News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by mynewtb on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:05PM (#10963546)
The movie left me so disgusted as its message was that torture works.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:37PM (#10963923)
If you watch almost any superhero show, even the ones that are explicitly for children, you'll see that a huge amount of "investigation" into crimes is done by threatening to kill criminals and often by torturing them. Look at Batman.

The idea that torture works is bedrock in the entertainment world, partially because it's a narrative shortcut and shows how far the "hero" is willing to go.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by colordrops on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:07PM (#10964714)
Even worse is the message towards the end of Dark Knight, where Robin throws his badge in the water, claiming that the system and law enforcement don't work, and the only option is their secretive extra-legal vigilantism. Sounds like an excuse for all the extralegal methods various agencies have been using in the supposed fight against terrorism.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by acqq on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:42PM (#10964864)
> sounds like an excuse for all the extralegal methods various agencies have been using

...and even for complete extremism, like pure terrorism.

Still, it's also true that the premise "the system and law enforcement don't work" is really the basis of all superhero narratives. That's how the need for the superheros is justified.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rhizome on Sunday January 24, 2016 @09:40PM (#10965273)
Is your idea that people in the agencies are justifying things because they saw them in a movie once?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:45PM (#10965442)
S/he was saying that the agencies and the fictional superheroes are using the same rationalization: that legal methods don't work, and a bunch of "good guys" need to use extralegal measures. And, to take that to its extreme, any method is acceptable as long as it's a "good guy" using it against a "bad guy".

Unfortunately, in real life, "good" and "bad" aren't possible to define, nor are they absolute characteristics.

GP was just drawing the parallel, not implying a real connection.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by OvidNaso on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:19AM (#10965723)
Check out the documentary 0.Casino Jack and the United Stats of Money read up on jack Abramoff. It certainly appears that he was living in a fantasy world created from pulp cold war fiction novels and he was not alone.

[0] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1540814/?ref_=nm_flmg_slf_6

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chillingeffect on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:24PM (#10965554)
It's even more insidious than that. Some people in positions of power are compelled to imitate socially-acceptable behavior as defined by popular media to the point where it requires active resistance to oppose the act of torture. See for example "Normative Social Influence"[1] and "Moral Conviction and Resistance to Social Influence" [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normative_social_influence [2] https://www.uic.edu/labs/skitka/public_html/OppTorture.pdf

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jessaustin on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:03AM (#10965676)
It's like I always say: the system has been exposed to good people before. It knows what to do with them.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by voltagex_ on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:24PM (#10965388)
I remember reading http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2008/nov/24/torture..., I hope it's exaggerated.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by hartpuff on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:41AM (#10965787)
From that article:

>"People [in Guantanamo] had already seen the first series, it was hugely popular." Others who were at Guantánamo at the time confirmed her account. Some described to me how the series contributed directly to an environment encouraging those in the interrogation facility to see themselves as being on the front line, and to go further than they otherwise might have

So torturers at Guantanamo had to get lessons on torture from a TV series which, prior to Season 4, was basically torture-free and pro-Muslim?

From Season 4, 24 was fascistic, pro-torture garbage, but it was taking its cue from real life US policy, not directing it.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by cturner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @08:41PM (#10965086)
I don't think this was always true. Torture used to be taboo in entertainment. I think that changed after September 11 - you started to see it used extensively by supposed 'good guys'. I remember noting this when the show 24 was coming through - it broke that rule and polite society seemed to have been disarmed to it. And now it's everywhere and we're the poorer for it.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @09:37PM (#10965266)
I guess I was talking about torture in a broader sense.

Yes, in 24 and Zero Dark Thirty it's realistic -- a state military or intelligence agency using torture in a prescribed way. They would actually have received training about effective techniques for torturing people, which is pretty chilling in and of itself.

But you can also watch the 90s Batman cartoon, where Batman holds criminals off of roofs to get them to talk, or the X-men cartoon where Wolverine puts his claws up to someone's chin. It's not strictly "torture", but using fear (of death) to make someone talk is similar to using pain. The person will do whatever is required to end it, whether that involves being truthful or not.

