News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by fnid2 on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:16PM (#1104500)
it's just the beta version people! Eventually, it'll have a camera and multi-tasking. For crying out loud!

In a forum full of entrepreneurs, it seems no one has any empathy for a company releasing a new product without all the bells and whistles. There's a huge amount of hypocrisy here from a group that espouses "Release early, release often."

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by DannoHung on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:39PM (#1104753)
I don't even think they need full multitasking. What they really need is some sort of API that lets you run a tiny cooperative process that can do some simple things like keep a socket open or send a push notification to the GUI. Little stuff like that. And then a manager makes sure that none of those co-processes hog resources. Keep app startup times down, which people should be doing anyway, and the rest of the whinging about Multitasking goes away.

Supporting quick application shutdown and startup is a better way to make apps in any case.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by Periodic on Friday February 05, 2010 @05:24PM (#1105082)
Simply having fast app startup times doesn't not solve the problem.

For example, very often I will want to quickly check my email or chat session while a page is loading, but if it stops loading that page when I switch applications I don't gain that benefit. I also like to have chat sessions open and get small notifications (usually a sound or on-screen indicator) when I have new messages even if I'm in the middle of reading a large article in my browser.

Without background applications, neither of these usage scenarios is viable. It is this sort of usage that sets it apart from a general-purpose computing device and makes it into an appliance for me.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by jws on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:42PM (#1104762)
Until the dollar and power cost of RAM is so low it doesn't matter. Then you can forget about those hoops.

Though one nice side effect of those hoops is that your app appears to survive a reboot.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by Periodic on Friday February 05, 2010 @05:22PM (#1105079)
I don't think it really has much to do with the total size of your RAM, and more to do with how it ends up getting used. Sure, we can get more RAM so everything we have fits in it, but then everything in the next generation will just use more.

It's about guarantees. We want to guarantee that one application bug doesn't bring the whole system to its knees. If that app you downloaded gets into some crazy polling loop and starts hogging all the CPU, making your iPhone run hot and run out of battery in 1 hour, you won't be happy and you won't have a good way to figure out what's going on and fix it.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @07:58PM (#1105424)
> In a forum full of entrepreneurs, it seems no one has any empathy for a company releasing a new product without all the bells and whistles. There's a huge amount of hypocrisy here from a group that espouses "Release early, release often."

Part of the problem may be that Apple does not present it's products as half-done. They may improve certain features that you're looking for; they may not. You don't know. There's no roadmap for future development, and the only feedback that users get about what features that Apple is focusing on comes at these SteveNotes.

Even when they release a product that is half-done (e.g. the original iPhone; no MMS, no SDK, etc) they try to present it to the world as a complete and final product (i.e. "We don't need a SDK! You can make everything a webapp!"). It's little wonder that people get upset (i.e. With the original iPhone people were upset at the lack of a SDK and Apple/Steve trying to push the "all iPhone apps are webapps" angle didn't give people a solid clue that they would eventually release a SDK).

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by jcromartie on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:51PM (#1104603)
I hope it doesn't get application multitasking.

We know by now that multitasking is a myth. Yes, your computer can do it very well, but you are not a computer. You are a human being, and you can't really multitask (even if you tell me that you can, I won't believe you).

Now, iPhone OS is actually perfectly capable of multitasking, and it does run many processes in the background, but the one-application-at-a-time choice is a UI experiment. It is the idea that people can only do one thing at a time applied. There are certainly cases for leaving running applications in the background, but those are mostly limited to power-users.

As a developer I need to be running a shell and a text editor and a database server all at the same time, but anybody can stop watching a YouTube video to write an email.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by dagw on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:33PM (#1104735)
There a couple of tasks where multitasking makes a lot of sense for even non-power-users. The huge one being to play music in the background, either via my mp3 player or streaming via my webbrowser. The other one being skype and chat programs. Someone sends you a link on skype and you don't want to shut down your chat session to look at the page. Even if Apple won't go full multitasking, perhaps they will allow some sort of selective multitasking based on tasks where it makes sense.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by smokey_the_bear on Friday February 05, 2010 @05:25PM (#1105084)
Yeah, I would really like it if they'd let third party alarm clock apps relaunch themselves at the right time. Or if they'd just add playing music as an option to the built in alarm clock. It seems crazy that there's no way to do this but leave the phone in the alarm clock app, plugged in all night.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by scott_s on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:42PM (#1104759)
The iPhone already lets people listen to music while browsing the web. I don't know what it does during third-party apps.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by lukifer on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:11PM (#1104868)
Nope, doesn't keep playing for third-party apps (at least, for games, haven't tried it everywhere).
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:44PM (#1104983)
Correct. App Store apps (including Apple's own) are sent a signal when the user presses the Home button. They then have a small number of seconds to persist whatever state they need to. Some nice apps are like Tweetie: it saves (most of) the current state of the UI so that when you come back, they reopen right where they had been. Apparently iWork for iPad does the same.

