Re:Fixing Reddit
by CM30 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @04:54PM
(#11129625)
I think the simplest fixes for Reddit would be just to make sure anyone who works for the site actually agrees with its goals. That's what caused most of the reason issues, they hired people who didn't really like the challenges that being pro freedom of speech brings, and who favoured doing well with companies and celebrities over being a place for communities of like minded people to discuss things they enjoy.
The other improvements they mention sound good, but Reddit's issues are more down to leadership problems than community/cultural/technical ones.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by cLeEOGPw on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:03PM
(#11130094)
> challenges that being pro freedom of speech brings
Well, the thing is, reddit is a private company and so the classic "freedom of speech" definition does not apply to it. And while their goal was unrestricted discussion a few years back, in attempt to pave road for profitability they have abandoned that goal. The goal of reddit right now it to become as attractive to advertisers as possible. What that entails is up to them to decide. One of the effects is heavy moderation of anything controversial. They seem to be attempting to "play it safe". We'll see if it will pay off.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by CM30 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:21PM
(#11130187)
Well, to some degree, that's their problem. They made their bed and they have to lie in it.
A key community manager rule is 'don't promise freedom of speech on your site, because you likely don't have it and you will get absolutely eviscorated the minute you try and censor anything':
If you say your community is pro freedom of speech or allows freeom of speech, you pretty much make yourself obliged to allow anything that's not literally illegal. That will include an awful lot of stuff that you personally don't like, that your corporate backers don't like, that other members on the site don't like...
And hence you have to make the awful decision; do you allow anything (like Voat or certain chan boards) and accept the consequences? Or do you start censoring and immediately lose the right to say you allow freedom of speech?
Making comments like this is a great way to cause a site or business to self destruct spectacularly. Reddit may be a private company, but their community was founded on a freedom of speech stance. They've turned against those ideals, so now they're going to struggle a lot more since people feel they've been betrayed.
That's a situation Reddit is going to have a lot of trouble escaping. And they could have at least delayed it by not hiring people who dislike the principles the company and site was founded on.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by cLeEOGPw on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:32PM
(#11130277)
It is frustrating for those that pioneered reddit to grow to what they are now that the site has completely changed, but looking from business perspective, early adopters are not the crowd that brings profit. They generate content, but they mostly generate content for others like them (mostly technology/programming and other geek stuff related). Those that generate profit, i.e. in reddit's case buy reddit gold AND don't use adblock, are the people that care about other things, and freedom of speech is the least of their concerns.
So from business analytic's perspective, he sees the numbers and he sees the target audience PLUS advertiser contract clauses (like no racism/sexism/certain porn things, non-liberal leaning things in general), and you get essentially private censorship. It's not a pretty sight, especially looking at deleted and locked threads daily, but it has a certain logic behind it. That logic is not in out favor, but we are not all people.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by knorker on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:11PM
(#11130131)
> reddit is a private company and so the classic "freedom of speech" definition does not apply to it.
I think you completely missed the point of the comment and instead answered in the lines of "why you can't tell your boss to fuck off without getting fired, despite the first amendment".
Re:Fixing Reddit
by fweespeech on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:10PM
(#11130124)
One of those people they "hired" is one of the original founders.
I think the reality is one of the founders believed as you did and it was allowed as long as it was expedient. It isn't expedient now and they've shifted gears.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by Huhty on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:29PM
(#11129863)
A lot of sites have tried to "fix" reddit. I even worked with one of them (snapzu) on some of their back-end stuff. One thing I did was research what else was out there to see what stuff was/wasn't being innovated on. Here's what reddit is competing with today (other than caucus):
That being said, I just want to wish you good luck on your endeavor... the social network game is a really tough nut to crack because community is 99% of the value.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by spinlock on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:56PM
(#11130048)
Why are there so many reddit clones? Reddit doesn't make money. Imgur, on the other hand, is printing cash by selling ad space. But, no one is trying to move into their market.
I just don't understand why people are going after a market that seems to be unprofitable. Am I missing something?
Re:Fixing Reddit
by CM30 on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:23PM
(#11130202)
Why do so many people run forums, blogs, social networks, wikis and other community focused sites?
Because for a lot of them, it's fun. And for a similarly high amount of them, it's a chance to run their own community that fixes the perceived problems with others they've been part of online.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by fweespeech on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:17PM
(#11130167)
1) Most of the Reddit competitors are hobbies while Imgur was built as a business. Similarly, their competition with Reddit is largely ideological rather than practical values people care about en mass.
