News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:46PM (#11476382)
Advertising as a business model is destroying the things we love. Nobody wants addictive content. We want informative, enjoyable content, but that's not profitable. Page views are profitable, and page views require addiction.

Turn on your ad blockers. Destroy addiction as a business model. The only content that will remain will be subscription-based, commissioned by crowds or individuals, or written for free. It will be better.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by brador on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:58PM (#11476436)
Naivity. The ads will be hidden in the content and articles/videos will be paid for by advertisers to shill their products with subtle mentions. Everything will be a PR piece, and you can't block that without blocking the content.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by username223 on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:35PM (#11476831)
We seem to have reached a bearable truce with spam. I think well north of 90% of email people try to send is spam nowadays, but no more than 50% of what I actually see on any given day is PR junk, unsolicited or otherwise. Granted, messages I care about sometimes get lost, but it doesn't happen often enough to make email useless. ML-based "native advertising" blockers will eventually become as common as spam filters, and the war will become a slightly unpleasant stalemate. Maybe the end-state will be something like current product placement in movies and TV, which is usually either comically heavy-handed, or completely unobtrusive and ignorable.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by aninhumer on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:45AM (#11477482)
Actually, I was quite interested to notice recently that I don't seem to get that much spam any more. There are apparently only 16 emails in my spam folder from the last 30 days. I'm not particularly careful with my email address either.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by jrnichols on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:22PM (#11483689)
I have fairly a boring Spamassassin configuration on my mail server, and I don't get a lot of spam reaching inbox.

What I have noticed, however, is that I am now getting more and more telemarketing phone calls (robo calls) on my cell phone than I am spam hitting my inbox. It's reached the point where I keep my phone on silent all of the time because I get 5+ robo calls each day.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by cosarara97 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:46AM (#11478243)
You must have a good filter. I get hundreds of chinese spam emails every month (which get moved to the spam folder automatically) since I made my address public on a couple mailing lists.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by aninhumer on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:27AM (#11478896)
No, I mean I use gmail and that's apparently all the emails that have been caught by the filter in the past 30 days. That's why I'm so surprised.

Unless Google is automatically deleting stuff it's really sure about straight away?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tim333 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:52AM (#11479048)
gmail is sufficiently good at blocking spam that a lot of spammers don't bother with it.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by esolyt on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:35AM (#11477290)
But PR pieces are not exactly spam.

You might block "27 Thoughtful Wedding Gifts" because it has product links, but there is chance some of those links would actually be useful to people looking for wedding gifts.

Such a blocker would have to block the entire Buzzfeed, for instance.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by niij on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:47AM (#11479007)
If anyone thinks that this behavior is desirable, download BuzzOff [1], it blocks BuzzFeed and other click bait on the web. It is more than a simple DNS block, it removes entire elements that contain click bait from websites like Facebook, so that they never even appear.

[1]: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/buzzoff/jhnikgaddd...

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by takno on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:04AM (#11477909)
I'm pretty relaxed about that
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by cfarre on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:39AM (#11478411)
Me too!
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Nullabillity on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:46AM (#11478993)
There are laws about disclosing ads, no machine learning required.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by username223 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:02PM (#11481296)
There is the CAN SPAM act, too, but it only works for legitimate organizations with reputations to preserve (politicians and legitimate retailers, mostly). SMTP-level blocking gets rid of most of the bottom-feeders, and ML targets the stuff in the middle. The web already has customer satisfaction and host-level blocking for the top and bottom, but ML will still be needed for the middle.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Nullabillity on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:33PM (#11483325)
The known sites aren't the one violating CANSPAM (and its ilk). There's a huge difference between websites that people choose to visit and an open inbox that anyone can ping.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by username223 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:42PM (#11484824)
Given that even reputable/suable ad networks have been caught distributing malware, I don't see ad slots served by third parties as much better than open inboxes (though at least most mail clients don't load external resources or execute JS by default...). I think the web equivalent of CANSPAM-compliant mail is first-party advertising and third party networks who make a real effort to block malware and enforce some sort of design and privacy standards; maybe they would even obey do-not-track. The bottom-feeders are most of what currently shoves ads at people's faces.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Monday April 11, 2016 @09:02PM (#11476455)
Yes, it's an arms race. We might lose, but until then, let's go faster.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by askafriend on Monday April 11, 2016 @09:45PM (#11476631)
We've already lost
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by dexterdog on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:55PM (#11476902)
We have, but I haven't.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tobltobs on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:15PM (#11476738)
Seriously?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by krzrak on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:59AM (#11478089)
I see an analogy with free/cheap IT conferences: you go there (naively) expecting content, but it turns out that almost every talk is an advertisement of the product or job openings.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Roritharr on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:48AM (#11478449)
I have the exact opposite experience. Most expensive conferences that i've been to had a majority of sales pitches as talks.

