News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Iv on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:16PM (#11577618)
I see what you mean and am often equally frustrated, but you know what this reminds me of? The state of infrastructure in a booming underdeveloped country, which is a good thing. Let me explain it a bit further.

Have you tried hiring a programmer lately? It is very hard, there is a huge demand and most programmers I know receive several offers a month. The demand for software is CRAZY. So we all do what we can: quick and dirty when it is good enough. Just like in a country with no roads, any dirt road and crappy pavement is better than nothing if you have hundreds of trucks that need to go through RIGHT NOW.

So here it is, websites are made hastily, tech half work, but are better than nothing. How much of the things you screencaped have more than 5 years of existence? Like you said, we are software developers. We write software and we write bugs. Right now, there is far more need to implement new features than to correct bugs. Hopefully it will change at one point but right now this is the crazy race forward, and that is a good thing!

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by turaw on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:06AM (#11577764)
> most programmers I know receive several offers a month

:'|

Could you take a look at how they're receiving offers and perhaps put some suggestions together on how to duplicate that effect? Most programmers I know have had extreme difficulty getting a job, especially one that would pay at-or-above the average rate (per Glassdoor).

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:33AM (#11578256)
Programmers can do very well by becoming contributors to high profile open source projects and standards committees. Post pull requests on github, write tech articles, answer tech questions on reddit and hacker news, and do it under your own name. Register yourname.com and put your resume there. Essentially, make a name for yourself instead of waiting for someone else to do it for you.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by anonymous41 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:24AM (#11579724)
Open source involvement is overrated. Yes, companies say they value it, but you can't listen to what they say; instead, you must look at what they actually do.

Are candidates with copious open source contributions getting hired primarily because of those contributions, or at the very least being spared the indignity of the white board and trivia questions during interviews? In my experience, no. Interviewers generally don't care, or perhaps their process is too rigid to admit the deviation that caring would require. In fact, when pressed, many will even admit outright that they don't care, claiming (as I've seen here on HN) that they have no way of knowing for certain that you're the true author of your purported contributions or that your contributions alone can't really demonstrate how you write code (like a white board presumably can).

The only reason they value open source contributions is that it amounts to free labor, and it demonstrates "passion"--a quality that they associate with susceptibility to exploitation.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by dkersten on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:04AM (#11581011)
The way I see it is that its about exposure.

If you contribute to open source, your name and work are out there. People can find out about you and see some of your work.

There are other ways than contributing to open source too. For example, I've got a number of offers because I run a local programming language meetup.

Basically anything that puts your name out there will help get offers. If nobody knows you exist, they can't offer you jobs. That, I think, is where open source can help a lot.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by kod on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @10:52AM (#11580895)
The job I'm at currently, the CTO skipped standard technical interviewing and went right to culture fit. He said explicitly that was because he had seen me giving a technical talk and read through my Github.

Some of that may depend on company size, but in my experience (mostly small startups) it has been a huge benefit.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:01PM (#11581630)
I'm reminded of the old joke of the advertising executive who said: "I know I'm wasting half the money I spend on advertising, the trouble is I don't know which half."
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by gaius on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:08AM (#11579337)
Can you think of any other profession that does anything like this? No doctors or lawyers or accountants or civil engineers or pastry chefs find work by posting on Reddit.

And besides, that is very specific to web jobs. There's an awful lot more to the industry besides.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by prions on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @10:00AM (#11580481)
As a non software person (civil engineer but going in for a CS masters), this is my biggest gripe when it comes to speaking with developers about their jobs: they lack perspective.

I can assure you that the bar for entry into my field is much higher than software. Like medicine and law, engineering requirements are strictly set by state law and professional boards. You need at minimum a bachelors in engineering to get a foot in the door. There is no self studying or civil engineering bootcamps. Afterwards, you need to become an engineer in training (EIT) by taking an entrance exam. Four years of experience later, you can sit for your professional engineers exam to become a licensed PE.

So now you're 8 years down the hole, finally licensed and ready to actually practice in a professional role. The kicker is that you're still probably making less than a fresh CS bachelors student working at <foo> corp in a tech hub.

