News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by protomyth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:10PM (#1148941)
Let's see, iTunes sells the songs for $1.29 (all new hits) so 30 songs would be $38.70. Now, you were bad and did something illegal so let's go for broke and say you need to pay 10x for being bad so you will not do it again. That gets us to a $387.00 fine. That would be a reasonable slap. $675,000 is some serious overstepping.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by vital101 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:15PM (#1148960)
I think that record labels would be far more successful getting money from people if they would bring suits of this size. Keep under a certain amount and it could even go to small claims court. A few people getting slapped with $675,000 in fines doesn't scare me, but 250,000 people getting $500 in fines might make me think twice because the odds of getting caught are higher.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by jsz0 on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:45PM (#1149060)
A few labels are doing this. I think it's a fair approach. It ends up being about $10 per song. I don't think they even make you delete the files -- just stop sharing them. You're basically just paying a 10x premium/penalty for obtaining them in an illicit way. Here's what it looks like:

NOTE TO ISP: PLEASE FORWARD THE ENTIRE NOTICE

Re: Unauthorized Use of Copyrights Owned Exclusively by the Zappa Family Trust Reference#: XXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXX PST

Dear Sir or Madam:

FFS Enterprises, LLC ('We') represent the following 'copyright owner(s)' The Zappa Family Trust ('ZFT') by agency agreement.

ZFT are the exclusive owners of copyrights for Frank Zappa musical compositions, including the musical compositions listed below. It has come to our attention that {ISP Name} is the service provider for the IP address listed below, from which unauthorized copying and distribution (downloading, uploading, file serving, file 'swapping' or other similar activities) of ZFT's exclusive copyrights listed below is taking place.

This unauthorized copying and distribution constitutes copyright infringement under the U.S. Copyright Act. Pursuant to 17 U.S.C. 512(c), this letter serves as actual notice of infringement.

The ZFT will pursue every available remedy including injunctions and recovery of attorney's fees, costs and any and all other damages which are incurred by The ZFT as a result of any action that is commenced against you. Nothing contained or omitted from this letter is, or shall be deemed to be either a full statement of the facts or applicable law, an admission of any fact, or a waiver or limitation of any of The ZFT's rights or remedies, all of which are specifically retained and reserved.

The information in this notification is accurate. We have a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of herein is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or by operation of law. I swear, under penalty of perjury, that I am authorized to act on behalf of the owner of the exclusive rights that have been infringed.

While The ZFT is entitled to monetary damages from the infringing party under 17 U.S.C. Section 504, The ZFT believes that it may be expeditious to settle this matter without the need of costly and time-consuming litigation. In order to help you avoid further legal action from The ZFT, we have been authorized to offer a settlement solution that we believe is reasonable for everyone. please copy and paste the URL below into a browser and follow the instructions for the settlement offer:

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by windsurfer on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:47PM (#1149273)
Isn't that message copyright FFS Enterprise, and distributing it may be illegal?
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by jsz0 on Saturday February 27, 2010 @02:58AM (#1155073)
Probably, yeah. If I was being critical of the policy I would be more concerned. I think it's actually a good alternative. All the information in there is public knowledge otherwise.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by jrockway on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:28PM (#1149213)
250,000 people getting $500 in fines might make me think twice because the odds of getting caught are higher

That would actually cause people to stop pirating their music. And instead obtain different music, leaving the record companies with nothing.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:18PM (#1148969)
In the Capitol Records case, the jury ordered Tenenbaum to pay $675,000 to several record companies for illegally downloading and distributing 30 of their songs.

##and distributing## There's a monstrous difference here that we should be working nonstop to educate people about.

If we can't get people to understand the difference between simply downloading, and becoming part of the distribution network, we are never going to have a meaningful debate. Both sides will seem completely irrational to each other.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by dantheman on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:46PM (#1149066)
But they do not know how much he has distributed. How much should he pay if he distributed 1 song, 100 songs, 10000 songs? Shouldn't Capital Records say how many songs were distributed & that be tied to the verdict?
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by Luc on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:29PM (#1149006)
I'm not sure this is the same case I have heard of before, but let's assume this person was torrenting some popular songs.

How much does it matter that he was distributing and not just downloading, if there were hundreds of others seeding at the same time? Other downloaders would have been inconvenienced just very slightly by him not being there. Did his contribution lead to an appreciable number of extra downloads, or did it just help the same number of pirates download faster?

With which I just mean to say that there are gradations in distribution...

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:47PM (#1149070)
That's actually so good I'm just going to repeat it:

With which I just mean to say that there are gradations in distribution

That's exactly what this whole thing is missing. No one has stopped to calculate what the impact (in monetary damages, even hypothetically on the download==lost sale metric) of a bittorrent client running for x days at home connection upload speed.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by chrisbolt on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:31PM (#1149013)
$675,000 divided by $1.29 comes out to 523,255 copies distributed, which is ludicrous.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:44PM (#1149055)
$38.70 is also ludicrous, but for the opposite reason. We can't get to the place where we start to ask "how many copies were reasonably distributed and what might the actual damage be?" until we clarify what the actual accusation is.

To the typical user, who thinks that all that is in question is $40 worth of downloads, $20,000 and $200,000 are equally ridiculous damage demands.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by protomyth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:56PM (#1149101)
I used $38.70 as the basis for what would have been bought. Most damages are based on something lost. How many seeds got data from the defendant? Is there some number that can be arrived at? I am not sure, I just don't think the amount of damage of the fine is reasonable.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:13PM (#1149158)
I am not sure, I just don't think the amount of damage of the fine is reasonable.

Of course not. Its so off the charts irrational, batshit-insane is about the only description that fits.

I'm just saying that until we get to the place where everyone understands that the real meat of the accusation is mass distribution, we won't have a meaningful dialog about what actual damages might be. Until then its just 3vi1-R144 vs. p1rat3z and most people will just believe that its all about "stealing" $20 worth of Britney Spears.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by protomyth on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:33PM (#1149228)
I understand the distribution, but I think some of the problem is the difference between distribution with intent to profit and distribution as part of getting the data. One is the intent at committing a criminal act for profit; the other is consequences of the technology means for committing a single criminal act.
Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:04PM (#1149322)
Except that using bit torrent is considered distribution automatically. Actual distribution is not shown.

I'd consider that using bt to get a copy of a recording you own (backup, format shifting) would be pretty close to fair use in the USA and certainly not immoral. If this were considered then even showing distribution would not necessarily show tortuous malfeasance.

However, being practical, a proper measure of the data distributed should be made using the available evidence. For example, the copyright holder can show the recording was available for 1 day and the ISP can confirm that the uploaded data that day was 1Gb (my broadband connection maxed for 6 hours).

This would yield a potential upload of about 150 tracks of 5MB. Assuming the tracks are 50p each then the maximum possible amount is about £75. Now apply whatever factor has historically been used in damages for those who sell bootleg CDs in the street and voila.

A few hundred pounds at most. Equivalent to a very large speeding ticket.

Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down... by kevinh on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:41PM (#1149048)
Agreed. Someone should not have their life ruined for downloading (and distributing) a few songs for no profit. If the RIAA sued people like this, I would be fully in support of it. Of course, the problem is that they would probably lose money on each lawsuit.