Even worse, you have scenes where James Bond (or some hero) is tortured and doesn't talk. It creates the idea that someone who talks when being tortured is a traitor or is somehow weak. In reality, it's really rare to be able to withstand torture, and the US Dept of Defense doesn't even consider soldiers to have failed their country if they talk.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by gaius on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:30PM (#10963656)
And 24. Someone is clearly running an orchestrated campaign to convince the public torture works...
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rayiner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:59PM (#10963777)
That torture works is a reflexive movie/TV trope that goes back long before the recent CIA programs. More generally, the attitude in Hollywood is that prisoners rights, procedural protections, etc, are just technical impediments that get in the way of law enforcement doing their jobs and saving lives.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jordanb on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:34PM (#10963905)
When Dirty Harry came out, Roger Ebert called it a fascist film: the rogue cop out violating people's rights and murdering members of the public was the hero and the courts, defense lawyers, etc were villains trying to stop him from "getting the bad guy."

But Dirty Harry became an archetype in American film. Now there are hundreds of films with the protagonist being a "tough guy cop" who "doesn't play by the book." It's no wonder how our society has become what it is.

Here's Ebert's review: http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/dirty-harry-1971

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rayiner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:37PM (#10963921)
My wife and I like to watch shows like Blacklist and White Collar. There are casual 4th amendment violations several times per episode. It's infuriating.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by dtornabene on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:33PM (#10964125)
So glad to hear this. I often wonder how much people with training pick up on things like this, and if they do what their response is. My parents watch Blacklist, I usually watch it with them, rationalizing it as "but James Spader...". And to be fair, the what, three dozen, federal-leo/police procedurals are even worse on things like 4th amendment violations and just general ethical compromises.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by voltagex_ on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:30PM (#10965403)
It's a TV show. Does it really have that much impact on day-to-day life?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by krapp on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:37PM (#10965425)
The CSI Effect is a thing[0], so it is possible.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CSI_effect

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by dtornabene on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:26PM (#10984779)
Wow, I didn't even know that was a thing. Thanks for taking the time to post that.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by voltagex_ on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:43PM (#10965434)
Thanks for that. Interesting and concerning.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by anonbanker on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:44PM (#10964623)
I know you're not a minority in this, but why do people like to watch shows that make them angry?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rayiner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:09PM (#10964720)
It's easy enough to turn off that part of your brain to watch what is otherwise an entertaining show.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jMyles on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:42PM (#10965609)
Is it really though? Or do you just think it's "turned off" while you're watching?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rayiner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:57PM (#10965657)
I mean, I also think television writers are misogynist and so over-sexed they can't depict normal relationships between men and women on TV. But somehow I manage to watch HIMYM or Friends without raging.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by anonbanker on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:48PM (#10969830)
yeah, I don't know how you do it. In that same situation, I'm actively contemplating the dead people in the laugh track to distract myself from the insulting of my intelligence.

You should consider that skill to suffer fools a superpower.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by JetSpiegel on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:01PM (#10964688)
And yet, Dirty Harry has the DA rejecting some evidence he collected on the basis is wasn't lawfully acquired. Have yet to see that in a modern procedural.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday January 24, 2016 @05:04PM (#10964247)
Dirty Harry's influence indentifiably extends beyond film, too. Castle doctrine laws (allowing the use of lethal force against home invaders) in some states used to be colloquially known as "make my day" laws, after an iconic line in one of the sequels. In context, the line heavily implies that Harry is motivated not by a desire to protect people from criminals, but by a desire to kill criminals.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by dtornabene on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:46PM (#10964172)
fwiw the Death Wish series with Charles Bronson was soooooooo much worse.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by mhurron on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:06PM (#10964473)
Except that Bronson's character wasn't a cop.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by dtornabene on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:43PM (#10964615)
Right, the cops just let him do it.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by refurb on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:21PM (#10963855)
That's actually a great point. Thinking back to all of the TV shows and movies about crime, it is a very common theme to have a character get off on a technicality or have the police complain "we know this guys guilty, but we just can't get the evidence".

This goes far beyond what the CIA is influencing. It's just a common theme in crime dramas.

What's the last major motion picture where the focus was on the importance of the rights of people accused of crimes? I can't think of many and the ones I can think of are the documentaries about actual cases of abuse.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by toomanybeersies on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:05PM (#10964700)
It's part of the trope/archetype of the infallible hero.

They don't need checks and balances, because they're always right. How many movies are there where the hero tortures completely the wrong person?

