News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Pxtl on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:33AM (#10973276)
The article identifies the problem, but the conclusion appears to be that we should win the race to the bottom by going straight down. If the USA adopts Ireland's tax code, what happens when another country goes even lower?
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Hermel on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:08AM (#10973414)
Another solution is to move from taxing profits to taxing consumption, i.e. through VAT, and then enforce it even for virtual services. That way, Apple's US tax would for example be proportional its US sales, which sounds fair.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by jcfrei on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:55AM (#10973621)
VAT is one of the worst possible solutions. The ones who carry most of the tax burden are usually the consumers, through higher prices (though it depends on the nature of the good). VAT is one of the most discriminating taxes out there, where the poor pay relatively speaking much more tax than the rich - because consumption doesn't increase linearly with wealth.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by matt4077 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:43AM (#10973567)
VAT is, unfortunately, a flat tax. Moving to a VAT-only system without any offsets would be the biggest redistribution of wealth (upwards) since the Bush tax cuts.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:15AM (#10973754)
VAT isn't flat. Since it does not apply to monetary instruments, a VAT is regressive.

I still think that VAT with offsets is the best taxation form available (and universal income the best offset form). But it alone is disastrous.

And, while we are at it, make sure the VAT is really a VAT, not a sale-value tax. Because it usually is, and it's the one tax form worse than a VAT.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Retric on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:43AM (#10973564)
That pushes people to buy goods and services overseas. AKA, why buy a US yacht and pay an extra 20%.

The real solution IMO is to tax US companies for world wide profits and have punitive taxes on foreign companies to keep US companies from pretending to move offshore.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by ryandrake on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:51AM (#10973607)
If I as a US Citizen were to work overseas, I would owe US tax on the wages I make outside the country. Why doesn't the same logic apply for a company that makes profits overseas? This is a rhetorical question, obviously, we all know why the system is stacked in favor of corporations.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:15AM (#10973750)
I am a US citizen who works overseas. You get to deduct your foreign tax obligations on your US tax returns (if you don't go for the standard foreign income earned deduction). Oh, well, some "taxes" aren't really taxes in the US sense, like taxes on health insurance, or what about social security contributions? And then there are weird situations where a US citizen goes on a business trip in the US and is on the hook for both Chinese and US taxes.

Believe me, US citizens working abroad and US companies doing business abroad suffer through similar pain when it comes time to file tax returns. Resolving differences in two completely different systems is very hard.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:12AM (#10973732)
You mean close the economy to foreign companies ala North Korea? I'm not sure that is a nice way to go, definitely not WTO friendly.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Retric on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:17AM (#10973764)
No, more like disqualify them for specific tax breaks, or slightly increase there tax rate ~1-5%. Don't forget China for example is very hard on foreign corporations, yet they are generally happy to jump though hoops for such a large market.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:23AM (#10973807)
Yes, they are, being a US citizen working in China I know that very personally. So if the US goes the China approach, we only welcome foreign companies that we can screw something from, like IP or expertise, and block the rest out (foreign social networking websites? create a great firewall).

The US benefits GREATLY from its open market while China's semi closed market in turn hurts it a lot. Ya, foreign companies still operate there, but only with an expectation that it will open in the future, not given today's situation!

Having a different tax rate for foreign companies would basically destroy the WTO, all those treaties that benefit the USA in lopsided ways go away, and we will just lose a lot of wealth in one swoop. All the other countries will retaliate of course, taking a significant chunk of global GDP that relates to trade down, almost probably causing a few wars and such.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Retric on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:29AM (#10973842)
Your vastly overstating things. All countries including the US already favor local industry's. Just look at the taxes on sugar.

PS: In a wider context, the benefits of free trade are overstated. Not all industries have equal long term benefits even if the short term looks great. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphate_mining_in_Nauru

The problem of Nauru presents a paradox. The striking contrast is between a superficially happy state of affairs and an uncertain and indeed alarming future... But this picture of peace and well-being and security is deceptive. Indeed it is a false paradise. For these gentle people are dominated by the knowledge that the present happy state of affairs cannot continue. (1962)

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:05AM (#10974071)
The benefits of free trade are of course lopsided in the USA's favor. But the whole world gets a boost anyways, especially Nauru who can't produce much locally. If America was left to its own market, there would be no Boeing or Silicon Valley to speak of.

