News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Animats on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:15PM (#11621931)
The ad blocking business is getting too cozy with the advertising business. Time to disrupt it again.

The Adblock people claim they're going to collect a half billion dollars a year in voluntary payments. Has anybody in the history of voluntary payments for software ever collected half a billion dollars? The American Red Cross collects about $700 million a year. Somehow, I expect that Adblock's system will not be "voluntary".

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Spivak on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:28PM (#11622065)
There's, at this point, nothing to worry about. The insanely dedicated people who maintain the ad blocking lists are the real heroes here, the client that uses them is completely replaceable.

If/When ABP goes over to the dark side people will stop using it. There are plenty of replacements, uBlock Origin being the current winner.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:54PM (#11622316)
ABP already is part of the dark side with their "acceptable ads." It boggles the mind why a program whose sole purpose is to block ads would not do so out of the box.

Anyone who hasn't yet switched to uBlock Origin should do so ASAP. It's super fast, has a much smaller memory footprint, has a strict policy against "acceptable ads" (https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/blob/master/MANIFESTO.md), licensed under the GPLv3, and hosted in a very active repository on GitHub (https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock).

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:11PM (#11622452)
> ABP already is part of the dark side with their "acceptable ads." It boggles the mind why a program whose sole purpose is to block ads would not do so out of the box.

I actually like the acceptable ads system. I don't inherently object to advertising (content has to be paid for somehow, and I'd rather pay with my attention than with my money). I just object to invasive or distracting ads, and ABP does block those.

Google Search ads, for example, are fine by me.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by sidko on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:31PM (#11623079)
Be careful with malware ads on Google Search. This happens fairly regularly, and in some cases can mean a direct loss of money, e.g. if you search for 'blockchain', instead of the online Bitcoin wallet showing up, Google ads often points to a malware that is a phishing site and occasionally people fall for it and lose all their Bitcoins [1]. This has been going on for a long time [2][3].

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/27j1gd/i_had_53_bt...

[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2pm4tx/blockchaini...

[3] https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4e99po/blokchalini...

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:36PM (#11623107)
I never actually click on Google Search ads.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by belorn on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:11PM (#11624271)
You can't pay for content if you don't click on the ads and buy something. Companies spend money on advertisement in order to increase sales, and if there isn't an increase in sale, they stop paying the content creators for providing ad space.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by bduerst on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:40PM (#11625111)
Search ads aren't the same as programmatic or display ads.

The latter supplements publishers (websites) with revenue that covers the cost of providing content to you. Search ads are typically acquisition driven, where companies are paying for new customers.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by andrepd on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:25PM (#11625319)
The above scam isn't targeted at you, or anyone of the sort of people that frequent HN.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Animats on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:02PM (#11624604)
Search Google with "credit card". Everything above the fold is a Google ad.

Five years ago, searching for "credit card" had top hits from credit card search spammers. Today, Google has brought that spam in-house and redirected the revenue to themselves. It's kind of depressing.

(We, of course, have Ad Limiter, to cut Google search ads down to size.)

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by raddad on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:25AM (#11628123)
>Five years ago, searching for "credit card" had top hits from credit card search spammers.

20 years ago it would have taken scrolling through several pages of porn to get to anything resembling a card. I do not miss those days at all.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:27PM (#11622603)
The "acceptable ads" initiative is how the company behind ABP makes money. It is their primary revenue driver and is the primary differentiator from other products on the market.

Yet, they choose to name their product in a misleading way, suggesting they do something which, by default, their product does not do.

If ABP was a drug, what would the FDA say? :)

We all know that outside tech circles most people don't even know what "acceptable ads" are, assume ABP does what it says on the label, and don't bother changing defaults. That's why ABP's business is so shady.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:51PM (#11625167)
The FDA would do nothing. All drugs have side effects and many drugs are taken for "off label use".
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:38PM (#11622683)
How does something generating revenue automatically make it immoral or unacceptable?

Pharmaceutical companies generate their revenue from selling drugs. That doesn't make selling drugs illegal.

