We'll be finding out how Tim runs a secret paedophile ring, or how he has been laundering money, or how he has been supporting IS through action and/or inaction. HUAC will return, lazarus like, but you'll call it the centre for American improvement or some such shit. Remember Chaplin?
Anyway. That's one potential future, an actual past, and while the apparatus is more subtle this time, it's the same old forces doing the same old things.
If this is the endgame, it's good that computers exist. Without Twitter, the public might believe absurd lies.
Nowadays, the lies would have to be pretty nuanced to have an effect.
Of course, there's something to be said for overwhelming power. If those in the government really want their way, and all three branches refuse to yield, and none of us can control who are in those branches, is there really anything we can do to stop it?
Luckily, this is roughly as likely as the moon disappearing. For now.
You mean like "Iraq has weapons of Mass Destruction, honest! So USA must preemptively invade a sovereign nation." Or, "Obama is a Muslim!" which 29% of polled people believed as late as 9/2015.
You vastly overestimate the sophistication of the American populace.
As for control of public opinion in the age of the internet, I don't think it's hard at all. First of all, we have several industries that are focused on just that - PR, advertising, political spin-doctors - and secondly those industries get more and more sophisticated tools through modern data collection...
For everyone else's sake, this appears to be a reference to Joseph Nacchio [1]. I hadn't heard of him before. It's a weird feeling to have sympathy for someone who has resources enough to bring their criminal case through appeals all the way to the Supreme Court. From the wikipedia article alone, I have no idea what to believe.
Why would that matter?! Do you seriously believe that because someone has the financial ability to actually protect his rights that they're somehow beneath your ability to have sympathy?
People still are people, with all their positive and negative sides. Some technological advancement is unlikely to change that.
People often believe "facts" more due to their own preconceived biases than due to logical investigation. So any reports that support their position are obviously the truth. Likewise, they dismiss reports that are contrary to their position.
There are lots of examples one could use as proof - recently Donald Trump. Notice there's absolutely no one in the middle? You're either fully behind him or your completely against him. Any time you see a highly polarized issue, I'd recommend asking yourself why there's no middle ground. Often it's because there's also no rationale for the extremes.
How do we use the scientific method on issues like this? Even our historical perspectives hold biases - and sometimes it's hard to collect a large enough sample size to have confidence in your conclusion.
> Facts don’t necessarily have the power to change our minds. In fact, quite the opposite. In a series of studies in 2005 and 2006, researchers at the University of Michigan found that when misinformed people, particularly political partisans, were exposed to corrected facts in news stories, they rarely changed their minds. In fact, they often became even more strongly set in their beliefs. Facts, they found, were not curing misinformation. Like an underpowered antibiotic, facts could actually make misinformation even stronger.
https://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2010/07/11...
One hypothesis imho worth exploring: how much does presentation matter? can we present the same facts in a way that is more pallatable? what if we tried to coax the audience into believing they came to the conclusion from the facts themselves?
I think I identified the problem. Hey, let's boil down all complex answers to complex problems along a 1-dimensional axis and then completely and voluntarily ignore half that axis! What could possibly go wrong?
> how much does presentation matter?
A lot, in my experience trying to change minds.
> can we present the same facts in a way that is more pallatable?
Humor is perfect for this. "If you want to tell people the truth, make them laugh, otherwise they'll kill you." -Oscar Wilde
> what if we tried to coax the audience into believing they came to the conclusion from the facts themselves?
This is much easier to do on an individual basis than en masse. You basically hand-hold someone down their line of thinking until you get to the dissonance, then comes the important bit, you take a step back. If the person feels coerced in any way, they will push back, which is why you simply try to walk them down their own train of thought. Eventually they will stumble, especially if you gently lay some facts in the way... At all times you must respect their opinion.
All of this would be much easier if people didn't tie their egos to their beliefs so tightly.
During Bill Clinton's first run for office against H.W.Bush, Al Gore said over and over, "Folks tickle down economics just don't work. We have proof.... " He was lying through his teeth yet people believed it. History clearly shows that despite record spending 10 out of the twelve years Reagan and bush were in office they lowered taxes and had an increase in income revenues.