The free cobbled together ones where you maybe get pizza and some soda are the ones where I learned the most.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by krzrak on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:12AM (#11478822)
You're right, I should modify my statement: there are free/cheap conferences that are organised by some for-profit organisations - and they're mostly pitches. On the other hand, there are lots of meetups, confs, tech talks organised by non-profits, student groups, enthusiast, etc. which are really worth attending.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by icebraining on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:00AM (#11478284)
Not so for FOSDEM, in my experience.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by yoz-y on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:43AM (#11477659)
I like native advertising in general. The one thing I do not like though is the growing prevalence of "un-advertising" i.e. blurring logos of brands that appear in the image for different reasons. I have not looked into this but I presume this is done because some sponsor earned exclusivity.

Also, I absolutely hate the current trend in tv shows to put a sticker over a logo on _every single_ computer. Real world does not look like this, it is ridiculous.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tracker1 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:05AM (#11477913)
Or the legal department is afraid of trademark case for showing the mark... or an advertising arrangement couldn't be reached before shooting was done.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by yoz-y on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:56AM (#11478477)
I don't know, it seems like a quite recent trend for me. For example in France they are now blurring the national railway company logo in news and tv shows. Which is a totally pointless action since it is on a railway station and there is (basically) only one railway company. Not to mention their logo is extremely recognisable even when blurred.

More recently I saw a show about clothing where they put some duct tape over Nike logos on shoes.

Are there laws that prohibit you from showing brands in videos shot in public places now? If Nike did not want to be recognised they would not put their giant logo on everything.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mhurron on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:45AM (#11478988)
> Are there laws that prohibit you from showing brands in videos shot in public places now?

No, but that doesn't stop the companies from filing lawsuits or threatening too if they don't like the context their brand was shown in.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by JetSpiegel on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:25AM (#11478886)
Just like Pattern Recognition.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by James001 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:25AM (#11477259)
I think you're missing the fact that everything already is a PR piece and has been forever
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mdpopescu on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @07:51AM (#11478708)
Agreed... I'm surprised that nobody linked http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html yet.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by taneq on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:59PM (#11476919)
You mean like product placement in movies and TV shows? Because honestly that's quite bearable.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by kriro on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:19AM (#11477581)
I disagree (until they do it better). The Microsoft PP is especially horrible. The way they force strange MS Branding onto laptops takes away quite a bit of immersion for me. I also hate forced dialogues that only serve PP (PlayStation in House of Cards comes to mind).

