News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by irishcoffee on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:11PM (#11120885)
I read this counter-point a lot. Its never clear to me how you invest the mortgage payment and also pay rent to live somewhere. Am I missing something? Sincere question.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by turar on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:32PM (#11121081)
I'm not sure I understand why you would pay rent to live somewhere else. I'm talking about living in the house that you bought and have a mortgage on.

Say your mortgage loan amount is $300K at 3.5%, locked in for 30 years. Instead of paying it off in 6-10 years with extra payments, I say invest those extra payments in the stock market, and keep paying the mortgage for 30 years at a locked rate of 3.5%. If that money that you invested makes anything above 3.5% over 30 years, then that's free returns to you.

On top of that, it also depends where you think the interests rates will be in 10-20 years from now. If you believe that they will be higher than they are currently, then that's even more reason to keep that loan locked in for 30 years instead of paying it off sooner. Hope that helps.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by JackFr on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:31PM (#11121578)
> On top of that, it also depends where you think the interests rates will be in 10-20 years from now. If you believe that they will be higher than they are currently, then that's even more reason to keep that loan locked in for 30 years instead of paying it off sooner.

That makes no sense. You'll be better off paying a lower interest rate than you would be not having a loan in a high rate environment?

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by turar on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:55PM (#11121755)
Remember, the loan is locked in. Everything around you may be a high rate environment, but your loan is still 3.5% when regular bank savings account would be paying, say 7%.

So, if you bought shares of an Emerging Markets ETF [1] with the money that you would have otherwise paid for accelerated mortgage payments. Today these shares are paying you around 3.5% in dividends alone.

Fast forward ten years to a high rate environment, and ten years of buying ETF shares and reinvesting dividends, I'm assuming that the dollar amount of your shares would be higher than the amount of debt you would have otherwise paid off already.

That's why no other country on Earth that I know of has 30-year fixed mortgages. They are essentially a government subsidy to homeowners via Fannie/Freddie.

[1] https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSEARCA%3AVWO

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by JackFr on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @06:29PM (#11122433)
Point taken about the high rate environment -- I'm not sure where I thought that other money would go. But it's still not obvious that you would be better off under your plan.

You're financing two assets, you home and your portfolio with some mixture of debt and equity. Without making assumptions about the expected return of the housing market, the return on your portfolio, the variance of those returns and the horizon, its not clear that you'd still be better off.

You say take advantage of the cheap (tax-favored too) leverage -- I'd be concerned medium term variance in returns. That ETF you pointed to is down over the past 10 years and underperformed the market -- and it looks like it missed a few dividend payments during the crisis.

https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=0&chdd=0&chds=0&chdv=1&...

> That's why no other country on Earth that I know of has 30-year fixed mortgages. They are essentially a government subsidy to homeowners via Fannie/Freddie.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by turar on Thursday February 18, 2016 @09:37AM (#11125983)
Correct, that's why I said that it was an assumption. I picked that ETF because I think the underlying assets would do well over the next 30 years, and also because it's relatively cheap to other ETFs because of the under-performance you mentioned. You can substitute any other asset there really that you think would perform better than 3.5%.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by distances on Thursday February 18, 2016 @05:44AM (#11124904)
A bit offtopic, but is it normal to have interest rates locked for the whole duration of the loan? Around here the interest rates usually follow 1, 6, or 12 month Euribor[0] with a small bank margin on top.

So yes, technically some people now could have loans with negative interest rates, but there is usually an extra clause for a minimum or 0% or 1% or somesuch.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euribor

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by minimax on Thursday February 18, 2016 @07:25AM (#11125249)
In the US, the 30 year fixed rate mortgage is the most popular type of mortgage by a wide margin.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by ryandrake on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @05:54PM (#11122218)
You need to discount your calculations because your ETF is not risk free.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by JackFr on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @06:31PM (#11122443)
In fairness the value of your home is not constant or risk free either.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by floppydisk on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:29PM (#11121051)
The basic premise behind that idea is rents are (historically were) cheaper than a mortgage so you could take the mortgage-rent delta, invest that, and generate a return greater than the interest rate on the mortgage and end up ahead. A lot of the mortgage calculators have a 3-5yr inflection point where renting, traditionally, was always cheaper if you planned on staying somewhere for 3-5yrs and moving.

