News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by jacquesm on Monday April 04, 2016 @03:49PM (#11424897)
Long read but very much worth it.

"As the drums of war sounded in America, Egyptians believed that we could not accept a foreign invasion of another Arab country. We were furious that our government, which was allied with the United States, allowed American and British warships to sail through the Suez Canal toward Iraq. I had an intuition that if the United States attacked Iraq, Egyptians would take to the streets."

There is so much irony in that paragraph combined with the title it is hard to know where to begin.

And what became of Egypt is also really not quite what he intended.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by civilian on Monday April 04, 2016 @05:42PM (#11425942)
Overall, I'm against the Iraq war. But... I feel like an egalitarian Arab should have supported the Iraq invasion. Saddam was cruel to his people, his sons would crash weddings and rape just about anyone. The new Iraq government still has problems, but at least it's some semblance of a democracy.

Sam Harris says it best:

> As I tried to make clear on Maher’s show, what we need is honest talk about the link between belief and behavior. And no one is suffering the consequences of what Muslim “extremists” believe more than other Muslims are. The civil war between Sunni and Shia, the murder of apostates, the oppression of women—these evils have nothing to do with U.S. bombs or Israeli settlements. Yes, the war in Iraq was a catastrophe—just as Affleck and Kristof suggest. But take a moment to appreciate how bleak it is to admit that the world would be better off if we had left Saddam Hussein in power. Here was one of the most evil men who ever lived, holding an entire country hostage. And yet his tyranny was also preventing a religious war between Shia and Sunni, the massacre of Christians, and other sectarian horrors. To say that we should have left Saddam Hussein alone says some very depressing things about the Muslim world.

https://www.samharris.org/blog/item/can-liberalism-be-saved-...

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by jacquesm on Monday April 04, 2016 @06:02PM (#11426087)
> I feel like an egalitarian Arab should have supported the Iraq invasion.

But they didn't. There is a lot of stuff wrong - from my perspective - in the Arab world, and nobody with actual power from the Arab world seems to actually want to do much about it. So we end with these half-hearted revolutions which are more regime changes than actual fundamental changes and if they are fundamental changes they tend to be for the worse rather than for the better. It's a real pity.

As for the Iraq war, Saddam and his sons - and all those supporting the regime - were complete assholes. And I would have supported regime change per-se for that reason alone, but that wasn't what was sold. Because if we did support regime change for those reasons then there would be a long waiting list of other regimes that would deserve to be 'fixed' long before we'd get to Saddam (in spite of all the crimes they were engaged in the world is full of such trash, they were not the exception, in spite of the media spotlight being very much on Iraq).

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by x5n1 on Monday April 04, 2016 @10:15PM (#11427320)
Saddam was replaced by ISIS after an American inspired civil war that Cheney saw coming in 1994, so from a geopolitical realpolitik perspective, Saddam as lying smugly in his grave with a smirk thinking he did nothing wrong. American rhetoric such as "he's killing his own people" holds little weight, when we have seen America prop up regimes that routinely kill their own people for example in Latin America. In the end I think they got rid of Saddam in 91 because they were actually scared that he could put them in check if he wanted to, and that was enough to warrant containing him. Sure dictators are bad, by imperialists are worse, especially when they don't give two shits about the people and use baseless rhetoric to justify their invasion.

What's need in the Middle East is a home grown secular, scientific revolution and rejection of Islam. Without that, nothing is possible there and all revolutions and evolutions will fail. The Imperialists will continue their half ass crusade to civilize the natives... while only causing havoc and destruction.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by visarga on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:21AM (#11428037)
> What's need in the Middle East is a home grown secular, scientific revolution and rejection of Islam.

I see change coming only through the gradual replacement of generations. As old people die, new people get born and they experience the world in a new way so they form new mentalities. I think the internet and mobile phones have a lot to do with it.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by acqq on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:18AM (#11429020)
> the internet and mobile phones have a lot to do with it.

Don't think the technology automatically brings the messages you like, ISIS uses the very internet and mobile phones for their purposes. They even established the new "internet centers" in the areas they took over.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by knughit on Monday April 04, 2016 @11:32PM (#11427578)
How is the Western rejection of Christianity coming along?
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by jacquesm on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:10AM (#11428457)
Quite well except for a certain continent. In NL churches are being sold for peanuts because they're empty on Sundays. As the last generation that went to church regularly dies the church makes one last effort at value extraction: real estate price increases are being liquidated.

In the USA and Canada it is still very much a popular thing, no idea how long it will take to get to the point where people realize they're being had.