But once they do it better it becomes rather problematic ethically. What good is a "this contains PP" label if it's the standard and you can't identify it. I guess once we cross that bridge my only recourse is non consumption. I guess there might be a disruption opportunity there somewhere where you can pay for content without the PP which requires shooting TV/movies/sports broadcasts in two different modes. Doubt there would be many customers for that though...maybe the other way around, dynamic programming with custom tailored PP.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tracker1 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:08AM (#11477922)
I think the PlayStation in House of Cards did serve a bit of a plot point... the shift when he was forced to switch to a secure network point and couldn't play anymore... That lack of a day to day stress relief can have a big impact. I don't play many games, but could see it as more than PP... I don't think most people who don't play would even recognize what game system it even was.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by pluma on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:36AM (#11478011)
Case in point: I'm not a console gamer and didn't pay any attention to what console he was using. It only registered as "playing a military FPS on a TV screen" which to me seemed like the obvious modern equivalent of punching a punching bag in the basement to relieve stress.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by slededit on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @11:43PM (#11494158)
What about the trend to use actual news casters in movies? Its absolutely product placement yet there would have been a generic fake newscast if not for the product placed one.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by smt88 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:28AM (#11477437)
No, much more insidious. Imagine that every article written about a company that isn't negative is actually a paid advertisement.

As a reader, I don't care that much if an article is paid or not. If it convinces me to buy something, it'll usually be something I can return.

As a citizen, it is terrifying that journalism and advertising may one day be indistinguishable.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by taneq on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:54AM (#11477696)
I actually amuse myself during movies / TV shows trying to pick which items are product placement and which are just necessary props.

I'm a lot more cynical of articles, though, and like you I generally treat any positive piece (even down to forum posts if they smell fishy) with a degree of suspicion.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by lmm on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:51AM (#11478458)
All journalism already has biases. Why does it matter whether someone's bias comes from their honest opinions or what they're being paid for?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by smt88 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @11:20AM (#11480314)
What is Theranos could have paid WSJ not to publish the article exposing them as frauds? They might still be pushing ineffective tests on people today. They might be raising another round.

Large actors should never have too much control over the media.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mserdarsanli on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:57AM (#11478480)
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by jlubawy on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:04AM (#11477189)
Sounds exactly like the premise to this South Park episode: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_and_Advertising
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by louprado on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:35AM (#11477291)
Is there some truth to this episode ? An acquaintance of mine (picture a stereotypical MLM-type guy) recently added a P.S. to an e-mail suggesting I subscribe to 60 Minutes All Access. I found this bizarre since I had recently clicked on 60 Minutes All Access link. It felt like my friend was advertising to me based on my browsing history.

But this would suggest Google monitors what I do in my Chrome browser then suggests an affiliate embed a casual link in an e-mail based on the friend he is writing. That sounds kind of evil and improbable. Anyone ?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tamana on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @10:59AM (#11480109)
Maybe they just had a recent big advertising push. Or the link is inserted after he sends it, before it is delivered to you?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by LoSboccacc on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:33AM (#11477627)
I don't know if this is the actual case but search re-targeting is surely a thing.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by sys_argv on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @09:11PM (#11484961)
naiveté
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by sytelus on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:26AM (#11477261)
Sounds good for upper middle class population. If your wages were $50,000/yr (aka US median wage) then you would think twice or may be thrice about anything that has word "subscription" in it.

Also, consider the fact lot of subscriptions have poor overall value. Advertises allow you to try and move on without making any commitments. If all internet websites enforced subscriptions then you won't be browsing around so often.

Finally, anyone who had been in media business for long enough knows that subscription is terrible business model. Subscriber churn is almost always ongoing threat putting significant pressure on aquition pipeline. If TV channels went subscription only, most would die quick horrible death. The open secret in media industry is that advertisers are forced to pay lot more money than return they would actually get which ultimately "subsidizes" the content creation.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by devishard on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:07AM (#11477540)
> Sounds good for upper middle class population. If your wages were $50,000/yr (aka US median wage) then you would think twice or may be thrice about anything that has word "subscription" in it.

Garbage content is not an improvement over no content, no matter what your demographic. I'm also skeptical that there's a very large demographic for whom even $10/mo in subscription fees would break the bank.

> If all internet websites enforced subscriptions then you won't be browsing around so often.

Sounds great to me. Most of the time I spend on the internet is spent looking for decent content, and most of that time is spent sifting through garbage.

