The Bachelor's degree is loosely similar to an apprentice's role. The young boy (they were almost exclusively male) worked in a shop or with a priest for some time. He learned the trade, the tools, and gained some experience from 'level 0'. When you are done with the apprenticeship, you are 'cleared' to work in other shops and are known to not be a total moron or break tools or burn down shops.
The master's degree is just that. You are considered a master of the craft (like plumbing or prinitng) or the discipline (like The Book of Mark or Crusader History). As such, you typically have a master's level project. Something that is 'new' or shows that you know your stuff. That might be a very decorative silver bowl or a thesis.
The Doctorate means you are 'world class.' Not just a mastery in a field, but a paragon of it. Today, that means that you are the expert in your little niche of underwater basket weaving. There should be no-one better than you. This means you MUST have produced something new or novel way of thinking about the God or something. This has always been the idea, if not the practice.
To change that and say that the doctorate should be the bachelor's is very big. To suggest that PhDs should just replicate experiments is anathema to the idea of graduate education and would be a tremendous waste of time and energy. When you enter the Phd, you are assumed to already know how to do all the replication and the facts about the field. Granted, fields are exponentially larger than they were in the 1600's, but you still should know stats and biology if your PhD is in cancer biology.
I think you are totally wrong about this. What you are suggesting should be covered in undergrad and I think it largely is.
I do think it makes sense to stick with the PhD meaning you're a world class expert in some area, but if so then we need to adjust our expectations for what Master's level work means in the sciences. Right now it seems to just represent a hurdle you need to whiz past on your way to the PhD.
The problem is that grade inflation means the majority of students will fall short of these goalposts. I agree with your assessment that undergrad degrees represent hurdles, regardless of whether a student is planning to stay in academia or not.
My experience with getting a Masters degree was that it was really tough work that required my full dedication for two years. But I had a world-class scientist as an advisor breathing down my neck the whole time and expecting results, and my experience doesn't seem to match that of many other MScs I know. Some departments seem to be "degree factories"; it takes an unreasonable amount of effort to follow up students in the classical "apprenticeship" tradition described by GP. It would be very strange if every department at every university managed this level of dedication, with student numbers being what they are.
I'm having trouble believing this.
In UK, most Masters degrees last 1 year, and there are several degrees considered good such as Imperial's MSc in Machine Learning, Cambridge's MPhil in Machine Learning, Speech and Language Technology, Edinburgh's MSc in Cognitive Science, and others. Is it really possible to become a "master" of machine learning in one year?
Also, at least in Computer Science, most of the Bachelors degrees considered good in UK do not seem to focus at all on replicating science. In fact, for my final year undergraduate project, I was encouraged to find something novel, and at no point my supervisor hinted towards focusing on replicability.
Is it perhaps more common in US?
Of course, you can define the term "master" to mean pretty much whatever you like. But I'd say that two years of additional, focused study when you are already proficient in your field should be more than enough to have a mastery of the specific skills and knowledge that is at least on a high national level. I'm from Norway, so the US picture is unknown to me.
Actually I think farming out replication to undergrads would be an excellent approach. Your final year undergrad project should be to choose an under-replicated study and repeat it, publishing your findings. Each individual study might be less reliable if done by an undergrad than done by a seasoned researcher, but if each study is repeated by say 5 undergrads and 2+ of them fail to replicate the results, that would be enough to indicate that the study warrants further attention.
> One student could spend their time working on a important result gaining tons of insight and expertise while another could be stuck replicating a task that turned out to be worthless bullshit and have very little to show for it.
The whole point of science is that we don't know what will turn out to be an important result and what will turn out to be worthless bullshit. No study is worth a damn unless it's been replicated but everyone is too busy trying to land-grab the next little piece of unexplored territory to actually validate anything that comes before.
If nothing else, we need to regain the perception that a negative result is just as important as a positive result - to paraphrase Edison, discovering 100 things that don't work is just as important as discovering one thing that does.
However, PHD students on average are very far from world class. And in just about every case they are simply looking at a problem so unimportant that nobody considered it before, and most likely nobody will ever look at again.