Religion can have positive effects in people's lives, but at the same time organized religion is used for vote marshalling and politics, it's just another power structure and a business to boot. This goes for most religions, not just for Christianity.

Personally I'd be fine with an englightened version of Islam, one that formally recognized the rights of women and that did away with the most antiquated and damaging aspects of the religion. Of course a push to effect that would result in even harsher pushback from the fanatics, for fear that such a strategy might succeed.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by cholantesh on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:43AM (#11431287)
Speaking as an ardent secularist, I hope at least some of the older churches are being preserved for their historical value.

>Religion can have positive effects in people's lives, but at the same time organized religion is used for vote marshalling and politics, it's just another power structure and a business to boot. This goes for most religions, not just for Christianity.

The relationship between the House of Saud and the Wahabbist establishment in Saudi Arabia demonstrates this. It's absolutely chilling stuff that is woefully unexamined for its importance to the making of the modern world.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by nsxwolf on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:48AM (#11431337)
There is zero incentive for an enlightened version of Islam. They're winning the population game and losers (the rapidly secularizing West) don't get to dictate terms.

Catholic Africa is growing and will possibly step in to replace the West after it goes majority Islamic.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by x5n1 on Monday April 04, 2016 @11:51PM (#11427656)
Very well.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-33256561

http://www.pewforum.org/2015/11/03/u-s-public-becoming-less-...

And Christianity does not have the same problems with science, humanism, and atheism that Islam does.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_humanism

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by rawTruthHurts on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:47AM (#11431331)
Compared to Christianity in the XII century or compared to, let's say, Islam?
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by visarga on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:19AM (#11428029)
> So we end with these half-hearted revolutions which are more regime changes than actual fundamental changes

I lived through such a revolution in 1989, in Eastern Europe. It's not just a problem for Arabs. I think revolutions are usually hijacked wherever they happen.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by zanny on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:44PM (#11426683)
I'm sure an egalitarian Arab would support democratic revolution by the people. Having foreign nations invade your country claiming to be bringing democracy on the backs of tanks and in the fires of bombs is not the kind of revolution that works, as Iraq and Afghanistan are continuing to show us.

It takes the blood of patriots to fuel the fire of democracy, not America's endless military industrial complex coffers.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by civilian on Monday April 04, 2016 @08:10PM (#11426809)
Right. And really, this is why I'm mostly against the Iraq war, or the Iraq war as-it-was-executed.

But like--- does the Arab world even have a culture of democracy? I think if we waited for that revolution to happen, we would still be waiting. Has the arab spring produced democratic results? The answer is mostly no--- they've just traded old regimes for civil wars among new regimes. Tunisia is a happy exception. http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/01/daily-c...

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by zanny on Monday April 04, 2016 @09:23PM (#11427113)
If the people themselves do not want democracy, we should not force it upon them. We should just open our doors to those that do, so they do not suffer under tyranny as a minority. But it is not our jobs to change the will of the majority.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by simonh on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:19AM (#11429023)
> If the people themselves do not want democracy...

I think a lot of people in the Arab world certainly do want democracy, probably a majority of them in many countries, but the problem is that once a majority bloc attains power they exercise it autocratically. Look at how Mohamed Morsi behaved in power in Egypt, or how Erdogan uses the police and courts to silence and persecute the opposition in Turkey. Look at Al-Maliki's lurch towards sectarianism [1] in Iraq that created the conditions for the rise of ISIS. As a firm believer in democracy, it's pretty disheartening.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nouri_al-Maliki#Sunni_friction

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by cholantesh on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:47AM (#11431329)
>Look at how Mohamed Morsi behaved in power in Egypt

Interesting discussion about the Arab Spring, particularly in Egypt, on /r/eli5 (of all places): https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4co5py/e...

The fact that Salafists are actually pretty well allied with Sisi's inner circle is especially disturbing.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by hoppa_liza on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:28PM (#11426613)
> Saddam was cruel to his people

So, let's bomb the shit out of those people and kill more of them. And everyone else should chip in as well.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by civilian on Monday April 04, 2016 @08:06PM (#11426788)
Don't strawman me, give me a steelman.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by imron on Monday April 04, 2016 @10:43PM (#11427447)
Sure.

It's not about rulers being cruel. A ruler being cruel to his people doesn't give another foreign power the right to come in and depose that leader by force. An egalitarian anyone would support that concept.

In any case, the Iraq invasion wasn't because Saddam was cruel - although that's definitely the ret-conned justification given that all the other reasons for the invasion turned out to be invalid.

