News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by kabdib on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:02AM (#11337088)
... and this is why people with severe allergies always always always read the ingredients list, even if the packaging has not changed. And always carry emergency medication.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by jerf on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:28AM (#11337273)
Since I've discovered I've had celiac (the real deal) ~6 years ago, I've read a lot more ingredient labels than I used to, and I can vouch for the fact that food formulations change more than you'd expect without fanfare. For all that you might find "gluten free!" splattered all over a lot of things, I can tell you there have also been a lot of foods that have silently gone gluten-free over the years, along with trying to minimize their use of the other major allergens.

This includes even very big name brands, such as Doritos. For a long time, Doritos was gluten free in nearly all of its flavors except its "default" Nacho Cheese flavor. Suddenly and silently, it went gluten free. I don't know exactly when because I wasn't looking. I was actually trying to show someone that only that flavor had the wheat in it, except the bag went and contradicted my claim. I may have missed it but I don't think they ever publicized it, or if they did, it wasn't much. (Contrast, for instance, Corn Chex which has talked about being gluten free on its box now for years after it changed.)

Imitation crab meat is another example; it has gone from reliably containing wheat, to unreliably being gluten free depending on brand, to what appears to be converging on generally not containing wheat, just in the past few years. I'll still be checking labels for a while on that one, though.

(And before the inevitable commenter pops up: The things that I do not know whether they contain wheat are, pretty much by definition, the highly-processed foods high in refined carbs, so my examples have a selection bias in that direction. I do not eat either of the things I mention often or in quantity. But I'm not always 100% in charge of my food environment and it is nice at someone else's party to be able to eat something sometimes.)

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Latty on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:07PM (#11337542)
I have a diabetic friend who has problems with this - Tesco does a mixed beans in tomato sauce that I liked and recommended to him, and he checked it out and it was low enough in sugar for him.

Later, it jumped, and he was upset about the change, and contacted Tesco - turns out they change the mix for each batch based on the price of certain beans - if the sweeter beans are more expensive, they put in more of the others and add more sugar to try and keep the taste consistent, while keeping costs low.

It makes sense, but it is a pain for people with dietary restrictions (or just those trying to track their intake accurately).

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by wyager on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:55PM (#11337912)
If they're keeping the taste consistent, shouldn't the total amount of sugar stay roughly the same? It seems like the only thing that would change is how much of the sugar comes from beans versus granulated sugar.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by colechristensen on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:17PM (#11338102)
There are many different sugars. They all vary in how sweet we perceive them and how they affect blood-glucose (and how fast).
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by trm42 on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @03:33PM (#11339320)
In many cases companies are not advertising "gluten free" as it may require additional tests and certifications which cost extra money and extra effort, especially smaller companies avoid these unless it's really important for their brand.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by duaneb on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:13PM (#11338615)
> Since I've discovered I've had celiac (the real deal)

Do people pretend to have celiacs? God why?

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by jerf on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:18PM (#11338653)
The "real deal" for gluten sensitivity. Also wanted to head off "are you sure you're sensitive to gluten? there's a lot of questions about that in medicine right now" questions. Yes, I have the one that's definitely medically real. I wish it were just my imagination. :-/ (Or, alternatively, that I had found out ~25 years earlier.)
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Nadya on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:24PM (#11338691)
Not necessarily. They are trying to be "health conscience". Sugar-free diet! Fat-free diet! Both arguably good, healthier diets to have.

Then you get people who reason themselves into "Gluten-free!" must be a good thing! I blame the "____-free" moniker often being related to "healthier for you" diets. People will seek out "gluten-free" and there have been cases of restaurants serving "gluten-free" food that wasn't actually "gluten-free".

I've heard a number of cases from actual gluten sensitive individuals who have a love/hate relationship with this fad.

1) More gluten-free things to choose from! Yay!

2) More "gluten-free" things that can potentially kill them, causing them to have to be even more careful than they already were with what they choose to eat! Boo!

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by duaneb on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:55PM (#11340254)
I get the gluten-free craze; are people seriously suggesting they have celiacs when they avoid gluten? It's easily tested for and basically impossible to ignore.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by eveningcoffee on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:40AM (#11337352)
I can tell you there have also been a lot of foods that have silently gone gluten-free over the years, along with trying to minimize their use of the other major allergens.