Ya, we could go back to local production, isn't that what North Korean juche is all about?

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by morgante on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:56AM (#10974013)
> Apple's US tax would for example be proportional its US sales, which sounds fair.

Apple's US tax already is proportional to its US sales. The major strategy that it and other US tech companies use is keeping overseas profits off-shore, not avoiding taxes on US sales.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Spooky23 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:29AM (#10973503)
Personally, I don't think the income tax for corporate entities makes sense. The scale and complexity of these organizations makes compliance and enforcement ridiculously expensive and unfair.

Most famously, General Electric has hundreds or low thousands of IRS employees on-site performing audit functions continuously. It's a waste of everyone's time.

IMO, it makes more sense to apply excise taxes, consumption taxes or taxes on corporate treasury balances. Or not to tax them at all.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by someguydave on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:04AM (#10973685)
> Or not to tax them at all.

Agreed. I challenge anyone who complained that Congress should not have 'default' back in 2013 (in other words, continue to issue debt forever) to explain why the tax rate ought to be nonzero? I mean, if people continue to purchase Federal bonds, why tax corporations (or anyone)?

If you want to tax people and corporations to 'reduce inequality', consider your position on fairness...

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by wavefunction on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:25AM (#10973819)
Because corporations use _and require_ a disproportionate amount of government regulatory protection/oversight and bureaucracy, as well as government spending.

For example, our navy is mighty and far-flung across the globe, and it's not because we're proud of our maritime traditions but because the force of the US Navy ensures stability for commerce.

The average American benefits to a small degree from this international commerce, but the corporations (and by extension the wealthy who own the corporations) benefit far more. This is why we have progressive taxation schemes where the wealthy pay more, at more levels. Or they're supposed to, at least.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:12AM (#10974119)
If this is true, lets just levy an international shipping tax on goods shipped under the protection of the US Navy. Anyone who doesn't pay their (purely voluntary) Navy tax will also be left to the pirates if that situation arises.

This tax will then be added to the cost of shipped goods.

If the wealthy are actually the people consuming those shipped goods, then they will in fact be the ones to pay. If you are wrong, and the primary beneficiaries of international trade are actually middle class consumers, then middle class consumers will pay.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Spooky23 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @12:59PM (#10974757)
The military cannot be a transactional service, no more than the justice system can be. It's in our national interest to be protected against the aggression of other nation states.

My original point was that we have a system today where a significant portion of the economy is devoted to calculating taxes. I'm not saying don't tax corporations. I'm saying tax corporations on a basis that can be enforced in a reasonable way.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by someguydave on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:51PM (#10978292)
Indeed, in general it strikes me as a good principle to align risk with benefit (skin in the game).
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by Spooky23 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @12:54PM (#10974729)
I don't really care about equality in this context. That's a different problem for a different day.

I do care about the overall integrity of the system. The notion that my uncle's carwash probably pays more in income tax than General Electric undermines the integrity of the system as a whole.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rorykoehler on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:02AM (#10973674)
If the USA adopted Ireland's tax code then companies would have to pay 12.5% on trading income. The reason Ireland is a good place for American companies is because of a loophole called the Double Irish. Basically Irish based companies pay tax where they are originally registered and in Delaware the code stipulates that taxes get paid where the revenue was generated. That means the US expects the companies to pay the tax in Ireland and the Irish expect the companies to pay the tax in the US. Therefore the potential tax payment ends up in no-mans land and never gets paid whilst remaining all perfectly legal.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by s_dev on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:05AM (#10973696)
Double Irish is virtually finished -- your information is outdated. Only a select number of companies can avail of it that had already done so and it's being phased out and will be completely gone by 2020.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rorykoehler on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:23AM (#10973805)
It is what brought all the big tech companies to Ireland in the first place but yes it is being phased out. The latest seems to be another loophole where companies register a subsidiary as tax resident in an actual 0% tax haven and then pay royalties to said subsidiary. This gives them zero profit and therefore zero taxable income but there is very little Ireland can do about without shooting itself in the foot (such as taxing revenue and ensuring Apple et al close up shop and take their business elsewhere).

If they decide to be tax resident in Ireland the 12.5% corporation tax is hardly a 'tax haven' but it's still better than most. Another big draw is the amount of money the Irish government puts up to attract FDI through their Industrial Development Authority (IDA).

