News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by ChrisBland on Thursday March 17, 2016 @12:49PM (#11305606)
What if a "terrorist" wrote some "bad words" down on a piece of paper and shredded it before/during a raid? Can the FBI require that paper shredders come with an auto re-assemble feature? What if a drug dealer keeps a coded ledger, can they go to crypto experts and compel them to work on solving it? The government has in its possession the data, the data is just not in a format the government wants so they are trying to bend the rules for themselves.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jpgvm on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:38PM (#11306055)
It's pretty clear that the laws need to be different for a device that goes with you everywhere and for all intents and purposes records your entire life.

I like the "extension of the brain" analogy. Where by searching your phone should be tantamount to thought policing.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:12PM (#11306319)
I don't think that's pretty clear at all. Back when people wrote down their daily activities and most intimate thoughts in their journals, one might have argued those were an "extension of the brain." Yet, peoples' desk drawers have always been subject to search with a warrant.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessegreathouse on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:27PM (#11306443)
No, it's more like mandating that those journals have to be written in english instead of sanskrit. The government has the authority to reasonable search and seizure, but they don't have the authority to mandate how we express ourselves in written word or data.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:49PM (#11306595)
I'm referring to this part of OP's comment: "Where by searching your phone should be tantamount to thought policing."
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by adamnemecek on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:26PM (#11306434)
But they have access to the phone. It's like if you wrote the diary in a language that no one understood. What would the gov't do then?
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by r0m4n0 on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:36PM (#11306516)
Having a warrant for a desk drawer doesn't put every person on the planet at risk for possible access of intimate personal life details.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by harryh on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:49PM (#11306594)
Neither does an encryption standard that allows for the unlocking of a device in one's physical possession.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jpgvm on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:01PM (#11306705)
It's highly unlikely a fully physical key could be developed for a digital system that would have sufficient security not to be exploited by bad actors that have physical access to the device.

Given that it's likely that fully physical access is unlikely to be a necessity to make use of the backdoor. Thus it's fair to assume it could also be exploited (or used "legitimately" by law enforcement) remotely - even if it is primary intended to unlock the device they have seized it physically.

Backdoors of any description are simply impossible to implement securely.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by harryh on Thursday March 17, 2016 @04:31PM (#11307358)
> Thus it's fair to assume it could also be exploited remotely

When the data in question only resides on the physical device that is not a fair assumption at all.

An alternate OS that allows all 10,000 4-digit codes to be rapidly tried isn't a piece of magic that allows you to do anything you want. It has a very limited use.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jpgvm on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:54PM (#11306639)
Someone already covered the goes with you everywhere part but it's worth noting that a diary though very personal is something you consciously populate with thoughts that you know one day could very well be read by someone else.

A lot of the things people do on a phone they may not even be aware is leaving history and other information on the device as they use it.

You could argue they they should be better informed, but should they really? Should we expect to forever limit ourselves to only our brain for storing secret information as it's the only place held sacrosanct in the eyes of the law?

I think not. The law should change with the times. The mind/brain is expanding into the electronic world and the protections afforded to our biological brain should be extended in concert.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @04:02PM (#11307127)
The law should change with the times only when technological change implicates the rationale of a rule. The rationale of the 5th amendment isn't to have a place for storing secret information. It's the uniquely pursuasive nature of confessions and the incentive to coerce them. Note that when there is no such threat, even being in your brain doesn't stop courts from getting at information. A court can compel a witness to testify, for example, so long as the testimony isn't incriminating.

Phones don't implicate the threat of coerced confessions regardless of what is on them.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @05:58PM (#11307966)
But the reason for the police being able to search you in the first place is to investigate crime because of the harm it causes to society. That needs to be balanced against the harm such searches cause.

If the harm caused by searches goes up, what changes to balance that?

You're taking the law as a given and saying that society must bend because the law has been constant for many hundred years.

But that's a bug. Yes, the systems for change are rusty and those in power would rather inflict the wrong laws than allow them to change, but the point in this discussion is more than what can Apple get away with now, but what should they strive for. In that sense, what should the law be to best serve people who feel that Apple is right in creating "unhackable" phones?

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:40PM (#11306539)
You did read the part about the differences right. Did you carry that desk drawer with you everywhere? Did it record your location?

The point is about what the law should be to be useful. Not about what the law says, or can be taken to say.

The FBI plays it as if the law binds the people, but the law is the people's, and binds the FBI. We don't have to care what they like. It isn't a two-way street, or a conversation. They're employees. So's Obama.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:50PM (#11306604)
> The point is about what the law should be to be useful.

