News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtkwe on Friday April 01, 2016 @12:10AM (#11402541)
Canaries are vague enough that I doubt it's of much concern to the government, especially if they're site wide and once a year like this. That combined with the fact that it's harder for the government to compel speech vs a simple gag means they're fairly safe probably. Really until it's tested in court they're always going to be a little dangerous.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtpg on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:19AM (#11403259)
Yeah, my guess is that they don't care if it's once a year like this.
Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by incongruity on Friday April 01, 2016 @08:34AM (#11404308)
And, given that massive lack of specificity, should anyone care?

I mean, yes, in a general sense, it's notable, but it doesn't tell me how often it has happened or who the target is, so there's no personal value nor any substantial value from a civil liberties perspective because it doesn't tell us all that much.

Re:Reddit removed NSL canary from 2015 Transparency Report by rtkwe on Saturday April 02, 2016 @10:18PM (#11414620)
> it doesn't tell me how often it has happened or who the target is, so there's no personal value nor any substantial value from a civil liberties perspective because it doesn't tell us all that much.

They never will be able to tell down to the person level. Those would definitely violate the gag order, which if you're willing to violate why go through the mess of a canary. Similarly the government is very particular about reporting just how often they're received. Testing that is a huge gamble on the lawsuit that would be filed when you get too precise for the government's tastes.