News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 21, 2016 @01:02AM (#11539808)
Waaaaay back when I worked at Intel it was pretty clear they didn't stop doing things that worked. And when the going got tough they stuck with what worked. In the 80's Intel had a really remarkable set of of computing products, from high integration "soc" type x86 chips (80186), high end graphics chips, (8276x), embedded chips (8051), and "server" chips (431 series). Plus a memory business and a whole passel of support chips.

But the chips in the PC had the best margin by far. So the more of those they made, the more profitable they became, and when the chip recession was in full swing in the late 80's and early 90's that is what they kept, shedding all the rest.

In the early 2000's when Moore's law ran right smack into the power wall, Intel was betting they could have an "enterprise" line (Itanium) and a "desktop" line (Pentium), and an embedded line (8051). They guessed wrong and for a brief time AMD's Opteron was kicking their butt. But once they realized the writing on the wall they realigned around 64 bit in the Pentium line and got back on track.

The problem with the ARM assault is that unlike AMD, which could be killed by messing with other users of the chipset and patent attacks and contract shennanigans, killing off someone making an ARM chip does nothing but make the other ARM chip vendors stronger. And they can't kill all of them at once. And worse, to compete with them they have to sacrifice margin on their x86 line and that is something they have never done, it breaks their business model.

Its a real conundrum for them, they don't have a low power, reasonable performance SOC architecture to compete with these guys. And that is driving volumes these days. Further, the A53 (ARM 64 bit) killed off the chance of trying to use 32 bit only ATOM microarchitecture chips in that niche without impacting the value of the higher end Pentiums.

One of the things Web2.0 taught us was that it doesn't matter how "big" the implementation of a node is if your going to put 50,000 of them in a data center to run your "cloud." Ethernet as an interconnect is fast enough for a lot of things.

It definitely makes for an interesting future.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by dba7dba on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:28AM (#11540637)
The problem with the ARM assault is that unlike AMD, which could be killed by messing with other users of the chipset and patent attacks and contract shennanigans, killing off someone making an ARM chip does nothing but make the other ARM chip vendors stronger. And they can't kill all of them at once. And worse, to compete with them they have to sacrifice margin on their x86 line and that is something they have never done, it breaks their business model.

Someone who was in IT before MS and Intel showed up said MS and Intel got big even though they did not have the best technologies. They got big essentially with smart alliances and good business practices (which included messing with competitors, some practices that can be called dirty).

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by ralfd on Thursday April 21, 2016 @06:58AM (#11540990)
Recently I talked to a 20 year old kid who didn't know that Apple existed before the iPhone...

Microsoft and Intel got big for one and only one reason: IBM chose them as suppliers for the IBM PC. Had IBM used their own in-house chip or licensed CP/M as operating system computer history would have been different (the Kildall link is especially interesting, Microsoft got really lucky here):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_801 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Kildall

For much of the 80s the Intel chips were inferior to other designs like the Motorola 68K. That is why the Macintosh, Atari (today only known for Pac-Man, but yes, Atari made computers rivaling Apple) and Commodore Amiga used more powerful Motorolas.

http://www.skepticfiles.org/cowtext/comput~1/486vs040.htm

But the "IBM-compatible" architecture won despite its inferiority through path dependency and the clones driving price down.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:43PM (#11543472)
Random bit, there was a story Greg Allman used to tell on the radio that he was in a record shop when a young girl picked up a Beatles album and says to her friend, "Hey look, Paul McCartney was in a band before Wings!"

I do agree that IBM's choice of the 8088 for their original PC was one of Intel's greatest design wins, but at the same time it was the execution of both Microsoft and Intel in their focus on pursuing the business market which made it truly successful. The "hobbyist" microcomputer market in the late 70's and early 80's was scattered. With small wins all over the map.

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by sitkack on Thursday April 21, 2016 @08:47AM (#11541639)
Sadly, Motorola came out with the expensive part (16 bit bus 68k) late. Had they shipped the 8 bit bus version earlier, I think things would have looked a lot different. Had they followed up with the 68000 and 020 earlier, things would be a whole lot different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_68008

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by kjs3 on Thursday April 21, 2016 @09:20PM (#11546469)
Motorola did have an inexpensive next-gen 8/16-bit chip. It was called the mc6809. That said, the whole point of the 68000 was that it's 16-bits wide, so I'm not sure a cheaper, narrow bus version would have made any difference.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by restalis on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:40PM (#11543436)
Isn't the CISC model contributing to better cache usage? As I understood, this was something that showed its strength in the time of raw computing-power rush and when cache started to matter.
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by flamedoge on Thursday April 21, 2016 @04:29AM (#11540427)
> if your going to put 50,000 of them in a data center to run your "cloud."

And therein lies Intel's quest to become relevant again. Make more bloated languages so more processors can be sold to servers :/

Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by pjmlp on Thursday April 21, 2016 @05:12AM (#11540579)
So what programming language has Intel ever designed?
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by joezydeco on Thursday April 21, 2016 @11:34AM (#11542913)
Anyone remember PL/M?
Re:Intel made a huge mistake 10 years ago by pjmlp on Thursday April 21, 2016 @12:49PM (#11543523)
I do, it was actually developed by Digital Research for Intel.

And it was better than C in terms of safety.

What influence did Intel have on the design, besides paying for it?