It's almost always a waste of time for both the student and everyone else involved.
PS: There are plenty of counter examples where PHD research happened to be valuable, but that's a tiny minority of cases.
Today the MS & PhD are both supposed to prepare you to do novel research & science. Since reproducibility is a core part of research & science, it would make sense for you to reproduce another study as part of your learning process.
We used to think placebo controls and double blinds were a waste of time. One great thing about the history of science your version excludes is that the way we do science is subject to review too, and we continually throw out what doesn't work in favor of methods that do.
Apprentices work on papers and research for their professors. No one is incentivized to do replication work: either you replicate it successfully (great) or you find flaws. In the latter case, you'll probably be a nit-picker anyway—also not really additive. On the off-chance that you refute a high-profile study (e.g., some of the outright instances of fraud), you might get some recognition, but now your name is associated with something negative (e.g., fraud: "X is not true") vs. positive ("X is true").
Finally, this is some of the role of review panels in journals: too pass the burden of proof.
It's important to note that though this seems to happen in all fields, it is far less common in some. I rarely hear of such things in astronomy; it does happen, but more often I hear about faculty explicitly working to ensure they can protect projects for their students so their students can get the credit deserved for doing the project. I hear of professors appropriating student research in biology and chemistry more frequently, however.
The occurrences of professors taking and publishing student research is certainly a problem, is unethical, and should be stopped. But the way in which it is usually discussed ("in science") implies that it's a systemic issue across all science, which (from my experience) isn't true. This topic of credit and attribution for research deserves more nuanced discussion and fewer blanket statements.
Edit: Spelling, wording clarification.
In the situation you describe, the paper would probably be singly authored, and the author would write something like "Thanks to my advisor _____ and to my colleagues ____ for many helpful discussions" in an acknowledgments section.
If the contributions were more serious, then possibly the author would invite the others to co-author with him/her, and the others would then either accept (and then help write the paper) or politely decline and say "just mention me in the acknowledgments".
At least in my experience, co-authorship carries responsibilities: to help with the writing, the figures, references, dealing with editors and with submission to journals, speaking about the research at seminars/conferences, etc.
For example: Mike Synder, a brilliant biologist, 'supervises' 36 postdocs, 13 research assistants, 11 research scientists, 9 visiting scientists, and 8 graduate students (http://snyderlab.stanford.edu/members3.html - thanks to Lior Pacter for noticing it).
In 2014, he had 42 published papers. How much scientific input do you think he had on each one?
These are some working definitions, based on my experiences in astronomy:
Postdocs: researchers with a a PhD who generally have fixed-term contracts. Generally these positions are full-time research, though some may include teaching components.
Research assistants: researchers, typically without PhDs, working in a group/lab. This is frequently a synonym for undergraduate or graduate students, or interns. It can also mean people with technical skills who are working in a group/lab but not working towards a degree.
Research scientists: Non-tenure track reseachers, often with PhDs. Their positions may be fixed-term or indefinite.
Visiting scientists: Researchers whose primary affiliation is with another institute. They may be fixed-term visitors (e.g., faculty on sabbatical at another University) or frequent but non-constant visitors of an institution. Their salary is often paid by their primary institute, unless the host institute has provided funding.
I know the feeling! Astro is great and I love it. But there's lots of other things I'd love to explore once I figure out galaxies :)
Is there any research showing this standard to be fair? People pay more attention to the first item of a list than to the middle ones, making me think that one's position on such a list could have a small benefit. Less important if there are overall less multiple name papers, which it seems from the rest of your comment, but still a factor as long as multiple names on a paper do happen.
I don't know of any.
Less important if there are overall less multiple name papers, which it seems from the rest of your comment,
Actually, I think multiple authors is far more common than single authors, though I don't know the numbers to back it up. I was responding to a very specific "what-if" scenario of bouncing ideas off someone else, and describing what would happen in that case.
In math, the group sizes are way smaller. A PI might only have 1 or 2 students.
Astronomy is too far to reach, mathematics is too abstract to patent, etc.
http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jour...
