News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by jobu on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:46PM (#11474095)
Money quote in the last paragraph:

"When we get into things like this," [Judge William Downing] said, "anonymizing stuff, that’s well over my head technologically, then it becomes very murky and hazy."

That sounds to me like the judge likely wouldn't have known what a TOR node was if the police had told him these guys were running one.

Technology isn't slowing down, so how can we make sure the law keeps up?

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by vidarh on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:08PM (#11474272)
He is willing to admit that it goes over his head, which presumably also means that he'd be willing to read up on it or seek advice if necessary.

The biggest problem isn't judges who doesn't know everything - they have to deal with cases covering every possible discipline and can't possibly know everything about everything put before them. The problem is when they believe they do, or don't care, or don't want to admit it and decides to just trust law enforcement blindly instead.

I'd like to think that a judge that readily admits what he doesn't know will make sure to learn or seek suitable advice when necessary.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by bargl on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:37PM (#11474483)
Or when a judge is given a request with missing information and he can't ask an expert, do research, or say, "Wait, what is a Tor Exit Node and why did you mention it in your report?"

The point of this article is given the fact that they left that off then he can't reasonably ask for more information.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by derefr on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:54PM (#11474598)
Right. This is somewhat the point of the oppositional trial system; we can't expect a biased party to bring up all facts relevant to the case, so we bring in someone else with the opposite bias to give the judge the rest of the facts.

In these expedited judicial-request hearings, there isn't an explicit defendant, so there's no oppositional counsel to bring in. Maybe we need to bring back the concept of a "devil's advocate"...

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by ant6n on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:25PM (#11474808)
...Or more simply, the concept of an 'advocate'.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by CamatHN on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:33PM (#11476000)
prosecutors have a duty to 'justice' not simply to deliver the strongest result against the defendant. This is why they have to disclose information that suggests innocence.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Sacho on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @08:09AM (#11478803)
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by 300bps on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:26PM (#11474414)
Exactly. It's the job of the police to present exculpatory evidence in their possession and it is the job of the judge to understand it.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by gohrt on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:08PM (#11474688)
... which is absurd and why the US Constitution provides for a better system, which sadly does not extend to protection for invasions short of prosecution.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adversarial_system

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assistance_of_Counsel_Clause

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by johansch on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:53PM (#11474587)
If I were in the position of that judge I would like to be able to bring experts on my own. Is that possible?

(I wouldn't trust either the defense nor the prosecution to provide me with neutral information via their selected experts.)

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by CaptSpify on Monday April 11, 2016 @05:31PM (#11475280)
Although I agree with you, but if I was on trial, I wouldn't want to trust a judge who brought in "his friend who knows a lot about computers". I'd want to make sure they were vetted first.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by cm2187 on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:35PM (#11476012)
But would you have suspected the existence of a tor node if nothing in the warrant suggested it? Would you have stopped the investigation to call some experts?
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by johansch on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:41PM (#11476051)
Clearly the missing step is for the judges to announce their tech cases on reddit and ask for ideas.

Only half joking.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by ownagefool on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:26PM (#11474413)
There's other problems, such as not having enough knowledge or context to know if what the paid for expert is telling is resonable.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by derefr on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:41PM (#11474509)
The judge wouldn't have known what a Tor node is—but that's not a bad thing. What he's saying here is that the facts as originally presented to him translated into a well-known "cached" judgement; but the facts as they actually were would require original thought and research on his part (and/or those of analysts working for the judge) to come to a decision. "Guy has child porn on his computer" has a clear-cut answer; "open proxy server contains child porn" is indeed much less clear-cut. What the law says about that subject is murky; hazy, even. It's something you would need to think about.

