Re:Should a Copyright Infringer Pay $21 or $675,000 for Down...
by noonespecial on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:47PM
(#1149070)
That's actually so good I'm just going to repeat it:
With which I just mean to say that there are gradations in distribution
That's exactly what this whole thing is missing. No one has stopped to calculate what the impact (in monetary damages, even hypothetically on the download==lost sale metric) of a bittorrent client running for x days at home connection upload speed.
How much does it matter that he was distributing and not just downloading, if there were hundreds of others seeding at the same time? Other downloaders would have been inconvenienced just very slightly by him not being there. Did his contribution lead to an appreciable number of extra downloads, or did it just help the same number of pirates download faster?
With which I just mean to say that there are gradations in distribution...