Makes one wonder whether the Cocoa Touch frameworks could help with that some...

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by shade on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:19PM (#1104900)
You know, I have to disagree. Without application multitasking, the iPad won't even replace the laptop that stays in my living room -- sure, I mostly surf the web, but I'm also running (multi-protocol) IM and IRC all the time and I want them to stay connected in the background.

I do realize that there's always BeeJive for the IM portion of my requirements, but I always thought that keeping your connection alive through a proxy server was an ugly hack that was only necessary due to the limitations in iPhone OS. That and I dislike sharing my login credentials with a third party server.

I also have to say (as an iPhone owner) that I really kind of hate the app switching experience as it stands now. I want an instantaneous switch -- more or less like alt-tab on Linux or Windows -- and waiting for the springboard to reappear and then for whatever new app to load kind of gets on my nerves, especially if I'm trying to bounce between reading an e-book in Stanza or reading a web page and a slow-moving IM conversation. This is one reason why I'm ditching my iPhone 3G for a Nexus One as soon as they're available on Verizon. It's also why I find the Android tablets that are in development, like the MSI Harmony, much more appealing than the iPad: Android multitasks.

But I do also recognize I'm not the iPad's target market.

On a somewhat unrelated note, I suspect a lot of the iPad hate, particularly regarding no multitasking, isn't so much the idea of making a device that normal people can use so much as it is the idea that this is the sum total of the future of computing: specialized devices that uni-task, attempt to lock us into specific content providers, lock up our data in apps rather than letting us have free access to the file system, and so on. In other words -- it's not so much about what it currently is, but rather the potential future it represents. I think those fears are a bit overblown, but I definitely empathize with them. I'd hate having a computer that (for example) forced me to use iPhoto or Aperture or Lightroom or Picasa to manage my photos rather than just keeping them in a nicely organized file structure that I created.

But at any rate, I think there's room enough in computing for both approaches and I don't understand why various groups on both sides seem so anxious to strip those choices away from everyone else. Which is to say: I don't think anyone who is confused by a file system or windowed multitasking is a drooling idiot who shouldn't be allowed to use the Internet, but I also don't appreciate the simplicity advocates telling me that I should get over it because I don't need the ability to multi-task or be able to see multiple programs at once anyway. There's room for both approaches and I suspect there'll always be a need for both.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by chime on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:31PM (#1104726)
I am filling a web form on Safari/iPhone and I need to enter 3 emergency contact phone numbers (relative, friend1, friend2). I don't remember all the numbers but I have them in my phone's contact list. How can I do this on iPhone/iPad if it doesn't let me run two apps at once?
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by jcromartie on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:42PM (#1104760)
It seems like they could improve that case by selectively allowing objects to be transferred from one place to another. The Address Book API already allows apps to pop up a people picker and choose contact details from it. It's too bad Safari doesn't use this. A general solution would allow apps to advertise the data that they want make available between applications.

A developer is already working on something like this: http://infinite-labs.net/swapkit/

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:00PM (#1104838)
When you come back to Safari, the page will still be there, with form fields as they were. [Though if the device runs low on memory in the interim, it may send a low-memory warning signal to Safari, which causes it to dump the current states of your pages.]
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by flogic on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:00PM (#1104837)
We tried life without multitasking. It sucked. It turns out there are a number of cases where multitasking helps especially when networked. I guess you can makes special cases for Email, Twitter, Instant Messaging, and Music however it starts to seem silly.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by mcantelon on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:35PM (#1104952)
The need to preserving state alone necessitates multitasking. When you quit an app you lose your application state. Checking your email shouldn't require losing your application state.