Easy enough. Some people take principled stands on issues, even when it's not always politically convenient. If you disagree with them, you are wrong, even if you are well-meaning. Even their political enemies can be seen giving them respect - Scalia and Ginsburg were good friends!
Some people take populist stands on issues, appeal to one group by attacking another - the Establishment Candidates in Washington, the 1%, immigrants, whoever. If you disagree with them, you are stupid or a bad person. "Neutral ground" is enemy territory.
"Apple had asked the F.B.I. to issue its application for the tool under seal. But the government made it public, prompting Mr. Cook to go into bunker mode to draft a response, according to people privy to the discussions, who spoke on condition of anonymity."[0][1]
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11133909
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/19/technology/how-tim-cook-be...
Haa twitter stopped trump's rise?
Actually no. Most people are jaded or just don't care. Lots of things the govt says are easily demonstrable lies but not enough people that matter care so they lie with impunity. The quality of the lie doesn't matter as long as not enough people (or the people that matter) care.
I completely disagree. Just look at the presidential candidates: someone who is regarded as a serial liar, someone who wants to give everything for free yet is ridiculed for not understanding economics, a billionaire who takes opposite sides of issues even on the same day, a brain surgeon who is forgotten in the polls, etc.
People believe many things even without a single shred of proof. "Crowdsourcing of truth" should be the meme of Twitter.
"Ex-con CEO Joe Nacchio accuses Apple of 'PR ploy' in iPhone dispute" http://www.bizjournals.com/denver/news/2016/02/18/ex-con-joe...
"I give Apple a lot of credit for being principled." - Joe Nacchio (starting 1:44)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cjBRxKV0WI4
Nacchio is saying Apple is going to lose, and that he fears they will retaliate against Apple. But he's not saying Apple is wrong to push back. He's saying Apple picked the wrong case to fight.
All those body scanners at airports? How many terrorists have they managed to catch?
(Meanwhile, TSA agents steal items from baggage all the time)
If all that surveillance couldn't catch the school shooters, the Boston bombers and this couple, is the only solution even MORE surveillance?
And the Boston bombers had been specifically pointed out to US law enforcement by more than one foreign intelligence agency, and they made no move to stop them.
Saying they need more power to surveil us is just ludicrous given they ignore in your face public data, or credible tips already.
But, TSA is kind of parallel to surveillance, my question was about whether we could possible judge the success of that, and other intelligence in the most secretive of government operations.
"That’s a particular stretch because (as Apple argues in another ongoing case) Congress has already passed a federal law outlining exactly what companies must do to help police spy on digital messages: the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act of 1992." (1)
A "hacking OS" more precisely. Now compare what is being requested with the apparent legal basis for it:
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Writs_Act
"(a) The Supreme Court and all courts established by Act of Congress may issue all writs necessary or appropriate in aid of their respective jurisdictions and agreeable to the usages and principles of law.
(b) An alternative writ or rule nisi may be issued by a justice or judge of a court which has jurisdiction."
-
That's really the whole act!
Which FBI claims to simply mean "we can order anything to anybody" including ordering Apple to make "a special operating system," and then later, obviously, even the special chips to allow FBI to snoop continuously, if they want. It's not an accident.
Should this particular act be allowed to be used to effectively ban encryption? That's how much is at stake.
1) http://nypost.com/2016/02/18/will-an-18th-century-law-force-...
The Dangerous All Writs Act Precedent in the Apple Encryption Case
http://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson/a-dangerous-all-w...
"Tim Cook, the C.E.O. of Apple, which has been ordered to help the F.B.I. get into the cell phone of the San Bernardino shooters, wrote in an angry open letter this week that “the U.S. government has asked us for something we simply do not have, and something we consider too dangerous to create.” The second part of that formulation has rightly received a great deal of attention: Should a back door be built into devices that are used for encrypted communications? Would that keep us safe from terrorists, or merely make everyone more vulnerable to hackers, as well as to mass government surveillance? But the first part is also potentially insidious, for reasons that go well beyond privacy rights.
The simple but strange question here is exactly the one that Cook formulates. What happens when the government goes to court to demand that you give it something that you do not have? No one has it, in fact, because it doesn’t exist. What if the government then proceeds to order you to construct, design, invent, or somehow conjure up the thing it wants? Must you?"