2) Everyone who tried to move into Imgur's position found image hosting was very expensive and impractical as a hobby. The problem is they've largely been ideological and cut off from Reddit's ecosystem due to Imgur's incumbency.
3) Ultimately, until Reddit or Imgur stumbles in a substantial way that pisses off users none of them will be viable even with VC money.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by fweespeech on Thursday February 18, 2016 @08:06PM
(#11130782)
It is a story he tells but he made the same claim on Digg and other places as well. It was effective social marketing but there are a few things like that about that just are popular beliefs that are just repeated 'cause the founder was a college student at the time.
Most of the original links/evidence of that are gone from the internet at this point tho and I'm tired of digging for them. :/
> imgur - the simple image sharer. The best in image hosting.
imgur.com — imgur is a free image sharing/hosting service that allows you to quickly upload and edit your photos and share them with friends the Internet. Now you're asking, "How is this different from imageshack, tinypic, or photobucket?" Well that's simple. imgur is free (as in beer), no ads, anonymous, and easier to use. It's my gift to the Internet. Enjoy!
Ah archive.org still has it.
But yeh, it was effective guerilla marketing only. It was posted to Digg slightly before Reddit btw.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by sdrothrock on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:37PM
(#11130308)
> Imgur, on the other hand, is printing cash by selling ad space. But, no one is trying to move into their market.
There are a few. Slimgur is one of the most common direect competitors I can think of, but there are also the various meme maker sites that host the resulting memes for users.
Another incredibly common competitor for a small slice of the market is gifycat, which used to be the crappy newcomer that never worked and is now almost a de-facto standard on Reddit.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by shostack on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:20PM
(#11130184)
One big issue that could impact Reddit if not addressed is Imgur.
Recently Imgur appears to have started redirecting some people from direct image links to their full site (some claim this happens even on submissions linking directly to an image/gif). I've noticed this quite a bit on mobile or in the Alien Blue app. Others have also reported this behavior. My guess is Imgur is doing this not to display ads right away, but to drive people to their own app for later monetization and growing their own brand/community.
Imgur has taken $40M in funding, and so is presumably needing to find an exit at some point. Reddit sending tons of traffic directly to images was great for establishing themselves deep in the Reddit ecosystem early on, but if people are going directly to images vs. to the HTML page, that's a lot of lost impressions beyond just those who visit it directly or go to upload photos.
The load times for their site vs. just direct image/gif files are pretty painful on mobile, and this ultimately impacts the Reddit experience. I'm really curious if Reddit would ever roll out their own image host as a result, and it will be very interesting to watch this.
It queries reddit.com/r/funny every ten minutes and collects the top 1000 images submitted. You as a user can then browse an endless stream of images much like Instagram.
At the end of the night it takes all the collected images from that day and parse them into 20 picture albums that user can be accessed by pressing the shuffle button on the top bar.
I double-checked today and count not find any indication that Imgur redirects images on Reddit referrers. (Although some Reddit submissions incorrectly submit the ad-page itself which is why people get confused)
If anyone has reproducable evidence of a redirect, let me know.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by flashman on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:52PM
(#11130404)
Reddit's not going to want the bother of an image host, with the associated DMCA, abuse and community issues. Its philosophy seems to be "let other people do as much of the work as possible," which makes sense, and I don't see why they wouldn't just let the community solve the problem if Imgur 'broke' itself by aggressively monetizing Reddit traffic.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by shostack on Thursday February 18, 2016 @07:52PM
(#11130694)
Perhaps they would let the community solve the problem.
However they are now stuck with the same issue any other company is that relies heavily on a 3rd party for a core component of their business. Namely, degradation in the experience of the 3rd party results in a perceived degradation of their own service as users view the experiences as one in the same. Most people probably realize that Reddit and Imgur are separate companies, but if a core part of their Reddit browsing experience gets messed up by Imgur, that is also Reddit's problem.
Now, I'm sure the community could come up with something eventually, as inevitably happens when an image host gets too spammy. The issue is that it is not easy to trust every host, and frankly should be something Reddit owns to have better control over.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by minimaxir on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:00PM
(#11129659)
One of the things Reddit failed at was miscommunication and low transparency between the admins and the users.