Apart from preserving state, being able to do things like track where I'm going via GPS AND check my Tweets are things people benefit from.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:45PM (#1104988)
See my reply above. Apps get several seconds to save their state. But lots don't save the UI state.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by njharman on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:45PM (#1104989)
Multi-taksing is no myth. Maybe I can't multitask but while I'm doing something in the foreground I sure as hell want my computer to be multiasking the following in the background;

downloading something(s) in the background, checking on my alarms, grabbing new emails|tweets|im's|sms's|RSS, 5min back in time continuous video/audio record, looking up what I type and search ala Rememberance agent, streaming my GPS location (and one day heartrate, bloodpressure other vital stats) to my server, and many, many more things.

Quit being limited by your simple single task mind.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by GHFigs on Friday February 05, 2010 @06:20PM (#1105239)
You had a good point until you turned it into a personal attack.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by gamble on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:33PM (#1104548)
One can hope. The Apple TV is an obvious counter-example. Despite being on the market for nearly three years, Apple hardly updates it and has yet to add any truly compelling features like divx/xvid support or DVR functionality despite obvious demand.

The iPad may not suffer the same fate, if only because Apple seems more concerned about its success at the moment. I'll need to wait for iPhone OS 4.0 before making a call. Honestly, there's rarely been a modern Apple product that demanded waiting for the second generation more than the iPad.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by jdietrich on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:49PM (#1104597)
Maybe it's hindsight, but the Apple TV seems more like a peripheral than a platform - the Airport Express streams music and the Apple TV streams video. I don't think it was ever intended to be a big hit, but an Applishly elegant solution to a specific problem. Viewed from that perspective, it wasn't really a failure - they sold plenty of units and have many happy customers. The fanboys may be let down that it didn't revolutionise television, but I don't think Apple had any such aspirations for the device.

I think the same gap in expectations applies to the iPad - we were expecting a conventional tablet and Apple delivered something that was tailored to a smaller, more specific set of tasks. Although as geeks we naturally prefer devices with lots of functionality, Apple prefer to deliver something that does one thing well. My mind is naturally drawn back to the Slashdot thread on the iPod - people criticised the lack of features, but the iPod came to dominate the market because it did one thing better than anything else could.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by gamble on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:23PM (#1104918)
I think you've actually identified the key problem with the iPad - it doesn't do anything better than other devices.

In contrast, the iPod had the scroll wheel - an interface so superior to the alternatives at browsing large collections of music that every iPod since has stuck with it. Similarly, the iPhone had a killer feature - a mobile web browser that actually worked. Also, both products were polished versions of devices whose commercial viability had been established for decades.

The iPad lacks a selling point. It plays music, but it's too large to replace a portable music player. It doesn't support the codecs that 99% of the video files people view today are encoded with, and has a poor aspect ratio for watching 16:9 TV or movies. It has a fancy ebook reader application, but I'm betting that glossy LCD screen will be unreadable in direct sunlight. And it has a web browser that works well on a phone, but will probably feel very constraining on a full-size device.

It seems as if Apple believes the touch interface itself is the compelling feature that justifies the iPad, rather than anything you might do with it. I'm skeptical - touch-based computers have been disappointing marketeers for the last twenty years. They have a certain cachet, but other interfaces are less frustrating in practice. The iPhone is probably the best-case scenario for touch, and yet there's still a huge market for phones with a physical keyboard.

In short, I'm still waiting to see a reason why someone would buy an iPad over a task-specific device or a laptop. (Particularly for $500+ a pop) Nothing in iPhone OS 3.2 is compelling enough to sell to a mainstream audience, IMO. Of course, the iPod and iPhone had significant issues in their first iteration as well, but Apple addressed them in subsequent generations and they'll hopefully apply the same treatment to the iPad. The difference is that the iPad starts at a disadvantage so long as it launches without a killer application.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by GHFigs on Friday February 05, 2010 @07:17PM (#1105358)
You're making a common mistake by assuming that a person would buy an iPad (or anything) for one specific reason and that it must be the best possible option for that purpose. People don't actually work that way.

For instance, you say it doesn't replace a portable music player, but that is only going to dissuade people who are specifically looking to buy a portable music player that fits in their pocket, in which case Apple will gladly sell them one. To everyone else it is still a potentially positive feature.

Likewise for everything else. Each supposed failing only matters to a fraction of the potential audience, and then to a variable degree. The degree to which readability in direct sunlight matters to a person is a function of how much they intend to read in direct sunlight. I don't know about you, but most of my reading happens indoors, at night, by lamplight.

an interface so superior...every iPod since has stuck with it

Not true. The Shuffle and Touch models, along with the iPhone, have never had scroll wheel interfaces. The scroll wheel was an exclusive feature of the iPod, but it was not the singular force behind its success.

the iPhone had a killer feature - a mobile web browser that actually worked

The iPad has this same browser on a larger screen and with better performance. That alone is a fairly compelling feature for people who might otherwise buy a netbook primarily for web-browsing.

