News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mc32 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:44PM (#11320617)
Whether or not this service displaces theaters in the mid term is anyone's guess. What's not that ambiguous is the fate of movie theaters as the main venue to receive new movies.

To me the only way they can remain viable is artificially by keeping a monopoly on distribution, otherwise there isn't a compelling reason for leaving the comfort of one's abode to go see a movie in a shared space next to strangers who might behave very annoyingly. Plus there is getting there, the grime on seats, the crowds, etc.

Once screens get big enough, the form factor will cease to be a deciding factor. Sure, they have some years before that happens but they'd better prepare.

On the upside, the theaters could be reused for other community purposes, either as rec centers, hack spaces, etc.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by zipwitch on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:04PM (#11320695)
Higher-end cinemas like Alamo Drafthouse are already adapting to this. Designated seating, tight controls on audience behaviour to create a more reliably pleasant experience, extra little perks like their great pre-movie content, plenty of showings of stuff other than current blockbusters, and much better food and beverages than the old overpriced popcorn and candy.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by bcook on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:15PM (#11320736)
Is audience behavior a problem? In my limited experience, it has never been a problem.

The showings of non-mainstream media interests me, as a MST3K/RiffTrax fan.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by pyre on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:16PM (#11321156)
I sat through the (not so good) "White Noise" with some guy spending a good portion of the movie explaining loudly to his girlfriend why Michael Keaton would have been editing his audio files even faster if he was on a PC instead of a Mac.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by quanticle on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:37PM (#11321532)
When I saw Furious 7, there was a large multi-family crowd in front of me who thought it would be a good idea to bring multiple (>3) 3-4 year old kids to watch the movie... and let them run around effectively unsupervised.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by DrScump on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:18PM (#11321161)
<Is audience behavior a problem?>

The only time out of the past six or so theater trips that I did not encounter rudeness (excessive/loud talking, cellphone use, etc.) was when I saw the new Star Wars at a late night showing a month or so ago. And that was mainly because I was (literally) the only attendee.

Theater behavior was essentially churchlike before the advent of home video.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by themartorana on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:37PM (#11321534)
I don't know if it was home video. Mobile phones (texting, taking pics, yes, even taking calls) are all things I've experienced in a theater. It might be the fact that we all carry decides capable of distracting us and everyone around us - and many feel perfectly entitled to do what they want when they want.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by pandaman on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:05PM (#11321611)
I blame iPod - it appears that a lot of people have their hearing damaged (supposedly with prolonged listening to headphones) and talk very loudly because of this. I don't remember people yelling to each other during early 2000s movies (when home video had been already quite old but the iPod was not so popular and $200+ headphones were only for crazy audiophiles). For the past 5 or so years it's pretty bad. Especially children, who probably trained their voices to communicate with their half-deaf parents. It could be me getting older and experiencing the "get off my lawn" syndrome, however I'd imagine I should become less sensible to loud speech due to natural hearing loss with age.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by ericabiz on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:52PM (#11321717)
If you like MST3K, definitely check out the Master Pancake series at the Alamo Drafthouse - https://drafthouse.com/austin/series/master-pancake . To be honest, it's one of my favorite things about living in Austin. It's live comedians heckling bad films. I've seen a ton of movies this way. Some movies, this is the ONLY way I'd watch them (I saw their mock of the second Twilight film--even they couldn't make that movie compelling to watch.)

The only negative is that they are so popular that tickets often sell out nearly a week in advance. It's a great way to spend a Friday or Saturday night in Austin.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by Sir_Substance on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:30PM (#11320793)
>Is audience behavior a problem? In my limited experience, it has never been a problem.

I hate, deeply and profoundly, the sound of people eating. If it doesn't bother you then you might not have noticed this, but about 50% of popcorn eating cinema-goers cannot chew with their mouths closed.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by adventured on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:36AM (#11322258)
Misophonia. [1] I have it as well. Extremely loud popcorn eaters are nearly the bane of my existence. I've developed a system for where I prefer to sit in movie theaters, based on certain very common crowd behaviors I've noticed, after carefully studying them for the last 15 years.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/06/health/06annoy.html

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by bcook on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:42PM (#11320826)
No, it bothers me (a lot), but I have never noticed it. Usually I have to be in a bad mood to notice it, so that may be why I have never noticed in theaters.