The problem is, the equation has flipped. Mortgage payments are now, in many cases, cheaper than rent and there's such a high demand for rental units in some metro areas that landlords have no problems keeping tenants increasing rent 3-10% year over year. Ideally, you could do the same arbitrage buying a house (ideally an asset that nets 0 when you sell it worst case and you get your money back) and invest the rent-mortgage delta into other assets. The problem is "unlocking" the house option. If you don't have exemplary credit, and a certain pile of cash available, banks are leery to touch you and make financing available. Ergo, you get forced into the rental market and there's a huge incentive to turn properties into rentals.

Tack on the millennial generation's hesitancy to settle down in one location and you get a set of economic conditions that encourage renting and regular rent increases.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by Phlarp on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:17PM (#11121477)
>Tack on the millennial generation's hesitancy to settle down in one location and you get a set of economic conditions that encourage renting and regular rent increases.

Are we hesitant to "settle down" or are we trapped in a death spiral of student debt, rising rents and underemployment?

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by floppydisk on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:26PM (#11121546)
As always, it depends. Speaking anecdotally, most of the millennials I know speak rather forcefully about their desire to not settle down, marry, or begin a family prior to 30. I can count the number (amongst my friends) on one hand who discuss factors like underemployment and debt as being significant in their decision to delay settling down. Most seem to enjoy the party/city lifestyle and spend their time focusing on their career/traveling instead.

Yes, it's possible all of those things are factors but I'm going to argue for most it's subconscious rather than explicit factors in a settle/not settle equation. I think a lot of millennials are buying into the "extended adolescence"/party phase/single life/no responsibility/free spirit/high mobility (pick your moniker) lifestyle choices and acting accordingly - based on my anecdotal experience.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by VLM on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @04:49PM (#11121711)
> landlords have no problems keeping tenants increasing rent 3-10% year over year.

Where are the accompanying income increases coming from? Clearly not W-2 income. What can't continue forever does tend to stop. Or at least what happens on an extremely small scale can't be the case over an extremely large scale. Can't squeeze blood from a stone...

Also never forget the cost of home ownership isn't the mortgage, at least when compared to renting. That's only about half, once the numerous additional expenses are considered. My bachelor pad rent included everything but the electrical bill. Mortgages do not pay the gas bill or for a roof or a new HVAC system or water bill or (generally) property taxes or ...

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by floppydisk on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @05:12PM (#11121892)
They're growing rent until they hit the breaking point that no one will pay. Many of the families in my metro area are 2-parent working families and many of the big corp positions here tend towards mid to senior level or executive positions with the requisite salary and landlords keep pushing the rent up so long as people are willing to continue paying it. For single people, it's common to be cramming 4+ into a single family home (which pushes rent down to <$1k/person depending, not including utilities). For married folks, I hope you're both working and bringing in bank. Apartments tend to be more reasonable than single family homes, depending on location, but they're still quite high (1br apartments are between 1.6k-3k+/mo depending on the building. Closer you are to a metro or major roadway, substantially higher price).

In essence, we're a victim of our own success. Back in the day, life revolved around the city center and much of what is the 'burbs now was farm land. Overtime, as more people moved to the area, the cheap real estate was always al little bit further out from the city so people would saddle up and buy a house (with a 20-30 commute as the penalty) for a reasonable price. Over time, companies started building offices in the 'burbs, more people kept moving to the area, and the creep has pushed "affordable" out almost 20-30miles from the city center (commute time >1hr). Factor in the road networks are terrible, and mass transit stations are rare enough that real estate near them commands a premium and you find people willing to fork over a chunk of change in rent to not have a terrible commute either to city center or their 'burb job. Houses for sale, in the neighborhoods closer to the city, with good schools, not terrible commute etc, are generally priced for 2-income families. (>$500k).

Yes, the tradeoff between renting and buying is you assume the risk and costs of maintenance in buying. Most of the rentals i know of (single family homes or townhouse) push the cost of utilities onto the renter so really, all we aren't paying for is standard house maintenance and taxes. I'd rather assume the costs and risks of maintenance and taxes (and budget for them accordingly) and live with a fixed housing cost rather than continue fighting variable costs and potentially cranky landlords. Nothing makes a good housing situation sour faster than a bad land lord.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by dsp1234 on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:36PM (#11121113)
The New York Times buy vs rent calculator[0] can help determine which side of the rent vs buy is better (from a financial standpoint only, not including factors like 'freedom') depending upon various factors.

