News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by jat850 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @05:57PM (#11400890)
Based on spez's language, is it safe to assume that a NSL has indeed been received? That's my interpretation (and it seems that of other reddit commentors too).
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by abetusk on Thursday March 31, 2016 @07:41PM (#11401456)
CEO of Reddit Steve Huffman, username "spez", writes:

"I've been advised not to say anything one way or the other." [1]

when asked whether he withdrew the canary voluntarily. The comment directly beneath sums it up:

"In case anyone is still confused or in disbelief, this is where he confirmed it. He really can't say it any more clearly without teasing the law to go after him."

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4cqyia/for_y...

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtpg on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:57PM (#11402465)
I do not believe that a canary can be a reasonable defense for "Oh I didn't say anything"

There's two situations here: Either the gov't doesn't care that you say you got an NSL (without specifics on time/subject), or they do care.

If they do care, discussion with judge:

- Did you say you got an NSL, despite there being a gag order?

- Well I didn't not say anything

- You had previously had a communication strategy set up to communicate when you would get an NSL

- ...

- So you did say it.

Case where the gov't doesn't care that you mention you got one (given you hide the time/subject through delays):

- Why did you do all the crazy stuff to tell people instead of just telling people?

- It was funner this way

Is the canary really a legal defence? I can only imagine that no, it isn't. At best it lets you imply that you got an NSL even if you didn't (oops we removed it from the template). At worst you're facing the same legal issues as before

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by redthrowaway on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:39AM (#11402672)
So why not publish positive canaries with an explicit expiry date that requires manual republishing? If you set in place a scheme, long before any agency contacts you, whereby you manually publish a statement saying you have not received an NSL, and that statement disappears on its own, how could they prosecute you for failing to publish that statement?

Better yet, make each canary in the form of an original haiku.

  Month 1:

    reddit.com  
    has not to date received  
    an NS letter

  Month 2:

    This, our company
    As of the time this appears
    Has not been silenced

  Month 3:

    Our routine remains
    A haiku for you from us
    On the month's first day
Is the USG going to claim that reddit must, in perpetuity, write a new haiku each month? That seems like a burden designed to be defeated in court.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by ghayes on Friday April 01, 2016 @02:00AM (#11402965)
I think the argument is that this a scheme clearly setup to flout the law. If those haikus kept going by a business exec until an associate should sell the company's stock, would that be an acceptable way of insider trading?
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by Odin78 on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:05AM (#11403597)
After some contemplation I must say I agree with you. Using technicalities like "well I didn't ACTIVELY say anything!" to get around the law shouldn't work in any situation - your example makes this very apparent.

At the same time, companies should not be forced to try and circumvent the law with cute tricks. Preventing companies from informing their users/customers that their privacy has been breached by a 3-letter-agency should be illegal.

We shouldn't be arguing about the legality of canaries, we should be arguing about the legality of gag orders. Arguing pro canaries is fighting a losing battle; it's fighting the symptoms instead of the cause.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by appleflaxen on Friday April 01, 2016 @08:11AM (#11404226)
The difference is in the timing. Prior to receiving an NSL, it's legal for you to say you didn't get one.

In the example of insider trading, it was NEVER legal for you to give inside information. So stopping your Haiku is legal, but the discussion when you agreed "sell your stock when my Haiku ends" was not.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by PeCaN on Friday April 01, 2016 @02:02AM (#11402977)
This is, in fact, how rsync.net's canary works: https://www.rsync.net/resources/notices/canary.txt
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by mirimir on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:56AM (#11402747)
I totally agree!

In fact, when I first heard of warrant canaries, that's how I expected that they would work.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtpg on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:23AM (#11403278)
at what point does it stop becoming "not publishing a statement" and becomes "publishing a coded statement"?

"No NSL Letter has been given for data to users with the 1st letter being P" "No NSL Letter has been given for data to users with the 2nd letter G" etc etc. Publishing 200 haikus a month like this would surely go against the gag order (since you could reveal the username like this).

