News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:52AM (#11572902)
Multiplying 3842 by 543 is very hard for humans. They're slow and inaccurate. Computers do it perfectly at incredible speeds.

Inventing multiplication is something no computer (as we currently understand them) would ever be able to do.

For another analogy, moving ten tons of rock a thousand feet is something humans can do, and have done for millennia. It's very slow and difficult. A bulldozer can do the same thing in minutes. But a bulldozer would never, ever have a reason to move ten tons of rock.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by arethuza on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:06PM (#11573027)
Doug Lenat's Automated Mathematician (AM) apparently did "discover" multiplication by itself:

http://web.onetel.net.uk/~hibou/ai-course/lenat.txt

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_Mathematician

Of course, you could argue that multiplication was implicitly there in the rules and facts it was programmed with.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by progressive_dad on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:30PM (#11573274)
Let me know when humans invent something not governed by the rules the universe was programmed with ;-)
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by maaku on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:39PM (#11573368)
Theoretical physicists do that every day. It's only noteworthy when they find one that actually corresponds to the real world...
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by kazinator on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:15PM (#11575228)
A lot of mathematics doesn't correspond to anything happening in the known universe. Mathematics describes infinities, infinitesimals and uncomputable numbers that are only hinted at using symbols which are not to be confused with those numbers themselves.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by camelNotation on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @02:54PM (#11574562)
Literature, Art, Music, Philosophy, Religion...

Basically everything that isn't a science.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:58PM (#11573562)
Poetry.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by progressive_dad on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:11PM (#11574682)
I wouldn't go that far. Maybe, "witty", but I wouldn't call it Shakespeare.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by adamsea on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:21PM (#11573774)
Write me program that could write Doug Lenat's Automated Mathematician. ;)

I think the OP's point was until humans invent true strong AI there is a qualitative difference between human and computer intelligence.

And even if/when a true "thinking machine" is invented, the intelligence which was able to create said machine would be nothing to sneeze at!

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by lyle_nel on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:49PM (#11574051)
Write me a programs that could write me a program that could write Doug Lenat's Automated Mathematician ... and so on and so forth.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @02:32PM (#11574402)
I wonder how many people in this thread have read Hofstadter's Gödel, Escher, Bach?
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by varjag on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:22PM (#11573787)
That's what Lenat himself argues in his follow-up paper. But I generally agree, there's nothing preventing computers "as we know it" to exhibit human level general intelligence. Humans weren't just smart enough so far to program it yet.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by DonaldFisk on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:10PM (#11573068)
> Inventing multiplication is something no computer (as we currently understand them) would ever be able to do.

AM, the discovery learning program developed by Doug Lenat, discovered multiplication, beginning with a few basic facts about set theory, and using about 200 heuristics.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by yequalsx on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:38PM (#11573345)
I don't consider this an example of discovering multiplication. The set theory rules were given to the computer. Can a computer be built to start only with sensory input and then discover the rules of set theory? Would it ever be able recognize why the patterns and rules for operating with sets are important and worth further study? I'm skeptical.

Would a program flag the discovery of multiplication as important because it understood that this discovery is interesting or would it flag its discovery as important because the programmer encoded it to have this understanding? That is can a program discover something new and alert to humans to this discovery and for it to be truly interesting and new?

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by DonaldFisk on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:59PM (#11573564)
Eurisko, AM's successor, did that: AM and Eurisko used a measure of interestingness to direct their searches. Here is one of Eurisko's inventions:

From EURISKO: A program that learns new heuristics and domain concepts: "Almost immediately, symmetry heuristics produced a very powerful yet simple device, one which simultaneously computes NAND and OR, using only two small metal regions, two n-doped regions, two p-doped regions, and one intrinsic channel region."

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by maaku on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:40PM (#11573382)
Absolutely. Look at Pat Langley's BACON program back in the 80's. He didn't work on multiplication per se, but given nothing but "sensory input" it discovered laws of planetary motion, rules of physical chemistry, conservation laws, etc.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by yequalsx on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:22PM (#11573776)
I looked at a summary of his work. I've never heard of him or of the BACON program so my knowledge is essentially zero in this. Looking at summary of his work it doesn't seem to me to qualify either.

