Re:Is the World Ready for a Guaranteed Basic Income?
by bryanlarsen on Thursday April 14, 2016 @12:23PM
(#11498013)
Why would rent go up? Some homeless people would rent apartments, sure, but they're a very small percentage of the population, and a good portion of homeless people have other issues that makes that unlikely. In other words, demand would not increase substantially. And supply wouldn't change. If neither supply nor demand changes, why would prices?
There would be some movement. The prices of the worst shit-holes would probably go down because people would gain the ability to move into a nicer place. That might cause a little increase in the price of low end apartments.
And any city that is currently supply-constrained would probably see upward movement on prices. But most cities that aren't San Francisco have vacancy rates around 3%, they aren't supply constrained. If one landlord raises prices, people can and will move to an cheaper apartment elsewhere. And if prices do rise, people will build more apartments, driving prices down. (again, assuming not San Francisco).
Because even though anybody relying on Basic Income may not be starving, they'll still be really poor, and really cost sensitive. If BI is $10,000 a year, a $100/month price increase is a huge chunk of their income, and worth the huge hassle of a move to avoid.
There would be some movement. The prices of the worst shit-holes would probably go down because people would gain the ability to move into a nicer place. That might cause a little increase in the price of low end apartments.
And any city that is currently supply-constrained would probably see upward movement on prices. But most cities that aren't San Francisco have vacancy rates around 3%, they aren't supply constrained. If one landlord raises prices, people can and will move to an cheaper apartment elsewhere. And if prices do rise, people will build more apartments, driving prices down. (again, assuming not San Francisco).
Because even though anybody relying on Basic Income may not be starving, they'll still be really poor, and really cost sensitive. If BI is $10,000 a year, a $100/month price increase is a huge chunk of their income, and worth the huge hassle of a move to avoid.