News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by pvg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:04PM (#1149980)
If only there were some sort of tokens employers could give employees as an incentive. The tokens could then be exchanged for goods and services. Perhaps the production and circulation of tokens could be managed by the government to prevent abuse.
Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by patio11 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:30PM (#1150011)
However, empirically we've seen that touching token allocations causes huge amount of resentment and is very, very difficult to do in an elastic manner. Demands of the business can arise in hours or days, token allocation tweaks take years to take effect. We've seen that people will react -- within seconds -- to non-token incentives to do things that certainly resemble work. Blizzard can make a database entry with a few purple pixels attached and wham several million people start doing very repetitive tasks to achieve it. Think of the business value that could be harnessed if a little alert on my dashboard said "Hey Patrick, that funky Mersenne Twister re-implementation that has been in purgatory for the last 12 weeks and is now blocking delivery now is offering purple pixels for unit testing!"

I know you can game any system for rewards -- it has been a near obsession of mine since a kid, when I found that 89.5% is still an A- and that meant I could still miss 3 homework assignments and not suffer any consequences as long as I did really well on the tests. Like was mentioned in the video posted yesterday, everyone knows that grades are a game... its just an unsophisticated game that sucks, but nonetheless seems to converge on education for many people. Grades as a game have always been Pong in a world where Pacman exists... now they're Pong in a world where WoW exists. (Or even where Farmville exists.) Holy cow, we can abuse that better. ("Little Timmy learned 7 * 8 = 56. Ding, Mathematician Level 14! Gratz Timmy!")

Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by pvg on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:48PM (#1150025)
token allocation tweaks take years to take effect

This is mostly a function of a particular method of token allocation, rather than a property of the tokens. There are entire lines of work where the allocation is quite elastic - people who work on commission, people who make a significant part of their income based on performance bonuses, etc. Even at start-ups, in my experience, bonuses for important milestones are not all that uncommon, even if they often are, well, token.

Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by petercooper on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:23PM (#1150003)
The problem with that idea is that eventually people feel entitled to win tokens whether or not they made any achievements. They get so angry at not automatically being given tokens that the government mandates a minimum amount of tokens every employee must win per hour.
Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by vyrotek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:12PM (#1149991)
Except those tokens are currently handed out by a person instead of a unbiased machine who could dispense them based on measured progress for some task. Still made me laugh, you get my vote :)
Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by frederickcook on Thursday February 25, 2010 @11:01AM (#1150872)
There is a distinction between monetary rewards and the kind of peer-recognition the author is discussing here.

"A raise is only a raise for three months, then it's just your salary."

The argument here is that there are many, many other game mechanics besides simply giving out "tokens" that have been demonstrated to be compelling motivators.

Re:Ask HN - Review My Idea: Make Work More Like Games by Psyonic on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:09PM (#1149984)
There are few times I care about voting, but for this I'd vote 5 times ;)