Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by slavik81 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:12AM
(#11066212)
Purchasing a license that's identical to one you know is freely available doesn't fit the English language meaning of 'necessary business expense'. Maybe the actual technical definition is a little different, but I don't see what fraud is being prevented by restricting donations if companies can just buy things for far above market value.
Let's say I fix patio11's backyard patio. Instead of requesting payment for the work, I fork Django and send him an invoice for a license. He pays me thousands of dollars for a commercial, OSS Django license, and writes it off as a necessary business expense.
It's the same scam whether it's a donation or a license purchase. I just don't get the point.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by infinite8s on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:22PM
(#11066937)
Fraud requires intent to defraud.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by zanny on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:33PM
(#11067033)
You're defrauding the IRS out of tax revenue by writing off OSS donations as business expenses when the product is free.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by infinite8s on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @02:23PM
(#11067954)
Then you can structure the invoice to include an hour of consultation time. In any case, the transaction is a taxable event - it just depends on who pays (your corporation, the recipient, or the US government (if you are paying a nonprofit)).
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:19AM
(#11065815)
Oh, corporate rules. Sure. So "its legally difficult if I'm to keep my tax write-off" would be a better statement? Because it could be a personal donation.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by maxerickson on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:27AM
(#11065875)
The comment was made under the discussion Ask HN: Does your company donate to free software it uses?.
I guess I think the positioning in the linked comment is bombastic, but litigating it out of context is boring.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by Mtinie on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:25AM
(#11065858)
> Because it could be a personal donation.
Not if it came out of the company's coffers.
But yes, if you change the premise of the original comment, sure, you can easily make a personal donation to an OSS project.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:32AM
(#11065913)
I thought the original comment was about contributing as in, doing work for. But I see the interpretation of "giving money" now, thanks!
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by masklinn on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:33AM
(#11065922)
The original comment was about donating not contributing, and the whole thread is in the context of corporate donations since that's the subject of TFA.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by Xylakant on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:45AM
(#11066000)
it's not corporate. Once you're some sort of LLC/GmbH, no money can leave the company without some sort of record who received it and why. That record is conveniently an invoice, but it can also be a receipt for the donation by an established charity etc.
Re:Funding Django is not an act of charity, it's an investment
by DomreiRoam on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:26AM
(#11066370)
The key aspect here is "established charity" recognized in the country where the company is located.
The point patio11 makes here is that as a company things are not so easy:
> Both countries are very lenient with regards to necessary business expenses (必須経費 over here). Neither particularly likes arbitrary money moving out of the company; that smacks of unreported income.
("unreported income" here means money paid to an employee but not reported as income). With a proper invoice and line item, all the boxes are checked and a random audit won't fall on the company like a ton of bricks.
Even if the system handles company donations, that tends to be more complex both internally and externally than a "software license" line item, and thus to have way more overhead and to be way more likely to be refused.