I'll stick to posting on Reddit and contributing to projects.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by krolley on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:59AM (#11580465)
If I am looking for a surgeon for an operation, it's enough for me to know that he was trained at a good school and has enough experience -- for that a bio online is already decent. I trust his education, after all the field of medicine is one of the oldest in existence.

There is no such trust in the education of software developers, perhaps because software development is such a new field. I've worked with great ones without a formal education and terrible ones that graduated from good schools. The way to 'prove' yourself to someone when they can't work with you (e.g. first stages of a hiring process) is to demonstrate your work by using technical articles, GitHub commits etc. Also, that stuff is not specific to web devs, I'm sure you can find every kind of project under the sun on GitHub.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by davidsong on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:04AM (#11579601)
> Can you think of any other profession that does anything like this?

Photographers, graphic designers and musicians.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nommm-nommm on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:33AM (#11579779)
Photographers, graphic designers, and musicians are expected to work for free in order to get hired?
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by klibertp on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:49AM (#11579867)
Aren't they? I don't know much about musicians, but graphic designers are expected to bring their portfolio with them to the interview. There's no interview at all without the portfolio... and you're not always lucky enough to have all your best works paid for by someone, especially if you're just starting.

EDIT: and, come to think of it, don't musicians need to practice for a long time before even getting a chance to perform for pay?

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:18PM (#11581784)
They sure do, and they often play for years for free in the hope of building a brand and being discovered. Like The Beatles.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by jwdunne on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:46AM (#11581465)
Hrm. Musicians play because they enjoy it. Know many a people who, despite or regardless of success, will play just for the enjoyment of it.

Programming is similar. You hear the stories about how some tech founders focused their energy on programming, it took off and they dropped out of wherever.

I'd argue that for every one of those, there are scores of people who do it just for fun like they did, get nowhere but do it anyway because they like it. Just like there are scores of guitarists for your Clapton, Hendrix, etc.

Open source contributions to me look a lot like people, for the most part, enjoying themselves and getting better at a hobby.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by dkersten on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:06AM (#11581027)
Having family members who are all three of those... yes. They, unfortunately perhaps, are. They all have to have portfolios of some kind to prove their ability.

It perhaps depends on the specifics of the jobs you go for. For example, if you're a musician producing audio for eg film, then you definitely are expected to have a portfolio, but if you go out and play for an audience, then you probably don't.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:15PM (#11581752)
Any business that spends $0 on marketing will likely reap $0 in sales. Think of it like marketing.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by eitally on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:05AM (#11579608)
I can't think of any profession where this kind of personal brand management and contributions to the public corpus of [whatever domain] knowledge wouldn't be a boon.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by howeyc on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:18AM (#11579687)
Perhaps not by posting on reddit, but they have other ways to raise their profile.

Doctors have conferences, Chefs have "Chopped", and those are only the "mainstream" ways the general public knows about. Most others you mentioned have industry/trade magazines for example.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:05PM (#11581670)
I've seen a lot of artists and craftsmen post their work on Reddit, and they're clearly marketing their names.

I suspect the other professions would benefit as well, it probably simply hasn't occurred to them yet. It reminds me of when I was watching a bodybuilding competition in the 80's and thought the posers could really use some advice from a professional dancer. Sure enough, this occurred to one of them, they did a routine that blew away the others, and then the rest of them did.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:43AM (#11580336)
I think you are just not very familiar with some of those professions. Lawyers frequently take on pro bono cases to get themselves publicity. Pastry chefs give out free samples of their work all the time to get customers. In basically any competitive profession some people will take on some non-paying work if they think it will benefit their career.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by gaius on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @11:13AM (#11581102)
But there is not the expectation in those professions that they will give up all their free time to it. No lawyers are suing people on their own time just for their own entertainment, I guarantee it. But programmers are expected to do their day jobs then go home and do more programming...
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:10PM (#11581708)
In any profession, to rise to the top tiers of pay, it is necessary to devote yourself to it.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by gaius on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:13PM (#11581738)
You're not comparing like with like, partner in a law firm vs someone whose actual job it is just to crank out CRUD websites.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by klibertp on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:25PM (#11581872)
You can land a job in cranking out CRUD websites without any kind of side-projects. Hell, with just a little bit of luck you can land such a job without any kind of experience or education.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:28PM (#11581917)
If lawyers want to rise to anywhere near the top they need to meet such stringent billable hours requirements that they will have essentially no free time in which they could sue people.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by klibertp on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:07AM (#11579615)
> No doctors or lawyers or accountants or civil engineers or pastry chefs find work by posting on Reddit.