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by nitrogen on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:51PM (#10963969)
I watched one or two seasons of 24. It was a lot more entertaining after I started thinking of Jack Bauer as the bad guy.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rpgmaker on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:51PM (#10964193)
I can't stand 24, the script is so transparently cheap. It's just one little plot device looped over and over and over each episode. I couldn't stomach more than two seasons.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by hoorayimhelping on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:52PM (#10963741)
I think clearly might be a little strong. It's not a very hard stretch of the imagination to believe that two separate groups of writers and/or producers think torture is effective.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by steveax on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:09PM (#10963808)
Don't forget Homeland, brought to you by the same folks.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by newman314 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:25PM (#10963868)
That movie and American Sniper were pretty blatant attempts.

I'm okay with say Die Hard as that's entertainment but these go far beyond with the veneer of "truth"

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rpgmaker on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:55PM (#10964207)
I do agree that they essentially endorsed torture but to me ZDT was just boring period. Ironically, the most entertaining/interesting part of the movie were the first 30 minutes when they dealt with torture, it's downhill from there. American Sniper is more entertaining, at least.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by samstave on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:13PM (#10963577)
We call that propaganda round these parts!

---

Seriously though, the disgusting narrative over the last 16 years has left me completely numb and disenfranchised from the idea of justice in the US.

There is just a mountain of evidence that we are living in the police-state side of an Empircal Oligarchy in the US.

The Oligarchs experience unfettered financial, political and legal freedom -- whilst their position is protected and enforced by the police-state-complex that punishes the poor or the questioning.

/cynicism

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by eternalban on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:20PM (#10964060)
Why sign off with cynical? I came to this country a few decades ago and it was nothing like this.

We are witnessing social engineering in action. It has been quite effective.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by cryoshon on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:54PM (#10963751)
Yeah, but the proles don't believe it yet because they've been propagandized since birth that the US can do no wrong. The propaganda is starting to seem a bit hollow for a few too many people, though.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by finid on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:32PM (#10963892)
That your comment and @cryoshon were down-voted shows how some of us feel about these things

The CIA and others like it, like our elected officials, is a reflection of who we are. They are a mirror.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by hueving on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:39PM (#10964145)
Yes, it shows that some of us think it's the same old melodramatic junk that is so over the top that it drowns out any actual reason.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by samstave on Monday January 25, 2016 @01:53AM (#10965971)
Refute my reason then, will you.

I have DECADES of knowledge on this subject. I swear I can refute anything you could possibly espouse.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by nitrogen on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:56PM (#10963981)
They are a mirror.

Maybe, if mirrors could reach back out and change what they are reflecting. Like a fun house mirror.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chroma on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:12PM (#10964027)
I didn't downvote them, but I find both comments lacking in substance. We live in a police state? There's an Empircal(sic?) Oligarchy? Americans are indoctrinated from birth? These statements seem completely disconnected from reality. If they were backed-up with some evidence or arguments, I'd be less dismissive.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by samstave on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:43PM (#10965615)
I will provide a detailed and backed up comment - but may I ask how old you are?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jevgeni on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:54AM (#10965815)
Real mature, Sam. And since the personality of the commenter matters all of a sudden, then tell me, have you ever lived outside of the U.S.? Because you must be incredibly sheltered and never really encountered the things you accuse the U.S. of, if you think that the country is an oligarchy or a police state.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by samstave on Monday January 25, 2016 @01:59AM (#10965984)
Apologies if you think me asking for world-view-context via the GPs age was immature...

Their personality is of no matter - I asked their age just to see where they were coming from, its a fair question.

While I have not lived outside the US, I have followed the intelligence apparatus for many years; My brother, a general in the Air force, who was personal doctor the the joint chiefs of staff as their flight surgeon, as well as me who was personal IT handler for the head of DHS... and a long time person in IT in SV... I dont fuck around with my credibility

This country is fucked. The whole system is fucked.

Do I really need to spell it out for you? If you want to say it is NOT fucked -- then please enlighten me!!! PLEASE

I need some hope - but other than what I see what is going on -- THERE IS NONE

So, give me some, please.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jevgeni on Thursday January 28, 2016 @04:34AM (#10987277)
U.S. has the 10th biggest GDP per capita in the world. People express their opinion and don't get shot, stabbed, or poisoned for it. There is no war. Your politicians may be corrupt, but not to the point where they shit in gold plated toilets[1] or have their own palaces[2].

Your main problems are income and social inequality. And your tax code.

There are people literally risking their lives so that their children could have a life comparable to yours.

Oh boohoo. Get your shit together.

