News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:24PM (#11412614)
So much bad advice.

(1) Actually it does matter how and where (relative to your body) you land your foot. Contrary to the article, many people do need to fix their "natural" form and/or get shoes that help them avoid pronation, both to avoid injury and to increase the enjoyment that will help them stick with it.

(2) Similarly, the article's advice about stretching is way out of date. It's now consensus that static stretching can not only reduce performance but increase chance of injury. The author weakly hints at some of this, but never actually recommends against static stretching like most would.

(3) Lastly, there's a pervasive assumption bordering on encouragement of people wearing headphones while they run. I realize there's a lot of controversy about this, but a responsible author would at least have mentioned that it's a safety issue as well as an aesthetic one. If you run all alone where there's no traffic - including pedestrian traffic - do whatever you want, but if you're running in crowded times or places it's irresponsible to deafen yourself. I've know runners who have both been injured and have caused injury to others because of this, so I'm not inclined to let that pass.

I'm sure many people could follow this author's advice and be fine, especially if they're young enough and slim enough that they've never had to overcome the barriers that face older/heavier runners. Good for her and good for them, but that doesn't mean her experience can or should be generalized to everyone. There are better sources. Just search for "beginner running advice" and pick anything, especially one of the articles from Runner's World. With all that was already out there - it's practically an industry - this one just doesn't cut it.

Re:How to Start Running by js2 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @05:43PM (#11413621)
a responsible author would at least have mentioned that it's a safety issue as well as an aesthetic one.

Not only will I second this, I'll add that it's also an athletic issue. I used to run with headphones. But I don't anymore, because I realized I wanted all my senses, not just to be aware of my surroundings, but to be aware of myself. I literally listen to my body when I run, because it's a cue for me that I'm running correctly. I know it's not for everyone.

Re:How to Start Running by weisser on Saturday April 02, 2016 @09:24PM (#11414470)
I used to always have earbuds in but then I ran an official 5k where earbuds were not allowed and I've never looked back. If you had told me I'd enjoy running without anything to distract me from the exercise I would have thought you were crazy but it turns out I now completely agree about wanting all of my senses.
Re:How to Start Running by fezz on Sunday April 03, 2016 @02:05AM (#11415121)
I listen to music with the volume fairly low so i can hear my foot strike and my breathing. For me, the music is not a distraction but a combination of two things i like to do... especially when it's music i love and the tempo fits beautifully with my pace. it becomes a the perfect score to your run.
Re:How to Start Running by z3t4 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:43PM (#11412705)
2) A little bit of stretching wont hurt, just don't do it too extensively. Stretching relaxes the muscles and increase range of motion, witch can have a positive effect on your running. It can also help the muscles "warm up". If stretching was so bad, you wouldn't see elite athletes do it, or cats and dogs.
Re:How to Start Running by RockyMcNuts on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:12PM (#11413760)
dynamic stretching and warming up before, static stretching after (ie holding 30 seconds at maximum extension).

if you run a lot, because it's a narrow range of motion, if you don't stretch, then over years you will definitely run into flexibility problems that stretching would have helped alleviate.

For instance runner's knee occurs when you strengthen and shorten muscles, and they tend to pull up your kneecap so it is out of position and no longer glides smoothly in its slot. (naive and possible not 100% complete or correct explanation).

If you're going to run regularly for years, a flexibility regimen is key to staying healthy. Also listen to your body, increase distance (and speed) gradually.

I think increased risk of injury applies more to e.g. sprinters or football players increasing risk of straining a hamstring by doing a static stretch prior to an activity with explosive acceleration.

Re:How to Start Running by enraged_camel on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:59PM (#11413107)
He said static stretching is bad, and it absolutely is. Athletes do dynamic stretching.
Re:How to Start Running by mynewtb on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:09PM (#11413748)
What's the difference?
Re:How to Start Running by arohner on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:28PM (#11413824)
Static stretching is probably what you think of when you think of 'stretching', holding a pose for 10-30 seconds. Dynamic stretching is when you move around. Lunges, jumping, calf raises are all examples of dynamic stretching. A quick google for 'runner dynamic stretches' would be informative.

The important part is that static stretching before workouts has been linked to increased risk of injury, and lower performance. Stretching post workout and on non-workout days is fine.

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:33PM (#11413853)
"Dynamic" means you keep moving. All of your squats, lunges, jogging in place, and so on are dynamic. "Static" means you hold a position. Your classic runner's stretch is static, as are the various "hold your toes" stretches in any position. The danger is only with static stretches prior to exercise, which can lead to over-extension and injury. The benefit of dynamic stretching before exercise is still kind of debatable. Some swear by it, others are more skeptical. Just about everyone agrees that both static and dynamic stretches after exercise, while everything's warmed up and maximally pliable, is generally beneficial.