Good find!

But as have been indicated here http://www.bbc.com/news/health-35727244 , this may be counterproductive.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by blairanderson on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:15PM (#11337598)
You're conflating disease and allergy.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Ensorceled on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @07:19AM (#11343452)
Disease, allergy and sensitivity.

My friend has celiac, my co-worker is mildly allergic to wheat, I'm sensitive to gluten.

Too much gluten makes me gassy so I avoid large quantities, but that's pretty much it. My co-worker breaks out in hives. My friend is in for a world of hurt.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by jerf on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:38PM (#11337770)
Possibly so. My gluten sensitivity is worse than my father's. Why? Environment? Different genes having slightly different effects? Heck if I know.

But at this point in my life, it also no longer matters for me. It is certainly the case that I must avoid gluten now. And, alas, to the extent that it matters for my children, they're almost certainly also going to be biologically-grown-up before we have any solid answers either. In the meantime I just do my best for them.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by rhodysurf on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:27PM (#11339727)
That is not how Celiac works. It is an Auto-Immune Disease
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by eveningcoffee on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @06:01PM (#11340293)
This is not about Celiac but about larger trend. Somewhat similar to mass usage of antibiotics.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Godel_unicode on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:08AM (#11337129)
I feel like that kind of comparison is a good candidate for a side project. Take picture, OCR, compare to old list, turn red if it's different
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by thaumasiotes on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:04PM (#11337517)
If anyone actually starts this project, be sure to record two more data points:

- price of product

- food mass of product

Those vary invisibly all the time, and it'd be great to have a record of it.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by bduerst on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:08PM (#11338022)
I worked on an idea/project a couple years ago to OCR prices off of shelves in grocery stores. Basically you could scan an isle in Safeway and have a geo-based price list of grocery goods.

After talking to people about it though, it became apparent that most grocery shoppers already have an idea of where they are going to buy groceries, making location more important than price. It's a razor thin industry, and even the price-sensitive coupon-using folks almost always just go to the closest Safeway equivalent.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by thaumasiotes on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @08:10PM (#11341012)
Well, if Hershey bars lose a few grams as a stealth price increase at one store, they're going to lose them at every store. What you're talking about is orthogonal to what I'm talking about.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by anexprogrammer on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:35PM (#11337758)
And records the congolmerate that actually owns the brand.

So many food brands are now just meaningless words in someone's brand portfolio. Especially silly when the two main competitors for an item turn out to now be owned by the same parent and rationalised to be made in the same factory.

They get traded around like football cards.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by jlg23 on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:05PM (#11337993)
And also get a very, very good insurance. Bugs in such an app can kill people.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by pyre on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:45PM (#11340184)
Since this is about OCR'ing the ingredient lists, I think that it would be much more likely to have false mismatches than false matches.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by bduerst on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:09PM (#11338029)
It could be covered in the TOS.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by jeromeflipo on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:23PM (#11337663)
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by teolemon on Wednesday March 23, 2016 @05:23AM (#11343036)
http://world.openfoodfacts.org/cgi/search.pl?action=process&...

We have them :-) We also store every single revision of the product, but we don't display the changes yet.

Join us on http://slack.openfoodfacts.org to see how we can just do that.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by reustle on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:31AM (#11337300)
Would be a cool app project. "Scan" each label as you put it in your cart, and see if it rejects it or not
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by bduerst on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:54PM (#11337898)
You wouldn't even need to scan labels per se, you could just take a picture of the box and identify the food item that is the largest in the FOV.

If your ingredients data is getting stale, you could reward users with coupons for stale-data items, so some users will take pictures of the ingredients list (kind of a 'bounty' list). You could do this for new items too - e.g. a popup after the picture is taken saying you can get $0.50 off if you take a picture of the UPC and ingredients list. Do a visual diff on the ingredients photo to see if the they have changed, and if so, OCR it to the database.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by pyre on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:40PM (#11340157)
Do the manufacturers change the UPC code when they update the ingredient lists? I doubt it. It's still technically the same item (and probably the same internal SKU too).
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by bduerst on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @07:24PM (#11340780)
Nope, but for new items in the database or if packaging changes drastically, you would need the UPC to join the update with previous data.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:47AM (#11337400)
The problem is, the ingredients can change without the UPC code changing. You would need manufacturers to purchase and use unique UPC codes for each version of their food formulations.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by gkop on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:52AM (#11337431)
Neither parent nor grandparent references UPC. Grandparent references the list of ingredients.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:15PM (#11337604)
Sorry about that! I didn't assume someone would suggest having a mobile device OCR an ingredients label, versus looking up a UPC code tied to an ingredients list and groking for your allergies.