The law creates a perfectly useful distinction. What's in your mind is in your mind. What's on inanimate objects, whether they be desk drawers or iPhones, is subject to search.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jpgvm on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:57PM (#11306661)
That is the current law. I'm arguing that it should be changed . Inanimate objects got a lot more advanced in the last 20 years, the law hasn't become nuanced enough to deal with this.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @06:18PM (#11308072)
What does it matter that inanimate objects got more advanced? Was the original distinction ever due to the fact that inanimate objects weren't advanced?
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @07:23PM (#11308476)
Because they now perform functions inconceivable in the past - such as inadvertently logging everything you do.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @05:17PM (#11307683)
> The law creates a [...] distinction

Fixed that. Citation needed for the elided segment.

Here's a physical iPhone that is not subject to search.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mindslight on Thursday March 17, 2016 @06:32PM (#11308165)
Legally, it's not at all clear. But morally it is. Which is why secure crypto needs to be adopted far and wide. Man-made laws follow physics, not vice-versa.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by Osiris30 on Thursday March 17, 2016 @12:55PM (#11305658)
I think the slightly better analogy would be a manufacturer that creates an unbreakable safe.

A box for which they can't make an individual key, only a master-key (at great cost of man-hours).

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by ChrisBland on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:03PM (#11305713)
The reason I don't like the safe analogy is that it is something physical, which the courts have repeatedly said is fair game. They can compel you to open a safe, they can not compel you to turn over a password. Something you have vs something you know. Which is why I also added the crypto example. The feds can not force me to decrypt my own crypto, I have 5th amendment protection against that. The 5th does not extend to something you have / are, which is why fingerprints to unlock an iphone can be compelled by the courts but they can't force you to turn over your password.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by HNaTTY on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:29PM (#11306892)
> The feds can not force me to decrypt my own crypto, I have 5th amendment protection against that.

That depends on what the gov't knows about what encrypted files you have. In the worst case, they don't need to ask you for your password, they just need you to decrypt your data.

In Re Boucher is the most famous case where the government ruled that the 5th amendment couldn't prevent the government from compelling someone to decrypt their data. On the flip side, Wikipedia has this short blurb on it's article on U.S. V Hubbell: "The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Hubbell. The Court held that the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination protects a witness from being compelled to disclose the existence of incriminating documents that the Government is unable to describe with reasonable particularity. The Court also ruled that if the witness produces such documents, pursuant to a grant of immunity, the government may not use them to prepare criminal charges against him."

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by Osiris30 on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:18PM (#11305855)
Yes thats the key point - but the physical safe analogy is how the DoJ thinks (or wants to think, and wants the public to think) about the issue.

crypto = 5th Amendment. Locked safe analogy = search warrant. Thats their simple messaging.

Apple needs to do what they do best - market this brilliantly but simply.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jkyle on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:10PM (#11306298)
Well, they can "compel" in the sense that they can demand the owner release it.

The owner can refuse and suffer the legal consequences.

In such a case, has there ever been a precedent of going to the safe manufacturer and compelling them to break into the safe? Have they ever then required all safe makers to make exploitable safes with master keys?

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by lern_too_spel on Thursday March 17, 2016 @04:14PM (#11307226)
In the case where the safe maker has special ability to break the existing safe, there is plenty of precedent. Every application of the All Writs Act follows that analogy, including this San Bernardino case.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by rayiner on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:15PM (#11306339)
> They can compel you to open a safe, they can not compel you to turn over a password.

Note that they can, however, force a third party to turn over a password. The privilege against compelled testimony only applies to self-incrimination.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mikeash on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:19PM (#11306370)
That's a tough analogy, because unbreakable safes aren't real and are probably impossible to make.

I prefer to look at the history of cryptography. Unbreakable cryptography isn't new. PGP is 25 years old. Classic techniques like one-time pads and book ciphers go back a very long time. Yet they never forced these things to be made insecure.

The government can listen, we can try to hide things, and they can try to un-hide them (with a warrant). Their ability to un-hide them depends on how well we do the hiding. It has always been this way, but they're not happy with it.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:42PM (#11306554)
It'd be pretty easy to make a safe lined with thermite that had more tamper-proof mechanisms than pick/drill-proof mechanisms.

Sure, you could drill it but you wouldn't get anything useful.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessegreathouse on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:32PM (#11306484)
Unbreakable cryptography isn't real either. It's not impossible to reverse engineer a private key it's just impractical. It would require immense computing power and only yield that individual private key broken.

