News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by rgbrenner on Thursday February 11, 2016 @08:40AM (#11080006)
Article is bs.

they lost 44m in _2014_. Raised 77m last year. They may need to raise more in 2016.

Nothing else. No other facts. No info on their balance sheet, etc. Doesn't even know if they're growing, what their revenue or losses for 2015 were.

And based on that, Fact thinks that's enough to say they "may be forced to close".

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by npalli on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:05AM (#11080138)
The auditor has clearly stated that it has doubts about the company as a 'going concern'. This is a technical term in auditing that implies the auditor has doubts that the company will survive (i.e, will have to liquidate) another twelve months. It's not a willy nilly "growing company is losing money" type statement, it means there is a fundamental problem in how the company is financed and operated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Going_concern

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by taylorwc on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:54AM (#11080433)
Auditors are required to issue such statements when there is no line of sight to the company being solvent (and no one can guarantee that the company can close a financing round.) I'd venture a guess that almost every startup at a similar stage to SoundCloud would have the same issue if they are audited.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by TheLogothete on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:39AM (#11080713)
Soundcloud is almost 10 years old. At what point a company stops being a startup? At what point it stops being feasible for a company to operate at a loss?
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by taylorwc on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:05AM (#11080924)
Are these meant to be rhetorical? You decide when you're going to stop calling it a startup. They are venture-backed and founded within the past decade. I'm going to call them a startup.

As for question number two, I'll let you count how many publicly-traded companies aren't profitable that have been around for decades.

I didn't register an opinion on whether SoundCloud should or shouldn't be profitable, I merely said what GAAS[0] requires an auditor to do.

[0] http://pcaobus.org/Standards/Auditing/Pages/AU341.aspx

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by sosborn on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:08PM (#11081391)
There is operating at a loss because you are reinvesting (see: Amazon) and there is operating at a loss because your business isn't viable. Soundcloud is somewhere in between those two extremes.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by taylorwc on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:42PM (#11081613)
Very true--Amazon would never have a going concern statement issued in its audit, because it voluntarily reinvests what would otherwise be operating profit. I was thinking more along the lines of a company like Sprint, where they are only solvent through issuance of debt and outside investment.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by rgbrenner on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:19AM (#11080229)
By reducing the statement to that, you're overstating what the auditor actually said:

KPMG said in the report that the need for more investment represented “a material uncertainty which may cast significant doubt on the company’s ability to continue as a going concern.”

And again, this was in their 2014 report. So clearly they've last more than a year at this point.

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by dopamean on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:13AM (#11080998)
I'm sure the same would have been said about Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and a billion other startups that eventually made it. Aren't auditors supposed to be very conservative? It's unsurprising to me that KPM, PWC, or any other auditing firm would have a pessimistic out look of a startup that is relying on raising money to exist.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by 4ndr3vv on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:39AM (#11080344)
I think you've misinterpreted this

From your link: "This accounting principle assumes that, a company will continue to exist long enough to carry out its objectives and commitments and will not liquidate in the foreseeable future."

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by reitzensteinm on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:46AM (#11080382)
You've missed a negation.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by raesene4 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @08:48AM (#11080048)
I'm not sure I'd agree there's no other facts. links from the article include excerpts from their financial accounts which don't look good (losing 39M on a 17M turnover is not healthy).

And the quote from the auditor is significant, auditors don't put that kind of thing in unless they have to as it annoys their customers to be reminded that there's significant concern over their ability to continue operations.

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:53AM (#11080822)
Do they have public accounts? I can't understand what SoundCloud could spend $60M USD on? Apparently they have over 300 employees, what do they do all day? Clearly I don't understand their operation.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:49AM (#11081269)
According to the 2014 accounts the employees earn a little less than €100,000 each, on average. So there's a huge wage bill.

I have no idea what they do either. Legal compliance - DMCAs, and avoiding DMCAs - seems to be a big problem. But I don't understand why they need 300 people to work on that.

if they raised $77m last year that gives them another year or two of runway. But given the continuing losses the current business model doesn't seem to be working, and the burn rate is too high for long term survival without real income growth.

As a user, I love finding music on SC. But I worry they'll try to make the site yet another pay-to-play streaming service, which will kill most of the interest.

Becoming a sales site seems like a better move. IMO there's a big niche for a Bandcamp-but-better site just waiting to be filled.

