News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by FreedomToCreate on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:16PM (#11284454)
This is the thing that mystifies me the most about the ideas of consciousness and the soul. If we are more than our mind, then how do we explain how changes to our brain, artificial or natural, can drastically change who we are. What does that mean for an afterlife, if we can't even really say who we are in this life.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by gerbilly on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:27PM (#11284534)
A monk asked a Zen master: “What happens when you die?”

The Zen master replied: "I don’t know.”

The monk said: “What do you mean. Aren’t you a Zen master?”

And the Zen Master replied: “Yes, but I’m not a dead one.”

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by melvinmt on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:29PM (#11285713)
"After some years we will die. If we just think that it is the end of our life, this will be the wrong understanding. But, on the other hand, if we think that we do not die, this is also wrong. We die, and we do not die. This is the right understanding. Some people may say that our mind or soul exists forever, and it is only our physical body which dies. But this is not exactly right, because both mind and body have their end. But at the same time it is also true that they exist eternally. And even though we say mind and body, they are actually two sides of one coin. This is the right understanding." - Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by jrapdx3 on Monday March 14, 2016 @06:48PM (#11286129)
Wonderful quote, great wisdom. Interestingly, the passage speaks to ideas that exist across cultures, and throughout the centuries. It's remarkably similar to the philosophy of Spinoza, particularly embodied in his seminal work, the Ethics published in 1677.

For example, in the Ethics Spinoza wrote (roughly translated) "eternity cannot be defined in terms of time, or have any relation to time". I puzzled over this idea for many years, extending to decades. More recently I've thought it prescient, in a way anticipating the concept of "space-time". Indeed that may not be coincidental given Einstein's statement that he was strongly influenced by Spinoza.

So it's not a surprise, in fact even reassuring that such insights permeate human thought, as the Zen Mind nicely demonstrates.

Edit: grammar

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by gerbilly on Monday March 14, 2016 @09:11PM (#11286797)
These questions are among the questions that the Buddha refused to answer one way or the other because he considered them distractions from the meditative life.[i]

The real goal of Buddhism is the elimination of suffering in oneself and others and is purposefully silent on the 'big questions.'

[i] http://www.faculty.umb.edu/michael_lafargue/104/204/budd/rdn...

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by over on Monday March 14, 2016 @10:11PM (#11287000)
Discouraging certain questions is at the core of most/all religions/cults/belief systems, it's how you maintain group integrity and subservience to leaders and deities/pseudo-deities. Questions are ultimately disruptive. I don't just mean spiritual beliefs, I mean anything that isn't hard science.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by meric on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @04:35AM (#11288233)
The goal of many religions also happens to help it's followers lead a peaceful life, and you're right certain questions are ultimately disruptive, and that's exactly why many religions are vague on certain questions - they distract you from being able to lead a peaceful life.

By the way, one religion without leaders and without deities is fundamental Taoism. There's no one who can lead you on the path but you.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by xg15 on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:09PM (#11285188)
I wouldn't say it is proven yet, but I think the possibility that our whole consciousness might be a based on biology is loaded with a lot more fear that is justified.

For the sake of the argument, let's assume it is true - there is no metaphysical soul, and all aspects of the self we asdociate with it - memories, character, consciousness, etc... - are the product of electrochemical reactions inside the body. In other words, we are "deterministic" and whatever we do could be perfectly predicted by following the laws of physics.

I think this wouldn't actually devalue the consciousness very much. "Cogito ergo sum" still applies. There still exists a phenomenon called "consciousness" and there still exist entities who can choose an action, given their memories and the impressions of the world they experience.

Technically, yes, humans would be reduced to "mere machines", however machines which are incredibly more complex and nuanced than everything we are capable to build or understand as of now. Also machines who are thinking about themself and have performed all the accomplishments of human history. And I don't think any of this would be going.

The need to consider subjective experiences and well-being wouldn't go either, btw. The need to have a solid ethical foundation and sound morals would be as strong as ever. If anything it could become broader and give more justification for e.g. animal rights. But I can't see anything bad with that.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by adrusi on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:37PM (#11285391)
Yes. The claim that explaining consciousness as purely a result of biology (physicalism) devalues consciousness is the same as the claim that explaining the color red as result of photons released when electrons settle into lower energy states devalues redness.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by kotach on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:25PM (#11285688)
Studies on twins, especially those that observe separated ones, pretty much show how much bodies behave in a deterministic way, from diseases, to relationships, names, jobs, wishes.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by gulpahum on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:39PM (#11284602)
Stephen Hawking has concluded in his book "The Grand Design": "So it seems that we are no more than biological machines and that free will is just an illusion." [1]

Machines don't have afterlife. So, enjoy every moment you live right now! :)

[1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/deepak-chopra/stephen-hawkings...