Nobody is getting tricked by ABP. For one thing, their homepage literally says "unobtrusive ads aren't being blocked in order to support websites" right above the install button. [0] Moreover, even if a user were to install it and still saw ads they would realize that it's not in fact blocking all ads.

Since you apparently hate capitalism, I'm curious how you're paid.

[0] https://adblockplus.org/

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Karunamon on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:07PM (#11623334)
Nobody is getting tricked by ABP.

I'd be surprised to learn most users ever even touch the homepage, rather than the plugin installation mechanism for their respective web browsers. Result #1 on Google for me goes straight to the Chrome store.

The immorality comes in when the program actively subverts its own purpose for existing... imagine an antivirus with "acceptable viruses" allowed out of the box. They don't steal your info, or ruin your computer, but its authors gave the company a backhander to leave them unblocked by default. This is directly analogous to ads.

It's also a conflict of interest, and gives the developer a perverse incentive to allow more ads, since they charge ad publishers actual money to be on the whitelist. ABP's customers are the ad companies, not its users. (Something something if you're not the customer...)

And "hating capitalism" is such a ridiculous strawman that it deserves no further comment.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Johnny555 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:02PM (#11624219)
_ The immorality comes in when the program actively subverts its own purpose for existing_

Depends on what you think its purpose is -- I don't block ads because I have a moral problem with advertising revenue paying for content I view -- I block ads because I'm tired of overly disruptive ads that interfere with my web browsing experience. I really don't mind if there are some unobtrusive ads and I might even click on them if they are particularly relevant (i.e. Google ads tend to be relevant enough that I click on them).

_ It's also a conflict of interest, and gives the developer a perverse incentive to allow more ads,_

But AdBlock devs have a strong incentive to not piss off users so much that they'll stop running the software or will click the button that says "block all ads". If developers remove that button, then users will move to different software.

I don't care how much money ABP makes from publisher payouts, I just care that my browser no longer freezes while I wait for a 2MB pop-over to load as it chews up my limited bandwidth.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Retric on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:17PM (#11622975)
Not OP, but I do things that people pay money for. I find advertising degrading and avoid it where possible. The real issue is most online content is terrible and not worth paying for.

Worse even when I do pay, the ads don't go away. (Hulu, premium cable TV, etc.) Because, it's the people with money that subsidize the Advertising model, let them opt out and it collapses.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by andrepd on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:33PM (#11625348)
Evidently, and as I'm very sure you completely understood but chose to disregard in order to go on a tirade, the above poster wasn't objecting to revenue making in itself, but to the fact that the way that this ad-blocker makes its money is by (ironically), displaying ads. Most non tech people instantly associate ad-blocking software with AdBlock Plus, and don't even realize that the software they are installing made a deal with certain companies to let their ads through. Your tirade against "those damn anti-american commies" (hyperbole but that was the gist of it) makes no sense at all.

Since you're apparently hate reading and replying to comments as they were written, instead of as you want to read into them, I paraphrase the above poster:

"We all know that outside tech circles most people don't even know what "acceptable ads" are, assume ABP does what it says on the label, and don't bother changing defaults. That's why ABP's business is so shady."

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:40PM (#11623133)
I don't hate capitalism and there's nothing wrong with generating revenue. In fact, the rise of ad blocking is a perfect example of market efficiency. What's important here isn't the software that blocks ads, but the expression of preference by hundreds of millions of people around the world who say "we do not want to see ads on the web and we know they can be stopped."

Believing "acceptable ads" can thrive alongside such knowledge is naively asking to be reminded of the tragedy of the commons and the fact that such widespread coordination usually happened in either dictatorial or communist societies.

Revenue will be generated, only that it will eventually have to come from consumers directly to publishers and content creators.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by bduerst on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:43PM (#11624838)
>the rise ad blocking is a perfect example of market efficiency

No it isn't - it's market inefficiency. Ad blocking allows content consumption without contributing to costs, which publishers have budgeted for. Flattr and Google Contributor are more efficient versions of blocking ads because it still contributes to content.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:56PM (#11623252)
You seem to hate capitalism because your argument against ABP was basically "they get revenue."