What the president is proposing would allow a key for law enforcement that would, presumably, work on many or all devices. Once cracked, it would give hackers access to all of those devices. This elevates risk considerably because it's no longer impractical to reverse engineer the encryption.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by richardthered on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:50PM (#11306609)
Unbreakable cryptography is real.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-time_pad

"If the key is truly random, is at least as long as the plaintext, is never reused in whole or in part, and is kept completely secret, then the resulting ciphertext will be impossible to decrypt or break"

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessaustin on Thursday March 17, 2016 @05:52PM (#11307919)
That's not a great example in this case, because any useful system that incorporated OTP would have to store the really long secret keystream somewhere. That somewhere would be vulnerable to subpoena.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mikeash on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:31PM (#11306914)
When that immense computing power is such that it would require turning the entire observable universe into computronium dedicated to the task, and running it for longer than the heat death of the universe, I feel comfortable calling it "unbreakable."
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by ChrisBland on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:53PM (#11306628)
This debate is not about the direct ask imo, but more about the precedent that it would set and what the fbi could compel a tech company to do under the AWA. While in tech we tend to turn up our noses to the 'its always been done that way' mentality, the law takes a different approach, once you comply with the first request, it makes it harder, if not impossible to stop the subsequent requests. Which is why the fbi waited until something related to 'terrorism' to make this ask. I would be willing to be every last dollar I have in the bank that there is no useful info on that phone, and that if there were useful info, the nsa would have already had access to it.

To me, the really fun mental exercise is to identify when this would be acceptable. If there was a bomb about to go off and hypothetically the location was written on the phone, and only on the phone, would we agree that apple should break in? What if the bomb was a dirty bomb, what about a nuke? Now the slippery slope is where does that stop, a backpack bomb? Bomb making materials, texts to people about a bomb, what about a gun? What about a knife....

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by zingermc on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:01PM (#11305698)
Honestly, it wouldn't take very much work for Apple to circumvent the lockout mechanism. It might even be possible just by commenting out a couple lines of code. The thing the FBI needs from Apple is the use of their private key.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mirekrusin on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:05PM (#11306258)
Not with the new iOS, right? There's no Apple's private key. There's only your own private key. If you loose it - you're loosing your data and nothing can help you. I think you have a choice of backing up your keychain in iCloud. If you haven't backed it up there's nothing that Apple can do to access data - except by changing security design. If you backed it up on iCloud then I don't know - maybe the whole keychain is just protected by password, in which case they could try to brute force it or something. Not feasible if your password is too long.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by zingermc on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:13PM (#11306330)
Apple has a private key for signing software updates.

The FBI wants a modified iOS that will allow them to rapidly try all possible passcodes without getting locked out after N attempts.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessegreathouse on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:52PM (#11306618)
The FBI wants legal precedent. If they truly wanted the data they could have handed the phone over to the NSA have have it hacked before the weekend.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by zingermc on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:32PM (#11306923)
I'm genuinely curious -- how would the NSA would crack it?

My understanding is that iOS's filesystem uses AES 256 encryption. Even if you physically removed the disk, brute force is not an option.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by puddintane on Thursday March 17, 2016 @05:20PM (#11307704)
Essentially there are two keys used to encrypt data on an iphone - one linked to the hardware (hardcoded and unique to each iphone, cannot be erased) and one linked to the software that's stored in NAND. After N attempts the NAND is erased and the key is lost thus all the data on the device is gone (one could try to brute force using a rainbow table style attack but at this point it's a lost cause because the amount of time it would take to decrypt the device). The NSA uses the old technique of copying this NAND to a backup and restoring it every time the device gets erased. This would give them infinite attempts at cracking the passcode with as little device meddling as possible

edit Apologies forgot to mention the passcode/fingerprint is tied into the 2 key process.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mirekrusin on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:40PM (#11306545)
Ok, right, that makes sense. That's probably doable - making iOS being able to run auto-update when locked. Once for example. Update still needs to be signed of course.

It would probably make all crooks use long passwords for keychain, but who knows, maybe it would help in some cases.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jonlucc on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:28PM (#11305958)
If I'm not mistaken, the FBI wants a version of the OS that circumvents those limits and runs in RAM. Apple said it will take their team something like 2 weeks to build.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by ChrisBland on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:56PM (#11306200)
What they have to build and how long it will take them are moot points and detract from the overall argument which is can the gvt use the AWA to compel a 3rd party to create something that didn't exist before.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by fapjacks on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:26PM (#11306878)
Who cares how much work it takes? That doesn't make what the FBI wants any less fascist (or their reasoning any less sociopathic).
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by nxzero on Thursday March 17, 2016 @01:12PM (#11305782)
Next they'll be asking China to share backdoors; clearly they already agree with China that Apple needs to give them a backdoor: http://www.theverge.com/2016/3/16/11244396/apple-vs-fbi-encr...
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by gambiting on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:54PM (#11306638)
"What if a drug dealer keeps a coded ledger, can they go to crypto experts and compel them to work on solving it?"

This is a very interesting question, because crypto experts would love to work on a challenge like this. I am fairly certain that they would refuse if they were forced to work on it though.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by bpchaps on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:03PM (#11306239)