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by austerity on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:53AM (#10973349)
At some point other factors like ease of contract enforcement, infrastructure, etc. become more important than shaving off a few more percents from the taxes. So in the end it boils down to which government is able to provide better services for your buck which is how it should be.

If only physical persons could relocate to a better place with the same ease corporations do now the governments would suck so much less.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rayiner on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:27AM (#10973499)
That creates a really significant free-rider problem. In your hypothetical, companies have a strong incentive to start in countries that have strong infrastructure and services (safety nets to reduce risk for founders and early employees, higher-education to ensure a supply of educated workers, etc), then move to a low-tax jurisdiction once they are successful.

Imagine if investors in startups couldn't take equity, but were limited to taking a percentage of current profits. That would create a huge disincentive to be an early-stage investor, and a huge incentive to be an investor that could come in with the cheapest rates at the last round of investment for a company that already had established growth and revenues.

In the alternate, consider the hypothetical of tax rate auctions at the time of birth. I.e. what tax rate would people bid in order to be born and try to become successful in the U.S. instead of somewhere else?

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:34AM (#10973869)
It doesn't create much of a free rider problem at all, actually. Most tax money is spent on wealth transfers to old people (and non-workers to a lesser extent) and the DoD. These are not particularly useful for startups.

If a company headquartered in Singapore makes use of US labor (and implicitly our effective, but extremely overpriced schools), it pays a fair rate of taxation on it. It simply doesn't have to pay taxes to the US on profits from selling goods manufactured in the Philippines to citizens of Japan.

That's ultimately the reason for moving corporate registration overseas, and that's the reason my next corporation will probably be headquartered in Singapore. Global taxation is insane; it's taxing US corporations for services that other governments have already provided and taxed them for.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rayiner on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:37AM (#10973893)
If you had to roll the cosmic dice again, would you rather be born in Singapore or the United States?
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:45AM (#10973945)
The US is obviously a better place to grow up, since I avoided 2 years of slavery and the risk of execution for selling drugs. I also don't like malls very much and I'm vegetarian, so obviously Singapore won't be my favorite place to live.

What do these (non-economic benefits) have to do with efficient corporate tax rates or your claims about freeloading?

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rayiner on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:10AM (#10974110)
The value of growing up in the U.S. (or starting a business here) isn't measured by the economic value of services you receive directly. Most of the value is in the social order cultivated by the country's people and institutions. Even things like liberal social attitudes create value--you likely couldn't have started Facebook in a country that expects half the population to veil their faces. Forget about Tindr.

Indeed, even those wealth transfers to old people create economic value. Those wealth transfers still exist in countries without Social Security--they just happen "off the books" through familial relationships. And that has a lot of downside. The burden of caring for elderly parents disincentivizes young people from taking career risks and limits geographic mobility. Not to mention: try creating Tindr in a society where everyone lives with their elderly parents.

Being born in the U.S. (or Germany or a handful of other countries), has an enormous impact on your lifetime income, keeping everything else constant. That has intrinsic value.

Creating social order costs money. Benefiting from that social order up through the point you're successful, then taking that success--which society has invested in--to the lowest bidder tax jurisdiction is freeloading. That's why I presented the hypothetical about people bidding on tax rates at birth. Choice is fine and competition between countries is fine, but letting people and capital move freely after they've found out how everything turns out does not incentivize countries to create the conditions that maximize prosperity and opportunity. It incentivizes countries to poach successful people (and companies) from other places, after another country has put in the initial investment and taken the initial risk.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by yummyfajitas on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:25AM (#10974175)
There is so much wrong with this comment that I don't even know where to start.

First, most of the benefits you describe (e.g., ample vegetarian food in NYC, very little in Singapore) are not paid for with taxes or provided by the government. The fact that the US govt happens to be the strongest bandit in a region where hookups are easy is not a justification for giving them profits earned by manufacturing goods in Bangladesh and selling them in Malaysia.

Second, if growing up/being born under the US/German social order were actually important, then there is a very easy way to measure it. Take people born outside this order but give them permission to work in global markets and compare their income to natives. Indian and Chinese immigrants tend to outperform Americans, which pretty much solidly refutes this claim.

