News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by jerf on Thursday March 31, 2016 @08:25AM (#11396624)
You still can't call that a meaningful organism. The speed of light still means it can't have had more than a few dozen "clock cycles" since the galaxy stabilized enough to permit it, and it doesn't have all that many more "cycles" before the galaxy will be too dead to sustain it. There is no activity it could set itself out to do and then actually do it that would not be literally at least tens of thousands of years behind the stimulus that produced it, and that would be an incredibly quick reaction. There is no force of "evolution" or anything else that could drive this entity. It's just not useful to model it as an "organism".

Even human society can only be analogized to an organism. It isn't one either. It's not enough to point out there's vague similarities but ignore the multiple-orders-of-magnitude differences in the various scales.

And there's no need for "everything to be an organism". There's no physical reality to that idea. It's merely a reflection of our own predisposition towards weak analogical thinking when we should be dealing with things on their own terms. For human society, analogical thinking can easily lead us astray; for galactic scale society it's even harder to get away from analogical thinking because there isn't one (so far as we know) from which we can derive any observations at all, so there's no concrete facts in which we can ground our thinking.

As a stepping stone, "human society as an organism" may be the beginning of understanding. But when you start doing things like bemoaning its lack of self-preservation instinct, it's a sign you've gone too far with the analogy at the expense of dealing with what is really there.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:00AM (#11397649)
> Even human society can only be analogized to an organism. It isn't one either.

Why not?

An organism can reasonably be defined as the minimal subset of a gene's phenotype that is actually capable of reproducing. On that view, an ant (for example) is not an organism, an ant colony is the organism. This neatly solves the puzzle of how it is possible for evolution to produce ants, since the vast majority of individual ants are sterile.

On that view, the minimal possible organism for a sexually-reproducig species is a mating pair. But a single pair of humans would not survive in the wild. At a minimum it takes a village (as they say). So a human village can reasonably be taken to be an organism, just as an ant colony can. But a village can't produce a technological society. At best, a village can subsist. So why is it unreasonable to consider (say) a city-state as an evolutionary advance on the village, and hence an organism in its own right even thought it isn't minimal? And so on through the Roman empire, the British empire, and the modern nation-state and multinational corporation, all of which are no less examples of the human genome's phenotype than the human body itself.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by titzer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:36AM (#11397929)
> An organism can reasonably be defined as the minimal subset of a gene's phenotype that is actually capable of reproducing.

Where did this definition come from?

> But a single pair of humans would not survive in the wild.

Not true; there are numerous examples of single families surviving in the wild.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:48AM (#11398005)
> Where did this definition come from?

From the puzzle: how can it be that evolution produces a creature (ants) where 99% of the individuals are sterile? And the answer: ants are not the organism, the ant colony is the organism. This idea was introduced by Dawkins in "The Extended Phenotype".

> there are numerous examples of single families surviving in the wild

Not without some external support. At a minimum they went into the wild with some clothing and tools.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by titzer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @01:02PM (#11398672)
> From the puzzle: how can it be that evolution produces a creature (ants) where 99% of the individuals are sterile? And the answer: ants are not the organism, the ant colony is the organism. This idea was introduced by Dawkins in "The Extended Phenotype".

That has nothing to do with the definition of the word organism. Maybe you want another word for the unit of reproduction, but the word /organism/ already has a specific meaning, independent of reproduction.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:23PM (#11399352)
That's news to me. AFAIK, the meaning of "organism" is inextricably bound to the concept of life, which in turn is inextricably bound to reproduction. But please do enlighten me: what is this established meaning of "organism" that has nothing to do with reproduction?
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by titzer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @05:45PM (#11400807)
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @05:53PM (#11400856)
"an individual animal, plant, or single-celled LIFE form"

"the material structure of an individual LIFE form"

"a whole with interdependent parts, likened to a LIVING being"

So let's go on to look up "Life":

"the condition that distinguishes animals and plants from inorganic matter, including the capacity for growth, REPRODUCTION..."

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by Razengan on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:26PM (#11401930)
So planets that host sentient life are a form of life themselves.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:41PM (#11401984)
Not unless the planet itself reproduces somehow.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by Razengan on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:05PM (#11402066)
If we go and terraform Mars, for example, and make it just like Earth, won't Earth be said to have reproduced?
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Friday April 01, 2016 @02:20AM (#11403040)
I don't think so. What really matters is the information that is being replicated. In the case of humanity, that information is encoded in our DNA and in our artifacts. But the planet exists independently of any information that is encoded on or in it, so I don't think it would be fair to say that the planet has reproduced. But it's arguable.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by Razengan on Friday April 01, 2016 @02:37PM (#11407340)
This mostly depends on whether the planets where life originates are anything like each other.