Is it good (for lawyers, accountants, etc.) or bad in your opinion?

It's true that the widespread expectation that a programmer will be programming (or doing related things) in his spare time is slightly unusual compared to other professions. Personally, however, I find that expectation natural and I would do it - write code in my spare time - anyway.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:22AM (#11578437)
I also know for a fact that many companies go to programming conferences to look for people to hire. Attending those conferences is a great way to network. Even better is to present at a conference.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by bcook on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:21AM (#11578864)
You seem to be well aware of this aspect of the job market; do you have blog or something with more in-depth musings on this topic?

If not, then can you share some tips on how to concisely include a job applicant's open-source contributions in their resume?

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by JanezStupar on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:28AM (#11579176)
Just list them under your projects category on your website.

Also that is what your github account is for.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by d2p on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:37AM (#11579449)
I've also seen a lot of recruiters going through GitHub and contacting people that way lately. People with public source on GH tend to be really passionate devs because they're frequently spending time outside work doing dev.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by jwdunne on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:56AM (#11578557)
Thank you. This is perhaps the most succinct guide to marketing your skills I've read.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by petra on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:54AM (#11579905)
Maybe the difference is between just contributing to open-source, and contributing highly-differentiated stuff to open-source, such that your name(or your creation's name, and not something that you just helped in a bit) gets passed around ?
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ryanobjc on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @01:35AM (#11578036)
Honestly, the first step is: have a job at a well regarded company.

There is no stronger signal that you're a good developer than already having a job at a company that has stringent hiring standards.

I get multiple serious recruiter contacts a week. Mostly via Linkedin, but also via direct email for the enterprising recruiters. All from companies most people would kill to work for. I even get linked-in email from linkedin recruiters.

I ignore most of them. They know it's part of the game. One day in the future I may need them, and there's no point in pissing them off - they're only doing what they can. You gotta have a huge funnel to hire even 1 person (it's probably 1000:1 for contacts/hire)

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ufukbay on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:04AM (#11579057)
This is absolutely true and was how I found my dream job or more like how a recruiter found my dream job for me. I'm using Xing since I live in Germany but I think it should work similar on LinkedIn.

I can understand that if you are starting fresh you won't be able to be already employed by a well known company. However you have to start somewhere and it's important that you get some experience in the field you want to work in. Obviously this depends on the job you are applying for whether it's a junior or senior position etc.

I think it's important that you don't have big gaps in your CV and can show or present strong social/soft skills. One of the most important things for me is to be honest. Be absolutely honest about what you can do and not. Don't flood your profile with all the latest buzzwords and technologies if you never worked with these before. This might attract couple recruiters but it will be most likely the black sheep amoung them.

Be serious, honest, friendly, open minded and just yourself. :)

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nfriedly on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @01:07PM (#11582308)
Thanks for mentioning Xing - I might be looking for something new around the beginning of next year, and while I enjoy working remote (in the US), my wife and I were just talking about how a job Europe might worth moving for :)

But of course, I'd only ever heard of linkedin as "the" professional networking site - I didn't even realize they had competition!

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ufukbay on Thursday April 28, 2016 @10:22AM (#11589039)
You are welcome. https://www.xing.com/ is very popular in Germany at least. Sadly I don't have any numbers on how they do in Europe.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by GoToRO on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:13AM (#11578176)
True. I interviewed once and they told me flat out that they didn't really read my CV but they saw I was hired at a big company and they liked that.

People are just people no matter what role they have in that moment and most people are susceptible to be impressed by superficial things (like your current company name).

Also most interviewers failed the interviews I was in... :)

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by qznc on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @04:28AM (#11578664)
Makes you want to give them a joke CV with a section "Companies I have not worked at yet" and just list some buzzwords like Google, Apple, Facebook, Microsoft, etc.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by _pmf_ on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:35AM (#11579209)
> have a job at a well regarded company

This is already highly contentious. Some consider startups who produce write-only code fast to be a joke, some consider slow moving behemoths like Microsoft, Apple or IBM as less than ideal.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ahlatimer on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:48AM (#11577888)
1. Where are you/they? I got a ton of recruiter spam when I lived in SF and a fair amount now that I live in Austin (the majority of which are companies that want me to relocate back to SF). I received 0 when I lived in El Paso, TX (where I'm from). If you're in an area that doesn't have a hot tech market, you're likely going to have a harder time finding a tech job.