ABP is in fact a capitalist solution. It gives advertisers an incentive to tone down their ads so they can be seen by more people.

Absolutist ad blockers are actually the ones exploiting the tragedy of the commons. Without advertising, the content which you're viewing without ads would not exist.

> Revenue will be generated, only that it will eventually have to come from consumers directly to publishers and content creators.

Why? That's your personal preference and political position. Reality isn't forced to adapt to your preferences and in practice advertising has existed for thousands of years—it's unlikely to go away anytime soon.

Moreover, I suspect that if you asked most people outside the HN echo chamber they'd actually rather have advertising than paying through subscriptions.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by nitrogen on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:22PM (#11623458)
You seem to hate capitalism because your argument against ABP was basically "they get revenue."

This is a very disingenuous representation of the other comments in the thread. It's a low-brow dismissal by straw man and an appeal to the sacrosanct "capitalism". You seem to be trying to manipulate others into supporting your view by labeling the other view as anti-capitalism. This is the same as accusing anyone who opposes government surveillance of "hating freedom".

ABP is problematic because of how they generate revenue. From the advertisers' side, it looks like racketeering. From the consumer side, it looks like the tobacco industry paying your doctor to get you to smoke. Accepting money to whitelist ads is the very thing an ad blocker should never do.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by hartpuff on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:22PM (#11623006)
Is ABP being paid by the advertisers whose ads they're allowing? I honestly don't know. But it's unlikely they're blocking ads they're being paid to show.

> Since you apparently hate capitalism, I'm curious how you're paid.

Is advertising a synonym of capitalism?

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by jlarocco on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:54PM (#11622812)
If a person wants to use an ad-blocker and then opt-in to ads then that's their choice.

But the default should be to block ads, because that's what an ad-blocker is supposed to do.

ABP allowing ads by default is just another one of the reasons uBlock Origin is better.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by perlpimp on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:35PM (#11625081)
acceptable ad by me is a bit of text and maybe an image I can click on if the context is right and I have a coinciding interest. Please no JS/FLASH etc stuff on your page.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by andrepd on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @08:38PM (#11625368)
Exactly. On a thread some time ago on the topic of ad-blockers, someone said something of the sort "The internet is a pull medium, not a push medium. I don't block ads, I just decline to request them and run their code on my machine"
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by coldpie on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:09PM (#11622443)
I've never understood the backlash against the acceptable ads program. They state clearly what policies the ads must adhere to, and review them manually for compliance. Sure, if viewing absolutely no advertising is important to you, then you'll want to turn that feature off or use a different client. But why do you think they're part of the "dark side" for trying to encourage inoffensive ads?
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:16PM (#11622499)
Because of the default setting that shows ads in a program called "ad block."
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by basch on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:51PM (#11622782)
good thing they didnt name it "completely ad block"
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by dghughes on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:28PM (#11623958)
I prefer "Sorta Ad-Block, Kinda".
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by cr1895 on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @11:18AM (#11628949)
Ad Block Plus (ads)
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by coldpie on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:23PM (#11622570)
Your definition of "dark side" seems borderline sociopathic.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:32PM (#11622642)
Both the Interactive Advertising Bureau and Ghostery accused ABP of extortion due to their business practices.

A program that labels itself as an "ad blocker" yet allows, by default, ads from companies who pay money, is part of the dark side.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by krapp on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:29PM (#11622621)
>I've never understood the backlash against the acceptable ads program.

Simply put, many people believe there is no such thing as an acceptable ad on the web, and that any ad blocker which allows advertising to be shown is by definition malicious, broken software. No advertising, anywhere, at any time, under any circumstances, regardless of the content, or how badly a site depends on it, is acceptable to users of ad blockers. They expect it to block ads, period.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:39PM (#11622694)
> No advertising, anywhere, at any time, under any circumstances, regardless of the content, or how badly a site depends on it, is acceptable to users of ad blockers.

I'm a user of an ad blocker (ABP). Don't put words in my mouth.