In that case, why are the vote scores on Caucus submissions blatantly inflated? There is zero probability scores are in the hundreds for completely random content. (glancing at the number of unique accounts who have made submissions, I question if 100+ active accounts even exist.)
Re:Fixing Reddit
by whack on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:24PM
(#11131322)
Hi there. Sorry if the scores misled you. That's not the intent at all. The scores that you see next to each discussion/comment are exactly that: a score. It's not intended to represent the raw number of people who have voted.
For example, on Reddit, the score that you see is extremely simple/primitive: upvotes - downvotes. The entire premise behind Caucus is that content can and should be scored using much more sophisticated algorithms. Some of the many factors that we use to generate scores: poster's reputation, voters' reputations, posters/voters' activity levels, community size, number of times the post has been seen by voters, etc.
If this all sounds very abstract and you're wondering what a sophisticated scoring algorithm looks like, here's a famous one that we drew inspiration from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PageRank.
Anyway, long story short: the scores that you see on Caucus aren't an indication of the number of people who voted on it. They are the output of our reputation-system-based scoring algorithm. Hope that clears things up!
Re:Fixing Reddit
by minimaxir on Friday February 19, 2016 @12:20AM
(#11131734)
That is highly misleading UI.
You can have a magic algorithm, that's fine. You can have it rank submissions behind-the-scenes, that's fine. But you can't copy Reddit's UI/UX and claim it doesn't behave the same.
(Also, PageRank is based on relationship networks, which makes no sense for a link aggregation where each link functions independently from each other. Saying an algorithm is sophisticated requires substantial proof which you do not provide.)
Re:Fixing Reddit
by minimaxir on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:52PM
(#11130014)
Vote fuzzing accounts for maybe a +/- 10 point spread at most, not a 100 point difference. And vote fuzzing is directly proportional to the true score anyways.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by 6stringmerc on Thursday February 18, 2016 @04:50PM
(#11129596)
>Hearing only the things that you agree with might be easy and comfortable. But the idea of a community where everyone only agrees with one another, and dissenting voices are promptly silenced, sounds more like dystopia to us.
I'm genuinely interested to see if this works out. Not kidding. However, with a straight face, I can also say I'm not optimistic, because 'echo chamber' tendencies are kind of why those "communities" tend to flourish, at least in my perspective.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by jonlucc on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:16PM
(#11130164)
I actually think the problem is sort of the opposite. People who agree are (usually) civil to each other. Online, where privacy or pseudonymity is the norm, people who disagree with each other tend to do so in ways they wouldn't imagine doing in person. Environments of disagreement seem to often devolve into aggression and rude personal attacks.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by KVFinn on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:36PM
(#11129915)
Every reddit seems to trend towards either 100% upvotes based on agreeing with the title of posts, or 100% image memes (sometimes both!) as it gets popular. The only exceptions being communities with extremely strict moderators like /r/askhistorians.
One trend I've noticed across lots of reddit clones is none of them match the information density of reddit. Everyone seems to think that good design = more padding
Re:Fixing Reddit
by natrius on Thursday February 18, 2016 @04:48PM
(#11129587)
Reddit only succeeded because Digg wasn't good enough: it changed in undesirable ways, so users left. How are you going to convince enough redditors that Reddit isn't good enough that a critical mass moves to your platform?
I think it's prohibitively difficult, and only a decentralized system will succeed.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by Smudge on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:26PM
(#11129846)
> By prioritizing the content and votes cast by highly reputed users, as opposed to anonymous new arrivals whom no one knows or trusts, Caucus is better able to figure out which content is most trustworthy.
How do you avoid the "Power User" effect that Digg (and arguably Reddit) ran into? If your most reputable users keep getting more and more reputable, eventually you have only a handful of very active users who have a majority of the voting power.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by jonlucc on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:18PM
(#11130176)
This was my first thought. The influence ought to follow a 4PL fit curve (not sure what the function is called). You're only trying to make sure the user is not terrible, you don't care once they've proven themselves worthy.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by whack on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:31PM
(#11131344)
Great observation. This is a core issue addressed by our reputation-system as well. All reputations are community-specific. Ie, your reputation-score on the politics community will have no impact on your posts/votes in other communities.