> Finally, anyone who had been in media business for long enough knows that subscription is terrible business model.

Excellent. I really hope the Buzzfeeds of the world go out of business.

Advertisers and the garbage they fund make the world a worse place. They prop up businesses that provide negative value. They drain resources from businesses that provide value but have to advertise to the level of their competition's advertising. They introduce insecurity and complexity to our infrastructures. They waste the talents of thousands of brilliant minds who could be solving real problems. They sell people things they don't need or want, for prices they can't afford. Worst of all, they poison the collective consciousness with ignorance and outright lies. They deserve to go out of business.

People are willing to pay for what they actually want, and people want good content, so creators of good content will be okay. The creators of garbage who need ads to legitimate their sorry existence, on the other hand, can burn.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by icebraining on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:31AM (#11477988)
I'm also skeptical that there's a very large demographic for whom even $10/mo in subscription fees would break the bank.

But what can you buy with $10/m? The subscription to a single newspaper is more than that (and you often still get ads).

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by RealityVoid on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @03:28PM (#11491396)
> Garbage content is not an improvement over no content, no matter what your demographic. I'm also skeptical that there's a very large demographic for whom even $10/mo in subscription fees would break the bank.

I wholly disagree. You think from the perspective of an US citizen but there are other places on the map where 10$ would be a great deal. This would restrict these people's access to information that they might need just as mush as you do. The side effect would be effectively closing off parts of the internet to a great array of people. You'd eventually get at the same impasse the film industry is now. Bad distribution, unserrviced areas, article piracy would pop-up.

My father earns ~300 EUR/month. How would you convince him to pay 10$/month for a website that publishes maybe ~5 articles that seem interesting to him a month?

And your information staple is not just _one_ provider, but many providers, and you'd probably have to pay them all.

The presence of paywalls would not necessarily exclude the existence of rubbish. Look at newspapers before internet, bad press also existed then, tabloids existed then. And people paid for them. No, the reason bad content exists is not because of the payment model, it's because people _like_ it. They enjoy shitty articles, they let themselves emotionally manipulated by factless press. We, as a collective, are pretty weak.

But open, even ad-based access to information can improve this. Open access leads to a more diverse information stable and eventually, people settle for the, it not best, at least better information alternative. Thing that would not happen if you were stuck in your information bubble, as is with a sole or few information providers.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:54AM (#11477349)
Advertisers aren't funding content to help the middle class. They're funding content to take the middle class's money. You might think advertising doesn't make people spend more, but there's a pretty big industry that disagrees with you.

I don't care if it's hard to build a business on subscriptions. The alternative—building a business on addiction and manipulation—is immoral. I will happily watch it die.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by icebraining on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:26AM (#11477967)
You might think advertising doesn't make people spend more, but there's a pretty big industry that disagrees with you.

So what would people do with the money if ads didn't exist? Make quilts out of bills? People are going to spend it all, that's the whole purpose of money, ads just redirect who gets it.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by terryf on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @07:26AM (#11478585)
So, you are agains people having some savings and less junk that does not make them happier? You do realise that much of advertising is geared towards getting you to do that impulse purchase that you later regret?

There are studies showing that people don't use their garages to park their cars, because they are full of stuff.

Ads constantly remind me that the newer model of the blender that I have will make me sooo much cooler (blender is just an example). But the last year's blender that I have works perfectly well. Why should I like the fact that the website tells me that I'm old and boring because I don't have a perfect body and I have last year's blender model?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by icebraining on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:50AM (#11479026)
Yes, people buy a lot of crap they don't need. It's not clear to me that they would stop doing so without advertising, or whether ads are just getting them to buy different crap. Besides, with the constant concern about "aggregate demand", it's far from clear to me that people would actually be allowed to keep those savings.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by pjc50 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:41AM (#11478415)
People would accumulate capital instead. After all, that's what the hyperwealthy do.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by LoSboccacc on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:36AM (#11477636)
also they are not funding insightful writing, but poisonous clickbaits, that's the real thing that ruined it (and virus served by ad networks)
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by ThomPete on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:25PM (#11476785)
Content marketing is destroying the things we love :)

It's almost impossible to read a well written popular piece of content today that isn't selling something either directly or indirectly.

