Ideally, with some sort of force opposing propriety, the incentive would be such that the government would think it in its best interests to granularize their code into small libraries, programs, and network services, so that they could open-source as much as possible, leaving tiny "classified kernels" as wrappers for libraries or plugins for apps.
For an idea of such a force: maybe create a "proriety credit" that a government department would to buy for each 1000 lines of code they refuse to release, whose funding goes to this effort to open-source everything else?
I still kinda think the blunt instrument is an improvement over the status quo, but it's hard to say.
I wonder if this would make it easier to build a replacement whose interface isn't utterly terrible. Of course, the hard part would be convincing the courts to use it. Based on a sample size of one Clerk of Court, who thinks PACER is absolutely fantastic, this will be hard. To be fair, it is state-of-the-art in terms of access to court documents in the US.
BTW - check out www.casetext.com for an idea of what private enterprise can do in terms of making public records useful.
"Security through obscurity" will mean that nothing gets opened.
/ (the stability, security, or integrity of the agency’s systems)
(an identifiable risk to) < (or)
\ (personnel)Whether or not it's feasible is entirely dependent on the project, though. Something that's ITAR/EAR (or classified) is never going to be open-sourced.
> Applicable exceptions are as follows:
> The release of the item is restricted by another statute or regulation, such as the Export Administration Regulations, the International Traffic in Arms Regulation, or the laws and regulations governing classified information;
> The release of the item would compromise national security, confidentiality, or individual privacy;
> The release of the item would create an identifiable risk to the stability, security, or integrity of the agency’s systems or personnel;
> The release of the item would compromise agency mission, programs, or operations; or
> The CIO believes it is in the national interest to exempt publicly releasing the work.
[1] https://sourcecode.cio.gov/Implementation/