This ensures that if anyone is ever dis-satisfied with the way the highly-reputed-users in a particular community are using/abusing their voting-power, they can simply create/migrate to a different community where those individuals will have no voting power at all. In the equilibrium, people will self-select into communities that match the tone/character that they are looking for.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by s_m_t on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:23PM
(#11129817)
My cynical/conspiratorial side says that the reason the voting system is 'fuzzed' isn't because it makes it harder for bots to game the system (this explanation doesn't make sense to me because you will always know how well a post is doing by its place on the page, who cares how many upvotes it has if you know you botted your post to rank #4?) but because it allows the admins to more easily manipulate votes. Instead of selling advertisements on the sides of the page they could just boost certain posts and it would be extremely hard to tell from the outside that they are doing this because the votes are kept obfuscated. Even better, instead of naively just giving posts upvotes you could apply a secret upvote multiplier to certain posts. This way only secret advertisements that people are already mildly receptive to would make it to the front page lest you alienate your audience too much.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by the_watcher on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:02PM
(#11129671)
Also, Reddit ads are among some of the least intrusive on the web. Every sub is filled with posts not everyone cares about, the ability to ignore the ads if you aren't interested in is built into Redditing
Re:Fixing Reddit
by mjevans on Thursday February 18, 2016 @06:13PM
(#11130139)
I didn't read the link BECAUSE it requires scripts to view.
Having said that, as someone that uses some subreddits for forums there is exactly one thing that I'd like to see done for Reddit (and any other site with a downvote/dislike button).
If you click the downvote button it should instead prompt you to create a reply denoted as a dissenting viewpoint. You will then explain your rebuttal.
Separately, a 'Report Abuse' button would flag a post for moderation attention (but also include who's reporting the abuse). A moderator should be able to see the full edit-history of a post (within the last day, maybe week).
Make contribution like a free market. The more you pay (with some kind of credit), the more visibility your post/comment will get. If people like your contributions, you earn credits. If they don't, you lose them.
I'm sure the gambling aspect (big gains if you invest a lot and wisely) would hook a ton of people. Quality, hopefully, would follow.
Re:Fixing Reddit
by dkarapetyan on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:48PM
(#11129985)
I just have a chrome extension that I call "add enemy!". When an enemy appears in a discussion their comment is automatically removed. It does wonders for my mental health. When some people consistently troll or have some kind of axe to grind it's much easier to provide people with personalized bubbles. Unsurprisingly the value I get out of discussions where the trolls are silent is way higher.
The other improvements they mention sound good, but Reddit's issues are more down to leadership problems than community/cultural/technical ones.
And when that happens, all the "objectionable" stuff gets cleared out. Can't have them associated with those "wholesome" corporate brands after all.
Well, the thing is, reddit is a private company and so the classic "freedom of speech" definition does not apply to it. And while their goal was unrestricted discussion a few years back, in attempt to pave road for profitability they have abandoned that goal. The goal of reddit right now it to become as attractive to advertisers as possible. What that entails is up to them to decide. One of the effects is heavy moderation of anything controversial. They seem to be attempting to "play it safe". We'll see if it will pay off.
A key community manager rule is 'don't promise freedom of speech on your site, because you likely don't have it and you will get absolutely eviscorated the minute you try and censor anything':
http://www.managingcommunities.com/2010/01/24/when-talking-a...
http://www.managingcommunities.com/2015/07/16/your-online-co...
If you say your community is pro freedom of speech or allows freeom of speech, you pretty much make yourself obliged to allow anything that's not literally illegal. That will include an awful lot of stuff that you personally don't like, that your corporate backers don't like, that other members on the site don't like...
And hence you have to make the awful decision; do you allow anything (like Voat or certain chan boards) and accept the consequences? Or do you start censoring and immediately lose the right to say you allow freedom of speech?
Making comments like this is a great way to cause a site or business to self destruct spectacularly. Reddit may be a private company, but their community was founded on a freedom of speech stance. They've turned against those ideals, so now they're going to struggle a lot more since people feel they've been betrayed.
That's a situation Reddit is going to have a lot of trouble escaping. And they could have at least delayed it by not hiring people who dislike the principles the company and site was founded on.
So from business analytic's perspective, he sees the numbers and he sees the target audience PLUS advertiser contract clauses (like no racism/sexism/certain porn things, non-liberal leaning things in general), and you get essentially private censorship. It's not a pretty sight, especially looking at deleted and locked threads daily, but it has a certain logic behind it. That logic is not in out favor, but we are not all people.