And if being cruel to your people is the yardstick by which you choose to invade other countries, how come the US isn't invading North Korea? Oh that's right, because they don't have oil, there's no family vendetta between the leaders of those countries, there's no visceral national tragedy recently that would allow the government to ride on the back of it and go to war on flimsy pretenses, and lastly because a war with North Korea would most likely draw in China, and that's a sleeping dragon the US would rather let lie.

The semblance of democracy in Iraq has come at the cost of over a hundred thousand lives. I'm not sure how many Iraqis feel they are better off.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by DasIch on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @12:34AM (#11427829)
You're ignoring that R2P[1] exists. It's far too rarely acted upon but that's international politics.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_to_protect

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by hoppa_liza on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:46AM (#11428128)
Call me naive, but I always put human lives as a first key to judging the success of any such "operation". Death, torture and general misery do not constitute a part of any solution. Specially when the solution is not a solution begin with.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by jacquesm on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:11AM (#11428462)
It does, but it is quite rare to see it executed without some hidden agenda. I can think of very few instances where this was done cleanly.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by DasIch on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:20PM (#11433503)
The concept has been abused and will no doubt be continued to be abused. It's very important to fight against such abuse. Nevertheless I think that the fundamental idea behind it is a good one.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by whack on Monday April 04, 2016 @07:56PM (#11426744)
I can understand where the author is coming from, and it's sad that more people here don't seem to get it. There are few things that evoke people's primal instincts, the way foreign invasions do. Especially one involving a foreign occupier belonging to a completely different ethnicity, language and culture. We're literally talking about a Millenia long history where warring empires in both the Christian west and Islamic east would set aside their differences and launch crusades against one another. I'm sure many in the Arab world have no problems with engaging with America diplomatically, or economically. I'm sure activists like Ahmed welcome American efforts to facilitate and amplify the efforts of local activists. But they would react to a western invasion of Iraq the same way we would react to a Chinese invasion of America. With tribal defensiveness.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by 001sky on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:38AM (#11428103)
The point you're missing tho is that pandoras box is not a box of chocalates. You don't know what you're gonna get when you unleash a war--or a revolution. It says something about the ability perhaps to look at the actions of other objectively, but be blinded by either hubris or wishful thinking when evaluating our own actions. You're arguing that people don't see or agree with what is correct in the one view, but it the contrast not the correctness that is being highlighted.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by jacquesm on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:12AM (#11428467)
You can only start an avalanche, it has no 'stop' button if it goes to a place you'd rather not.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by acqq on Monday April 04, 2016 @03:51PM (#11424918)
> There is so much irony in that paragraph combined with the title

The irony is more apparent when you read further in the article that the author received support from the very same U.S. for his activity of making a democratic revolution. However he was just an "activist" and Muslim Brotherhood the "political force." Which developed exactly how it sounds, as he also describes.

My other comment here contains some more interesting quotes.

Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by Demiurge on Monday April 04, 2016 @04:44PM (#11425464)
It's unfortunate hyperbolic use of 'revolution' has kind of muddied and made the term less relevant. A revolution should mean a fundamental change of political system, not change of political power. Going from monarchy to socialism is a revolution. Going from feudalism to democracy is a revolution. Egypt experienced a coup, not a democratic revolution.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by apalmer on Monday April 04, 2016 @05:18PM (#11425750)
what happened in Egypt was a revolution, you are attaching additional meaning to the word that it really doesnt hold.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by Demiurge on Monday April 04, 2016 @06:03PM (#11426094)
Obviously I commented because I think otherwise, based on my interest in history and semantics of the subject, I explained why. Just telling me I'm wrong hasn't changed my opinion, but thanks.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by marcosdumay on Monday April 04, 2016 @09:56PM (#11427247)
The French Revolution brought the country from a monarchy to an empire - what are just two names for the same thing. I doubt anybody would claim the word "revolution" isn't suitable for it.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by Demiurge on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:06AM (#11427972)
The French Revolution fundamentally changed the government institution, from monarchy to republic. Being an empire, as in, containing heterogeneous cultures or states is besides the point. The point is that the states might gain some legal rights.
Re:From Leading the Egyptian Revolution to Making Minimum Wa... by justizin on Monday April 04, 2016 @05:17PM (#11425747)
> And what became of Egypt is also really not quite what he intended.

An activist's job is to point out things that are wrong. It is true that often, removing an individual or a group from power does not necessarily result in a better leader, but it is something that leaders fear happening to them.