Third, you seem to be conflating the purchase of services with equity investments. All your critiques of freeloading should apply equally if I build V1 of my software on AWS but switch to Softlayer for V2.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by rayiner on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @01:53PM (#10975120)
> The fact that the US govt happens to be the strongest bandit in a region where hookups are easy

The U.S. government, and the American public on behalf of who it spends tax money, did not just come along and take over an existing liberal productive society. It created that society. That society wouldn't exist without it.

> Second, if growing up/being born under the US/German social order were actually important, then there is a very easy way to measure it. Take people born outside this order but give them permission to work in global markets and compare their income to natives. Indian and Chinese immigrants tend to outperform Americans, which pretty much solidly refutes this claim.

The U.S. immigration system, by design, is very selective about which Indians and Chinese it allows to emigrate. Their performance says nothing about the value of growing up in the U.S. Besides that, your argument proves the opposite of your intended point. If there is no value to the U.S. besides the economic value of the government services people receive, why would the best and brightest from India and China struggle to come here to start their careers? Is it because of our fantastic public transit?

> Third, you seem to be conflating the purchase of services with equity investments. All your critiques of freeloading should apply equally if I build V1 of my software on AWS but switch to Softlayer for V2.

Amazon will charge you $X for AWS whether or not your product ever generates any revenue. The U.S. government's investment into education, infrastructure, and the social safety net will be there for you whether or not you succeed. It's much more like an equity investment than a simple exchange of services for money.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by meanduck on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:36AM (#10973883)
(Not OP)

> In your hypothetical, companies have a strong incentive to start in countries that have strong infrastructure and services (safety nets to reduce risk for founders and early employees, higher-education to ensure a supply of educated workers, etc), then move to a low-tax jurisdiction once they are successful.

In this hypothetical, governement will know that a company will migrate away once it find a better one. This will be reflected in how gov't will charge. It will probably mean the end to "% of income" based taxes instead fixed taxes.

Think of government as a corporation providing some services because that what it will be once movement and /citizenship/ becomes easy. The people who stay (i.e. actual citizens) will play the role of shareholders and (hopefully) will be more critical of their goverment.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by austerity on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:05AM (#10973694)
While that's true, holding everyone by force is the most primitive and inefficient (in terms of common good) solution I can think of. For example, the safety net is in fact an early stage investment so it would be logical if the government providing the safety net would take equity in exchange. In fact that's one of the reasons why safety nets aren't such a good idea. The government essentially becomes an angel fund that funds every single idea no matter how dumb. Can't imagine this bringing about an optimal outcome.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by cuckcuckspruce on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:06AM (#10973405)
>If only physical persons could relocate to a better place with the same ease corporations do now the governments would suck so much less.

If physical persons could relocate to a different country with the same ease as corporations then the instability of their tax bases combined with the difficulty of ensuring compliance with their taxing regime might very well spell the end of nation states.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by wrong_variable on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:09AM (#10973416)
Global GDP would double if labour was allowed the same freedom of movement as capital.

But the human condition is such that I do not think it's not going to happen anytime soon :(

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:22AM (#10973477)
>Global GDP would double if labour was allowed the same freedom of movement as capital.

Really? And would global average wages double, or would the profit margins on ever-cheaper labor do all the growing?

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by wrong_variable on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:24AM (#10973488)
Assuming inequality is constant - then yes. Your purchasing power would double, you could afford twice as much food, apple would produce twice as many ipads, etc.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:41AM (#10973557)
>Assuming inequality is constant - then yes.

Variables rarely remain constant in the real world in the way that they do in ceteris paribus thought-experiments.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by jcfrei on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:04AM (#10973689)
Removing restrictions on immigration aren't a silver bullet. The opening of labor markets in the EU has caused much lower social mobility than previously expected (ie. many Greeks stayed in Greece even though they could get much better jobs in Germany).
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by austerity on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:19AM (#10973782)
Is there anything I can read up on this? I hear the population of Baltics halved, sounds like a rather drastic effect.

Although I didn't imply immigration restrictions are the only problem either- indeed the language and other cultural barriers as well as our tendency to form bonds that are painful to break all work against mobility.

Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by jcfrei on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @08:22AM (#10979870)
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by malchow on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:12AM (#10973734)
It isn't a race to the bottom. The U.S. can have a 0% business tax rate and still have plenty of tax receipts.
Re:A Tidal Wave of Corporate Migrants Seeking (Tax) Shelter by lukasm on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:01AM (#10973672)
reduce corporate tax by half and introduce revenue tax of 0.5% ?