I think we will see advertising in the form of a piece of promotion attached to other content is going to disappear as we become better and better at injecting it into our normal content.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mozumder on Monday April 11, 2016 @11:16PM (#11476994)
The problem is, the entire purpose of life is to sell.

People sell themselves just by brushing their teeth in the morning, so that they're more marketable than the slob that doesn't.

I am selling you my influence right now.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Retra on Monday April 11, 2016 @11:57PM (#11477164)
I brush my teeth because I don't want them to rot out of my face and make my life difficult. And I'm writing this comment because I think your perspective is amateurish and stupid, and maybe I'm really just a compulsive asshole.

You're pounding round pegs into square holes and just ignoring the shredded bits that went flying when you did that.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mozumder on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:24AM (#11477427)
No, you wouldn't care about "making life difficult" if you weren't selling yourself.

Everybody markets.. some are just better at it than others.

You exist to market yourself.

The moment you partake in a social group, whether it's through one more person, or through a nation, you have marketed.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Retra on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:00PM (#11484633)
That's an extremely myopic way of looking at it. Not everything that is done is done solely for the benefit of the one doing it.

And I really don't see why you're so committed to generalizing marketing and sales terminology into a general human philosophy, save for your lack of familiarity with the existing, perfectly suitable terminology.

More importantly, human identity is complex and multi-faceted, and is not entirely defined by human individuality. I can see myself as an individual, and maybe I'm selling something there, but if I see myself as a living creature, there is nothing for me to sell myself to, since rocks and stars don't give a shit what I'm 'selling.' Humanity itself is not selling anything, and my ability to see myself as an agent of humanity precludes me from selling anything in that role. So anything I do in service of those goals isn't marketing.

Imagine you just stubbed your toe. You've just participated in life. Now what are you 'selling' by doing that? Nothing.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by thrownear on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @03:37AM (#11477822)
Yes.

Nature has given us needs that needs to be full filled, like thirst and hunger. There is also higher level needs, like need to fit in and seen as a desirable mate.

What do we get in return of this pursuit? Pleasure in some cases or relief from pain, in other. In other words, it is a fair game, IF you consider that pleasure and pain are "real".

Now ads are evil because the create needs that often conflicts with our natural drives. For example, a man who loses sleep, or does not spend time with family for advancing in career, often so that he can buy more stuff. In this case, the man sees pleasure in seeing his bank balance increase and makes him afford more and more expensive stuff.

Now this pleasure, I say, is a lie. Because it is not natural, and does not serve a natural purpose. Also, this manipulation by Ads also serves to distract people from constructive thinking.

Imagine all the revolutions and all the breakthroughs of the world. They came from People who think freely. When you are distracted 24x7 by ever increasing ads, where do you have time to think for yourself? I am not saying that all the creativity from the world has disappeared. But imagine if the great artists of the past were distracted by Ads like we have today? Do you think the great works in arts and literature would have been created?

I am not even considering ads that Inject fear and insecurity into the minds of the masses to make then spend, spend, spend all day long..../rant

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by nether on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:37AM (#11477299)
"Men are estranged from one another as each secretly tries to make an instrument of the other, and in time a full circle is made: one makes an instrument of himself and is estranged from it also."

C.W. Mills

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by ThomPete on Monday April 11, 2016 @11:49PM (#11477119)
Yup. I am with you.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by VenkiPhy6 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @03:20AM (#11477773)
Personally I have gotten access to some legitimately good products via ads. So, I don't believe advertising is destroying things - only irresponsible, immoral advertisements of bad products is. This latter form of advertising thrives only via junk content(like daily newspapers, reality television etc.). No good company will be willing to advertise its products via junk content and no creator of good content is going to let a bad product get advertised. So I feel, speaking against junk content is the way to go. That way we will have good content making money by advertising products that actually deserve it while also getting rid of bad companies and junk content.

