News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by keithflower on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:05PM (#11647340)
Note to tech world: THIS is how you take responsibility, make things right when mistakes happen, and look out for the communities we live in.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by lemming on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:28PM (#11648258)
It's good to see the apology, it's very well written and dang has seemed consistently genuine throughout this process. My respect for him has increased because of this episode, and I think he does a great job shepherding HN.

I wish I could say the same for YC. Kevin's post about why Maciej wasn't accepted was a textbook example of the sort of thinking that leads to the terrible lack of diversity we have in tech. Nothing about this changes that. 20k is relatively little money for both YC and Maciej, it's nice to see it go to what looks like a worthy cause but it doesn't really address the core issue at all.

The arguments about diversity in tech are normally framed in terms of race, gender, sexual orientation etc. But in this case the issue was in diversity of ideas relating to startups. I think Maciej makes some very compelling arguments that the sort of model that YC promotes is seriously flawed, and was basically rejected because of that. I think his arguments are ones that many young entrepreneurs should hear.

If you replace the first couple of sentences of Kevin's post with "The simple answer is that ${the woman | the black person | the gay person} was clearly the best candidate, but just made me feel uncomfortable in the end. It’s touchy feely, I know, but the truth." they could have been successfully sued, and for good reason. Think of the 20k as settling out of court.

I generally agree with Maciej's assessment of the startup world, and it's sad to have one of my major prejudices about it confirmed so clearly. My estimation of YC has definitely sunk even lower after this.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by thenomad on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:11AM (#11658654)
Do you have a link to Kevin's post and Maciej's responses at all? I (and I suspect a lot of other readers) completely missed all this, and whilst I'm not very interested in the drama, I am interested in the points you bring up in this post.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by exolymph on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:40PM (#11661616)
Here's the thread you're looking for: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11633517
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by jlarocco on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:22PM (#11648061)
I don't know if this is such a great example.

The right thing to do seemed pretty obvious, and it would have been easier to just give it to Pinboard in the first place. The skeptical view here is that they're only fixing things because they were so vocally called out for screwing up.

So yeah, taking responsibility is great, but doing the wrong thing and taking responsibility only you're called out for it, isn't so great. When possible, just do the right thing in the first place.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by santoshalper on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:29PM (#11648081)
You have to give people a path to get apologize and get better. Sometimes, it takes getting yelled at to realize that you are wrong. That doesn't make the learning any less real.

Otherwise, we just live in a world where everybody demonizes each other and we are knives out all the time. Oh, wait...

You can't ask for much more than a full apology and an offer to make it right. This was as good as we can expect to get.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by jlarocco on Friday May 06, 2016 @11:59PM (#11648329)
I'm not sure I agree with that in general. There should be negative consequences for doing the wrong thing. Companies shouldn't be able to do whatever they want and say "Oops, our bad! Look how awesome we are for owning up to it!" Otherwise there's no motivation to do better in the future.

I'm not saying YC should go out of business, or YC funded companies should be boycotted or anything like that, but some negative publicity is well deserved. The parent comment seemed to be sweeping the whole thing under the rug.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by vidarh on Saturday May 07, 2016 @06:35AM (#11649075)
The consequence is closer scrutiny next time, and less likelihood of "getting off" as easily next time.

Being allowed to go "oops, our bad" every time would have bad consequences, I agree. Being able to go "oops, our bad" every now and again because you usually do ok is another matter entirely.

One of the incentives to do good can very well be that it makes you more likely to get off easy when something occasionally goes wrong - it's good insurance.

It boils down to trust: You get off easy with a "oops, our bad" when people believe it is a genuine, occasional mistake, rather than a regular case of "shit, they caught us, better backpedal".

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by fiatjaf on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:31PM (#11647479)
If you have the money to give.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by dredmorbius on Friday May 06, 2016 @07:44PM (#11647531)
No, the money was pledged regardless. Maciej said how he'd like it bestowed, and HN have followed his request. The money wasn't in question.

Owning the problem was in question, and HN owned it.

[dead]
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by Alex3917 on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:05PM (#11648019)
> he wanted a different outcome and he is still so dishonest

Not only is this completely inappropriate and unwarranted, but it's doubly so because you're taking advantage of dang and kevin acting professionally to misrepresent the situation.

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by SherlockeHolmes on Saturday May 07, 2016 @05:20AM (#11648939)
I don't see many coming to Pinboard founder's defense when he is being accused of fraud.

acting professional strikes at the core of what went wrong here, at why so many are antagonized by the tech culture despite the enormous value it has already generated, and partly at why the yuga that is ending has been the worst of the four in cycle.

be human, don't act professional. how? self actualize.

edit: down vote made me realize my first line was a personal attack. changed "you" to "many"

Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by scott_s on Friday May 06, 2016 @10:12PM (#11648038)
dang is one of the kindest, most thoughtful people I have ever spoken with.
Re:Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision by chris_wot on Saturday May 07, 2016 @11:09AM (#11649858)
I agree. Calling anyone "human garbage" deserves a ban from HN until a full apology is made. This sort of appalling attitude I think we can do without!