I believe in compensating creators for their content and would rather compensate them with my time than my money.

Don't lump everyone into your political agenda.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Gracana on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:52PM (#11622788)
"Many people," not "literally everyone, especially HN user 'morgante.'"

I'm certainly in the "fuck all ads forever" camp. There are just way too many downsides to downloading/seeing/playing/executing advertisements. If all the websites that relied on ads today had to disappear or redesign to reduce their operational costs, I think the web would be a much better place.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by manigandham on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:33PM (#11623531)
> I think the web would be a much better place.

Except it wouldnt. Only state-sponsored media and paywalls would exist, which won't be fun.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by krapp on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @04:01PM (#11623737)
Paywalls would probably be a more stable revenue model than advertising. Everyone else would have make money some other way, but alternatives (like Patreon) already exist.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by CaptSpify on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:39PM (#11624453)
Before ads on the web, we had tons of non-state-sponsored sites without pay-walls. I see no reason it would deteriorate into that.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by manigandham on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:43PM (#11624477)
When exactly was this "before ads on the web" period of history?

I hear this a lot but there was just a very small early period where a few enthusiasts were on bulletin boards (and definitely not "tons of sites").

As soon as the web was mainstream and had any appreciable amount of content, there were ads right alongside.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by DanBC on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:58PM (#11624585)
1996 and earlier. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercialization_of_the_Inter...

> Prior to the disestablishment 1995 commercial traffic on the Internet in the United States was limited by law, and prior to 1988 for the most part strictly forbidden, with the exception of traffic with research and defense aims.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by manigandham on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @07:41PM (#11625115)
There were ads on the internet before 1996. Most ISPs had them in their portals and directories.

Also the first cross-network banner ad ran in October 1994: https://hbr.org/2013/02/stop-selling-ads-and-do-someth

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @06:14PM (#11624678)
Yes, there were and will always be amateurs and forums. Plenty of content is produced by people whose job is not to produce content.

Nobody was getting their news from the web in that era though. People still subscribed to print newspapers and magazines.

Content has moved online. Of course revenue had to move online as well (including advertising).

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by CaptSpify on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @09:28PM (#11625538)
> Nobody was getting their news from the web in that era though

ummm.... Actually a lot of people were. It just ended up being blogs, forums and other methods.

Personally, most of the news I read comes from "non-news" sources. I find the vast majority of news-sites to be terrible in quality.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by krapp on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:52PM (#11622794)
I believe you're in the extreme minority when it comes to ad block users.

The web was always presented as being free - the content was free, the browsers were free, the community that built it believed information wanted be free. Most people don't want to compensate anyone for anything on the web by viewing ads because they've been conditioned to expect that they shouldn't have to - they simply see advertising as a nuisance. Until recently when sites started detecting ad-blockers, there was no negative effect to blocking it.

I do believe advertising doesn't work on the web, but mostly because of the way the web was designed and implemented, not entirely because of politics. Content creators can't expect to be compensated through web ads as long as they can't stop users from viewing their content without the ads. At least with other forms of media, you're expected to pay before you consume, or viewership is estimated, so the effect of avoiding advertising isn't so direct, but on the web, every view counts.

Given the poor reputation (entirely deserved) of web ads, the degree of control users have over their browsers, and the number of people who view piracy and ad-blocking as a moral imperative, alongside the majority who just consider ads to be annoying and useless for them, it's simply not possible for advertising as a revenue model to work on the web. The number of people who consider "ethical" or "acceptable" ads to even be a thing isn't large enough to support the web's economy.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by gorhill on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:06PM (#11622899)
> I believe in compensating creators for their content and would rather compensate them with my time than my money.

But there is money involved, a lot of 3rd parties inserting themselves between you and the creators are getting paid real money (Eyeo, through its "acceptable ads" campaign, is such a 3rd-party).

Surely that money is not created out of thin air, hence the question: where is this money coming from ultimately?

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by morgante on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @02:16PM (#11622967)
> Surely that money is not created out of thin air, hence the question: where is this money coming from ultimately?