I think at one point common sense comes int play

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by lukevdp on Friday April 01, 2016 @06:26PM (#11409038)
The law and common sense only partially intersect
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by michaelt on Friday April 01, 2016 @04:56AM (#11403566)

  There's two situations here: Either the gov't doesn't care
  that you say you got an NSL (without specifics on
  time/subject), or they do care.
There's a third option: The government might want to get rid of canaries without litigating their legality, so they concoct a reason to send NSLs to major parties with canaries and turn a blind eye to the removal of the canary.

If 100% of canaries were removed a month later, canaries would be pretty information-free, because the removal of a canary would just mean a canary was added a month earlier.

And it would be a simple matter to send a spy to use coffee shop wifi to post some bomb making instructions or something similar. Hypothetically.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by CurtMonash on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:31AM (#11403696)
Right.

One reason canaries are likely to be legal is that the government can work around them.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by unchocked on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:06AM (#11402515)
Can the government compel you to lie? (I don't know). If they can't, then the canary is a legal defense, unless of course the gov't prohibits those of us who haven't got an NSL from confirming that we haven't got one. But even that could not be retroactive.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtpg on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:18AM (#11403255)
It's not about compelling you to lie. Nobody compelled you to start the canary in the first place. The gov't gives you a gag order, and a priori gag orders are constitutional, so... you're going to have a hard time finding a judge who will accept the "Oh I was going to follow the gag order but my duty to my redditors to not write my haiku was so big!" argument.

The government has no responsibility to assist you in self-perpetuating logic puzzles.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by bees22 on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:17AM (#11403639)
To say "you weren't compelled to lie about X because you weren't compelled to say X in the first place" is unreasonable. It involves two actions taken by parties with opposing intentions. The latter party is exclusively responsible for the consequence of the latter action. A similar line of logic would be "you weren't compelled to give me your wallet because you weren't compelled to carry one in the first place".

That being as it is, the distinction is between compelling someone to nondisclosure and compelling someone to active deception. I imagine that's a tough battle in court, particularly if it's part of a service agreement between a company and its customers. Compelling continued publication of the canary would extend well beyond 'gagging' the company and would force it to commit what is essentially contract fraud.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by FeepingCreature on Friday April 01, 2016 @04:30PM (#11408327)
No, but at the point where you set up the canary, you aren't violating a gag order. You can't violate a gag order that doesn't exist yet.

And by the point where the gag order comes into force, it's too late; you can't comply with it in a way where you aren't compelled to lie, a power that the gag order does not possess. That's the point of the canary; you have preemptively removed from yourself the ability to fully comply. Which is entirely legal.

Gag orders aren't retrocausal. Either it's fundamentally illegal to say that you haven't received a gag order, or gag orders can force you to lie, or canaries work. One of those three options must hold.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by bennofs on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:14AM (#11403627)
What would happen if I hadn't set up the communication strategy voluntarily, but instead was asked the question "Have you received any gag order" by an outsider (which I do not know and I didn't ask them to do this or plan it with them)? Can I be forced to lie by law? Or can you just not answer that question in general, even before you've received a gag order, just so that you don't have to answer it differently once you've got a gag order? (If I always said " I can't answer this", my answer wouldn't have to change if I get a gag order).
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by austinjp on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:24AM (#11403668)
This seems nice. A network of agents could agree to regularly ask each other (or others outside the network) this question. They could even publish the results.

Of course, agreeing ahead of time to participate in this network could be interpreted as "communicating" (see other discussions here).

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by bennofs on Friday April 01, 2016 @10:04AM (#11404810)
You wouldn't even have to agree. I could just start myself going around and asking various companies the question, without the companies themselves knowing about my plan. But perhaps then I am myself acting against the law, because I do this with the intent of circumverting gag orders?
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtkwe on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:10AM (#11402541)
Canaries are vague enough that I doubt it's of much concern to the government, especially if they're site wide and once a year like this. That combined with the fact that it's harder for the government to compel speech vs a simple gag means they're fairly safe probably. Really until it's tested in court they're always going to be a little dangerous.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtpg on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:19AM (#11403259)
Yeah, my guess is that they don't care if it's once a year like this.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by incongruity on Friday April 01, 2016 @08:34AM (#11404308)
And, given that massive lack of specificity, should anyone care?