We just assume that every life-harboring planet will have water and trees and blue skies, but even the "dead" planets that we've seen so far are nothing like each other.

However if Earth is the only place with leafy green trees, for example, and we go on to plant these on Mars and other planets, we will essentially be making copies of Earth (which would otherwise be the only example of itself) by replicating its attributes and variables on other worlds as much as we can, for our own comfort.

Over a large enough scale of time and space, Earth could be seen as a successful organism that managed to replicate itself. It doesn't need to have any direct agency over its reproductive components (us) any more than we have any agency over our own sperm and eggs.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Friday April 01, 2016 @03:00PM (#11407569)
That's a good argument, but it depends entirely on whether we (earth life) adapt new planets to suit our preconceptions of life, or whether life from earth adapts to the conditions in finds on other planets and becomes very different from what it once was. In the former case, yes, I would totally accept that earth had replicated. But I think the latter scenario is more likely.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by apalmer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:44PM (#11399526)
Thats not true, they have lone individuals who can live isolated in the wild. its just not a factually true statement.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @03:10PM (#11399744)
First, the vast majority of people who survive in the wild take tools and clothing with them. And second, it's not enough to just survive. You have to reproduce. And it's not enough to just make a baby, you have to raise it to the point where it is capable of independent survival.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by apalmer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @04:03PM (#11400183)
You have a very very mistaken view about the level of sophistication necessary for reproduction. Its just not based in fact. There are still multiple stone age level tribes on the earth. take a woman and man from such a society with no tools and clothing, and put them in a environment similar to what they are used to and they will build the tools and clothing they need and reproduce.

Most modern humans are completely disconnected from this lifestyle and probably would not be able to adjust quickly enough... but its not some impossibility of biology.

Do you think a gorilla or chimpanzee male and female couple placed in an appropriate habitat with a reasonable amount of luck could survive to reproduce?

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @04:28PM (#11400344)
> There are still multiple stone age level tribes on the earth.

Yes, of course. The key word there being tribe. Not isolated breeding pairs.

> take a woman and man from such a society with no tools and clothing, and put them in a environment similar to what they are used to and they will build the tools and clothing they need and reproduce.

Maybe. But even if this were true, the couple would still be relying on knowledge gained through their upbringing in the tribe. That's the reason doing this experiment with humans not raised in a stone-age tribe would almost certainly fail.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by Strom on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:45AM (#11397982)
Isolated families surviving does happen indeed. A good example is the Lykov family who were completely isolated for over 40 years. [1][2] However they brought with them tools made by others before starting their isolated life, like steel axes. They also imported education & language. I haven't heard of any isolated family success stories that start without any external help.

--

[1] http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/for-40-years-this-russ...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tt2AYafET68

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @11:53AM (#11398059)
> they brought with them tools made by others before starting their isolated life, like steel axes

Exactly. This is just a piece of an organism (society) "budding off" and surviving for a while on its own, not unlike an individual ant wandering away from the colony, or Henrietta Lacks's cancer cells (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henrietta_Lacks). AFAIK there is not a single example of a human mating pair completely cut off from all technological artifacts and successfully reproducing.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by V-2 on Thursday March 31, 2016 @03:06PM (#11399714)
While I do believe this hasn't really happened, surely there's a strong observational bias involved ("AFAIK" - but why would you know? :) If they're isolated, chances of learning about them would be very slim by definition)
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @03:14PM (#11399778)
Actually, we do have some actual data:

http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/naked-and-afraid/

It's not a well controlled experiment, but it's data. Even in that minimalist scenario they have some tools. Because it's just obvious that if you had no tools your odds of survival are pretty frickin' low. People die in the wilderness all the time even with tools.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by titzer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @01:08PM (#11398722)
Humanity survived with nothing more than stone hand axes for thousands of generations, and there are plenty of instances of individuals, even in modern times, surviving in the wilderness, alone, without significant tools for an extended period of time. People have been stranded and survived on deserted islands, alone, for extended periods of time. With a plentiful food source and decent shelter, it's been done many times. It's both harder and easier than you imagine.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:28PM (#11399402)
> with nothing more than stone hand axes

And a community of other humans.