I think you completely missed the point of the comment and instead answered in the lines of "why you can't tell your boss to fuck off without getting fired, despite the first amendment".
I think the reality is one of the founders believed as you did and it was allowed as long as it was expedient. It isn't expedient now and they've shifted gears.
1. http://snapzu.com (worked with this one about a year ago)
2. http://getaether.net
3. https://stacksity.com
4. https://frizbee.co
5. http://hubski.com
6. http://empeopled.com
7. http://voat.co
8. https://piroot.com
9. http://www.linkibl.com
10. http://criticl.me
That being said, I just want to wish you good luck on your endeavor... the social network game is a really tough nut to crack because community is 99% of the value.
I just don't understand why people are going after a market that seems to be unprofitable. Am I missing something?
Because for a lot of them, it's fun. And for a similarly high amount of them, it's a chance to run their own community that fixes the perceived problems with others they've been part of online.
Not everything is about the money here.
2) Everyone who tried to move into Imgur's position found image hosting was very expensive and impractical as a hobby. The problem is they've largely been ideological and cut off from Reddit's ecosystem due to Imgur's incumbency.
3) Ultimately, until Reddit or Imgur stumbles in a substantial way that pisses off users none of them will be viable even with VC money.
For instance:
https://www.reddit.com/r/MediaCrush https://www.reddit.com/r/MediaCrush/comments/2tzuv0/mediacru... https://www.reddit.com/r/MediaCrush/comments/2v8ume/why_didn...
which was followed by:
https://www.reddit.com/r/MediaCrush/comments/2vpfwe/imgrushc...
Currently the only really one I know of is:
https://voat.co/v/veuwer aka http://www.veuwer.com/
Slimgur
http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2015/11/03/imgur-alternative-s...
which became:
https://voat.co/v/slimg https://sli.mg/
https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/7zlyd/my_gift_t...
Most of the original links/evidence of that are gone from the internet at this point tho and I'm tired of digging for them. :/
EDIT:
http://web.archive.org/web/20090328080325/http://digg.com/od...
http://archive.is/JS5DV
> imgur - the simple image sharer. The best in image hosting. imgur.com — imgur is a free image sharing/hosting service that allows you to quickly upload and edit your photos and share them with friends the Internet. Now you're asking, "How is this different from imageshack, tinypic, or photobucket?" Well that's simple. imgur is free (as in beer), no ads, anonymous, and easier to use. It's my gift to the Internet. Enjoy!
Ah archive.org still has it.
But yeh, it was effective guerilla marketing only. It was posted to Digg slightly before Reddit btw.
There are a few. Slimgur is one of the most common direect competitors I can think of, but there are also the various meme maker sites that host the resulting memes for users.
Another incredibly common competitor for a small slice of the market is gifycat, which used to be the crappy newcomer that never worked and is now almost a de-facto standard on Reddit.
Sometimes, people make a website because they want that website to exist, not because they want to get rich.
Recently Imgur appears to have started redirecting some people from direct image links to their full site (some claim this happens even on submissions linking directly to an image/gif). I've noticed this quite a bit on mobile or in the Alien Blue app. Others have also reported this behavior. My guess is Imgur is doing this not to display ads right away, but to drive people to their own app for later monetization and growing their own brand/community.
Imgur has taken $40M in funding, and so is presumably needing to find an exit at some point. Reddit sending tons of traffic directly to images was great for establishing themselves deep in the Reddit ecosystem early on, but if people are going directly to images vs. to the HTML page, that's a lot of lost impressions beyond just those who visit it directly or go to upload photos.
The load times for their site vs. just direct image/gif files are pretty painful on mobile, and this ultimately impacts the Reddit experience. I'm really curious if Reddit would ever roll out their own image host as a result, and it will be very interesting to watch this.
The article should also highlight overzealous mods that paint every outgoing link as spam.
It queries reddit.com/r/funny every ten minutes and collects the top 1000 images submitted. You as a user can then browse an endless stream of images much like Instagram.
At the end of the night it takes all the collected images from that day and parse them into 20 picture albums that user can be accessed by pressing the shuffle button on the top bar.
It's a never ending stream of funny images
This has always been true for traffic from FB and Twitter, but are you saying this is now also true when the referrer is reddit.com?
I double-checked today and count not find any indication that Imgur redirects images on Reddit referrers. (Although some Reddit submissions incorrectly submit the ad-page itself which is why people get confused)
If anyone has reproducable evidence of a redirect, let me know.