FWIW, I don't do any pre-exercise stretching. On the other hand, I practically always do at least one kind of stretching after every run - simple ankle rotations in both directions with one leg across the other knee while seated. I really notice the difference later in the day and/or next time I run. If particular muscles feel sore, I'll throw in one or two other kinds of stretches. That minimal approach has kept me out of trouble despite running more even than most other runners - consistently five or six days a week in every kind of weather. Just an anecdote, not data, but seemed worth sharing anyway.

Re:How to Start Running by xiaoma on Saturday April 02, 2016 @07:31PM (#11414106)
>That minimal approach has kept me out of trouble despite running more even than most other runners - consistently five or six days a week in every kind of weather.

Meh. I ran thirteen times a week for years, quit for years, started again overweight more than once to slim down again and have done many 5 hour + mountain runs on the wrong side of 30. I've generally done static stretching both before and after running when I have time. After tens of thousands of miles, I'm still at zero injuries of note.

IMO the biggest thing is to not do the same thing every day. Take easy days and easy weeks between the more intense ones. Also, try not to go too fast except on speed days or tempo runs. You'll actually be healthier and faster if you let your body recover (whatever it takes at your fitness level to do that).

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @09:52PM (#11414551)

  > I ran thirteen times a week for years

  > Take easy days and easy weeks
Something doesn't quite add up here. Also, as impressed as you might be with yourself for running some unspecified distance more often than someone else while you were in your twenties, it doesn't change the fact that most runners go out every other day at most. Every distribution has its outliers, and your "meh" was unnecessarily dismissive.
Re:How to Start Running by xiaoma on Sunday April 03, 2016 @06:22AM (#11415621)
The meh was because many, many runners who do static stretching do train at a higher volume than what the poster felt was a lot and do so without injuries. One data point from someone who only runs five or six times a week not getting injured says only that his approach probably wasn't unusually destructive.

>"Also, as impressed as you might be with yourself for running some unspecified distance more often than someone else while you were in your twenties, it doesn't change the fact that most runners go out every other day at most."

It's pretty common to run twice a day on university cross country teams. As far as I know, most competitive 10k runners do. I wasn't an outlier by any means. In fact, at that time I wasn't quite good enough to make the cut. I am not "impressed" with myself for having done >200km on hard weeks.

I do think that having done that and also having done a lot of running at different sizes and shapes in my 30s without injury is at least a decent data point that static stretching isn't absolutely horrible. It might be sub-optimal but it can be done regularly for years without leading to an injury.

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Sunday April 03, 2016 @07:47AM (#11415796)

  > It's pretty common to run twice a day on university cross country teams
That's what percentage of the population, again? "Meh" to anyone who wasn't on their university cross-country team is just damn rude, no matter what factoids you're trying to get across. That sort of casual condescension toward strangers must go over really well at parties.

  > it can be done regularly for years without leading to an injury.
Nobody ever claimed otherwise. It's all about the odds. If you don't care for my anecdote, fine. Your own's even less relevant to most people. If you want the facts, stop escalating the claims about yourself (which by their very mention say a lot about whether you're impressed with yourself) and look at actual studies with real samples and controls. You might start by looking for anything by Thacker or Shrier, as mentioned here[1]. I challenge you to find anything scientific from the last ten years that leads to a significantly different conclusion.

[1] http://www.runnersworld.com/stretching/does-stretching-preve...

Re:How to Start Running by xiaoma on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:04PM (#11416553)
You're attributing malice that just wasn't there. The anecdote was meh, not the person or the drive behind it.

Honestly, I find your personal attacks and comments about how you believe I perceive myself to be the only nasty behavior on this thread.

> If you don't care for my anecdote, fine. Your own's even less relevant to most people.

I disagree. Maybe this analogy can make where I'm coming from clearer:

There are certain postures that are easier on the back than others when digging with a shovel. Imagine you have a single data point from someone who grew some vegetables in their backyard and did a bit of shoveling every weekend and a single data point from someone who worked as a tree planter in Ontario for three consecutive summers and spent long hours every day digging and planting.

I believe that neither would be scientific or conclusive, but that if all else were equal, then knowing how the posture/technique that worked for the tree planter would be more useful. I would go with that until encountering problems or taking on something more demanding than what the tree planter did.