And this thinking is, in practice, what the vast majority of a judge's every-day job is: to Do The Research—to become experts in the things they're asked to rule on, to build up the context necessary to discriminate between assertions made to them by opposed parties. Judges are already experts on the law; but that only helps when the law is already so well-established that a judge isn't even necessary. In most cases, the law is vague: it doesn't already have the answer for what should happen in this particular case, with these particular facts. The point of the judge is to decide what the law should be—to gather facts about the world, and use them to answer a question in a way that sets legal precedent going forward.

Everyone else in the court's job is, then, to feed the judge all the necessary facts about the case, on both sides, so that the judge can know just what subjects must be made clear—must be researched, or questioned, or followed up on—before the case can be decided.

(Even the irrelevant statements; the judge is the one expected to know what the law must blind itself to, so the judge wants to hear everything, and then cull the pile of statements themselves. When a jury is present and must be the one to decide, the judge will attempt to moderate the jury using this same legal-blinding... but with mixed results. In jury trials, you'll see judges trying to keep attorneys from making certain assertions that might irreparably bias a jury; but in non-jury trials, judges just want all the information they can get.)

In short: as long as judges are doing their jobs, the law keeps up. That's what we pay judges to do. If the law isn't keeping up, we've just hired some bad judges.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by wookasz on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:52PM (#11476885)
Judges don't decide cases. The jury does. Judges are there to lead the proceedings and instruct jurors in matters of the law. No evidence or facts exist outside the courtroom. Only what is stated in court can be considered. It is against the law for a juror to research an issue outside the courtroom.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by derefr on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @12:00AM (#11477171)
Most trials don't have juries. Think small-claims court, divorce court, etc. That's the default—the judge, judging. Jury-trials are a special case, there for when where no judge could be impartial enough, but they're still implemented in terms of a judge sitting there and then delegating some, but not all, of their responsibilities to the jurors.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by cplease on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:46AM (#11478050)
The entire story here is about crime, specifically in the USA. All criminal defendants in the USA are entitled to a trial by jury on all factual elements of the offense to reach a verdict, unless explicitly waived by the defendant. Most defendants waive a trial (usually by plea of guilty), but relatively few who go to trial waive a jury.

Judges do rule on pretrial proceedings including warrant applications; although in federal and some state jurisdictions grand juries still return indictments on felonies.

That said it is wrong that judges do not decide criminal cases. Besides ruling on evidence and instructing jurors, they can also acquit, dismiss, or declare mistrial without the jury.

N.B. Right to jury may not apply to so-called "petty" and/or non-criminal offenses which can carry as much as 6 months jail.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Floegipoky on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:36PM (#11476020)
>> If the law isn't keeping up, we've just hired some bad judges

The real problem is that we can't ever fire them, no matter how bad they are (see FISC)

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by intherdfield on Monday April 11, 2016 @06:02PM (#11475509)
Just pointing out that the judge who authorized the warrant didn't say that. From the article:

Judge Bowman, who authorized the warrant, said he could not talk about the case and referred me to his colleague Judge William Downing, who spoke about some of the underlying issues. "When we get into things like this," he said, "anonymizing stuff, that’s well over my head technologically, then it becomes very murky and hazy.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by cmurf on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:07PM (#11474684)
For good or bad, the American legal system (and the English one on which it's largely based) is about who makes the better argument. It's a debate contest among expert jurists. The judge is supposed to be knowledgeable about the law, and particularly good at recognizing logical fallacies.

A good judge who is not an subject matter expert should be good at asking the salient questions and stopping a rambling jurist in their tracks. The whole idea isn't to become an expert, it's to find the right questions, and provide the opportunity to expediently arrive at conclusions and solution to them. And it often is just one question.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by wookasz on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:54PM (#11476895)
Glad to see someone here understands the basics of our legal system. All this arguing about what happens when a judge is deciding a case they don't understand makes me cringe.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by dsmithatx on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:53PM (#11474143)
Let's hope that was his quick answer to reporters. I'd hate to think that when a Judge has a hard time learning something he decides, well I don't understand this so, let's just violate someone's 4th amendment rights and go harrass them rather than learning how I should apply the law (aka do my job).
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Rhapso on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:20PM (#11474354)
This will be the question that defines the era.