Regardless, does the theater in question seriously notify loud eaters to quiet down or risk being removed from the theater? That is way too strict. Or maybe the theater uses sound-cancelling tech?

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by Sir_Substance on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:21PM (#11320967)
They space the seats farther apart, which helps a little, but the reality is that given a choice between home or cinema, I'll always pick home.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mikeyouse on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:46PM (#11320838)
I went and saw a movie in SF last weekend.. The couple in front of us, took off their socks and shoes and were dangling their bare feet over the row of seats in front of them.. I was appalled.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by tuttifrutti on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:09AM (#11322323)
Ah, the commotion :)
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mattmanser on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:36PM (#11321375)
When I went to see the Martian some parents thought bringing their young baby to see it would be fun.

The other big annoyance at the moment is people checking their phones. It's like getting flash lights out and shining them around.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by alexgrist on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:11AM (#11321997)
This happened to me recently, I asked a man of probably the age of 40 if checking Facebook was really important right now.

He'd been scrolling through his timeline for a few minutes before I said anything, he put his phone away and started watching the movie but started checking every setting for iOS shortly after which I spoke louder so everyone could hear that he was being an annoying prick.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by robeastham on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:56PM (#11320667)
Cinema screens at home might actually get bigger than those at your local cinema very soon. How's that even possible I hear you ask? Well anyone who has tried a virtual cinema in VR will know what I'm talking about.

It's pretty clear to me that this is the way a lot of people will want to watch movies in the future once resolution in VR is increased. This will either by higher pixel density or a move to retina projection based technologies. Both of these things are likely to hit the market with the required resolution within the next 2-5 years.

I go to the cinema a lot, but usually only if I can see the film I want on to on Screen 1 - i.e the biggest one.

VR will negate the need for me to do that so often, though I'm still sure I'll go with friends once in a while.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by TylerE on Saturday March 19, 2016 @08:31PM (#11321198)
Personally, any tech that involves wearing a headset can just go die in a corner. DO NOT WANT.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by cma on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:08PM (#11321303)
Walkman?
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mc32 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:02PM (#11320690)
That's a very good point indeed. One way or another the value of their screens will become negligible. They can force deals to keep them in business a few more years, maybe a decade, maybe more on the outside, but time and technology are definitely not on their side. They'd better have a plan B for making money.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by magic_man on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:55PM (#11321417)
Going to the movies is a social activity. Sometimes people just want to get out of the house.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by onion2k on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:32AM (#11322252)
Going there is, but actually watching the film isn't.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mc32 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @10:03PM (#11321440)
Yes, I get that. Some people will still want what will be an old-fashioned experience --just as there are a few people who still go to drive-thru movies.

Still, as the interactive aspect ramps up (where you can "watch together" virtually (VR, or alternative), this will be less of a concern.

As for the part about "getting out of the house" there are lots of other things people can do for that, walk the dog, go to the caffe, "get some milk" at the grocer's, drop by the pub, etc.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by nommm-nommm on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:16AM (#11322009)
This may shock you but people do enjoy things you may not enjoy. Your opinion is not universal truth.

In fact someone can even say "there isn't a compelling reason for leaving the comfort of one's abode to go get a beer in a shared space next to strangers who might behave very annoyingly. Plus there is getting there, the grime on seats, the crowds, etc." to your suggestion.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by CyberDildonics on Saturday March 19, 2016 @09:00PM (#11321270)
Since VCRs it always been about a monopoly on distribution plug a difference in quality. The size of the screen hasn't been a big deal for a long time, it is the resolution. Now that the resolution is basically matched by blu-ray and 4k / higher frame rates haven't made it to theatres we are seeing an opening for internet distribution. This same situation has been played out multiple times but not with the internet as a distribution model.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by ArnoldP on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:03PM (#11320438)
And they are completely correct. Even if people aren't able to bypass the HDMI encryption (which they will), a camera recording at 60fps at the screen will produce a near perfect copy, certainly 'good enough' for most people.

I do still see movies in theatre on occasion if the movie is better experienced in a group. Movie theatres need to start showing live events and offering better concessions, and alcohol. essentially become sports bars but with exceptional viewing quality.