For example, here in Oregon based on all of the factors I adjusted, the result was "If you can rent a similar home for less than $1,422 per month then renting is better.". I could probably break even by moving to a different location, but then (for me) the freedom factor pushes it back towards home ownership.

So you put your own assumptions in, and that can give you a good idea of where your own situation results.

Its never clear to me how you invest the mortgage payment and also pay rent to live somewhere.

As a direct response to this, the calculator will actually show what the expected costs are assuming you invest any difference between the rent vs mortgage in a vehicle with the specified returns (and over the time period you specify)

[0] - http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc...?

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by heywiseguy on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:28PM (#11121043)
people who say this are talking about markets where the spread between renting and the finance cost of a similar bought property are huge. San Francisco, New York, LA...

Let's say you're a couple years out of school and you work at Snapchat. Somehow you have a lot of money saved up and you can buy a little house near your office in Venice. A small house in Venice runs about $2m. So let's say you borrow 1.8m to pay for it, your monthly payment is about $8,500 on a 30 year fixed and thats before maintenance and insurance.

That same house in Venice probably rents for somewhere between $3k and $4k/mo net of everything.

So what those people are saying is to live in a rental and invest _the saved money_ in the market.

Remember, in both cases you are renting: in one, you are renting real estate. In the other, you are renting money. But they have different tax treatments, and renting money allows you to lever yourself into eventually owning an asset who's value you might expect to rise.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by Grishnakh on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @06:18PM (#11122359)
Renting is cheaper than buying? That really doesn't make sense, and I don't think that's the case in most markets. In California, it might because of the funny way they do property taxes there, where new buyers get stuck with huge property tax bills but long-time owners are grandfathered at far lower rates, so the landlords are likely people who've owned the house for ages. Other states just aren't like this.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by ArkyBeagle on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @06:42PM (#11122511)
Renting can be cheaper or about the same as buying. And I mean a comparable property. You have to add it all up.

My landlord has probably shelled out $10k in repairs ( the house is at that magic 20 year point where everything fails ) in five years.

I've done the "buy cheap and spend the rest at Home Depot" thing. It's not bad, but it's not ideal. Unless I'm categorically certain of living in the house at least five years, I'll continue to rent.

I've done the math - I'd have less equity in a house of the same value than I have in raw cash freed up just from renting. And that's really not counting fees and closing costs.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by heywiseguy on Monday February 22, 2016 @10:21PM (#11156254)
Renting is vastly cheaper than buying in many of the most expensive markets in the USA, if your only assumptions are like "borrows 30 year fixed at good credit rating current rates at 80% of the value of the property".

Vastly. Fancy parts of LA. SF. All of New York. Pretty much anywhere in the train-serviced urban/suburban Northeast.

It might not "make sense" but it is true. I'm also sure it's not the case in most markets in the USA, but in the large metropolitan markets, it is true, and that's the point people are making when they say "you know, it might make more sense to invest your investment money in a different asset class and rent rather than pay the ownership premium here in Santa Monica/Pacific Heights/Williamsburg"

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by MrApathy on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:37PM (#11121139)
It's an argument that's highly dependent on how high rents and purchase prices are correlated. In many markets the two are somewhat aligned, but on occasion the two diverge significantly. For example, if the cost to rent is $3k and the monthly mortgage on a comparable place (including insurance, RE tax) is $4k, then in the longer term it may make more sense to purchase. Over time the $1k difference will grow smaller and equity will be built up. But what if there's a "frothy" market where investors are bidding up the price of an apartment and after taking ownership they're renting them out rather than living in them. So it's $3k to rent, but $1.2M to purchase, meaning the monthly mortgage is closer to $6k. Well now it makes sense to rent and invest the difference outside of your local real estate market. This obviously looks like an extreme example, but during the housing boom and happened in Miami, Vegas, and many other cities, and it's arguably occurring in many localized markets today.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by feverishaaron on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:17PM (#11120937)
Especially when rents are rising 5-10% per year.
Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by fist on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:32PM (#11121077)
I believe what they're arguing is that you don't pay your mortgage off early with a 3.5% mortgage rate.

You invest your excess money in the stock market (hopefully returning more than 3.5%) instead of paying off your mortgage early.

Re:The Rise of Renting in the U.S by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday February 17, 2016 @03:19PM (#11120951)
I have very often wondered the same. Someone somewhere said it, lots of people repeat it, nobody does it and nobody has fact checked it.