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:42PM (#11417906)
Besides the fact that data (which I have cited and you have not) beats any anecdote, your analogy is awful. For one thing, since I happen to know people in the tree business, I can assure you that the pros use equipment the amateur isn't likely to have. It's a different activity. Second, people are broadly similar when it comes to how their bodies will handle tree planting. There's no huge difference in speed and resulting stresses on the body. What's likely to injure one person is likely to injure another, even if one is twenty and fit while the other is fifty and overweight. By contrast, few runners will ever be operating in the same milieu as someone who's competitive at the college level. Most have never been capable of it, and almost none once they've passed forty. Injury risks are most definitely not comparable across the two groups.

You're an outlier. You should be proud of that, and clearly are, but you want to have your cake too. You want to believe, contrary to the evidence I've cited, that your outlier's experience is relevant for people who have never had the benefit of working with professional coaches and trainers, for whom any likelihood of that is decades behind them, who might have struggled with all sorts of mid-life health issues before they took up running. That's the typical beginning runner who needs to know this stuff. They're ill served by your willingness to hold forth without benefit of relevant experience or familiarity with the actual science of the matter. Was there ever any rational expectation that your anecdote - which is the only thing you offered, in contrast to what you were supposedly answering - would help anyone else avoid injury? If not, then why did you feel the need to speak up?

Re:How to Start Running by xiaoma on Monday April 04, 2016 @02:34AM (#11419790)
Yeah, it was to help others avoid injury. I really do think that the biggest factor is taking easy days as well as easy weeks.

>"They're ill served by your willingness to hold forth without benefit of relevant experience or familiarity with the actual science of the matter."

This is really rude and makes more uncharitable assumptions.

The fact is I have helped a lot of friends and family members of various ages and sizes get into running without injury, and to go through marathon programs in some cases. While I've read more books and journals on running than most people ever will, I don't think trading links to them with angry people on the internet is productive. Have a good day.

tldr; Take easy days. Take easy weeks. Listen to your body.

Re:How to Start Running by JeremyNT on Saturday April 02, 2016 @10:34PM (#11414648)
Do you have some citations on 1 and 2?

I started running a few years ago, and noticed that there is a massive amount of cargo culting and folklore surrounding technique and training regimens. I ended up just discarding it all and doing what felt right because I found it impossible to filter through the noise. If these things have been properly studied and documented, I'd like to see it.

Re:How to Start Running by slgeorge on Sunday April 03, 2016 @03:16AM (#11415256)
Not the person you're replying to, but I have some sources. The best consistent source I've found is Alex Hutchinson. He reports on scientific studies and tries to sift the wheat from the chaff. Quick search found this one on stretching [1] from him. Foot strike and mechanics is a much more complicated area AFAIK.

He also wrote a fantastic book on the state of sports science "Which Comes First, Cardio or Weights? Fitness Myths, Training Truths, and Other Surprising Discoveries from the Science of Exercise" [2] which I highly recommend if you're interested in hearing about the source studies (and their limitations).

[1] http://www.runnersworld.com/sweat-science/should-you-stretch... [2] http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11115311-which-comes-firs...

Re:How to Start Running by massysett on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:15PM (#11413774)
I also think the idea of a total beginner picking a marathon is bad advice. A very fit person could pull this off, but they know who they are. Someone who has been running for quite some time and wants to start off with a marathon could do it too. But couch to marathon is a bad idea.
Re:How to Start Running by CJefferson on Saturday April 02, 2016 @04:47PM (#11413351)
I agree, I started doing a couch to 5k, I'm now off running, and I've got a constant pain in my knee which shows no signs of going away.

Turns out my technique was bad and I had a week muscle in my knee, now I've badly messed it up. The worst thing is that it never hurt seriously -- you can build up some serious damage without ever being in serious pain.

Re:How to Start Running by saulrh on Saturday April 02, 2016 @05:42PM (#11413615)
Same thing happened to me, though in my case it was less of naturally bad technique and more that I have naturally weak joints that I tried using without sufficient other supporting muscles for stabilization. Missing a few http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RequiredSecondary.... Now it's going to take a year or two, maybe more, to get the joints back to where they were so I can try again.
Re:How to Start Running by Chris2048 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:15PM (#11413771)
I had to go through a few cycles of getting shin-splints, stopping for a while, then starting again. Each time I could run further before the splints.

Maybe it's technique, but I thought it was my tendons/bone needing to strengthen after endured stress.

