That's the orthodox theory. You shouldn't buy it wholesale.
On the other hand, it would be a very heterodox environment indeed if producers were able to steal all the increases in wealth from consumers. That could only happen in an environment of no competition, not imperfect competition. Or an environment with 100% occupancy and no ability to build more units of housing.
Also, there would need to be no substitutes for the good. For instance, that people couldn't move between cities.
Surely the game is, to some extent, rigged. But can it be rigged so badly that it is possible to believe that transferring wealth from richer to poorer will not lead to an increase in the purchasing power of poorer people?
I don't have a decided opinion on guaranteed minimum income, but to deny that it would have a marked effect on purchasing power of the recipients of the wealth requires one to posit a truly exceptional economic theory. To attack minimum income on its efficacy of all things: that is either an ill-considered or truly radical view.
If minimum income can't help, what possibly could? The only option left would be the confiscation and redistribution of capital.
let's say you have 5 people who have the following amount available to spend on TVs:
$100
$80
$50
$30
$10
And you have 5 TVs to sell. What price do you sell them for? If you price them at $100, you sell 1x$100 and make $100
If you price them at $80, you sell 2x$80 and make $160
If you price them at $50, you sell 3x$50 and make $150
At this point you see a trend - you should price your TVs at $80 and just eat the loss on the three TVs you don't sell.
So now we have a society in with 40% of people have a TV and 60% don't. As a government, you want 100% of people to have a TV, so you intervene to try to fix it.
First, you double everyone's income.
That doesn't change anything. The new price for TVs is $160 and two people get TVs.
So instead, you give everyone $50.
If you price them at $150, you sell 1x$150 and make $150
If you price them at $130, you sell 2x$130 and make $260
If you price them at $100, you sell 3x$100 and make $300
If you price them at $80, you sell 4x$80 and make $320
If you price them at $60, you sell 5x$60 and make $300
So now 80% of society gets a TV. Better! Sure, you haven't eliminated inequality, but you've reduced it.
But let's say it isn't TVs, it's houses. And you have three of them, not five.
Everyone needs a house. So you'll bid as much money as you have to to beat the next guy trying to get one. So the first house will go for $80 to the person with $100. The next house will go for $50 to the person with $80 The final house will go for $30 to the person with $50.
If you double everyone's income? Nothing changes. We've already seen that doubling people's income does nothing.
If you give everyone an extra $50? The distribution ends up the same, except everyone pays an extra $50 for each house.
TL;DR: inelastic goods like real estate will just go up in price. Elastic goods like electronics will, but less than the amount of the wealth transfer. The most important thing is to change the wealth ratio rather than the gross amount.
Prices are set by available credit for purchase and by wages less other essentials for rent.
I'm afraid this isn't simply supply and demand fudge factor after construction costs at all.
-------------
Reply to child post as HN hates rentier slayers and throttles.
They function in that prices are set. But they are set by credit. And supply is inelastic. Banks use land to gain unearned income through their monopoly on money creation as debt.
Money is just an abstraction for real goods and services produced by the economy. Presumably we need people to live in Philly since that's where our industry is. If people moved away to some remote place, wouldn't our economy take a hit? Not to mention the transportation costs of servicing a more remote, less dense area.
The creates upward pressure on wages, as businesses need to attract more workers.
Dont see how this is a bad thing, given that wages have been stagnant for decades
I have so many examples of this. For instance due to terrible public schools - private schools cost roughly what it would cost you to move to a good neighborhood with good public school.
Day care - costs around what the government contributes as day care assistance.
Etc...
There would be some movement. The prices of the worst shit-holes would probably go down because people would gain the ability to move into a nicer place. That might cause a little increase in the price of low end apartments.
And any city that is currently supply-constrained would probably see upward movement on prices. But most cities that aren't San Francisco have vacancy rates around 3%, they aren't supply constrained. If one landlord raises prices, people can and will move to an cheaper apartment elsewhere. And if prices do rise, people will build more apartments, driving prices down. (again, assuming not San Francisco).
Because even though anybody relying on Basic Income may not be starving, they'll still be really poor, and really cost sensitive. If BI is $10,000 a year, a $100/month price increase is a huge chunk of their income, and worth the huge hassle of a move to avoid.
Remember that these "costs" are seen as revenue to providers of goods and services. What follows can be thought of as the opposite of trickle-down economics.
How will it help them to get higher paying jobs?
I'd say they have less leverage.
If, all of a sudden I don't need your $4 per hour job, I quit. If everyone else also doesn't need it they quit.
Then you as an employer need to pay more to get people to work for you, or use self driving mopeds to deliver the pizzas.
I think. I'd welcome any clarification to my attempted summary.
A disabled relative of mine is considering signing with Uber to lease their car (did you know Uber leases?) to make some money. After paying for gas and insurance - he is literally working slave wage. I thought this is relevant somehow.
This is a bit of a tautology. Low-rent housing is usually pretty bad, so when people can afford to pay more they just move to a nicer place.
As far as I know, the first-time home buyer credit made a tiny ripple in the low-end housing market - where did prices "balloon"? College education is quite different because the "market" has a massive barrier to entry (in terms of creating a new university).
People do not understand how prices are set and this is a major barrier to stopping rentier activity.
Rents are set by what the market can bear. I hope we get land value tax and stop the leeches.
It reminds me of Tobias Fünke in Arrested Development, when asked if open relationships ever work, saying "No, it never does. I mean, these people somehow delude themselves into thinking it might, but ... But it might work for us."
This happens every single time the poor get any sort of money. In poor neighborhoods the rents cost as much as people are able to pay, no more, no less.
Do you know when most rental deposits are collected? Around the tax return season.
If suddenly the poor had some money to spare - the rents will simply go up. The water bill will go up. Electricity, gas. Etc.. until there's no extra income left. And then the poor will be in exactly the same situation as they are now.
Source: long time resident (and landlord btw) of poor neighborhoods of Philly.
P.S: Government is willing to help poor with mortgages? House prices balloon. Government is helping with education grants - colleges raise tuition. Borderline-broke municipalities with enormous unfunded liabilities are looking for any opportunity to collect back taxes and make up new ones. I can go on.
Why would this be any different? As the history shows it will provide a benefit for only a short amount of time until costs catch up.
P.P.S: I am not an opponent of helping poor, quite the opposite. I just don't know how to go about it in real world.