News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mikeash on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:19PM (#11306370)
That's a tough analogy, because unbreakable safes aren't real and are probably impossible to make.

I prefer to look at the history of cryptography. Unbreakable cryptography isn't new. PGP is 25 years old. Classic techniques like one-time pads and book ciphers go back a very long time. Yet they never forced these things to be made insecure.

The government can listen, we can try to hide things, and they can try to un-hide them (with a warrant). Their ability to un-hide them depends on how well we do the hiding. It has always been this way, but they're not happy with it.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by EdHominem on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:42PM (#11306554)
It'd be pretty easy to make a safe lined with thermite that had more tamper-proof mechanisms than pick/drill-proof mechanisms.

Sure, you could drill it but you wouldn't get anything useful.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessegreathouse on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:32PM (#11306484)
Unbreakable cryptography isn't real either. It's not impossible to reverse engineer a private key it's just impractical. It would require immense computing power and only yield that individual private key broken.

What the president is proposing would allow a key for law enforcement that would, presumably, work on many or all devices. Once cracked, it would give hackers access to all of those devices. This elevates risk considerably because it's no longer impractical to reverse engineer the encryption.

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by richardthered on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:50PM (#11306609)
Unbreakable cryptography is real.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-time_pad

"If the key is truly random, is at least as long as the plaintext, is never reused in whole or in part, and is kept completely secret, then the resulting ciphertext will be impossible to decrypt or break"

Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by jessaustin on Thursday March 17, 2016 @05:52PM (#11307919)
That's not a great example in this case, because any useful system that incorporated OTP would have to store the really long secret keystream somewhere. That somewhere would be vulnerable to subpoena.
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by mikeash on Thursday March 17, 2016 @03:31PM (#11306914)
When that immense computing power is such that it would require turning the entire observable universe into computronium dedicated to the task, and running it for longer than the heat death of the universe, I feel comfortable calling it "unbreakable."
Re:The Law is Clear: The FBI Cannot Make Apple Rewrite its OS by ChrisBland on Thursday March 17, 2016 @02:53PM (#11306628)
This debate is not about the direct ask imo, but more about the precedent that it would set and what the fbi could compel a tech company to do under the AWA. While in tech we tend to turn up our noses to the 'its always been done that way' mentality, the law takes a different approach, once you comply with the first request, it makes it harder, if not impossible to stop the subsequent requests. Which is why the fbi waited until something related to 'terrorism' to make this ask. I would be willing to be every last dollar I have in the bank that there is no useful info on that phone, and that if there were useful info, the nsa would have already had access to it.

To me, the really fun mental exercise is to identify when this would be acceptable. If there was a bomb about to go off and hypothetically the location was written on the phone, and only on the phone, would we agree that apple should break in? What if the bomb was a dirty bomb, what about a nuke? Now the slippery slope is where does that stop, a backpack bomb? Bomb making materials, texts to people about a bomb, what about a gun? What about a knife....