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://...
http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/01/15/463237871/episo...
tl;dr A false technique can be described and it can be hard or impossible to detect the technique is flawed by using it
For example the paper at http://www.jstor.org/stable/222500 describes a method of using the stationary bootstrap to eliminate data snooping bias in studies of "technical analysis" in finance.
Published in the Journal of Finance in 1999 at the time I worked with it in 2010 it had been cited over 500 times.
The proof in the paper is inscrutable. I could find no one who could explain or verify the proofs at my institution.
I attempted to reproduce the results in the paper which is where the problems started. The authors did not give enough information to do this in all cases, but in some cases I was able to reconstruct the algorithms.
They did not perform as described. Of the five algorithms I could reproduce (from memory) one of them worked roughly as described and two others were not completely hopeless.
Looking more closely I realised that the original authors completely disregarded important factors in the implementation of the techniques described by the algorithms. Transaction costs. Allowing for transaction costs (a difficult but not impossible task) the effects noticed by the authors disappeared completely.
Looking even closer I examined the assumptions behind "White's Reality Check" that the paper relied on the Stationary Bootstrap by Politis and Romano from 1994. But financial returns are not stationary. Not at all.
So dodgy logic, misuse of statistics, irreproducible experiments, ignoring important aspects of the data and I suspect wishful thinking add up to a paper that is comprehensively false. Cited hundreds of times and used many times to verify other results.
taking a huge risk here is where my research is: https://ourarchive.otago.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10523/4346/T... Section 5.12.1 "Bootstrapping and Other False Discoveries"
Non-stationarity is a problem though. Still, you need a bit more to call complete bullshit on this imo -- e.g. say something like "after switching to a different bootstrap method that works in presence of stochastic volatility the result suddenly disappears". Perhaps that is what you do in your paper :) I should take a look.
All that being said, not many people believe in technical indicators working in equities these days, or anywhere really (FX was a bit of a holdout -- not sure if it still is?), so perhaps science has kinda sorted itself out in this case :) I've seen far worse cases of snooping and non-replicability though, and some are still going strong.
Irreducibility is also enough to call it very bad and should not have been published in that form. They talked a lot about their algorithms, without properly describing them.
Ignoring transaction costs is also enough to call bullshit. It is a mistake that should only be made by rank amateurs, and it is the most common mistake made by amateurs in the Technical Analysis field IMO.
It is a very very bad paper but because it gives a technique that can be used to show that TA is possible it is much beloved by researches in the field.
My own conclusion is that (generally) TA is not possible to do profitably at these time scales.
I agree about algorithms; rather unfortunately, this is true in more than this one paper. There certainly is movement towards requiring people to make their code fully available, but we are not quite there yet. But if you describe your failure to replicate, this is definitely a strong argument that the authors would IMO need to address.
Ignoring transaction costs would be a major problem if the paper's main point was "we found a strategy returning X% above market, it's awesome and people should give us money" -- but this is written for a very different purpose and audience. That being said, today it would not be published without a transaction cost analysis -- but I would have no problem with them saying "with such-and-such costs, profits are not there any more", it would not invalidate the paper at all. But at the time it was written, TC analysis was not as standard in academic literature as it is now.
I agree with you about TA, and TBH most serious researchers are of the same opinion, and have been for a long time -- even at the time of publication, it was a bit of an outlier, and this is not a particularly popular area of research (how many of those citations are in recent top journal articles?). Forex was a bit of an open question last time I checked, but it's been a few years, not sure if it still is.
Whether this "works" or not depends on how the previous projects enter into it. If the results of previous projects are used as assumptions to justify the methods, data, etc. of the subsequent project, there is no check and we risk the research becoming a house of cards which could collapse due to faultly, untested assumptions that were used.
If the subsequent projects are performed in such a way that they also test the previous results/assumption, this can be avoided. I can't tell from your wording which you are suggesting, though it seems to lean towards the former.
If the field were sane, you would train all the apprentices on replication studies. Once they demonstrated dispassionate expertise with the tools, only then would they be allowed to try to use those tools to test their own ideas, where they will have a strong emotional preference for how the study will come out.
If universities hired grad students based on their replication work, not on their eye-popping original research, we'd have better science and better scientists.