

http://arxiv.org/abs/1103.4649

"Understanding why we age is a long-lived open problem in evolutionary biology. Aging is prejudicial to the individual and evolutionary forces should prevent it, but many species show signs of senescence as individuals age. Here, I will propose a model for aging based on assumptions that are compatible with evolutionary theory: i) competition is between individuals; ii) there is some degree of locality, so quite often competition will between parents and their progeny; iii) optimal conditions are not stationary, mutation helps each species to keep competitive. When conditions change, a senescent species can drive immortal competitors to extinction. This counter-intuitive result arises from the pruning caused by the death of elder individuals. When there is change and mutation, each generation is slightly better adapted to the new conditions, but some older individuals survive by random chance. Senescence can eliminate those from the genetic pool. Even though individual selection forces always win over group selection ones, it is not exactly the individual that is selected, but its lineage. While senescence damages the individuals and has an evolutionary cost, it has a benefit of its own. It allows each lineage to adapt faster to changing conditions. We age because the world changes."

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by tomp on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:28AM (#11690589)
Why would survival of older individuals be in any way detrimental to the species' success? In the absence of aging, organisms living longer simply means that they are still sufficiently-well adapted to the environment. When the environment changes beyond what they can adapt to, they die off and (hopefully at least parts of) the new(er) generation will carry on.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by dasil003 on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:07AM (#11690793)
Because we are social creatures and there are still limited resources. Older generations have outsized influence on the tribe based on their experience which can drag the rest down.

For a contemporary example, consider the real estate bubble. When the bubble burst and everyone realized how badly the banks had screwed up, what happened? Well, everyone who owned a home worried about losing its value. The banks took some stock off the market to hide it, and all the leadership up to the president vowed to do everything possible to "maintain real estate values", even though the "value" was predicated on sub-prime mortgages that people couldn't actually afford.

In this way, the older generation whose experience is tied to a particular environment exerts its influence in a way that damages the younger population. Being young and inexperienced means being adaptable but naive and inefficient, being old and wise means knowing how things work and a vested interest in keeping them that way.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by aetherson on Friday May 13, 2016 @02:17PM (#11692160)
Aging is present in non-social species.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by dasil003 on Friday May 13, 2016 @06:25PM (#11693599)
There's still limited resources up for competition within the species.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by fossuser on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:55AM (#11690736)
Speculating - older individuals take resources and even if they were continuing to reproduce advancement comes through successive generations of genetic mixing. It's probably advantageous for the species if an individual has a child (mixing up genetic code) and then that child has children while the parent dies.

Otherwise you might have less biodiversity which may make the species less adaptable overtime (and maybe lose to another species with aging).

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by BurningFrog on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:50AM (#11690711)
That was valid in the old world.

Now we're on the verge of human assisted gene design vastly outperforming natural evolution.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by adrianN on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:27AM (#11690586)
Negligible senescence does not mean immortality. You still get eaten or die in other accidents. There are a number species that show this trait.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence

So I don't really buy that argument.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by reasonattlm on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:49AM (#11690706)
Immortality has a specific meaning here, which is that risk of death due to intrinsic causes does not increase over time. This is distinct from negligible senescence, which is more a case of few manifestations of aging until very late life.

Immortality seems to be the case for hydra, for example. (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22689361)

Immortality is also observed for flies in late life (http://discovermagazine.com/2001/may/breakdialogue). They have a very high mortality rate at that point, but it doesn't increase further over time. That doesn't seem to be the case for humans, though, based on the very sparse data for people at extreme old age.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Ericson2314 on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:19PM (#11691712)
Human cancer cells are another interesting example besides hydras.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by kv85s on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:58AM (#11691126)
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Max_Planck

often summarized as "Science advances one funeral at a time."

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by javajosh on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:22PM (#11691736)
This is a non-trivial benefit of mortality. Not just in science, but in politics too. Wouldn't it be horrible if, oh, Genghis Kahn was still alive and in charge? Death may limit the good that some people do, but it limits the bad that people do, too, and roughly speaking it seems to be worth the trade-off. Even the most ruthless dictator of the most powerful, untouchable empire will eventually fall to entropy.

(One of the reasons _1984_ is such a nightmare was not it's cruelty and horror, but it's all-too-believable stability, even with human mortality. Orwell's appendix gives a ray of hope, however, when he discusses the fact that human language itself would, in the long run, prevent even that world from continuing indefinitely.)

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:53PM (#11691976)
> but it's all-too-believable stability, even with human mortality. Orwell's appendix gives a ray of hope, however, when he discusses the fact that human language itself would, in the long run, prevent even that world from continuing indefinitely.

