News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by winter_blue on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:40AM (#11103006)
The entirety of blame for all of this pain, loss, and suffering falls squarely on the Republicans who oppose immigration reform, and keep calling for the merciless deportation of everyone including children who overstayed their visas or came over the border.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by dang on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:35PM (#11105057)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11102015 and marked it off-topic.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by melling on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:51AM (#11103355)
If I go to another country and overstay my welcome, I end up in trouble. There's a 90 day visa limit in a few countries in Central America, for example. I once had to go to Mexico for a day to reset my visa. What a hassle; one painful bus ride! Everyone else can apply for a temporary visa then simply permanently stay?

The Republicans did give amnesty to 3 million illegals:

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1283036...

The United States let in lots of immigrants. The world is full of people who want to come here. Shouldn't there be a more fair system?

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by pkaye on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:46AM (#11104299)
What should be done? A amnesty for existing illegal immigrants? Having an open border? Do you thing this will result in an influx of economic migrants as it is happening in the EU?
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:55AM (#11103073)
I think there are two issues there. One, the immigration rules. Two, the enforcement of those rules.

On the second, I have little sympathy for the category of people who intentionally break a law and then cry foul when that is discovered and addressed.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by Lawtonfogle on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:35AM (#11103564)
>On the second, I have little sympathy for the category of people who intentionally break a law and then cry foul when that is discovered and addressed.

So homosexuals put in prison because homosexuality is illegal in places (including the US not even 20 years ago)... no sympathy for them? OR... do you think not all laws are equal and that there are bad laws?

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:47AM (#11103612)
There are absolutely bad laws. There are also unconstitutional laws. I have no support for the latter, of course.

For bad but constitutional laws, we have a process for challenging and changing them. While they're in effect, I believe that if you're going to break them publicly, you should not expect to escape consequences.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by winter_blue on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:35AM (#11103863)
Regarding constitutionality, FYI:

Back when the U.S. constitution was written, visas did not exists, and getting permission to immigrate was uncommon. You could literally walk into most countries without any papers. As such, the enumerated powers of Congress actually only contains the power "To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization" (Article I, Section 8, Clause 4). Nothing about restricting immigration.

The US did not regulate immigration at all until the passage of the Chinese Exclusion Act (1882). The Act was challenged in the courts, and the SCOTUS ruled that Congress' power to "To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization" meant that it could also exclude people from entering the country – which is quite a stretch. For more, see: http://openborders.info/blog/immigration-

Popular opinion at the time was that Chinese and other Asian people were unfit to be part of American society, and the SCOTUS was willing to stretch the meaning of those words in the Constitution to grant Congress the new powers necessary to exclude them.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by Lawtonfogle on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:18AM (#11103759)
>There are also unconstitutional laws.

The problem is that a law is or is not constitutional based on numerous other factors such as popular opinion. The truth is that the SCOTUS is partially impacted by the will of the people at any given time (to say nothing of the entire issue of the political nature of the SCOTUS). Crying foul is one way to modify the will of the people. In some cases, what is constitutional is even explicitly tied to external factors (such as obscenity tests which in part depend upon current morals of the community).

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by NN88 on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:45AM (#11103915)
Your straw man is on fire
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by Lawtonfogle on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:10AM (#11104084)
There is no straw man. The person did not differentiate any laws, so I pulled up a set of laws that I guess them to at least consider making an example for.

If they did mean to create different laws they felt differently about, I left them an opening to do such in my last question.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by gnaritas on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:21AM (#11104147)
That is a perfectly valid argument he made, you can't just randomly call things straw men, they must actually be straw men.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by winter_blue on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:02AM (#11103101)
You would have more sympathy if you understood how those rules actually worked.

There is no visa for unskilled people like the parents of the dreams in the movie. Even skilled people have a very hard time getting a US visa (more than any other country).

I don't think it is morally wrong for people to move another country seeking a better life, even if that country by a thin majority is unwelcoming of them (by making it impossible for them to immigrate legally).