___

[1] - http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/23/world/europe/dazed-ukraini...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putin%27s_Palace

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by InclinedPlane on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:29PM (#10964102)
Sadly this is a very common message in popular culture. In a race to be "gritty and realistic" there are so many cop and military shows where torture is used by the "good guys" in service to the plot, with positive results. It's a shame how willingly and unthinkingly hollywood puts forth this torture propaganda, most of the time of their own volition.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by touristtam on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:59PM (#10964225)
I am pretty sure that is due to the medium and the target audience. We, in the west, have had a Manichean view of the world for quite a long time. No wonder Hollywood is reusing this common and almost confortable view of the world.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by InclinedPlane on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:13AM (#10966146)
It's more than that. There's a deep-seated idea of the virtue of retributive violence. There is the idea of not just the value of vengeance but the rightness and necessity of it, and this is thoroughly involved in popular culture and the entire criminal justice system. This is the reason why people believe in the value of torture and why people laugh about the idea of sexual assault in prisons (because "bad guys" deserve to be hurt, even brutalized). It's the reason why we're ok with medieval conditions in our prison system even as those individuals end up back in society (because in so far as prison is hellish that makes it an even more effective punishment for wrong-doing). And so on. It's an incredibly barbaric value system which seems to be changing incredibly slowly.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by wmeredith on Sunday January 24, 2016 @08:32PM (#10965046)
Wait am I dumb? The tip that led to Bin laden in the movie had nothing to do with interrogation program, right?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chrisbennet on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:00PM (#10965325)
A Pakistani intelligence guy tipped the US off for the reward. Neither torture nor diligent work by NSA or CIA was responsible for locating Bin Laden. That wouldn't make a very good movie though.

From Wikipedia: In August 2010, a former Pakistani intelligence officer approached the U.S. embassy station chief in Islamabad and offered to provide Bin Laden's location, in return for the $25 million reward, according to a retired senior U.S. intelligence official.[17] This story was corroborated by two U.S. intelligence officials speaking to NBC news, and had been previously reported by intelligence analyst Raelynn Hillhouse.[18][19] The Pakistani official informed U.S. intelligence that Bin Laden had been located by Pakistani ISI in 2006, and held under house arrest near Pakistani intelligence and military centers ever since. The official passed polygraph tests, after which the U.S. began local and satellite surveillance of Bin Laden's Abbottabad residence.[17]

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rmc on Monday January 25, 2016 @06:34AM (#10966606)
The US also set up a vaccination centre that collected and analyzed DNA of people they vaccinationed in order to confirm that Bin Laden's family (and hence Bin Laden himself) were in there.

The downside of this is clear, "Foreign vaccination centres are really CIA spying stations!" is now no longer a conspiracy theory, but something that actually happened.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chrisbennet on Monday January 25, 2016 @06:42AM (#10966634)
I wonder if that little project will (by making people avoid vaccines) eventually kill more innocents than the drone program?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by kiba on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:15PM (#10963835)
It feels intuitive that torture works.

Even I think that, even though with sufficient amount of torture, you can get a guy to say anything you want to hear.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by acdha on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:11PM (#10964503)
When people say “torture doesn't work” it's usually meant to counter the way the U.S. used it in an attempt to get valuable secrets, almost always in a time sensitive context. It's pretty widely agreed that, given time and monstrous creativity, torture works for things like getting false confessions because we have examples of the public false confessions the North Vietnamese, USSR, etc. forced people to make or the many false stories the CIA tortured out of people like bin Laden's driver.

What's contentious is the idea that you can get someone dedicated to reveal a secret before their friends notice their absence and change the secrets. The classic movie plot is something like a bomb disarm code but that's a [fortunately] rare situation and likely futile when e.g. a dedicated extremist who knows they only have to hold out for a short period of time.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by api on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:45PM (#10963946)
... which is valuable if you want "intelligence" to launch the next war.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chroma on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:44PM (#10964162)
OK, what is the implication here? That a cabal of government officials would deliberately start a war under false pretenses, costing trillions of dollars and thousands of their own countrymen's lives... for what? Profit? They could rake in far more by tacking a couple riders on popular bills.

It's unwise to caricature your opponents as evil or stupid. Not only is it an impediment to understanding them, but it makes any sort of dialogue impossible.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by CamperBob2 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @05:27PM (#10964344)
I assume this is the dryest sarcasm this side of a Martian sand dune.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by thephyber on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:11AM (#10994114)
What if it's not for "profit", but for the perceived long-term national security interest of the US? The kind of "national security" which doesn't directly protect us from attack, but rather prevents us from having to fight future wars when the nation is energy-starved.