If you are thinking of blocking ads then that will hit not only the pockets of junk content creators(which is fine) but also that of good content creators who will then eventually turn to the junk.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by amelius on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @06:42AM (#11478420)
> Personally I have gotten access to some legitimately good products via ads.

Don't worry. When, someday, ads are gone, you can probably subscribe to some product recommendation service if you so desire.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tracker1 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:10AM (#11477927)
X10 is the brand I will forever associate with popover/under ads... The product itself and the company weren't necessarily bad. That said, I've always avoided them because they started it all in my mind.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tamana on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @11:01AM (#11480130)
Ha, I recently thought of X10 as an alternative to the modern IoT cloud crapware, I forgot about their webspam.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by return0 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:13AM (#11478146)
I don't think it's advertising that has got people addicted to facebook & twitter.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:19AM (#11478163)
The advertising business model is why those companies built addictive products. To make money from ads, you have to keep them coming back as often as possible, even if it isn't adding value to their lives.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by return0 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @07:03AM (#11478510)
Facebook or twitter was addictive even before it had any ads on it. How is blocking ads going to change that? You can't change human nature.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by dota_fanatic on Monday April 11, 2016 @09:04PM (#11476464)
The masses have been strongly motivated to prefer the easy, the immediately satisfying, the addictive, for centuries via advertising. If nobody wants addictive content then we wouldn't be where we are---domesticated, holding certain preferences that we like to believe are our own which are actually merely beneficial to certain businesses.

Turn on your ad blockers (and destroy addiction as a business model)? Yeah, right. Really, you're kidding, right?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by dcgoss on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:59PM (#11476443)
While I understand your position, I'm not so sure that Google, Facebook, and Twitter would look the same today if they charged each user directly for access.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Monday April 11, 2016 @09:09PM (#11476489)
Right, they'd look very different. But charging money isn't necessarily the answer there. I'm betting on decentralization. Facebook and Twitter manage identities that let us interact with our friends, but we have the technology for decentralized identities that have no middlemen. We'll replace these services with clients that act on our behalf.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Chronic51 on Monday April 11, 2016 @11:57PM (#11477161)
Who is "we" in "we'll replace these services"? Because it sure won't be me or my organization. Just like everyone who reads this comment, we will hope someone else will do it.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by flashm on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:40AM (#11477653)
That's it. Everyone is too busy trying to make money, which is fair enough. Even open source to an extent. What's the first thing programmers say when someone says how do I get a programming job and earn loads of cheddar writing apps? 'Do some open source and get it on your CV'.

No one is going to build this stuff unless it has some sort of personal gain for them. There's nothing wrong with that at all, it's just the way things work.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mbrock on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:53AM (#11477692)
If I had a basic income, I would spend my days working on exactly this type of thing, with a bit of consulting on the side to earn travel money or whatever.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by flashm on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @07:34AM (#11487287)
You've proven my point. If you had money on a tree, you'd do it, but as you don't (as far as I know!) you won't.

I would love to have a basic income, or an endless supply or money and be able to work on what I want, when I want. At the moment I'm not quite there, so have to find the odd day or two per week to work on more interesting 'stuff' than paying bills.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mbrock on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @08:09AM (#11487451)
I wasn't trying to disprove your point!

It's interesting that there is this huge contingent of programmers who have a picture of what they would do if they had basic income, and that that picture is very different from what they do at their "day jobs."

It's part of why I think basic income experiments are so very interesting. Just this question of what would people do? What new things would happen? How would software change? How would everything else change?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by flashm on Wednesday April 13, 2016 @08:25AM (#11487539)
Ah sorry that's the way it read, probably my comprehension!

It's a very interesting field. I'm not waiting around for it to happen though, especially in the UK which is a very conservative country in the main.