I find your lack of sympathy repugnant.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by HarryHirsch on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:15AM (#11103178)
If the law wasn't so selectively enforced and if the US weren't directly responsible for the political instability south of the border I'd have some sympathy for your view.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by delazeur on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:55AM (#11103973)
Except that all four of these people were brought into the country as young children. Were you in control of your life when you were five?
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:18AM (#11104125)
I was not. My kids are 4 and 6; they absolutely depend on me to make good choices on their behalf. I know that they will benefit from or suffer the consequences of many of my choices.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by kaitai on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:45AM (#11104286)
Yep. Isn't it great that these kids could compete in robotics competitions and work to support their families in relative safety instead of being stuck in a corrupt and dangerous country in which a drug war has torn apart civil society? Looks like their parents made a pretty rational choice!
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:32PM (#11105043)
Agreed. Their parents took significant risk and made a choice that, albeit illegal, worked out very well for their kids for a little over a decade. Well done and I hope that I'd have done the same for my family in analogous circumstances.

That doesn't mean that, once discovered, the kids are entitled to residency or citizenship.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by MisterBastahrd on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:12PM (#11104468)
Suppose you made a mistake... say you were messing around with your phone while driving and ran over a family. Would you find it reasonable that your kids be prosecuted for your crime because they were in the back seat of your car? Because that's what's happening here.
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @01:21PM (#11104959)
That's not what's happening here (IMO). What is closer to happening is whether my kids should suffer the economic and loss of parenthood if I were sued civilly or incarcerated as a result of that incident. They would so suffer and that is proper.

The young adults in question were born as non-US citizens and immigrated illegally (stipulated/agreed that this was not by their choice) to the US. Many years later, this is discovered. Now, the question is, "what to do about it?"

None of the above facts support a claim to US citizenship nor US permanent residency under the current immigration laws (as I understand them).

Whether it should is a different question. I _am_ in favor of a thoughtfully designed amnesty program for people who have lived peaceably and productively in our country for some extended period of time. I am also in favor of thoughtfully designed immigration program for people likely to live peaceably and productively in our country.

A key element to my support is that these policies be thoughtfully designed by experts (ie. not by me, and not in an internet chat room) and that it be enforced (in both directions) when violations or qualifications are discovered. I believe there are some natural limits to how many people we want in the United States, and as one of the preferred nations (as measured by net immigration), we do need some policies, ie: open borders are not the default option.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by aljones on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:09AM (#11103137)
Why do you have such little sympathy?
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @08:29AM (#11103254)
Because I believe in the sovereignty of nations and in the stability that the rule of law gives to a free society.

I'm entirely open for reconsidering (and am nowhere near an expert on) the first point (what our immigration policies are/ought to be).

I'm fairly unwavering on the second. When someone says, "ah, screw it, I don't like that law, so I'm not going to follow it," they put themselves at peril of being discovered and prosecuted.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by crpatino on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:54AM (#11103643)
> When someone says, "ah, screw it, I don't like that law, so I'm not going to follow it," ...

Yes, I am Mexican and I agree 100% with you.

So, I would be extremelly happy to see that every time an illegal Mexican immigrant was caught in the US, before throwing him/her to the other side of the fence, and investigation was open to persecute and file criminal charges to every American national that said "screw it, I dont like that law" and gave an illegal job (at below-market wages) to the illegal immigrant.

I would be even more happy if other American nationials that were deprived by those illegal practices of honest livelihoods would start class-action civil lawsuits against the fat cats that lined their pockets with the sweat and blood of "wetback" labor. That would make my day!

But, you know... here in the real world, I would settle for you, sokoloff, to admit that whatever stability that those particular rules provide to American society is derived more from the discretionality to apply the same laws to some class of people but not to others. There is an old joke about democracy being 3 wolves and 1 sheep voting on what's for dinner tonight. I don't think that is precisely the case here, but there's a kernel of truth hidden there as well.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:17AM (#11103756)
Uneven prosecution is a real problem. I think if we decided to strictly prosecute every transgression, we'd either end up in a police state or in a state where people rejected and amended dumb laws. I'm not sure which center of gravity is stronger.