And bars are currently eating their lunch, expanding in to other markets than sport that would be well suited to cinema venues. A number of bars in my area offer nights where they stream pro video games and they are regularly filled completely. Same thing with live streams of plays/operas which repertory theatres in my area have started to do, albeit with projectors that aren't nearly as good as your local cineplex.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by Nux on Saturday March 19, 2016 @07:16PM (#11320949)
Everyman Cinemas in UK do this (cozy sofas, drinks, pizzas), it's a nice change from the 'traditional' experience.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by dragonwriter on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:06AM (#11322313)
Movie theaters (the cineplex kind that also show major first-run Hollywood movies, not just arthouse ones) in the US already show live events (particularly art events -- live theater and other performances -- but I think there has been some sport events, as well), and there are several (including at least one chain) that have full menues, including alcohol, for at-seat service.

So what you are saying needs to happen already is happening.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by CharlesW on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:10PM (#11320466)
Do these theater chains not realize that another company has been doing this for several years?

http://www.primacinema.com/

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by eli on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:35PM (#11320574)
Isn't that like $25k to get started? Maybe they figure (correctly or not) that people spending that much aren't pirates. I wouldn't be surprised if the movies are watermarked as well.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by bcook on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:17PM (#11320743)
One thing that has surprised me on HN is that even the wealthy pirate, but perhaps not for financial reasons.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by slang800 on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:24AM (#11322018)
Not for financial reasons at all - it's convenience, the ability to get releases earlier, and the lack of DRM-free video on legal sites.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by bcook on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:35AM (#11322257)
I thought Google & Apple both supplied DRM-free movie downloads. I have the entire Star Trek original series (among other series & movies) from iTunes loaded on my Plex server with zero DRM problems.

For me, piracy has never been as convenient as clicking a button on iTunes.

Everyone likes to save money though... :)

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by __david__ on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:35AM (#11322363)
As far as I understand, nobody has drm free movie downloads. Apple's are most definitely drm protected and I'm near certain that Google's are, too.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by bcook on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:33PM (#11324776)
You seem to be right. I wonder why I am able to play my iTunes videos on non-Apple devices...
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by smitherfield on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:43AM (#11322273)
They're not wrong. Nobody is going to pay $50 to rent a movie, so all that it's going to do is create a new avenue for instant, high-quality leaks.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by intopieces on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:08AM (#11322319)
I thought that too, but then I remembered that for a family of four, a trip to the movies can easily exceed that much, especially for a 3D movie. AMC charges ~$15 for kids and ~$18 for adults. That's $66 before you even get to the snack bar.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by smitherfield on Sunday March 20, 2016 @05:59AM (#11322395)
People aren't perfectly rational beings when it comes to "sticker shock." They won't compare the $50 to the cost of tickets and concessions for the whole family, they'll compare it to the cost of a single ticket. And, somewhat more rationally, they'll compare it to the cost of renting the movie after it's left theaters (maybe $5).
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by msh on Sunday March 20, 2016 @09:37AM (#11322847)
I would, at least for select movies.

After getting kids the time we have for going to the cinema have decreased a lot and the technical capabilities of home systems have improved.

So if we could watch for example the new starwars on launch day I would have absolutely no problem paying 50 USD.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by cat-dev-null on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:46PM (#11320372)
Nice try (commercial experience meets PopcornTime), but BitTorrent Live didn't go anywhere and Netflix is nowhere near comprehensive because licensing deals are few and far between. Doubtful this will go anywhere because it's too expensive, competing with nearly free (ease of theft and cheaper-but-fragmented services) and Netflix has far deeper pockets and still has a minuscule catalog. Perhaps some Sean Parker Jedi w00w00 mindtricks can tease out deals where others have failed. Double-ended marketplace and kind of late# a highly-competitive/incumbent-monopolized market... (sincerely) good luck with that.

It's probably a good idea because it seems like a terrible idea, especially if it offers multiple defensible, durable advantages.

# There's both 'last-mover' and 'first-mover' advantage(s) in most categories.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by mcintyre1994 on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:41PM (#11320349)
It seems movie theatres make most of their money on concessions, so obviously this is a massive problem for them. Nobody's going to buy that product instead of the supermarket's snacks if they're watching at home.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by SoreGums on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:22AM (#11322234)
Funny thing here in NZ, the main theatre chain Event doesn't even care if we go downstairs to the supermarket and bring in those snacks....

