News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by striking on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:11AM (#11502721)
It doesn't make sense to require authentication on chargers, because then either only a small elite group can make chargers and charge insane prices, or everyone can make a charger after licensing the authentication procedure and then we're back at square one.

It doesn't solve the problem, it moves the stupid somewhere else.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by MichaelBurge on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:34AM (#11502784)
If you have an authentication procedure, you can do things like force the manufacturer to put down a security deposit, do background checks on the applying company to make sure they have history, or force him to undergo some kind of standardized testing on the product. It doesn't help on a technical level, but helps on a social one.

Game consoles historically have done all of these: You have to spend tens of thousands on a developer kit, they often prefer to see companies with a history, and they review your game before they allow you to sell it. I think all of these do help increase the quality.

The negative of course is that you end up with a walled garden.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by striking on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:13AM (#11502899)
That means we'll get to see low or slow (or no!) rates of adoption, like with Thunderbolt.

Instead of getting cool, inexpensive eGPU or other external PCIe tech, we have to pay upwards of $200 just to connect our existing PCIe cards. And take note of the cost difference between external hard drives that incorporate Thunderbolt rather than USB3.0: they're way more expensive.

What's more convenient for consumers? USB3.0, not Thunderbolt. Even though Thunderbolt is way more interesting and has way more promise (it's the entire PCIe bus, exposed!), it was nearly stillborn because of its inane licensing.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by anexprogrammer on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:41AM (#11502981)
I'd prefer rigorous licencing and somewhat expensive authentication to the current USB free for all where a £5 charger can destroy your £500 device.

If we end up replacing the current market where chargers run £1-£30 with one where they're £8-£35, but can be confident of reasonable levels of basic electrical functionality and safety, I'd be happy enough.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by MichaelBurge on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:55AM (#11503016)
My surge protector comes with a $10,000 mini-insurance policy if it fails to protect against a surge. It seems like something similar could be done for any market: Buy up 10,000 USB chargers for cheap, have them all inspected, underwrite an insurance policy that reimburses the customer for manufacturing defects, and charge more. Have a backup policy with a big insurance company for the sole purpose of assuring customers that they have someone to file a claim with in the event that you're bankrupt.

You don't even need a standards consortium to do it.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by noja on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:44AM (#11502986)
Good for you. Then you can go and buy the authenticated charger, and others can move on to something else.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by ghshephard on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:55AM (#11502849)
Well, define "Insane" - if we're talking an extra $5-$7 on a $20 charger, I, personally, am completely fine with that as long as it means I can rely that it will perform to spec, not damage my equipment, and provide full data rate performance. Particularly how important USB chargers are every single day of my life.

This is a much bigger deal with USB 3.1, as according to http://www.extremetech.com/computing/197145-reversible-usb-t..., we're looking at up to 100 watts of power being sent down the wire - I very, very, very much want to be certain that the gear I'm connecting to the charger doesn't get torched by the wrong power levels.

I think there is a reasonable middle ground between "Small Elite Group" and "Everyone" - I.E. given that the global market for USB chargers will be on the order of approx 1 Billion units/year (certainly more than 100 million, and probably less than 10 Billion) - and given that a 4-port charger goes for about $20 today, presuming the cost of those chargers goes to, say, $27, then that's $27 Billion revenue/year. (Some chargers will be single/dual port, but other chargers will be more expensive/featured - we're schwagging here). Probably sufficient to support on the order of 2-3 thousand companies that have been certified, presuming that each company needs to drive around 10mm revenue/year after certified their product(s).

I'm satisfied with being limited to 2000 or so USB charger vendors of hopefully higher quality, than 10,000+ of who-knows quality.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by gambiting on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:02AM (#11502867)
The problem is that there are other countries out there apart from UK, US, Germany and other rich western ones. Where I'm from(Poland) the minimum wage is about $2.60/hour at the moment. And it's not like Apple/Samsung/Sony/any other big manufacturer sell chargers cheaper just because we earn less. Original Apple USB charger costs about $30 here - that's more than a day of work for a lot of people. Those people are going to look for cheap USB chargers, even if they are sub standard quality - and the market will fill that niche one way or the other.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by ghshephard on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:25AM (#11502934)
If I'm making very little money, and I have equipment that requires a USB 3.1 charger, then it is even more important that my (expensive) equipment is not damaged - then, instead of being out an extra $7 for a charger, I've potentially lost many hundreds of dollars damaged by a out-of-spec charger/cable.

This is a very real problem: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/02/google-engineer-finds...

This wasn't that big of a deal in the Pre 3.1 era, because the power levels typically being supplied were less, and there was a broad understanding of the power levels that were going to be supplied.