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by cgio on Monday March 14, 2016 @06:21PM (#11286007)
Hawking makes a careful statement and employs the word "seems" not as a padding but intentionally. I take his statement at face value and still don't get to the confident deductions you make. For one "seems" is allowing room to account for something currently or forever invisible. And then how can you assert that machines don't have an afterlife?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Monday March 14, 2016 @03:03PM (#11284756)
I don't buy the we're smarter than we've ever been argument. It sounds very much like the religious people who feel certain of witnessing the end of the world.

> Einstein had a strong feeling for the presence of awe and wonder at the far horizon of the cosmos and saw evidence for the existence of a unifying, rational presence in the mathematical order of the cosmos. But since then the universe of theoretical physics has become random, complex, paradoxical, and barren of divine presence.

At least the atheist brigade remains constant. That's a comfort.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by SpaceCadetJones on Monday March 14, 2016 @03:38PM (#11284991)
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by paol on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:23PM (#11284504)
Well, that's why the null hypothesis is that there is no metaphysical soul.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:54PM (#11285860)
The null hypothesis is this: "There is a 'self' which persists through time and is the locus of one's identity."

It is this 'self' that people generally mean when they talk about the soul. We have a hard time giving a metaphysical analysis of what this soul is, but that does not mean it does not exist. As it is, the soul (in this functional sense) provides an explanation for too many things that would otherwise be inexplicable.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by akavi on Monday March 14, 2016 @06:01PM (#11285899)
That's definitely not what most people mean when they refer to the "soul". And using "soul" to mean that is both confusing and unhelpful.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by lliamander on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @01:32PM (#11291386)
It is certainly included in most people's definition of the soul, and it is difficult to satisfy the definition I provided above and still be a material reductivist.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by rcthompson on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:07PM (#11285185)
I'm pretty sure that the majority of people on the planet do not consider this their null hypothesis.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by labster on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:38PM (#11285774)
The majority of people on the planet do not know what a null hypothesis is.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by unclebucknasty on Monday March 14, 2016 @06:40PM (#11286086)
Perhaps, like the rest of the body, the brain is more an interface between the physical world and the "true self" (call it "soul" if you prefer). That includes relationships with others' interfaces.

In this view, changing the brain merely changes how we perceive the world, our behavior in it and, thus, how we are perceived by and relate to others. Interestingly, it can also change our sense of our own self in relation to the world.

When you consider disorders like depersonalization and derealization, they seem to be exactly a defect in this sensory system. The nature of who you are hasn't changed, but your sense of who you are has.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by mjklin on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:39PM (#11285775)
It may be the case that a healthy brain is necessary for a healthy personality. It is not clear, however what follows from this.

If a person's brain stops functioning normally, does he become less human? If a dolphin or monkey can demonstrate more intelligent actions than the brain-damaged person, does this make them more human than they are? More worthy of life?

These are the kind of questions they ask in your local philosophy department.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by Jimmy on Monday March 14, 2016 @05:47PM (#11285819)
Almost no philosophers today (who specialize in the philosophy of mind) believe in an immaterial soul. They believe that there is nothing beyond the physical when it comes to consciousness.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by mjklin on Monday March 14, 2016 @08:35PM (#11286671)
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by monomyth on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:30PM (#11285352)
If you break your leg, you will change the way your walk, but not the brain (of course it will change adapting to what has happened, but that's not he point here). Going up a level: if you change your brain you will change the way you think, but not the fact you can think. Going up another level: by changing your mind, you might not change your consciousness.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by Houshalter on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @01:07AM (#11295166)
There's zero evidence of an afterlife or souls of any kind. And overwhelming evidence that your behavior is controlled entirely by your brain. You are your brain. Nothing more. This life is the only one you will get!
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by jsprogrammer on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:40PM (#11284612)
What do you mean, "who we are", in your second sentence?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by FreedomToCreate on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:01PM (#11285148)
I mean i relation to our mind. If I took a hammer to your skull, I could fundamentally alter your personality. So the person you are right now is variable, depending on the state of your brain. So with that has a fundamental fact, who are you really but the state of your brain at the moment?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by lliamander on Monday March 14, 2016 @06:12PM (#11285959)
A: "it seems the evidence of the prosecution overwhelmingly identifies you as the robber of the convenience store. What evidence do you provide in your defense?"

B: " 'I' am nothing other than my present brain state. Since the entity that robbed the convenience store possessed a different brain state, we cannot be the same person."

Not sure how that would fly. Maybe there is a meaningful concept of personhood that transcends specific brain states?

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by ux-app on Monday March 14, 2016 @07:38PM (#11286406)

  >Not sure how that would fly
I think it's generally accepted that, barring mental illness, we're accountable for our previous brain states.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by lliamander on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @01:20PM (#11291266)
Indeed we are.

FreedomToCreate's point, as I read it, is that our identity as a person is nothing more than our brain state at the present moment. That is, from moment to moment we are a different person as our brain states change.

If 'I' am nothing more than my brain state at this precise moment, then any previous brain states that preceded this are separate persons. How then can I be held responsible for something "other people" (i.e. my previous brain states) did?