I mean, yes, in a general sense, it's notable, but it doesn't tell me how often it has happened or who the target is, so there's no personal value nor any substantial value from a civil liberties perspective because it doesn't tell us all that much.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtkwe on Saturday April 02, 2016 @10:18PM (#11414620)
> it doesn't tell me how often it has happened or who the target is, so there's no personal value nor any substantial value from a civil liberties perspective because it doesn't tell us all that much.

They never will be able to tell down to the person level. Those would definitely violate the gag order, which if you're willing to violate why go through the mess of a canary. Similarly the government is very particular about reporting just how often they're received. Testing that is a huge gamble on the lawsuit that would be filed when you get too precise for the government's tastes.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by cjbprime on Friday April 01, 2016 @02:10PM (#11407097)
> So you did say it.

There is a legal difference: compelled speech is especially and obviously unconstitutional in the US, in contrast to a restriction on what you can say.

You do still, as you point out, need to be willing to put the law to the test. Presumably Reddit has received legal advice that it's okay to take that risk in this case.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by brador on Friday April 01, 2016 @07:09AM (#11403997)
Can a government compel you to lie? Is omission the same as a lie?

It's an incredibly complex issue that your screenplay doesn't quite capture.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by Sean1708 on Friday April 01, 2016 @06:37AM (#11403903)
https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4cqyia/for_y...

Makes it a bit easier to see what's going on.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by jessaustin on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:00PM (#11400909)
Any other interpretation would call into serious question the entire concept of canaries.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by jat850 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:01PM (#11400921)
I agree. One commentor suggested that they could have voluntarily removed it for some other unrelated reason, but then they would have no reason to not say exactly that - which they aren't. Seems to leave only one reason why they did.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by hxegon on Thursday March 31, 2016 @07:08PM (#11401308)
Which spez responds to and says: "I've been advised not to say anything". Only explanation I can see is NSL.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by firebones on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:01PM (#11402256)
Which leaves open the possibility of the nefarious catch-22 of the pre-emptive NSL: the NSL that threatens you to take down the canary before they have to issue you a substantive NSL!
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by look_lookatme on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:40AM (#11402678)
This is not how an NSL works.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by recursive on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:58AM (#11403399)
But if you knew how an NSL worked, how could you say?
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by irascible on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:45PM (#11402424)
N.ot to S.ay A.nything.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by nickpsecurity on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:59PM (#11402472)
People see NSA everywhere they want to. Yet, domesric authority here is FBI which compels SIGINT-enabling for NSA per leaks. Court order, NSL, or backdoor are all FBI if coerced.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by vacri on Thursday March 31, 2016 @08:02PM (#11401547)
So, one disadvantage of these loophole canaries is that they only work once. What happens when another NSL is issued at a later date?
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rdtsc on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:28PM (#11402143)
Moreover. The state, as an actor, should simply generate constant stream of NSL requests to trip as many canaries as possible. They have the time and resources. This would basically nullify the effectiveness of canaries as a concept.

"Hey George, did you hear Reddit has a canary now too. Ok, add it to the list. Pick a user there and issue an NSL. And don't forget about Google and FB this month as well, they are about to reset theirs".

Putting oneself in the shoes of such an actor this is a rational approach to take.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by nroach on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:57PM (#11402244)
In theory, a NSL still requires a good faith belief by the issuing agency that the recipient possesses information relevant to a national security matter. That's not to say agencies couldn't use them maliciously, but it would require implying deliberate malice or deception on the part of the human agent who decided to issue the fraudulent NSL. Then again, any organization over a certain size is likely to have some conversation in their records that could be deemed nominally relevant.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rdtsc on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:17PM (#11402320)
> would require implying deliberate malice or deception on the part of the human agent who decided to issue the fraudulent NSL

Can be done by re-interpreting what is happening -- "we are not issuing bogus NSLs to troll them, we are fighting terrorism and these sites deliberately shelter and protect terrorists and other criminals. We want to periodically issue NSLs to establish protocols and methods so we can more effectively protect our country and do our work".