You write, "Those people are going to look for cheap USB chargers, even if they are sub standard quality - and the market will fill that niche one way or the other." - and I totally agree with you, which is the entire reason why these certification programs are required - to ensure that only systems certified to be in-spec will be recognized.

My 10 Watt USB charger, that I've carried with me all over the world for 2+ years, powers up my iPhone, my iPad, and my battery-backups. I use it every single day, usually multiple times/day. I realize that an extra $7 can be a lot of money for some people, but, spread over 2 years, for something so important, it seems to be a reasonable investment.

It becomes an even bigger deal once you can also charge your laptop off the same charger.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by baq on Friday April 15, 2016 @01:26PM (#11506083)
i'd gladly pay a bit more for a charger that does it all, except i want to not have a charger at all - i want a usb port in my AC socket. the best part about it is that i've already got some. i want them to keep working, as right now i don't need a charger sticking out of the socket at all and would like to keep it this way.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by adiabatty on Friday April 15, 2016 @02:22PM (#11506497)
Maybe I'm just used to living in older houses, but doesn't the thought of having your expensive phone plugged into the grid, without surge suppression, fill you with dread?
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by nraynaud on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:37AM (#11502962)
If they actually cared about energy quality and equipment protection, they would check and protect on electric criteria at the plug, not add an electronic signature.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by ghshephard on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:48AM (#11502998)
I don't know which, "they" you are referring to here - the end customer, the standards body, the charger manufacturer, or the manufacturer of the equipment being charged?

The customer quite often just wants the cheapest price, the charger manufacturer doesn't care about anything other than selling lots of chargers, the two groups that do care, the Standard Body, and the manufacturers of the equipment being charged do care about energy quality and equipment protection. In the case of the manufacturer of the equipment being charged - you are right, they can take steps to protect their equipment, but it costs a bit of money to engineer a subsystem to detect a 100 watt charge and protect the upstream gear - likely cheaper just to query and confirm that the downstream device is certified and then trust it (somewhat). You still need the protection (defense in depth) - but starting off with certified chargers certainly helps. The standards body, really has every incentive to ensure that the only certified vendors can manufacture chargers that will be (broadly) accepted.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by 2muchcoffeeman on Friday April 15, 2016 @07:07AM (#11503408)
Is it really a problem though?

As you said, the market will fill the niche either way.

This extra effort is not going to effect people who can only buy the cheapest chargers. They will buy the knock offs as they have always done.

The rest of us can now be certain that our chargers are within spec.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by saiya-jin on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:12AM (#11502896)
buying overpriced equipment (apple) while complaining that with low wage you really feel the difference of price for a freakin' charger doesn't make much sense.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by wila on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:46AM (#11502992)
I lived in a country where $10 was a normal day wage. Lots and lots of iPhones there. It is a choice, THEIR choice. It is not up to you (or me) to be snobby and tell them not to buy expensive products because they don't earn enough money to do so.

When the charger that comes with the product breaks they'll need another one. If they can buy a cheap one that "just works" then yes that will make a difference. Even if the cheap one isn't certified. Not all of them are the horrific death traps that have been highlighted.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by striking on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:16AM (#11502909)
In this case, the Apple charger is the only one you'll be able to get, because USB3.1 is restricting the group of people that can make chargers.

That or the licensing will make it prohibitively expensive no matter what. Pick your poison, I suppose.

Seriously, the tech situation in Poland is really sad. We don't need USB3.1 making it worse. (I'm a citizen)

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by StavrosK on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:20AM (#11502919)
It doesn't make sense to complain that an accessory you can buy for $5 will now cost $30 because your phone is expensive? How does that line of reasoning even follow?

This is literally the same as saying "I won't be able to afford higher cigarette prices" "well don't get an expensive phone then".

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by f_allwein on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:31AM (#11502780)
well, there is a growing problem around counterfeit chargers and there are good reasons to use (more expensive) original ones - see e.g.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11325150

So it makes sense to regulate chargers somehow. Not sure if this is the best solution, but if we can prevent the small elite group from charging insane prices, that could work.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by f_allwein on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:31AM (#11502779)
well, there is a growing problem around counterfeit chargers and there are good reasons to use (more expensive) original ones - see e.g.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11325150

So it makes sense to regulate chargers somehow. Not sure if this is the best solution, but if we can prevent the small elite group from charging insane prices, that could work.

Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by foota on Friday April 15, 2016 @03:31AM (#11502781)
Not necessarily, the certification could involve testing, similar to how I believe wifi certification works.
Re:USB 3.1 now has digital signatures: may force you to use ... by mtgx on Friday April 15, 2016 @04:35AM (#11502961)
If they are certified I don't think that would happen.