Of course, we could say that the legal and philosophical definitions of 'person' are different, but what purpose is the philosophical definition if not to inform our definitions in other domains like law?

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by jsprogrammer on Monday March 14, 2016 @07:47PM (#11286445)
Accountable to who? This sounds like mind police. Who can examine your actual brain states anyway?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by ux-app on Monday March 14, 2016 @07:58PM (#11286494)
My comment was in reply to a scenario involving a crime. In this case you would be accountable to society/law enforcement.

Unless you live in a cave, we're all accountable to many others, employers, loved ones etc, and, finally even to ourselves. After all haven't we all felt embarrassed or ashamed of something we did in a 'prior brain state'.

  > Who can examine your actual brain states anyway?
Much can be inferred from actions.

  > This sounds like mind police
A hyperbolic term. Aren't we all in a sense policing each other's minds? Part of living in a functional society involves creating and reinforcing social norms so that we can live in a slightly less chaotic world.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by jsprogrammer on Monday March 14, 2016 @08:32PM (#11286655)
Actions are different from brain state (as I can gather its definition in this thread). Are their brain states that shouldn't be allowed?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by ux-app on Monday March 14, 2016 @09:20PM (#11286827)

  > Actions are different from brain state
I think it would be fair to say that actions are a result of brain state, but not all brain states result in actions.

  > Are their brain states that shouldn't be allowed?
Seems you've gone for a more philosophical angle. Of course your secret heat of hearts is yours and yours alone. We don't yet have the technology to decipher your thoughts, and even if/when we do we probably(hopefully) won't police them.

In a more practical sense, when policing your own thoughts there certainly are thought patterns and by extension brain states that you should avoid because they have negative side-effects. Some examples are OCD, depression etc. For these there are medications and therapies designed to help correct aberrant brain states.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by jsprogrammer on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:14PM (#11285229)
How do you measure a personality? What are its constraints?

It appears to me that I am more than my brain. I have a body that I think I can control. If you define "you" as a sequence of states of matter, then the rest of your body should count too.

>So the person you are right now is variable, depending on the state of your brain. So with that has a fundamental fact, who are you really but the state of your brain at the moment?

This feels a bit circular to me.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by bendbro on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:26PM (#11284519)
I think most tech savvy millennials already subscribe to determinism in some form.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by Swizec on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:30PM (#11284549)
Yes and no. I think when most people say "determinism" they actually mean "probabilitism". You can't deterministically define the outcome of events, but you can assess the probabilities of outcomes.

Determinism does work retrospectively though.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by chrischen on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:27PM (#11284536)
Quantum physicists do not. Determinism has been experimentally disproven.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by GolDDranks on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:45PM (#11284641)
That's not right. The combination of

1) local 2) realist 3) determinism

has been disproven by Bell's theorem. But I it's still a "pick two" kind of choice.

I, personally think that by Occam's razor, the Everett interpretation ("Many Worlds") makes the most sense, because it's simplest. And actually it retains all of the above three, but it introduces "self-locating uncertainty" (http://arxiv.org/abs/1405.7907), which effectively has the same kind of effect from our perspective.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by chrischen on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:51PM (#11284680)
If you subscribe to many-worlds, then you subscribe to quantum theory, which means you subscribe to quantum indeterminacy. Non-determinism is literally the name of the principle.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by zardo on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @02:41AM (#11287898)
But the only thing that's undetermined is which universe you will find yourself in. In many worlds the multiverse is determined.

It's a space-time graph (tree?) with a root at the start of time and leaves at infinity.

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by bendbro on Monday March 14, 2016 @03:46PM (#11285041)
Is quantum indeterminacy related to the Uncertainty Principle? Also, isn't it assumed that quantum effects don't bubble up to the classical level?
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by miltondts on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:04PM (#11285169)
Bell's theorem has not proven anything because it assumes free will.[1] This has not been shown to exist.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdeterminism

Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by misnome on Monday March 14, 2016 @04:44PM (#11285437)
But in the contexts of this argument, it depends how much of the operation of the brain is dependent on quantum mechanics, which is unknown (if any).
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by balfirevic on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:32PM (#11284566)
Parent commenter might have meant materialism instead of determinism.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by erikpukinskis on Tuesday March 15, 2016 @01:40AM (#11287660)
Speak for yourself.
Re:The Neuroscientist Who Lost Her Mind by chrischen on Monday March 14, 2016 @02:25PM (#11284515)
Your afterlife starts when your physical brain is revived in the distant future, or when you deviate from the branch of the universe in which you die. In this case some people see you die but you continue living in a different universe. Crossing universes doesn't just happen when you die, it is happening every instant. Obviously when you die your consciousness won't cross into the next instantaneous universe in which you are dead (by definition your consciousness does not exist there anymore so it's not a possible reality to cross into). See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_suicide_and_immortal... for more details.

We aren't more than our physical brains, at least not when you include the encoded set of experiences in your brain.