However they are now stuck with the same issue any other company is that relies heavily on a 3rd party for a core component of their business. Namely, degradation in the experience of the 3rd party results in a perceived degradation of their own service as users view the experiences as one in the same. Most people probably realize that Reddit and Imgur are separate companies, but if a core part of their Reddit browsing experience gets messed up by Imgur, that is also Reddit's problem.
Now, I'm sure the community could come up with something eventually, as inevitably happens when an image host gets too spammy. The issue is that it is not easy to trust every host, and frankly should be something Reddit owns to have better control over.
In that case, why are the vote scores on Caucus submissions blatantly inflated? There is zero probability scores are in the hundreds for completely random content. (glancing at the number of unique accounts who have made submissions, I question if 100+ active accounts even exist.)
For example, on Reddit, the score that you see is extremely simple/primitive: upvotes - downvotes. The entire premise behind Caucus is that content can and should be scored using much more sophisticated algorithms. Some of the many factors that we use to generate scores: poster's reputation, voters' reputations, posters/voters' activity levels, community size, number of times the post has been seen by voters, etc.
If this all sounds very abstract and you're wondering what a sophisticated scoring algorithm looks like, here's a famous one that we drew inspiration from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PageRank.
Anyway, long story short: the scores that you see on Caucus aren't an indication of the number of people who voted on it. They are the output of our reputation-system-based scoring algorithm. Hope that clears things up!
You can have a magic algorithm, that's fine. You can have it rank submissions behind-the-scenes, that's fine. But you can't copy Reddit's UI/UX and claim it doesn't behave the same.
(Also, PageRank is based on relationship networks, which makes no sense for a link aggregation where each link functions independently from each other. Saying an algorithm is sophisticated requires substantial proof which you do not provide.)
You are incorrect about the timing of the 2000 point threshold on Reddit though. Those have been regularly hit since the Digg migration in 2010.
I'm genuinely interested to see if this works out. Not kidding. However, with a straight face, I can also say I'm not optimistic, because 'echo chamber' tendencies are kind of why those "communities" tend to flourish, at least in my perspective.
I think it's prohibitively difficult, and only a decentralized system will succeed.
- Nobody wants to read a bunch of different ways to say the same things.
- Nobody cares about the person that happens to be the first to say something.
- Nobody wants to read through a tree of indented comments.
- Nobody has the time to read a wall of text when all they care about is the TL;DR.
Ain't nobody got time for this. I want a clear visual representation of the community's reaction to a post:
- Why I should care about this post.
- Why I should ignore this post, which doesn't deserve any of my attention.
- Why I should have a positive reaction to what the post is about.
- Why I should have a negative reaction to what the post is about.
- How accurate and representative of reality is this post?
- What actionable items I can take from this post.
- What related content/posts should I seek if I want more of this.
The pyramid of why-should-i-care-ness should be presented to me in the right orientation, or time is wasted.
What alternative is there?
How do you avoid the "Power User" effect that Digg (and arguably Reddit) ran into? If your most reputable users keep getting more and more reputable, eventually you have only a handful of very active users who have a majority of the voting power.
Ironically Slashdot actually did this. Of course it had lots of other problems.
This ensures that if anyone is ever dis-satisfied with the way the highly-reputed-users in a particular community are using/abusing their voting-power, they can simply create/migrate to a different community where those individuals will have no voting power at all. In the equilibrium, people will self-select into communities that match the tone/character that they are looking for.
But if nobody wants to pay for a service, then maybe it isn't as useful as we thought.
Having said that, as someone that uses some subreddits for forums there is exactly one thing that I'd like to see done for Reddit (and any other site with a downvote/dislike button).
If you click the downvote button it should instead prompt you to create a reply denoted as a dissenting viewpoint. You will then explain your rebuttal.
Separately, a 'Report Abuse' button would flag a post for moderation attention (but also include who's reporting the abuse). A moderator should be able to see the full edit-history of a post (within the last day, maybe week).
I'm sure the gambling aspect (big gains if you invest a lot and wisely) would hook a ton of people. Quality, hopefully, would follow.
Sounds like commie bullshit to me.[1]
It also sounds counter-productive to "building engagement". If I only have so many "points" to give out, I won't upvote much, will I?
[1] I'm being funny, but I do have a point.