One is easy, the other is hard.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by khedoros on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @04:12PM (#11339623)
> One is easy, the other is hard.

There are APIs and libraries for OCR, so that might not be so bad (even on a mobile device). A low-end phone is faster than the first PCs I did OCR on anyhow, and about 20 years more research has gone into algorithms.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by cbhl on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:58PM (#11339013)
OCR isn't that hard, just expensive. You do a first pass with an algorithm, and then use Mechanical Turk to correct for errors.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by lettergram on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @01:25PM (#11338177)
Having multiple allergies that can kill me, I always read the ingredients, and even check online.

For example, ice-cream manufacturers make ice-cream with peanuts in it on the same line as everything else. However, because they clean it between runs it's supposedly fine, and wont list it... It's all good until I have a reaction and have no idea why.

If you have allergies it's a great reason to learn to cook your own food. As said, you should also always carry and EpiPen and other drugs.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by pyre on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @05:37PM (#11340143)
> If you have allergies it's a great reason to learn to cook your own food

Yes, but they may severely limit your life-choices, and it also defeats the purpose of ingredient labelling (if you can't rely on it).

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by gberger on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:49AM (#11337415)
Isn't doing this illegal? Since it makes people think they're buying the same product they always have but it has actually changed.

At least in Brazil, every time the formula of a product, or the quantity in the package, is changed, companies have to disclose that on the packaging.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by pkaye on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:55AM (#11337448)
It is disclosed in the packaging. They just didn't do a big promotion prior to the change.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by mikeash on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:00PM (#11337485)
When you say "disclose that on the packaging," do you mean something more than just changing the list of ingredients printed on the package?

Here, the packaging must describe the contents and that description must be accurate, so changes must be reflected there. But nothing requires them to say "hey, we changed this" beyond changing the nutritional information, which most people don't pay attention to.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Latty on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:13PM (#11337582)
And it's worth noting this is one of those places where the technicalities kill it. How major a change is needed to trigger a 'formula changed' warning? The reality is lots of products these days change on a batch-by-batch basis to reduce costs or use what is available.

Legislation forcing companies to disclose that something has changed in a more noticable (less specific) way, would no doubt just result in those warnings always being there, making them just as useless (I mean, maybe you could say 'new formula as of <date>', but again, people are probably just going to ignore it with that much detail).

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by aninhumer on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:50PM (#11337855)
I feel like a decent compromise would be requiring a date of last change along with the ingredients list on the back. That way people with particular concerns can just check that to know whether anything has changed without having to carefully check the whole list every time.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @02:14PM (#11338616)
Do all those batches have customized nutritional information and ingredient lists? If those are the same, then the variations on the formula don't matter.

I think having the year+month of the last recipe change would work perfectly fine. If you care what the ingredients are, it's very easy to notice. Much better than 'new'. The goal is not to force anyone to care. The goal is to have information be convenient. Scouring the entirety of the nutritional info is not convenient. And adding the date is a minimal burden to the company.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by Latty on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:24AM (#11429523)
Yes, they do - I know of at least one case where they make large changes to the sugar content in a product based on costs at the time.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by elros on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @12:55PM (#11337918)
Yes, in Brazil AFAIK the law involve more than, let's say, listing it somewhere in the back in small print. You actually need to visually shout it out, think bold letters in white on a red background, occupying a sixth of the height of a can, for a canned good, for example.

If a reasonable person who's not paying attention doesn't notice it, it's not enough.

Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:51AM (#11337425)
It was disclosed on the packaging.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by a3n on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:55AM (#11337444)
not the fact of the change itself
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by gberger on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:55AM (#11337445)
Then how come they only "announced" it now? Unless the disclosure was very discreet, I'd count it as an announcement.
Re:Kraft Reveals Revamped Mac and Cheese, 50M Boxes Later by gohrt on Tuesday March 22, 2016 @11:58AM (#11337470)
This is thoroughly explained in the article.