I'm actively building my business so that I can take a back seat, or sell it within 3 years and thus spend more time solving different problems (that may or may not have a monetary end-game for me).

At the moment they are just side projects!

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by Godel_unicode on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @09:27AM (#11479340)
Really? What value are you assuming "basic income" would take on?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by mbrock on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @10:00AM (#11479616)
Well, enough to live a frugal lifestyle. It's an established concept, if you're not familiar:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:47AM (#11477331)
My day job is to solve this exact type of collective action problem. Wish me luck!
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by jnicholasp on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @01:04AM (#11477374)
I do wish you luck. Can you give more detail about your day job?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by jcslzr on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:22PM (#11482164)
Ads are not bad, they allow more content to be available, its one thing to see my ads on every site like a virus or spam but if you enjoy visiting my site the least you can do is allow the ads so I get a profit out of it. Also Free content is not better, and it makes easier for people with money and an agenda to fill the space of people who tries to make a living HONESTLY with ads.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by pink_dinner on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:18PM (#11476754)
Ad blockers will eventually do to the content industry what file sharing has done to the music industry: it will make it impossible to make a living at it unless you are part of a very large corporation, mostly because they have other businesses to subsidize the unprofitable content models.

Even podcasts don't do that well as a business. The longest lasting podcasts are the ones that are essentially one large advertising vehicle for products or services owned by the individual or company running the podcast.

open source, another example of this, has pushed many individuals out of business because they give away many of the same set of features for free and then charge for support. A support company doesn't scale well with a single person or even a couple. This is why pretty much all popular open source projects are funded by large corporations. I can't think of one that isn't.

The pattern has been pretty clear in the last decade: push to give something away for free, the big corps take over because the individual can't compete with free, complain that big corps are ruining everything, and the latest: we now need a basic income because there are no jobs left.

Money is a necessary evil. It can give even the individual more power over their own life. I'm just surprised that so many people here advocate the voluntary shift in power away from the individual and into the hands of big corporations.

I guess I shouldn't be surprised. The whole progressive movement does exactly this. In the Nordic countries for instance, it's nearly impossible to run your own company due to the crippling taxes and regulations involved. Your only choices for employment are big corporations and the government.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by stevesearer on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:33PM (#11476822)
My ad-run business is doing pretty well and I'm the only person running it. Ad blocking doesn't seem to have affected me - yet - because my ads are relevant, nice to look at, and self-hosted. Readers and advertisers (and me) get value out of them.

I hope I'm around in the future, and I hope that other websites will see the light and follow good practices.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by zdean on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:58PM (#11476914)
This is a really great perspective. My background is in the print publishing world...going back to the late 90s. What I realize is that we keep going back to that world for guidance on what the future of the web will hold (in terms of content publishing). The first place I saw this was in design. In the wild west of the early net (prior to about 10 years ago), there was really not much rhyme or reason to how websites were designed. Then people like Khoi Vinh started advocating for grid structure in web design...bringing a concept that was well developed in the print world.

Today, we seem to be fighting for this false binary of either a web with ads or one without. What the old world of print might teach us is the importance of quality, limited, relevant advertising. When done well, people are not only OK with advertising, they embrace and look forward to it. Magazines were best at this...but they've gone down the path of devaluing their ads by moving towards more and more paid content (advertorials) and by overwhelming the content with the quantity of ads.

I think in the end, publishers will have no choice but to see what you see or else perish.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:29AM (#11477607)
"When done well, people are not only OK with advertising, they embrace and look forward to it."

Only in the mind of some advertising execs, what on earth makes you think people bought magazines for the adverts?

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by camillomiller on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:51AM (#11477683)
I have the copy of Newsweek that run only Macintosh ads back in 1984. I bought it on eBay just for the ads, certainly not for the feature about Ronald Reagan!
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by tamana on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @11:03AM (#11480147)
All of women's fashion magazine industry.

Computer Shopper.