It's coming from advertisers, obviously. Unlikely so many on Hacker News, I don't think advertisers are inherently immoral and horrible people. I'm happy for them to pay for content and the technology to deliver that content.

Ironically, in this system the advertisers are actually subsidizing the blocking of non-compliant ads. That seems ideal: advertisers are competing to provide quality ads and to block poor ones.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by untog on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:12PM (#11622462)
> It boggles the mind why a program whose sole purpose is to block ads would not do so out of the box.

Well, maybe the purpose of that particular program is to block awful, obstructive, auto-playing ads, but allow sensible levels of advertising to support web sites.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by raddad on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @09:18AM (#11628062)
>Anyone who hasn't yet switched to uBlock Origin should do so ASAP.

I looked at it, I tried it, I love it so far. I added uMatrix(1) and uBlock Origin Websocket(2). Now I just need to read the documentation to get the full advantage(3).

(1) https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix

(2) https://github.com/gorhill/uBO-WebSocket

(3) To RTFM; https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by jessriedel on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:54PM (#11622322)
> The insanely dedicated people who maintain the ad blocking lists are the real heroes here, the client that uses them is completely replaceable.

Who are these people and why do they do it? The wikipedia article on uBlock Origin didn't help much.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by kozhevnikov on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:09PM (#11622439)
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Fundlab on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:29PM (#11622083)
Is it impossible to deliver ads natively ie serve ads directly from the publisher's platform instead of 3rd party?

How do you skirts ad blocking applications without triggering an inconvenience on your readers?

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by losteric on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:55PM (#11622328)
Ads themselves are an inconvenience on readers.

It's possible for a website owner to directly publish ads, and those ads would be harder to block (but still trivial). Site owners trade screen real estate in exchange for ad revenue, just like billboards of old. This used to be the model in the early 2000s and I actually OK with it... though it probably wasn't the best model, a bit like running a diner on revenue from ads in the menu.

The problem is centralized publishers. They offer higher revenue through highly targeting ads from thousands of advertisers. It's a race to the bottom where all websites are incentivized to use publishers and consumers are forced to use ad blocking tools against the publishers (hurting content creators)... undermining the long-term sustainability of the internet as a content publishing medium.

As with many things, both consumers and producers are acting justifiably. It's the man in the middle that needs to go. He's just skimming a short-term profit and hurting both sides in the long-run.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by ascagnel_ on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:33PM (#11622117)
uBlock and it's ilk let you flag pieces of the DOM to block. I use it to block clutter on webpages as well as ad slots.

Compare [0] (with DOM-based blocking) to [1] (without).

[0]: http://i.imgur.com/5hlPhqx.jpg [1]: http://i.imgur.com/TrxMlkz.jpg

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by paulmd on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:12PM (#11622464)
I normally surf with uBlock Origin and most of the filters turned on (anything that's not experimental or a subset of a larger filter), and I get a shock every now and then when I use a browser without filtering and see what the internet has turned into. What the shit, that looks nothing like the Guardian that I am used to seeing. Youtube ads are a real shocker too.

About the only time I ever actually notice advertising is when some site sets up an aggressive anti-adblock or airs 2 minutes of dead air where an ad spot would have gone.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by danieldk on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:06AM (#11626535)
I normally surf with uBlock Origin and most of the filters turned on (anything that's not experimental or a subset of a larger filter), and I get a shock every now and then when I use a browser without filtering and see what the internet has turned into.

Indeed! I got this experience every time I used Chrome (rather than Firefox) on Android. The web has become quite horrible. I am now back on iOS and the author of uBlock has made a great blocker for Safari on iOS:

https://www.purify-app.com/

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Raed667 on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:36PM (#11622142)
It is possible, but it requires that ads people trust publishers. Otherwise publishers will just say they served a million ad that day, and cash on it without any proof. Everyone is putting their own tracker in the ads because they can't trust other people data (unless you're Google or Facebook, or other giant)
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:51PM (#11622285)
It is still not clear to me whether uBlock or uBlock Origin should be preferred. It seems that the original author of uBlock had a falling out with some contributors and decided to fork it and go do his own thing his own way with uBo. People assert that this makes it "better", but I'm not sure. I've tried both and they do appear to have substantially differing featuresets. Can anyone finally clarify the situation, and the pros/cons of each?
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:56PM (#11622333)
Use uBlock Origin, see my other post. The author of uBlock Origin makes it clear that no donations are sought for the development of the extension. That is not the case with the other version.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:07PM (#11622429)
Your post (here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11622316) seems to address ABP v. uBo, not uBo v. uB.