> it's been done many times

I am not aware of even a single instance where a single pair of humans with no technological support successfully reproduced (by which I mean: raised a child until it was old enough to survive independently. Just having a baby doesn't count.) If you know of such a case, please give me a reference.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by apalmer on Thursday March 31, 2016 @02:51PM (#11399578)
What are you talking about? You are completely out of touch with reality. Society is great and is humans natural state... the vast majority of people are going to eventually experience psychological issues due to being alone and will lose the will to live. However being able to successfully hunt and gather enough sustenance to survive without a larger group, is not particularly 'impossible'...
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by lisper on Thursday March 31, 2016 @03:09PM (#11399734)
It's not enough to hunt and gather and survive. You have to be able to reproduce. And you have to do it without any tools or clothing or shelter that was produced by civilization. That is very, very hard. It might not be impossible, but AFAIK it has never been done.
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by dakami on Monday April 04, 2016 @10:17AM (#11422009)
I like the metaphor that ants are "cells with legs".

Life really isn't constrained to any of our neat categorizations; life really is whatever works over time.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by dave_sullivan on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:45AM (#11397067)
I think you'll find this interesting: http://accelerating.org/articles/transcensionhypothesis.html

It argues almost the opposite of your points re: "everything is an organism." One of the things the author talks about is the possibility that our universe (and just about everything in it) is exposed to evolutionary forces. It even deals with your "distances too large to form a feedback loop" issue (by taking the relativity of distance and time to logical extremes).

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by adrusi on Thursday March 31, 2016 @10:56AM (#11397622)
You seem to be assuming that an intelligent organism would have uniform thoughts across their entire body. Cephalopods, at least, don't entirely match that description. Different parts of their bodies act on their own, often with no need for central organization. A larger intelligence could perhaps work like that. Maybe then you would consider just a single section that is still intelligent when severed from the rest to be the "organism" and the rest to be some sort of "colony", but what if the borders aren't clear. What if any cubic meter chunk of alien flesh was sentient, no matter where you cut it from?
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by stcredzero on Thursday March 31, 2016 @01:40PM (#11399020)
You still can't call that a meaningful organism. The speed of light still means it can't have had more than a few dozen "clock cycles" since the galaxy stabilized enough to permit it

Signals inside the cerebral cortex were cited as traveling as slow as 7mph. (I think I'm getting that from the old Cosmos series.) So a brain could be at least 95 million times larger. So Marvin the Paranoid Android's complaints referencing his "brain the size of a planet" could be realized in theory. In Michael Swannick's Vacuum Flowers the Earth had been taken over by a hive mind called "The Comprise" but it couldn't grow any larger because of lightspeed delays. Attempts to do so would result in "mitotic division" into rival sub-entities, one of which would kill the other.

(op cites 300 kph as neural transmission speed, but this is primarily true for long nerve fibers. In the brain, it's much slower, IIRC.)

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by stcredzero on Thursday March 31, 2016 @01:36PM (#11398978)
You still can't call that a meaningful organism. The speed of light still means it can't have had more than a few dozen "clock cycles" since the galaxy stabilized enough to permit it

Signals inside the cerebral cortex were cited as traveling as slow as 7mph. (I think I'm getting that from the old Cosmos series.) So a brain could be at least 95 million times larger. So Marvin the Paranoid Android's complaints referencing his "brain the size of a planet" could be realized in theory. In Michael Swannick's Vacuum Flowers the Earth had been taken over by a hive mind called "The Comprise" but it couldn't grow any larger because of lightspeed delays. Attempts to do so would result in "mitotic division" into rival sub-entities, one of which would kill the other.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by alanwatts on Thursday March 31, 2016 @09:09AM (#11396848)
I'm curious how you define "organism", and what it means to be a "meaningful organism"?
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by eternalban on Thursday March 31, 2016 @01:59PM (#11399161)
(1) substrate -> (2) corpus -> (3) metabolic order.

Let's build one:

(1): plasma

(2): plasma cloud contained by EM

(3): Charged particle flows in context of a network of causality.

Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by alanwatts on Friday April 01, 2016 @01:43PM (#11406833)
Does EM stand for electromagnetism? If so it seems that force is the most important factor in an organism?
Re:Can a Living Creature Be as Big as a Galaxy? by transpy on Thursday March 31, 2016 @12:15PM (#11398255)
> And there's no need for "everything to be an organism". There's no physical reality to that idea. It's merely a reflection of our own predisposition towards weak analogical thinking when we should be dealing with things on their own terms.

This. I look forward to a future where science is made by machines. What we know so far has the imprint of human values and limitations. I am very suspicious when a theory 'makes too much human sense'. Reality has no obligation whatsoever to be intelligible. What really is, outside from the human mind, has a structure that is unfathomable complex: human knowledge is necessarily a reduced representation of a tiny slice of such underlying reality. And most science is pragmatical science for human purposes, not fundamental work towards the comprehension of the inner workings of reality. This is a task for superior intelligent beings, not for us.