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:36PM (#11413865)
Everyone has their favorite shin-splint exercise. The one that works for me is one that I've rarely seen mentioned, so I'll share it here. After your run, sit normally and place one ankle across the other knee, then simply rotate your ankle in as big a circle as you can in both directions a dozen or so times. Repeat with the other ankle, of course. ;) For fun, you can put your fingers on your shin while you're doing the rotations, and really feel those muscles moving around. A simple thing, and I've never gotten shin splints nearly as much as others seem to, but I find it helps with that as well as other common kinds of post-run soreness.
Re:How to Start Running by arohner on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:30PM (#11413833)
Shin splints is commonly caused by tight calf muscles and tendons. Try foam rolling your calves and dynamic stretching before a run (google 'runner dynamic calf stretch').

It can also be technique, or shoes. But calves are a good place to start.

Re:How to Start Running by lispm on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:47PM (#11412726)
Don't listen to music while training. Especially not as a beginner. Relax. While running.

Personally I think some form stretching is useful - just my personal experience. I'm having a break for it at around 2km.

Re:How to Start Running by ak217 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:07PM (#11412830)
You're entitled to your opinion, but music is what pushes me to go hard and keeps me motivated in my runs. I literally run 25%+ faster with music on. Not only that, but it's just not nearly as enjoyable without the music (and the scenery).

If you listen to music, just wear good earbuds that don't block ambient noise, and don't crank it too loud.

Stretching: By now most runners know not to static stretch from cold start, but not stretching at all is a bad idea. In my experience static stretching after the run works great, and so does dynamic stretching after a substantial (1mi) warmup. Also, most runners don't know how to stretch their upper body. In my experience it's really important to stretch your back.

Re:How to Start Running by Bluestrike2 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:51PM (#11413067)
You can run with headphones, but at least try and minimize their dangers. Don't use ones with high isolation, like in-ear canal earphones, because you'll hear very little of the outside world. Plus, a lot of models produce lots of microphonics (cable noise), which will drive you positively batty during a run. Turn the volume down so that you can at least hear a car horn. And be sure to run on the left side of the road, where you'll be able to see cars coming towards you and move out of the way if there's ever any danger. You aren't a bicycle trying to fit in with traffic.

A lot of people prefer to run with music. That's fine, and not a problem in a park or similar area. But you need to be extra careful on public roads when you're willfully dampening one of your senses.

Re:How to Start Running by massysett on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:03PM (#11413714)
Ha. As someone who used to walk a mile to work along a very busy street, I wish I could find in-ear-canal earphones that actually blocked out the outside world. I heard every car no matter how ridiculously loud my volume was. People talking on phones often don't hear cars but I think this is because they aren't paying attention (note this can be a problem even with no headphones at all.)
Re:How to Start Running by jeffwass on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:58PM (#11413105)
What do you listen to? Do you choose specific songs to match your target cadence?
Re:How to Start Running by ak217 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @08:59PM (#11414396)
That's obviously a personal preference, I listen to a mix of stuff that you might hear on A State of Trance, as well as Hans Zimmer and Two Steps From Hell, among other things.

I don't do cadence matching, I just fast forward through the playlist :)

One other thing that has made a big difference for me recently is a latest generation Garmin GPS running watch hooked up to Strava. The end effect is that you have your running log pushed effortlessly to Strava over bluetooth once you're done with the run, and there your friends can see it and vice versa. The motivation of seeing your friends' training logs is more awesome than I ever expected.

Re:How to Start Running by dennisgorelik on Saturday April 02, 2016 @08:51PM (#11414362)
> wear good earbuds

Is there such a thing as "good earbuds"?

Earbuds, as anything else, quickly accumulate dirt.

I do not like the idea of sticking dirty things inside of my ears.

Re:How to Start Running by ak217 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @08:54PM (#11414370)
The earbuds that Apple ships with their newer devices are very high quality. I think they've set a new standard with those.

By the way, I'm talking about earbuds, not in-ear-canal earphones. I don't like those and I agree they get gross. They also block out far too much ambient noise to be safe when running.

Re:How to Start Running by eapen on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @04:31PM (#11483312)
How do you prevent it from falling off? I am on a quest to find something that is comfortable (ideally around the ear) and won't slip out. I would also like something thing so I can put on a headband and cover my ears in cooler weather without crushing the bands into my skull.
Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:11PM (#11412857)
Which is more important to you: "going hard" or being safe and considerate to those around you?

ETA: good point about stretching before vs. stretching after, though. I should have mentioned that, and so should the OP.