I'm not sure how to convey the idea in my head to English in such a way to make it clear why I think BACON doesn't qualify as discovering new ideas. I'll try though.

From the write up, by Langely, of the program he wrote the program to detect regularity in data and if it found such regularity it would "leap out" to the program so that "it could take appropriate" action. As I understand the program it picks up on any sort of regularity. The program doesn't understand which forms of regularity are important and which are not. The programming system and data it looks at are geared to finding regularity that are meaningful. If the data inputs are vastly widened then it seems to me it would find regularity that wouldn't be considered meaningful. I can imagine the program fixating on a regularity pattern that is meaningless. I hope what I'm writing makes sense.

The work he did is interesting and I wonder what advances have been made since then.

Let me ask this question. Would a program that looks for regularity discover that in finite probability spaces probability zero events never occur? I think this is something a computer could discover. Could it end up concluding that probability zero events can occur if one looks at uncountable probability measure spaces? It seems to mean that programs will never be able to think or discover things at a meta level. Would a program be able to discover Godel's incompleteness theorem? Of course I don't know the answer. I just suspect that the answer is no. However, humans took thousands of years to discover these things. So perhaps an AI that ran for that long could as well.

Thank you for pointing me to the BACON program. I'd never heard of it before.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by maaku on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @02:14AM (#11578178)
I'm not the one giving you downvotes. I believe you are incorrect, but you have taken the effort to explain your thinking and have the courage to admit that you could be wrong, so I wouldn't down-vote that.

In any case, let me flip the question around at you: how did Goedel come up with his incompleteness theorem? Surely it didn't just magically appear in his head? Most likely he followed some standard procedures of mathematical practice: manipulate symbols according to learned rules, look for 'surprising' features in the result, build a sample demonstration of a surprising result, and use intuition regarding its outcome to drive further thinking, etc.

You can look at any intellectual behavior and find processes underlying it, unless you want to argue that we don't live in a materialist universe and people have souls. Unless you go down that route, there must be mechanisms to thought, and indeed applied psychology agrees. So if there are mechanism to thought, why can't those run on a computer instead of biology?

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @11:32PM (#11577671)
> Can a computer be built to start only with sensory input and then discover the rules of set theory?

Yes. Abstract knowledge is learnable, and the brain is an inference machine.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by danielam on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:36PM (#11582027)
Non sequitur. In fact, what appears to be your stated premise actually argues against the conclusion, not for it. Besides, the mechanistic characterization of mind (you say brain, but for all intents and purposes here it makes no difference) is highly problematic.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by klipt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:36PM (#11573325)
The average human couldn't invent multiplication either - it took humanity as a whole thousands of years to get to that point. Even writing was only independently invented a handful of times in history.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by baddox on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:33PM (#11573292)
Does that really matter though? It seems a bit like not giving humans credit for their accomplishments since, after all, sexual reproduction evolved a billion years before humans even existed.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by jhayward on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @04:20PM (#11575287)
In this thread we rediscover the truism that "AI is everything that hasn't been done yet." [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by danielam on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @01:23PM (#11582465)
It is no truism. It is merely dismissive and does not constitute a legitimate argument. There are numerous philosophers who have made arguments that challenge the notion of AI in the strong sense and who have no such interest in "preserving" feelings of human specialness that are allegedly being threatened. To lump all arguments against strong AI and computationalism in with "AI effect" is ignorant.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by dota_fanatic on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:42PM (#11573395)
How many people work jobs today that are akin in nature / level of fulfillment to inventing multiplication? How many people work jobs that are best done by a machine? How much energy does it take for a human intelligence to do these jobs vs a machine? How many people are furthermore stunted in their growth due to forced submission to their middle managers, a power differential that hardly need exist but feels great for the manager (king in their little castle)?