Makes me think of stackoverflow for some reason.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by philh on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:23PM (#11691744)
I'm willing to slow down science, in exchange for the lives of everyone on earth.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Retra on Friday May 13, 2016 @07:18PM (#11693823)
This a probably true as a matter of status quo, but it is not necessitated by anything. Science advances because it is designed to advance. It just advances faster when social power cycles regularly.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by BurningFrog on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:48AM (#11690700)
I'd prefer to find a way to clean off myelin coating over embracing death.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by civilian on Friday May 13, 2016 @04:59PM (#11693210)
One of Heinlein's books plays with this concept. There's a Martian race that are essentially immortal, at least from natural causes. Every 40-50 years they go through a change and become childlike for 5 years. Lack of awareness, playfulness, no interest in sex, and an emotional state that changes quickly. It's explained that it's how they are able to rejuvenate themselves.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by ewzimm on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:27AM (#11690932)
Or better yet engineer a more efficient replacement for the central nervous system. 100 years in the future at increasing rates of technological development, it seems very likely that we could engineer a substance that could interface with the brain to augment it and eventually replace it seemlessly with no jarring loss of consciousness.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by mrfusion on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:06AM (#11690481)
Unless there's also a way to reset your brain to a younger state.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by js8 on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:23AM (#11690906)
This also a reply to similar comment about "cleaning myelin".

The big question here is (to which I allude in my comment): How do you control the "resetting" process, so that you wouldn't lose the information that you consider important? I simply don't think there is a good way to do it.

We already have a way to be immortal - have kids and teach them what you know and think is important. Which is an arduous and complicated process; I don't think this "myelin cleaning" or whatever will be any easier.

I don't think I want this reset. It may mean you become entirely different person, or your memories get lost. Let's say you and your wife resets, and forget most memories you have of each other, pretty much why you're together. Or you reset and you become a different person to your kids, and they become different to you.

I personally find either having kids, or teaching (if you can't have kids for whatever reason), a more interesting proposition than some magical procedure that will clean my brain. If anything, it sounds really irresponsible to your future self - kinda like leaving your kids in the forest to take care of themselves.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by sedachv on Friday May 13, 2016 @12:27PM (#11691315)
> I don't think I want this reset. It may mean you become entirely different person, or your memories get lost. Let's say you and your wife resets, and forget most memories you have of each other, pretty much why you're together. Or you reset and you become a different person to your kids, and they become different to you.

This already exists in the forms of psychedelic drugs and transcranial magnetic stimulation. There is no memory loss, you just start thinking and feeling about things differently. It can and does lead to divorce and changes in relationships to relatives: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/03/18/an-experimental-aut...

This is not at all the downside you portray it to be. Many people use these methods to change or leave dysfunctional relationships.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by nathan_f77 on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:39AM (#11691015)
I would much rather lose important information, and perhaps experience many different lifetimes, than simply dying and not existing at all.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by fnovd on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:50AM (#11691077)
The person you are right now will be dead in 20 years. In its place will be a person who has access to some of your more important memories as well as the resources you have made available for it. After a long enough period of time, the difference between wiping your own brain and starting over vs having children will be small.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by sievebrain on Friday May 13, 2016 @10:15AM (#11690527)
Or unless retirement is legally enforced, voids voting rights and lasts forever, so people past a certain age are prevented from having any influence (except to the extent that they can persuade other people using their wisdom and experience).

Quite how that'd work economically though, I have no idea.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by aantix on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:10AM (#11690811)
tDCS has been shown to help with neuroplasticity.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by Retra on Friday May 13, 2016 @07:16PM (#11693810)
"Aging" is what costs you flexibility and speed. If you reverse aging, you'll maintain your flexibility and speed.

Moreover, aren't you assuming that we couldn't possibly manage loss of flexibility? Even if most people are inflexible because they've aged, this doesn't prohibit them from having a base level of flexibility and thus find a workaround for whatever limitation you're imagining this imposes.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by pvg on Friday May 13, 2016 @12:26PM (#11691306)
How is that question more interesting or even related to they key question in biology the article discusses?
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by dengnan on Friday May 13, 2016 @11:49PM (#11694486)
I think they are different topics under different environment. Software changes, a lot, over time. You can hardly recognize a software's source code if you don't touch them for a decade. The features changed, new features added, old features deprecated, etc. On the other hand, over the life time of a person, their DNA will not be changed dramatically. What their cells need to do is just an exactly copy of its genes. There won't be a case where one person needs to grow a third arm, while in software world, we constantly change requirements.

Software evolves more like the evolution of a species: Small changes over time to adapt the ever changing environment.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by wapapaloobop on Friday May 13, 2016 @01:21PM (#11691730)
>we become experts at many things, but at the cost of flexibility and speed of learning

It's partly because you are an expert at a unique combination of many things that you have great irreplaceable value. This is threatened by aging diseases even before you die.

Also I don't think that more knowledge makes it harder to learn. This would be true if knowledge was purely about breadth. However it's really about explanatory depth, and depth ultimately wins. For instance, your mind has formed many connections between those aforementioned different fields of expertise, and some of these ideas reach into yet more fields.

Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by make3 on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:04PM (#11692508)
yeah, if dying wasn't a thing anymore, we would need to at the very least boost the brain plasticity of everyone by quite a lot, or we would be facing a complete stop in the progress of societal values. We would still have slaves probably, for exemple, and racism would be much crazier.
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by ajcarpy2005 on Friday May 13, 2016 @03:47PM (#11692774)
Death is why we get stuck in the old ways of doing things. I mean death of passion, dreams, soul...
Re:Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable by alanwatts on Friday May 13, 2016 @04:00PM (#11692855)
Passions and dreams are dynamic, not static. If one "dies" you can find a new one