2. What technologies do they specialize in? I see lots of job posts for Rails and React and relatively few for COBOL. I see a lot of jobs for Java, but a higher percentage of those are of the lower paying variety. This is likely location dependent and is a bit of a catch-22.

3. Are they any good, but perhaps more importantly, are they able to demonstrate that they're any good in an interview setting? There are a fair number of truly bad programmers out there. There's also a fair number of programmers who may be good but are unable to demonstrate that in an interview. Interviewing is hard to get right -- everyone has their own take on it, and it's rarely backed up back actual data.

The people you see getting tons of offers probably have the right combination of location, resume, and interview ability. If I had to pick the single most important factor in getting a lot of offers, it's location. If you are in an area with limited tech jobs, the number of offers you can get is obviously going to be limited as well.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Chris2048 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:18AM (#11580100)
In my hometown, I couldn't even get a job in a computer store, let alone software development. :'-/

Getting a career at all without a CS degree required moving away..

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by mostlystatic on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:34AM (#11578259)
Maybe I'm being overly literal, but do some people just receive offer letters without going through an interview process?

Sure, I get lots of recruiter emails, but almost all of them are sent identically to 100 other people as well.

Most emails I get come from external recruitment firms, only sometimes does someone at a company reach out to me directly. But even then it's only an invitation to apply, it doesn't mean I'm actually especially likely to get the job.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by briandear on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:04AM (#11578374)
I got a no-interview, no resume offer for a contracting gig simply off the basis that my LinkedIn showed that I worked at "reputable company." I couldn't believe it -- but the contract worked out and everyone was happy. Social proof often means more than a resume or even Github.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nfriedly on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:57AM (#11579563)
It happened to me recently, the offer was from someone I had previously worked with who just knew and trusted me.

(I also get about 1-2 recruiter spams a week and occasionally one that seems genuinely tailored to me specifically. This might be what the OP was calling "offers".)

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by fleitz on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:04AM (#11579060)
Yes. I was taking my wife out to dinner once and a recruiter stopped us (me) in the street to get me to work for their company, technically I interviewed but it's kinda just a formality when they want you that badly. Apparently a former co-worker said I was a genius.

As others have mentioned, it's social proof.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by codingdave on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:56AM (#11579297)
In my community, most programmers receive several inquiries a month (or week, or even day)... but saying there are several offers a month would imply they are actively interviewing enough for inquiries to become offers. The "several offers a month" is an exaggeration of reality that I hear often, but when you really dig into it is just that... exaggerated.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by mgkimsal on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:38AM (#11579452)
Thank you for the clarification - this is exactly my experience too, and that of most others. I don't think I've known anyone in the past 20 years of working who consistently received multiple job offers per month, especially when they weren't interviewing.

Most of the inquiries I know of (for myself and others) are generic recruiter spam, or word of mouth referrals by people looking for really cheap work. So yeah, there's lots of work out there to be done, but much of it is in far less than ideal situations.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Kurtz79 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @09:56AM (#11580442)
It's my experience as well.

I do receive several "inquiries" per week, mostly due the fact of having left my CV (obviously now very outdated) in many job sites when I was looking for a job in London, almost 10 years ago.

They are of the type "Dear [Name], I hope you are well. Would this role be of interest for you in your current situation ? [role description]. If not, do you know some friend of yours that would ? Best regards, [name of person totally unknown to me]."

This is not even a serious inquiry, much less an "offer".