Re:How to Start Running by gk1 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @03:23PM (#11412922)
It's not an all-or-nothing decision. I run with music but I keep the volume low enough that I can hear what's around me.
Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:41PM (#11413891)
It's not all or nothing, but the two do often come into conflict. I'll bet hardly anybody reading this runs only by themselves on empty roads or trails. When such contention does occur, I think it's pretty clear that safety and consideration have to take priority. Isolating and distracting yourself with audio, even at low volume, is contrary to that. Also, I seriously doubt that anyone who uses music to "pump it up" and "go hard" is staying at low volume.
Re:How to Start Running by maxerickson on Saturday April 02, 2016 @05:39PM (#11413600)
If your earphones are loud enough that you aren't hearing traffic, it's probably close to loud enough to be damaging your hearing.
Re:How to Start Running by thrownaway2424 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:04PM (#11413716)
"but if you're running in crowded times or places it's irresponsible to deafen yourself"

Odd that every car sold today is marketed on the basis of being quiet inside and having a deafening sound system. Why is it so important for runners to have their senses of hearing? So that they don't inadvertently get murdered by the functionally deaf in cars?

Re:How to Start Running by enkephalin on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:28PM (#11413829)
although it of course also may happen in normal traffic, dogs, children, bikes, and other joggers suddenly appearing in your path can happen a few dozen times on a long run, if you're in a crowded place.
Re:How to Start Running by xiaoma on Saturday April 02, 2016 @07:35PM (#11414120)
Dogs are the worst. As a former dog owner I know what it's like to love one, but they're still territorial animals and a considerable safety concern when not properly leashed or fenced. Older runners have even been mauled to death by dogs whose owners didn't see fit to restrain them.
Re:How to Start Running by Spooky23 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @08:41PM (#11414321)
The consequences of failing to pay attention in the car is offset by the seatbelt, crumple zones and airbag.

As a pedestrian getting hit by or running into a car will likely kill you.

Re:How to Start Running by megablast on Saturday April 02, 2016 @08:01PM (#11414187)
You just explained why. Drivers aren't going to hear or see you, so you have to pay more attention to avoid them.
Re:How to Start Running by thrownaway2424 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @09:47PM (#11414535)
Yeah but victim blaming isn't helping the situation. Drivers create a dangerous streetscape. They need to own responsibility for that. Harping on headphones, cyclists without helmets, or "distracted walking" is not a positive response.
Re:How to Start Running by jschwartzi on Saturday April 02, 2016 @10:28PM (#11414635)
We should consider it personally as far as our individual risk assessments go, but it should never be a talking point, because it makes it seem like drivers shouldn't be responsible for paying attention.
Re:How to Start Running by jat850 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:27PM (#11412634)
Can you elaborate what you mean regarding point three, when you mention the aesthetic part of the issue?
Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:52PM (#11412747)
The author's first mention of this issue is "choose your playlist" (which already assumes it's an operative concept). Then she goes on to say:

  > If you’re a runner who likes the quiet and solitude of
  > running, then pick a bucolic path and go run.  But many
  > people like
This makes it all about what you like - i.e. an aesthetic issue. Nowhere does she suggest that what you like should be balanced against what's safe or considerate of others. Hence my objection.
Re:How to Start Running by jat850 on Saturday April 02, 2016 @02:54PM (#11412758)
Better understood now - thanks for clearing that up.
Re:How to Start Running by wjagodfrey on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:05PM (#11413724)
This comment needs to be at the top
Re:How to Start Running by msellout on Saturday April 02, 2016 @06:50PM (#11413936)
> (1) ... Contrary to the article, many people do need to fix their "natural" form

I'll second that. I'm not a natural athlete. I have very poor kinesthesia (our 6th sense). I accidentally walk into doorframes as I try to pass through. It wasn't until my wife told me that I realized my originally learned running pattern was bad for my joints.

Re:How to Start Running by msellout on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:30PM (#11417843)
I'm curious about the downvotes. Is it in poor taste to share personal experience?

Perhaps I should clarify: I used to step too long while running, landing on the heel. With shorter strides, I feel much better afterwards.

Re:How to Start Running by notacoward on Sunday April 03, 2016 @07:10PM (#11418271)
I think your comment is exactly what we need more of in this thread, because it represents the most common kind of experience. All of the data I've seen indicate that overstriding is the most common problem new runners face. This aligns well with my own experience talking to others about running. It comes up so often that I'd say it's the #1 thing separating those who stuck with it from those who didn't.

When people first start to pick up speed, they naturally tend to increase stride before they increase tempo. I think it comes from their experience with walking. Whatever the reason, it turns out to be a dangerous tendency that even runners far more experienced than me have to fight sometimes (and some lose). As more people hear that, fewer will become injured or discouraged. Hearing it from people who they can identify with, who haven't been elite athletes since junior high, is most helpful.