News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fixing Reddit by whack on Thursday February 18, 2016 @10:24PM (#11131322)
Hi there. Sorry if the scores misled you. That's not the intent at all. The scores that you see next to each discussion/comment are exactly that: a score. It's not intended to represent the raw number of people who have voted.

For example, on Reddit, the score that you see is extremely simple/primitive: upvotes - downvotes. The entire premise behind Caucus is that content can and should be scored using much more sophisticated algorithms. Some of the many factors that we use to generate scores: poster's reputation, voters' reputations, posters/voters' activity levels, community size, number of times the post has been seen by voters, etc.

If this all sounds very abstract and you're wondering what a sophisticated scoring algorithm looks like, here's a famous one that we drew inspiration from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PageRank.

Anyway, long story short: the scores that you see on Caucus aren't an indication of the number of people who voted on it. They are the output of our reputation-system-based scoring algorithm. Hope that clears things up!

Re:Fixing Reddit by minimaxir on Friday February 19, 2016 @12:20AM (#11131734)
That is highly misleading UI.

You can have a magic algorithm, that's fine. You can have it rank submissions behind-the-scenes, that's fine. But you can't copy Reddit's UI/UX and claim it doesn't behave the same.

(Also, PageRank is based on relationship networks, which makes no sense for a link aggregation where each link functions independently from each other. Saying an algorithm is sophisticated requires substantial proof which you do not provide.)