Consider this video featuring Retired General Wesley Clark talking about plans in the Pentagon (circa 2001) to regime change 7 Middle Eastern countries in 5 years.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RC1Mepk_Sw

Assuming there is any truth to this claim (and I'm suspicious because we can't independently verify the claims), the implication is that the US military investigated and drew up plans to free the countries and make their oil available to western nations in order to fuel future economic growth (I'm taking liberties and drawing inference from previous US intervention in Middle Eastern foreign policy). It's not "profit", but it's the long term "security" (which can be extremely subjective) of the US.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by api on Sunday January 24, 2016 @05:11PM (#10964276)
So given that torture is objectively not reliable for obtaining truthful evidence, what is a good non evil non stupid explanation?

I consider torture itself evil under all but the most extreme and rare ticking time bomb scenarios. Little to none of the enhanced interrogation stuff I've read about fits into that category. So that leaves the question of whether the motives are also evil or just stupid.

Doing something that you know doesn't work on the theory it will intimidate is stupid, especially with an enemy that comes from an honor culture that relishes conflict and values martyrdom. Failing to evaluate your techniques for actual success rate is stupid. And so on...

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jMyles on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:44PM (#10965620)
> That a cabal of government officials would deliberately start a war under false pretenses, costing trillions of dollars and thousands of their own countrymen's lives... for what? Profit?

....yyyes? precisely that?

Or are you being super sarcastic? Or something?

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by MaysonL on Sunday January 24, 2016 @05:56PM (#10964439)
So for what reason did they?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by JabavuAdams on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:09AM (#10965694)
Fear, greed, and stupidity.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chroma on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:37PM (#10963920)
I haven't seen the movie and I don't know what's depicted in it, but I'm pretty sure torture can be morally justified in some cases. Consider a real-life example of torture described in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.[1] At a gas station, a woman briefly leaves her car to pay for fuel. In the minute she's gone, a man hops in and drives away. Unbeknownst to the car thief, the woman's infant is sleeping in the back seat. The thief soon discovers this and ditches the car. Police quickly catch him at a nearby train station. He's carrying valuables from the car. There is video of him stealing the car. Despite his denials, there is no question this man is the car thief. It's over 100ºF out. The police need to find the car before the baby dies of heat stroke. A police officer describes the incident:

> In the police truck on the way to the police station: “Where did you leave the Hyundai?” Denial instead of dissimulation: “It wasn't me.” It was—property stolen from the car was found in his pockets. In the detectives' office: “It's been twenty minutes since you took the car—little tin box like that car—It will heat up like an oven under this sun. Another twenty minutes and the child's dead or brain damaged. Where did you dump the car?” Again: “It wasn't me.”

> Appeals to decency, to reason, to self-interest: “It's not too late; tell us where you left the car and you will only be charged with Take-and-Use. That's just a six month extension of your recognizance.” Threats: “If the child dies I will charge you with Manslaughter!” Sneering, defiant and belligerent; he made no secret of his contempt for the police. Part-way through his umpteenth, “It wasn't me”, a questioner clipped him across the ear as if he were a child, an insult calculated to bring the Islander to his feet to fight, there a body-punch elicited a roar of pain, but he fought back until he lapsed into semi-consciousness under a rain of blows. He quite enjoyed handing out a bit of biffo, but now, kneeling on hands and knees in his own urine, in pain he had never known, he finally realised the beating would go on until he told the police where he had abandoned the child and the car.

> The police officers' statements in the prosecution brief made no mention of the beating; the location of the stolen vehicle and the infant inside it was portrayed as having been volunteered by the defendant. The defendant's counsel availed himself of this falsehood in his plea in mitigation. When found, the stolen child was dehydrated, too weak to cry; there were ice packs and dehydration in the casualty ward but no long-time prognosis on brain damage.

I think the actions of the police are unimpeachable. Had they not tortured the thief, an innocent child would be dead. Now, does that mean I think torture should be legal? Of course not. Do I think the CIA has committed atrocities and violated human rights? Yes! But that doesn't mean torture doesn't work.

1. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/torture/#CasStuBea

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by CamperBob2 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @05:31PM (#10964360)
I haven't seen the movie and I don't know what's depicted in it, but I'm pretty sure torture can be morally justified in some cases.

It can be, as long as the perpetrator of the torture is willing to be held accountable for it. In the stereotypical '24' scenario, what happens if you torture somebody and don't find out where the bomb that's about to destroy the city is hidden?