It doesn't support the codecs that 99% of the video files people view today are encoded with

Is there data to back up that claim? It seems a bit...exaggerated.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by gamble on Friday February 05, 2010 @08:36PM (#1105495)
99% is probably being charitable to Apple.

The iPad's limitations will only be known once people get their hands on them, but I think you can extrapolate from experience with the iPod Touch and Apple TV. All of Apple's devices are limited to MPEG4 in the mp4 container or h264 in mov, with strict limitations on resolution and bit rate. They don't support divx/xvid, avi, or mkv. Very, very few files are encoded under those restrictions unless they were created specifically for an Apple TV or iPod.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by GHFigs on Saturday February 06, 2010 @05:02PM (#1106749)
So, again, you don't actually have any data to back up that claim? Ok, that's my point. You're talking from your own experience with your video collection. That's fine, but you should understand that that may not always be a good indication of the demands of millions of other people. I strongly disagree with your estimation, but I likewise lack data, so I won't make any claims about percentages.

The iPad's limitations will only be known once people get their hands on them

The video codec support is listed on the tech specs page on Apple's site. A more exhaustive resource is Apple's developer site. This is not mysterious unknown information.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:46PM (#1104586)
> Eventually, it'll have a camera and multi-tasking

Maybe the camera, but the multi-tasking might not happen. The reason they don't allow multi-tasking on the iPhone is due to battery life issues (or so they claim). I would assume that they might leave multi-tasking out in order to deliver longer battery life to their customers (or else allow it only on apps that have been vetted for their power usage during the AppStore approval process).

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:03PM (#1104847)
And it helps allow them to not use a virtual memory swapfile. This makes performance much more constant and predictable. One of the things you don't see nearly as much of on iPhone OS is beachballs/hourglasses and random interface-freezing lag. This not only improves the experience, it makes it easier to use: lag that makes the UI unresponsive can be really confusing to users. "Why didn't my button click do anything this time?"
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @05:49PM (#1105149)
There was an old post on here with complains about memory constriction on the iPhone. One of the problems was not having a consistent amount of memory available to things like games. Sometimes there was enough memory to run the game, sometimes not. (Things like Safari are allowed to multi-task and eat up RAM outside of the currently running program)

[edit] I should add that another complaint was that the iPhone kills off processes that are using too much RAM (so if a game starts up and fills too much of the available RAM, it dies with no feedback to the user as to why this happened)

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by gamble on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:31PM (#1104940)
Obviously you aren't using an iPhone 3G. Unbelievable lag at times...
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:42PM (#1104979)
This is when an app is tied up doing something CPU-intensive. There's just plain no way around that one (though the app "should", when possible, be doing its work on another thread so that the UI stays responsive). If there were several more apps in the background all further tying up the CPU, it'd be way worse.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by gamble on Friday February 05, 2010 @05:14PM (#1105061)
My 3G is unresponsive regardless of what app is running or whether an app is using the CPU. Even the springboard locks up at times. It's the OS itself (or the 3G hardware, more likely) that's the problem.

Not saying that multitasking wouldn't make things worse, but don't give any props to iPhone OS for avoiding delays. OS 3.0 is embarrassingly laggy on the 3G.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by ynniv on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:33PM (#1104547)
I would be even more critical of the HN crowd nay-saying the device. Its too soon to tell, but I think that Apple may have made Something That People Want. To say that it sucks because the highly specialized group people that we belong to thinks that it is "wrong" is to miss the point of entrepreneurship entirely. And really, any time that you say "I won't use one... but I might get one for my Mom" should set off The Bells And Whistles On High.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by abstractbill on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:45PM (#1104585)
And really, any time that you say "I won't use one... but I might get one for my Mom" should set off The Bells And Whistles On High.

I think that's a little unfair. I would characterize most of the negative responses I've seen on HN as more like "I won't use one... if it had a camera at least I could get one for my Mom to use Skype on... maybe rev 2 will be better".

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by TrevorJ on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:34PM (#1104738)
I guess I don't see the need to pay 400 bucks for a piece of 'beta' hardware.

I do see your point, and you are right, I think it will get better in V 2.0, but it's expensive and it is hardware so I think the example only goes so far.