Lucky.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by cheetos on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:24AM (#11477593)
Can you tell us a bit more please? Did you essentially roll your own internal AdWords? How do you manage customers, campaigns, tracking, payments, etc.?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by stevesearer on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @03:40AM (#11477834)
Sure, it really isn't anything special. I essentially treat the site like a magazine and sell advertisements on a monthly basis because that is the easiest thing for both myself and advertisers understand.

The site runs on WordPress so I just use one of the ad rotation plugins available [adrotate pro]. Most campaigns are for some set number of weeks or months and the plugin takes care of that.

I track clicks and advertisers track referrals traffic plus whatever other metrics they want to on their own websites. Because a number of advertisers renew regularly, I trust that they are happy with the results they are seeing. For payments, it kind of depends on the customer, but basically I just invoice them.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by seeing on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:53PM (#11476414)
Are you willing to pay?
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by natrius on Monday April 11, 2016 @08:59PM (#11476444)
I subscribe to four publications and fund two nonprofit publications. But let's assume I wasn't willing to pay. We should still stop supporting our own addictions. Especially since the people feeding us junk literally sell changes in our behavior to the highest bidder. This is madness, y'all. Opt out.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by dingaling on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:54AM (#11477350)
> Are you willing to pay?

Yes, because it doesn't have to be a direct exchange of money.

For example I feed live data to Wunderground, Flightradar24 and several other smaller sites and in exchange they give me ongoing advertisement-free subscriptions to their services.

That costs me a few pence per day in electricity, on top of initial equipment acquisition, but neither of those costs is tied to one particular service. I could change from Flightradar to Planefinder or Flightaware, for example, and receive the same benefits.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by kriro on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:13AM (#11477562)
If I were a cynic I'd say the result of such a plan would be more articles like the one we're discussing here. Thinly veiled PR pieces. I should probably dust of my Zotero subfolder on subliminal stimuli, too.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by qznc on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:18AM (#11477946)
In Germany we have mandatory media flatrate. A different business model. However, many people don't like it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beitragsservice_von_ARD,_ZDF_u...

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by pluma on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:56AM (#11478079)
It's not a media flatrate. It's a tax by any other name to maintain publicly funded television and radio channels while maintaining a separation of state and media (because of bad experiences with state-controlled media in the Third Reich and the German Democratic Republic).

The reason many people don't like it are:

* it feels like a third-party license fee due to how it is charged (e.g. you have to pay it yourself and it is charged per household rather than per citizen)

* prior to the simplification of the rules in 2013 many people would be subjected to "inspections" by the media companies, with ethically and legally dubious behaviour like peeking into bedroom windows and rummaging through trash cans (in the days of tv magazines)

* it costs money, unlike most private channels (via satellite or antenna)

* you have to pay even if you don't use it or don't want it

* despite being something you have to pay for, there is no obvious way to influence the programming

* although they are the only channels that are required by law to feature a certain amount of educational and cultural programming, in practice a lot of it is basically "entertainment for the elderly" (like telenovelas and cheesy romance flicks) or game shows

Personally I'm also extremely annoyed that they give free airtime to the dominant religious groups (Catholic Church of Germany, Evangelical Church of Germany and sometimes Jews or Muslims) "because culture", to the point that they always invite religious ministers or monks for ethical debates and frequently give them more weight than secular arguments (though to be fair: the religious representatives usually come off as fairly progressive although their arguments are of course still entirely based on theology).

Plus, of course, the fact that while BBC subscribers get Terry Pratchett we only get Rosamunde Pilcher -- and German actors, who are mostly horrible and take themselves too serious.

Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by qznc on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @07:26AM (#11478586)
I think the system needs some serious changes. However, the core idea that everyone pays a small fee for some basic media looks good to me.
Re:Medium and Twitter founder: ‘We put junk food in front of... by themartorana on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:24PM (#11476778)
And that content will be served through what internet paid for by who(m) exactly?