Furthermore, non-solicitation of donations is a political reason to prefer uBo. I'm curious about the technical reasons. As a side note, I personally have no problem whatsoever with an extension creator soliciting donations as long as they're not doing so in a deceptive or annoying manner.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by neerdowell on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:33PM (#11622651)
> I'm curious about the technical reasons.

uBlock hasn't been updated in almost a year. uBlock Origin is actively developed. uBlock has effectively had no significant changes or improvements since the uBlock Origin fork happened.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by deprave on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:39PM (#11622689)
Fair point.

There's some background here which might be relevant. Another extension, AdBlock, used to have a policy against "acceptable ads." The author sought donations to keep development going, but later sold the business (and the users!) to an entity that immediately started allowing such ads through.

Maybe the author of uBlock Origin wants to make it clear that this can't happen here.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:25PM (#11622590)
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:34PM (#11622656)
I understand that a political issue is what drove them apart originally. However, people continually assert that uBlock Origin is the better extension. Is there anyone who has done an objective, non-political comparison of their featuresets and/or technical properties to really evaluate which one is superior for end users?

I can say anecdotally, that I found plain uBlock more featureful for everyday usage, but I haven't done a thorough review. I currently use uBlock Origin.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:54PM (#11623678)
For one thing, uBlock Origin is constantly being updated, while uBlock hasn't been touched in quite awhile[0]. The uBlock maintainer seemingly quit working on it so that he could work on a paid ad-blocker for iOS called Purify instead.[1]

[0]https://github.com/chrisaljoudi/ublock [1]https://www.purify-app.com/

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by nitrogen on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @03:31PM (#11623517)
The uBo author, gorhill, is on HN, and lots of information about the split can be found with a few cycles of searching HN.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by coolsunglasses on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @12:28AM (#11626196)
ABP have been extortionists for years. They'll let anybody show the ads they want as long as they pay protection.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by FussyZeus on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @01:56PM (#11622818)
The performance bump alone sold me on uBlock. Switched a year or so ago and never looked back.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by kobayashi on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @12:30AM (#11626203)
Who are those dedicated individuals?
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by Grishnakh on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @05:36PM (#11624431)
I don't see the problem at all, or any need for disrupting it. If you don't like AdBlockPlus, then just switch over to uBlock Origin. It doesn't believe in "acceptable ads" and doesn't have a cozy relationship with the ad business. It even uses the same filter lists. All you have to do is switch. ABP isn't even installed by default anywhere, so you can't compare it to IE on Windows in the browser wars.
Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by kriro on Wednesday May 04, 2016 @02:28AM (#11626599)
The idea outlined in the article is actually good. I'm not a fan of AdblockPlus due to the "we'll let adds through for payments" and much prefer uBlock but I do think it's strategically smart to include content micro payment with add blocking. They vastly overestimate how many people will pay for it (imo) but the segment of customers who hate adds but don't mind paying for content is a bit under served.

I am a very strong believer in good content being voluntarily rewarded if the business model is right (which includes strong price discrimination measures i.e. keeping the content free for a large chunk of people). It might be naive idealism (OpenBSD/OpenSSL, PGP not getting more donations has me scratching my head) but at the end of the day I think free (as in speech and beer) with optional payment to keep the excellent content creators in the business of creating content will work and should work.

Re:AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay pub... by lintroller on Tuesday May 03, 2016 @12:52PM (#11622294)
"Voluntary" is all about definitions. I imagine they'll count an automatic opt-in as "voluntary".