I think it is mostly because they charge $20+ for the movie ticket in the first place, though I get cheep tickets, $11, because of the deal with the major telco Spark

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by pink_dinner on Saturday March 19, 2016 @02:43PM (#11319820)
Many people thing $10 is too expensive for a movie ticket, why would they pay $150?
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by tssva on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:12PM (#11320225)
Each movie is $50. The set top box is a one time fee of $150. Tickets at the closest theater to me are $12.10 and that is average for the area. With popcorn, drinks and online ticket fees your total approaches $50 for 2 people. If you have a family with kids the cost is going to blow by $50. Some people like the theater experience and this may not appeal to them but there is definitely a large number of people it will appeal to.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by forgetsusername on Saturday March 19, 2016 @04:48PM (#11320375)
>definitely a large number of people it will appeal to

How large? Because we can't pretend that piracy isn't a thing.

The theatre is expensive, sure. But it also has an audio visual experience that dominates anything anyone can have in their home, which is part of the premium.

Is it worth $50 for a one-time movie experience in your home? Are people so desperate to see a movie they can't wait for it to reach Netflix or Amazon for "free", or pay $20 to own it on Bluray? I'm skeptical.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by tssva on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:40PM (#11320594)
For some movies the audio visual experience at the theater is key but for many movies it doesn't provide a huge increase to the enjoyment of the movie. I think you over estimate it as a driver of people to theaters. I think the a more than large enough number of people are there because they don't want to wait for the movie to reach Netflix, Amazon or Bluray.

Unfortunately despite this I don't see this service becoming a reality. At least not with a selection of movies beyond indies. I don't believe the major studios will risk their relationships with the theater chains.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by pavel_lishin on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:36PM (#11320579)
> Are people so desperate to see a movie they can't wait for it to reach Netflix or Amazon for "free", or pay $20 to own it on Bluray? I'm skeptical.

Plenty of movies I want to see will never see Amazon or Netflix (Where can I stream The Avengers?), and plenty of people have no interest in cluttering up their house or apartment with BlueRay copies of movies they only want to see once.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by douche on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:40PM (#11320592)
The Avengers has been on steady rotation on TBS (or maybe it's FX, one of those channels...) for years now. I think I've watched it at least a dozen times, without even trying.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by pavel_lishin on Saturday March 19, 2016 @06:29PM (#11320789)
But that's TV, not Netflix/Amazon - not on demand. Entirely different thing.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by alexhutcheson on Saturday March 19, 2016 @11:42PM (#11321682)
The Avengers is on HBO Go now
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by Karunamon on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:10PM (#11320464)
Visual maybe just due to screen size, but audio? No way. 5.1 on a even modestly specced surround receiver is at least as good as any theater.

There are fewer and fewer reasons to go to the theater. Why would you pay upwards of $10 for a ticket, $20 for a popcorn and soda to sit in someone else's filthy chairs to be advertised to for 30 minutes straight and listen to people chatting and children screaming?

Unless you're there for the social aspect, i.e. with friends, the value just ian't there.

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by douche on Saturday March 19, 2016 @05:35PM (#11320571)
Exactly. I can watch a movie on my own couch, with my own popcorn and soda, and my friends and family basically for free. With a 40"+ flat screen that costs about the same as four or five trips to the theater.

I've noticed in the last few years that there are fewer and fewer movies that I'm even vaguely interested in seeing. Maybe when I was living at home and near a theater that offered $4 tickets, and no ads, I might take a flier on a potentially bad movie, but at $12-15 a pop at the chain cinemas around here, when the movie doesn't start on time because they are showing 45 minutes of ABC commericals... Nope

Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by Thlom on Sunday March 20, 2016 @02:56AM (#11322082)
Regarding ads: 45 minutes sounds crazy. At least in most of Europe the advertisements are programmed to end 10-15 minutes after scheduled time or the feature to start 10-20 minutes after scheduled time. depends on the cinemas agreement with the advertisement company.
Re:Napster Founder's Movie Plan Will Fuel Torrent Sites, The... by svarrall on Sunday March 20, 2016 @04:59AM (#11322300)
I don't keep track, but when was the last time a major film wasn't pirated on release or even before release?

Is additional piracy really a major concern with this?