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by zdkl on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:16PM (#11083327)
I'd guess interfacing with music labels and copyright holders must be a special kind of tedious. Seems to be a recurring problem of music platforms who don't fit the industry's royalty model
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by rgbrenner on Thursday February 11, 2016 @08:58AM (#11080099)
one excerpt of their P&L does not equal "excerpts from their financial accounts" (plural). And again, it's from 2014.

For all we know Soundcloud was profitable last year. Maybe it's not likely.. but the article has no information at all on last year, yet they feel comfortable making this statement.

The auditor statement is standard boilerplate. It applies to every company that is losing money. That's right -- if the company is losing money, they may need to raise money in the future to continue. No kidding.

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by raesene4 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:05AM (#11080135)
there are two excerpts from their financial accounts in there if that makes you any happier (and justifies my use of the plural :) one from the P&L and one from the staffing section

The article is working on what's publicly available (there's a surprise), as they can hardly work on what Soundcloud hasn't released! My guess would be that if Soundcloud had managed to get into profitability that quickly then soundcloud would've got a press release out to say that.

edit - didn't realise they were a UK company. So the full accounts and company filing history are https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/06343600/filing-h...

definitely their cash position at the end of 2014 was not of the best...

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by kevcampb on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:30AM (#11080659)
Wait... _BETA_.companieshouse.gov.uk? Company records available for free? A website that is online 24x7 and doesn't close at night?

I've obviously been living under a rock

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by raesene4 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:24PM (#11081496)
yeah it's super useful, nice interface and all the docs are hosted on S3 which is interesting...
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by zekevermillion on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:03AM (#11080129)
Agree. The article could just as well be written about any other successful high-growth company. Continued survival will require further capital investment...no sh@*t! Obviously the author is just trolling for views. If SC announces another round, and then turns a profit in 3 years, someone will write another article about their "amazing turnaround".
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by x1024 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:10AM (#11080176)
Just like how we're now writing about Twitter's 'amazing turnaround' after only 10 years of losing money. Oh, wait...
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by zekevermillion on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:40AM (#11080350)
Twitter is a public company now, not a high-growth company. It's quite fair to criticize Twitter, or Zynga, for selling to the public at an inflated price based on hype -- after which their respective stock prices have languished. Keep in mind that there has been plenty of criticism of twitter from the very beginning, all while they went from being worth zero to $20 billion. The point is, criticizing a high-growth, privately-backed company like SoundCloud for losing money only makes sense if you want to criticize the entire model of venture-backed entrepreneurship.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by x1024 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:17AM (#11080574)
Yes, that's what we want to criticize.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by zekevermillion on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:48AM (#11080779)
OK, but that wasn't the gist of the article. The article was only about one company as if the author is unaware of how VC works, for better or worse.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by x1024 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:57AM (#11080849)
If we listen to you, it would seem that SC is both blameless, and - in fact - not in trouble at all.

And that's all fine and well. It sounds plausible. But it seems like every company is "blameless, and things are actually going peachy... but we still need more funding". And at that point the whole thing starts to become unraveled.

Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by zekevermillion on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:29AM (#11081120)
Really, is that what I said? You are committing a logical fallacy concluding that "this article doesn't prove SC is in trouble" implies "SC is not in trouble". Also you are making a big assumption that I approve of the venture funding model as applied here.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by camillomiller on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:10AM (#11080178)
The problem is that now investors are asking themselves more frequently, after a few years of sight-unseen venture investing, if it really makes sense for them to keep funneling money into companies that might never turn a profit, let alone have a profitable exit at the horizon. The talk around here (let me say that again: "the talk") is that investors are getting tighter and tighter and money is not so easy to get anymore. If you follow the startup scene here you can certainly spot some worrying indicators that confirm that sentiment. Add to the mix that the traditionally conservative German/European investor is reading the same news we're all reading about the imminent burst of the Silicon Valley hyper-valuation bubble.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by rgbrenner on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:15AM (#11080203)
Where is the evidence that Soundcloud is or will have trouble raising money? Pandora just raised $300m in December. Deezer (france) raised €100m less than 2 weeks ago. And Spotify is looking for $500m (just 8 months after raising ~$500m) right now.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by camillomiller on Thursday February 11, 2016 @09:19AM (#11080231)
No evidence yet. I stated pretty clearly that it's "talk" I was writing about, and it was centered around the Berlin scene. Which is global, of course, but has its own peculiarities.
Re:SoundCloud could be forced to close after $44m losses by vox_mollis on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:57AM (#11081330)
The story is larger than soundcloud.

This is data point #8794390820385 that the bubble has been pricked.