News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:04AM (#11065719)
Legally not allowed? You can donate to anybody you please I would think.

Anyway I'm all for using software you pay for, because it has a higher probability of being around next year. One person donating a responsible amount is not going to guarantee that. Its a start I guess.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by eloisant on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:21AM (#11065831)
I think what he is saying is that it's easy for him to buy a commercial licence for Open Source software (even if the licence doesn't grant him any additional right or service) but donations are legally harder to pay before tax.

I think it boils down to the fact that you can have business expenses, you deduce that from your revenue and it's all good, but other than that if you want to get money out of your company (salaries, dividends, etc.) you're being taxed.

I guess the tax office wouldn't want you to just "donate" money from your company to get it out without paying taxes.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:17AM (#11066267)
It must be the cross-govt payment/tax issue?In the US its dead simple. Django has a Corporate Membership that covers just this case.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by masklinn on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:12AM (#11065765)
> Legally not allowed? You can donate to anybody you please I would think.

The point patio11 makes here is that as a company things are not so easy:

> Both countries are very lenient with regards to necessary business expenses (必須経費 over here). Neither particularly likes arbitrary money moving out of the company; that smacks of unreported income.

("unreported income" here means money paid to an employee but not reported as income). With a proper invoice and line item, all the boxes are checked and a random audit won't fall on the company like a ton of bricks.

Even if the system handles company donations, that tends to be more complex both internally and externally than a "software license" line item, and thus to have way more overhead and to be way more likely to be refused.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by slavik81 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:12AM (#11066212)
Purchasing a license that's identical to one you know is freely available doesn't fit the English language meaning of 'necessary business expense'. Maybe the actual technical definition is a little different, but I don't see what fraud is being prevented by restricting donations if companies can just buy things for far above market value.

Let's say I fix patio11's backyard patio. Instead of requesting payment for the work, I fork Django and send him an invoice for a license. He pays me thousands of dollars for a commercial, OSS Django license, and writes it off as a necessary business expense.

It's the same scam whether it's a donation or a license purchase. I just don't get the point.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by infinite8s on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:22PM (#11066937)
Fraud requires intent to defraud.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by zanny on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:33PM (#11067033)
You're defrauding the IRS out of tax revenue by writing off OSS donations as business expenses when the product is free.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by infinite8s on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @02:23PM (#11067954)
Then you can structure the invoice to include an hour of consultation time. In any case, the transaction is a taxable event - it just depends on who pays (your corporation, the recipient, or the US government (if you are paying a nonprofit)).
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:19AM (#11065815)
Oh, corporate rules. Sure. So "its legally difficult if I'm to keep my tax write-off" would be a better statement? Because it could be a personal donation.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by maxerickson on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:27AM (#11065875)
The comment was made under the discussion Ask HN: Does your company donate to free software it uses?.

I guess I think the positioning in the linked comment is bombastic, but litigating it out of context is boring.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by Mtinie on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:25AM (#11065858)
> Because it could be a personal donation.

Not if it came out of the company's coffers.

But yes, if you change the premise of the original comment, sure, you can easily make a personal donation to an OSS project.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:32AM (#11065913)
I thought the original comment was about contributing as in, doing work for. But I see the interpretation of "giving money" now, thanks!
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by masklinn on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:33AM (#11065922)
The original comment was about donating not contributing, and the whole thread is in the context of corporate donations since that's the subject of TFA.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by Xylakant on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:45AM (#11066000)
it's not corporate. Once you're some sort of LLC/GmbH, no money can leave the company without some sort of record who received it and why. That record is conveniently an invoice, but it can also be a receipt for the donation by an established charity etc.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by DomreiRoam on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#11066370)
The key aspect here is "established charity" recognized in the country where the company is located.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by rmc on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:47AM (#11066013)
It could be a personal donation. But then tax takes part of it first. Basically, would the OSS project like €1,000 or €500? Because either way the company has to pay €1,000.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by maxerickson on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:09AM (#11065745)
There's more explanation at the link, it's largely a tax thing where a donation ends up being more expensive than an invoice. It's also apparently uncomfortable for the donation to come from the company.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by caminante on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:52AM (#11066046)
Uncomfortable's a good descriptor. I get the impression Patio11's involved in mostly "solo" enterprises. If that weren't the case, I'd like to think he'd run these "discretionary expenses" by his partners.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by k33n on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:37AM (#11066492)
The part that confused me was his claim that these are "necessary expenses" when in fact, they aren't. Very shaky ground.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by nommm-nommm on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:47PM (#11067130)
>Legally not allowed? You can donate to anybody you please I would think.

Cooperations can probably only donate to 501(c)(3)s without it being considered paying someone off the books or, worse, money laundering by IRS standards.

If the project doesn't have any ability to send an invoice then they probably aren't formal enough for a 501(c)(3).

That being said, its only a few clicks to send someone an invoice in PayPal so its a little odd this is a difficult thing for an open source project to do.

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by DanieleProcida on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:06AM (#11065737)
Using software you pay for, or pay for software you use? In the end, the money goes to the same place.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:11AM (#11065755)
Its just that (almost) nobody pays for open software. Its the tragedy of the commons or some such. Being the only guy to do so, hardly begins to help insure the product will be around in a year.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by DanieleProcida on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#11066377)
No, it does begin to ensure it. It doesn't do the whole job, you need others to do it too, but it's a necessary step.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by jasonjei on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @01:06PM (#11067292)
Ubuntu does this, don't they? They charge you a license for a year of support...
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by stephengillie on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @01:23PM (#11067456)
Do they actually provide support? Like an email address where you can get questions answered? That's a lot different than just stapling an invoice to the free license that everyone gets.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by bcook on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:27AM (#11065873)
I hate to be a buzz-kill, but I have never "paid for" Linux.

Well, maybe I have... through some hierarchical, open-source, licensing "tax".

Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by hnbroseph on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:49AM (#11066027)
what do you mean?
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment by bcook on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:02AM (#11066129)
That "paying for" software means "it will be around next year".