The singularity has come in the sense that technological progress has been accelerating and the rate of legal adaptation to it is constant. The rate of technological change outpaced legal change 20-30 years ago and now the difference is really starting to hurt.

This problem will only get worse. Can we build new laws that handle the ever growing expanse between the capacity of technology and the legal system and cultural expectations?

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by rayiner on Monday April 11, 2016 @11:02PM (#11476934)
The purpose of the legal system is to enforce cultural expectations. There is no reason to let technology run ahead of cultural expectations.

Maybe one day running Tor will be routine and not a cause for suspicion. Until then, there is nothing wrong with investigating the origin of illegal activity, with appropriate measures, and requiring Tor to be raised and proven as an affirmative defense.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Balgair on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:59PM (#11474202)
It likely will never 'keep up' and really, the law never has been 'up to date' with technology. American law allows most things until a lawyer is needed and then makes a decision to forbid or not (this is law, so there are many exceptions). We are a common law system (except Louisiana), not a code law or theocratic law system [0]. As such, the law will inherently lag. Remember, we are dealing with humans here, nothing can be perfect nor can we anticipate the ingenuity of idiots.

[0] http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/law/3-kinds-of-legal-syste...

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Zigurd on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:10PM (#11474290)
The judge is allowed not to be an expert. The police are not allowed to lie by omission when getting a warrant.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by sickbeard on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:46PM (#11474542)
A lie is a false statement, hence you cannot "lie by omission". This is an absurd assertion.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by gingerrr on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:25PM (#11474809)
A statement made that leaves out pertinent information in order to suggest a different conclusion than would be reached with the information is an implicitly false statement.

Logic is fun, kids.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by tremon on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:50PM (#11474560)
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @05:49AM (#11478252)
Sounds like just the judge you'd want to go to if you had a warrant that really wouldn't fly if he understood the technology.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by alanwatts on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:00PM (#11474640)
>Technology isn't slowing down, so how can we make sure the law keeps up?

That depends on what you me by "the law". Paper based systems simply can't keep pace with the speed of information flow in electro-magnetic systems.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by mistermann on Monday April 11, 2016 @02:56PM (#11474178)
The tech community would undoubtedly volunteer resources in the interests of a better world, the problem is it seems the government has very little interest in the justice system actually dispensing justice, it seems to increasingly be one of many tools used to control the populace. It's not only "a" tool, it is almost a magical "wild card" where you can put any opponent away forever if you so choose, and it is completely indefensible.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by ethbro on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:28PM (#11474421)
Would it / they / we? From what I've seen, the tech community (on the whole, averaged) isn't great at synthesizing and communicating information to non-technical people.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by geggam on Monday April 11, 2016 @03:42PM (#11474519)
the same non technical people whose eyes glaze over and change the subject first chance they get ?
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by 15charlimit on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:47PM (#11474948)
The blade cuts in both directions.

Yes it is a disservice to themselves and others that non-technical people zone out as soon as someone starts talking about technical issues.

But it is also a disservice to themselves and others when technical people don't even try to simplify (in a non-patronizing way) high level concepts for consumption by the general public.

Both sides aren't actually "trying". Both sides should be. Someone has to take the first step toward a halfway point, and history shows it ain't gonna be "joe/jane public".

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by CaptSpify on Monday April 11, 2016 @05:35PM (#11475310)
We need a Nye/Tyson/Sagan/Feynman for computers.
Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by Joof on Monday April 11, 2016 @06:48PM (#11475760)
"Oh, I don't understand computers."

To be fair, I rarely understand what they do even if it's rather mundane. I do like to hear passionate people talk and see them work, but I admit that my curiosity is higher than most.

Re:Judge Who Authorized Police Search of Privacy Activists W... by mulmen on Monday April 11, 2016 @04:06PM (#11474679)
The judge didn't get a chance to ask in this case.