On your last paragraph, I do admit to parts of that (not necessarily whether it's more than 50%, but otherwise I agree), and that selective prosecution is a good thing in some areas (no sense ticketing someone for 56 in a 55 on a clear, dry, sunny day with light traffic). See also my last comment at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11103596

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by Lawtonfogle on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:46AM (#11103924)
>I think if we decided to strictly prosecute every transgression, we'd either end up in a police state or in a state where people rejected and amended dumb laws. I'm not sure which center of gravity is stronger.

So aren't we already in an unfair anarchic system, so what then is the problem when people cry foul that the system violates its own principles to give benefit to those least needing aid while strictly enforcing itself on those who most need help?

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by crpatino on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @08:18PM (#11114458)
I was not talking about littering, jaywalking, or traffic tickets. I was talking about the economic warfare that the American moneyed class is waging to the American working class; and one of which's fronts is illegal immigration.

It saddens me how blue collar Americans can get so incensed at "Juan, the wetback", but never stop one minute to think that the one who is screwing them both is "Johnny 'Honest J' Howell".

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by winter_blue on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:32AM (#11103548)
What do you think about the laws that were passed in the Jim Crow era? Suppose the United States had Jim Crow -esque laws at the federal law, would you support them because of "the stability that the rule of law gives to a free society"?

As you've said say you are not an expert on immigration rules; I can give you a super-quick summary: in 1965, they changed the law to allow non-Europeans to immigrate. But they made it so extremely restrictive that practically no one could immigrate legally. Their objective was to ensure the ethnic composition ("whiteness") of the United States didn't change significantly. Which is why I don't see a family coming here seeking a better life as morally wrong.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by sokoloff on Monday February 15, 2016 @09:43AM (#11103596)
I think a lot of the marijuana and peyote drug policies were also "fear of non-whites" driven. It's a real thing; I agree.

To answer your specific Jim Crow law question, prior to the passage of the 14th and 15th Amendment, yes, I would support those chartered with the enforcement of those laws while seeking to change the law at the legislative level. (These are morally repugnant laws to be clear; the choice is between an orderly society with some bad consequences, or an anarchic society with different bad consequences. I choose order.)

After the 14th Amendment, those laws are unconstitutional, and I do not support the enforcement of unconstitutional laws.

Those states who had Jim Crow laws or even plantation owners who bought and sold humans; I can't understand it and can't support it, but it clearly was the majority point of view at that time and place.

This issue is running up against the fundamental challenge of democratic society: how to have a government that expresses and supports the will of the majority of its citizens without unduly restricting the freedom of those citizens who find themselves in the minority.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by winter_blue on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:03AM (#11104030)
I would've willfully and knowingly violated the Fugitive Slave Clause of the U.S. Constitution, if I'd lived in the 1800s US.

I would have helped slaves escape from slave states into free states, and would have harbored them in my home (and whatever property I owned) in total defiance and violation of the law. And I would've been willing to go to jail for it.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by chillacy on Monday February 15, 2016 @07:25PM (#11107078)
I don't anticipate any of you to change each other's minds, but it's interesting to see how you've both built up the world on different principles (sokoloff believing that right and wrong is defined by law and you believing that laws may not reflect morality, and if I might guess, sokoloff seems to be a relativist and you an absolutist)
Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by Lawtonfogle on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:44AM (#11103909)
> (These are morally repugnant laws to be clear; the choice is between an orderly society with some bad consequences, or an anarchic society with different bad consequences. I choose order.)

Why not a little of column A and a little of column B?

>I can't understand it and can't support it

Most people economically support slavery, albeit through a few layers of companies supplying companies. In the last 24 hours I ate a piece of chocolate from Nestle which I paid for, thus adding to demand that goes all the way back to child slaves harvesting chocolate.

Re:Ten years ago they beat MIT. Today, it's complicated (2014) by gnaritas on Monday February 15, 2016 @11:28AM (#11104192)
Rule of law in this country is already a joke; it only exists in the minds of the underclass. Constitutionality is also largely a joke and certainly not by any means a stamp of moral approval. Your hard stance on enforcement of said jokes just comes off as a complete lack of sympathy for real people and honestly perhaps a bit phony.