I'm pretty sure computers, as we currently understand them, are entirely capable of inventing multiplication, provided sufficient source code and input. Evolution is unique in being able to "create" a thing that can formalize multiplication? Human intelligence is not magic.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:47PM (#11573449)
Human intelligence is not magic, but it is categorically different from machine intelligence.

What's amazing isn't that Deep Blue could beat Kasparov, given the depth of analysis it could do. What's amazing is that Kasparov could beat Deep Blue, despite not being able to analyze thousands of possible moves a second in his head.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by fossuser on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:50PM (#11573473)
I think Alpha Go is more in the category of human intelligence.

My probably oversimplified understanding is that the neural network training on a massive amount of games develops something like intuition. It can't explain why a certain move it makes is the best, but only that it is the most likely to win.

This seems similar to advanced human play.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:24PM (#11573793)
One heuristic is that anything that is AI that actually works gets reclassified as something else.

Are Kalman filters machine intelligence? It sort of doesn't matter, really.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by ta_donk_gt on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:26PM (#11573221)
Small nit, but as hinted at by the other responses, humans didn't "invent" multiplication, they discovered it. In the same way we didn't "invent" the fact that the earth revolves around the sun, we discovered it.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by cderwin on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:30PM (#11573863)
I actually don't think this is true. Multiplication isn't some natural phenomenon that humans just stumbled upon, like gravity or nuclear energy, even if it does help to explain some observable phenomena. Multiplication is entirely a human idea -- it only exists in human brains. Multiplication was only "discovered" in the same way love, or music, or any of the liberal arts were "discovered" -- which is to say, not at all.

I guess the straightforward counterargument here is that if multiplication only exists in humans' minds how can computers do it, but computers have absolutely zero autonomy -- a computer can't compute a product, or even "discover" multiplication without receiving explicit intructions from a human to do so -- in my mind a computer can't be deemed the one discovering multiplication if that discovery relied 100% on the design of human beings.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:31PM (#11573276)
I'd argue that we discovered the earth goes around the sun, but we invented multiplication. It's a philosophical argument, however.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by Retric on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:37PM (#11573335)
Generally invention applies to the first discovers. I would suggest in the entire universe both observable or not we are unlikely to be the first species to discover multiplication. Languages like English, French etc on the other hand have much better odds even if language as a concept is really old.

PS: I have even seen 'rediscovery' used for the same situations when a math idea was lost etc.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by simondedalus on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:38PM (#11573348)
that's debatable, once you appreciate the point about having a reason to do something.

calculation itself really only exists with purpose. it's a thing to do if you have a reason to do it. of course, these kinds of things too seem more "discovered" than "invented", but it's a very different kind of discovery than "the earth revolves around the sun". the earth revolves around the son, as far as we can figure these days, whether any agent/subjectivity/etc intends anything or not.

however, no full-blooded calculation will ever occur anywhere in the universe unless someone needs to figure something out. in other words, intention is implicit with calculation (and truth-functional representation, by the by). as such, you could make a case for an argument for "inventing" strategies in mathematics. and of course, a lot depends on your ontology of mathematics in the first place. if you're a wittgensteinian about numbers, and you think any of what i said above is at all compelling, you may be inclined to believe that mathematics itself is an invention. you may admit of some more nuanced way that entities like "number" still exist without mathematics as a tool, you may not, but you'd probably see all mathematics existing as active work, not pre-existing objective Truth.

of course, most people think of math as an always-there abstract object (roughly). maybe they're right. even so, there must be some force in the "i use it as a tool" and "it just revolves around the sun no matter what anyone--god or man or beast--wants" distinction.

Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by beat on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @02:36PM (#11574427)
Calculation can be done purely for pleasure. I have math nerd friends who sit and do math for fun. It's related to other challenging, creative pursuits, like playing music or writing poetry.
Re:Human intelligence is overrated (2012) by danielam on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @12:33PM (#11581978)
Calculation is not math per se.