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Raticide on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @01:23AM (#11577994)
I get random recruiters poking me on LinkedIn. Only about 1 every couple months. But I'm not looking for work and not a big user of LinkedIn. I'm in Auckland, New Zealand and have a bunch of experience if that matters.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nathan_f77 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @04:50AM (#11578739)
Hey, from what I can tell, Auckland is still not a great place to work as a software developer. I would probably recommend looking at some companies in Wellington or Christchurch, or becoming a freelancer for clients in the US.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by beatpanda on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:01AM (#11578359)
I don't have a big name on my resume (unless you count freelancing for EFF). All I have is a public portfolio and a well-manicured LinkedIn profile, and I get several cold calls or emails from recruiters per month.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by fleitz on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:01AM (#11579039)
Post on LinkedIn, add recruiters as friends (or whatever they are called on linkedin), look for what jobs they are looking for, add those skills to your linked in profile. Wait for them to find you.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Iv on Thursday April 28, 2016 @04:56AM (#11587352)
the only programmers that I know that have a hard time finding a job are those who only have a very narrow specialization, typically on some web technology.

People who focus on solely ASP.Net without an understanding of the underlying tech will have a harder time finding a job than someone who knows several language and understands how a computer works.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nommm-nommm on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:18AM (#11579371)
This is highly geographic specific, there are no absolutes.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by not_kurt_godel on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:10AM (#11577773)
The programmers you know aren't very good, sorry.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by bpchaps on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:22AM (#11577807)
Or, I dunno, they live in a place without a condensed, ego mad, hyper-inflated job market?
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nommm-nommm on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @08:25AM (#11579727)
Or are over 30?
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by briandear on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:07AM (#11578384)
I live in the South of France and my LinkedIn profile says so.. I get at least 10 recruiter emails a week with 3 or them being for remote positions. Geography is not a huge factor, it's about the skill match.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by bpchaps on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:49AM (#11578533)
And I've received 17 this week with difficulties finding jobs still. Mostly within Chicago, but a lot are remote - what's your point? You're still oversimplifying the issue.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by marmaduke on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:33AM (#11578475)
Do you work remotely or for a local company? Most jobs I find seem to be in Paris.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nikofeyn on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:20AM (#11577802)
i am very good at what i do but when software engineers try to act like they know how to hire people, you have problems. i have been interviewed by a company that prided themselves on hiring smart, diverse people who weren't necessarily experienced in a certain field and language. they literally called this out in the job description.

the interviewer proceeded to ask me a deluge of very specific questions about said language, including implementation details of the language itself! all of the questions could have been looked up by an intelligent person online within minutes. and this was a well established, small, but well known company.

all of my software interviews can be summed up with two words: algorithm questions. but yet, my skills lie in architecture, writing bug free code, general design skills, testing, UI dev and client feedback, etc. none of these skills have never had the chance to be discussed in an interview. i came from another field and haven't spent a lot of time in the algorithm space. i can work through them as needed in interviews just as i do in a job, but that is rarely cared about in interviews. people want binary answers.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by WalterBright on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @03:26AM (#11578451)
It's often possible for you to drive the interview rather than waiting for the interviewer to ask your questions. Bring up and expound on your skills if they're not asking the right questions.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by mgkimsal on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:41AM (#11579470)
Whether or not I get an offer, I tend to the enjoy the process more when I try to be collaborative in an interview process, vs waiting to be asked questions. I naturally want to show off some stuff and ask questions - if even that doesn't go well, it's probably not going to be a good culture fit, regardless of whether I can do the raw work.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by kybernetikos on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:27AM (#11578229)
I've worked with programmers from many of the big names (amazon, apple, facebook, google), and I've met quite a few programmers at least as good in little out of the way companies. I think recruiters massively overvalue having one of the big names on a cv.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Joeri on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:43AM (#11578292)
Then again, if you do have a big name on your resume, it lets the recruiter reasonably safely assume you can program well enough. That sort of confidence in a candidate is hard to overvalue.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by kybernetikos on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @04:36AM (#11578686)
There are lots of things that can give you as good or better confidence that a candidate can program well enough, and a big name on a CV is no guarantee either.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by fsloth on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:39AM (#11577856)
I think the correct conclusion is that their profiles are not visible for recruiters.

To my knowledge there is no proven way of finding out how talented one is except working with them for a while.

The best way to gauge ones skill level, IMO, is to observe how their code survives contact with the end user for a couple of years.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by turaw on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:22AM (#11577808)
How do you signal goodness, though? I wound up with a cushy position (largely by luck), but practically everyone else is barely scraping by. Side projects? Prestigious internships? l337 hax0r skillz? Maybe the 80/20 rule [1] applies and there are only a few, key factors that make some applicants stand out?