So it has to be story which will look good on paper and workers will tell themselves without feeling like they are doing something illegal.

Another way is to do it as a side-effect of something else -- say "we decided to double our efforts to track down drug dealers on these sites, therefore we'll put 2x more people on it and they will conduct research and open new cases and so on". So simply by allocating more resources to the "problem" they'll ensure any of these large sites will simply get a constant stream of NSLs without explictly writing that down as "we are busting the canaries" as a goal anywhere.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by sixothree on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:50PM (#11402217)
I thought the reason for NSL was to get the entire site, not just a single user.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rdtsc on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:02PM (#11402259)
Either way even better, don't have to pick a particular one.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by lugg on Thursday March 31, 2016 @08:30PM (#11401705)
It doesn't matter.

Once is all it takes, from that point forward you can't fully trust anything they say about their privacy / security.

The only real questions are: is this an april fools? And does it matter?

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by jat850 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:02PM (#11401835)
I suspect you were being tongue in cheek about it, but I don't think this would be an April Fools' matter for Reddit.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by colejohnson66 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:39PM (#11401979)
They could bring it back but with a catch: "between 1 April 2016 and (today) we have not received any NSLs, etc." But if you're gonna do that, you could do: "Yesterday, (date), we did not revive any NSLs, etc."
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by grrowl on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:38AM (#11402664)
THAT would definitely draw the ire of the law. They're even limited in how many regular orders they received to ranges of 500.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by colejohnson66 on Friday April 01, 2016 @05:35PM (#11408778)
But as has been said before, it's undecided if warrent canaries are even legal. So until we get a ruling on wether they are legal or not, we really have no way of knowing what we can and can't do.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rconti on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:00PM (#11400911)
"maybe they just got bored of it". Haha.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday March 31, 2016 @07:39PM (#11401449)
Or Twitter sent then a C&D. All your birds are belong to us.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by shmerl on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:02PM (#11400933)
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by shalmanese on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:07PM (#11400963)
Better link with context: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4cqyia/for_y...

edit: There appears to be a bug in the reddit context code, here's the original root comment that sparked the discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4cqyia/for_y...

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by schneidmaster on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:55PM (#11402239)
Incidentally, it's not a bug per se, reddit only supports contexts between 0 and 8, presumably for performance reasons. It's documented in the API docs: https://www.reddit.com/dev/api#GET_comments_{article}
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by freehunter on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:02PM (#11405816)
If you decide to put in a canary and then at any time after remove the canary, the only way to interpret that is that the canary died. There's no point in debating any nuance in his comment. The canary died.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by JdeBP on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:44PM (#11406262)
No; it's just pining for the fjords.

... What? A canary? Oh, right ...

No; it's just pining for the volcanoes.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by grecy on Friday April 01, 2016 @10:31AM (#11405009)
The more important part is that in a country that supposedly has very strong free speech laws, the government can issue a gag order, for any reason they deem, without using normal courts.

Surely that's a very, very bad thing.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by Aelinsaar on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:22PM (#11401059)
It's the ONLY safe assumption.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by yk on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:25PM (#11401078)
I think there are basically two plausible scenarios, either they received a NSL or they do no longer believe that a canary is necessary and misjudged the interpretation. (In the second case, they could of course clarify in the comments.)
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by krapp on Thursday March 31, 2016 @06:40PM (#11401156)
It's a dead man's switch. If it's gone, they've been served with an NSL and the site has been compromised. There's no room for interpretation and no other scenario can be considered plausible.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by yk on Thursday March 31, 2016 @07:58PM (#11401529)
That's precisely what I said, if you read my comment again. (But since this is the internet, I should have been more explicit.)
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by krapp on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:17PM (#11401893)
Sorry.

I really was capable of seeing nuance, once.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by 794CD01 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:54PM (#11402234)
Why does it matter? Are you really going to change your behavior based on this assumption?