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle In case you didn't know this but srs you're on hn

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by Udo on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @05:38AM (#11578927)
There is a drastic oversupply of programmers, and I firmly believe more than half of us should not be in software development at all. I think you have a choice to make as a programmer:

a) do something interesting

b) do good/high-quality work

c) be excellently paid

- pick two. Unsurprisingly, most people choose high-paying jobs that sound interesting, resulting in shitty bloatware from hell. Of course, many programmers don't even get to choose at all, they can call themselves lucky if their job has one of these benefits.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by anonymous41 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:50AM (#11579521)
>there is a huge demand and most programmers I know receive several offers a month

You mean recruiter spam? That's not a job offer. At best it's a liberally-dispensed invitation to submit yourself to some company's drawn-out, degrading, and ultimately capricious interview process.

The "huge demand" is for 20-somethings who graduated from top schools who are "passionate" and can be over-worked and under-paid.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by nightski on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:39PM (#11577689)
I think it's fine we are using what we have to make things work today. But it seems like very little research and development is being performed to build a brighter future. Computer science is a field seemingly led by the loudest voices, not necessarily the brightest. It feels like OS, language, database, and other computer science research is at an all time low and instead is being driven by ad-hoc open source development for better or for worse.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ewjordan on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @01:04AM (#11577936)
Money is the loudest voice, every time. And nobody has lost a single dollar because OS or database research is lacking.

Even a major revolution in database tech would maybe reduce costs, downtime, or latency by 10% or so, max. Since that sort of expense is never the dominant factor in a company's success, it will never be worth serious commercial investment. And as far as academia goes, there is research happening, it's just a slog because all the low hanging fruit has been picked and now people are just optimizing. Fields always slow down after the good stuff is discovered.

IMO AI is the only pure CS field worth studying right now, that tree has barely been touched at all. The mundane stuff like OS, databases, and languages have been studied to death, and unless an Einstein comes along, there's not going to be any serious motion unless the AI nut gets cracked first.

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by zappo2938 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:19AM (#11577799)
There is a saying in professional kitchens. You can make the best soup in the world but if it takes you all day to make it, you will never make a money in this industry.
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by ArkyBeagle on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:53AM (#11579283)
"Several offers a month" != "several emails about job postings a month".
Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by finishingmove on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:56AM (#11579295)
> you know what this reminds me of? The state of infrastructure in a booming underdeveloped country

Here's what it reminds me of: "jungle capitalism".

Re:Have Software Developers Given Up? by dschiptsov on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:57PM (#11577742)
That's probably true only inside the valley, otherwise there will be a market for contract-based remote coding, a-la "pay per github commits (which passes all tests).

Back in 90s one could easily land a job or a subcontract if one is capable to do so. I used to be UNIX system administrator and Informix DBA, and there were literally tons of requests for complex database server setups and performance tuning even in such shithole like Russia. That was the market.

Nowadays, except for bunch of valley startups and megacorps, which routinely select top graduates from the ivy league universities (as we have seen in now famous salary disclosure posts), there is no real demand for programming. There is no demand for high-quality components or specialized solutions outside established insanely beurocratized packer's ecosystems, such as Java EE, MS, etc, which allows middle-aged mediocrity to get its salary.

Suppose you are a freelance programmer, who has that golden classic CS education (algorithms, data structures, programming languages). Is there any offers beside Jomla theming or JS or occasionally Android coding? Nope. All remaining software engineering action is inside startups or megacorps, and even it is usually nothing but piling up layers upon layers of Java (or nowadays Node) crap, which can't even be polit-cortectly called "over-engineered", because it is simply arrogantly-stupid.

The mantra "write your own Nginx first" does not work either. Igor had a nice sysadmin's job in an oil company so he was able to spend couple of years for prototyping and slow knowledge-based engineering, as opposed to fast and "productive" copy-pasting in an IDE.

If there is a real demand, there must be the market for it. Have you seen any demand for good stuff (Erlang, Haskell, CL, Golang, kernel-quality C)? Me neither. What we see is mere evolution of valley's sweatshops for top graduates we call startups.