In a just world, if you save the city, the governor or the President will likely pardon your crime, so it's all good. If you don't, you should go to prison for a very long time. But it never seems to work out that way, does it? It's all upside for the torturer, no downside. That's about as close to the definition of "evil" as you can get in my book.

We see it in action every time we read about police who step over the line (as in your anecdote) or a berserk prosecutor who seems bent on setting an example or furthering his own career rather than seeking justice. When it comes to violating peoples' rights in the name of Truth, Justice, and the American Way, there are almost never any consequences for failure.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by underbluewaters on Sunday January 24, 2016 @08:12PM (#10964980)
Cases like these are so extremely uncommon that trying to twist the law to accommodate them would do more harm than good. In fact, the harm from authority figures committing torture is so extreme that I'd say even in this case the officers should face some disciplinary consequences. The leniency and understanding of prosecutors, judges and jury should be enough of a safety net if their actions are truly justified.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by detaro on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:18PM (#10965372)
How does your evaluation change if

a) The kid would have been already dead?

b) They didn't get an answer?

c) They got the attribution wrong and tortured an innocent man?

All aside, I don't agree that hiding what they did could be morally right.

In Germany we had a case where during a kidnapping a very high-ranking police official threatened the suspect with torture, which actually got the location of the child (that had already been killed). He put a note what he did in the protocol and handed that to the DA.

He later was sentenced for it (very mildly), and the courts made clear that even this doesn't fly and cannot be excused. And of course we got a big public debate about it during the trial.

You misuse (legally speaking) your position of power to be morally right, at least face the consequences for it. Don't decide for yourself that you deserve to get away with it.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by asdfzxc on Monday January 25, 2016 @10:25AM (#10967637)
In cases like this, there is clearly a time limit, a very short time limit, where any information thus retrieved would be useful, and life saving. It is the officers' duty to use whatever means, within limits, to get the information out of the suspect. Also the evidence on scene is very strong, the suspect is in fact the perpetrator of said crime.

In case of terror suspects, quite a few have emerged innocent which is quite embarrassing in the first place, but understandable. Also, one should question the relevance of any information retrieved after long sustained periods of torture when surely facts on the ground have probably changed significantly.

Moreover this person, in the stanford thing, is a petty thief who is quite likely to fold under pressure since the crime has manageable consequences for him, and he doesn't possess training and motivation to withhold info at all costs. This trait wouldn't be present in case of some death cult, military, or even a serious gang member.

The point is, it isn't correct to make blanket statements like torture wouldn't work, ever. But the prevalence of incidences where some force might work shouldn't be used to justify comic levels torture demonstrated in the recent cases.

And finally, One might however see value in the dampening effect torture has on enemy morale. However, you can't play both sides, pretend to be a great champion of human rights and values and continue to come up with hilariously OTT torture routines. That is the problem US & Allies face regarding this whole torture debate/narrative. You have to own up to the uh assholery.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by ridgeguy on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:03PM (#10964463)
"I think the actions of the police are unimpeachable." No, they're not.

Their actions were effective but illegal. Effective in that they forced disclosure of the child's location. Illegal for excessive force, denial of due process, etc. Their illegal behavior weakened the rights all of us depend on.

More broadly, we'd probably convict more criminals if we ditched the legal presumption of innocence and other defendant protections. And of course, it can be heartbreaking and enraging when a palpably guilty defendant escapes justice because of prosecutorial error or other "technicality". Just as those cops were heartbroken and enraged at the arrestee's callous disregard of the child's life. I can imagine how they felt, and I don't know if in their place I'd have had the courage to follow the law.

My point is that the rights we've agreed any of us should have as a defendant in a state criminal action do lead to occasional awful circumstances like those cops faced. I think the more awful the circumstance, the more important it is to uphold those rights. They're fundamentally important, and they're not much use if we only enforce them when it's easy or convenient.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chroma on Sunday January 24, 2016 @06:45PM (#10964625)
> Their illegal behavior weakened the rights all of us depend on.

I disagree. It's good to be wary of this sort of thing, but Australia (where this happened) doesn't seem to have a police brutality problem. Had the police done the legal thing, an innocent child would have been cooked alive. So in this case, I'm glad they broke the law.

Laws and morals don't always agree. When they disagree, that is a failing of laws, not morals. Many things are illegal, but moral. For example, it may be necessary to steal or trespass to help save a life. Sometimes, despite your best efforts, those actions are for naught, and the person dies anyway. Does that make those actions wrong? No. And in those cases, you'd be hard-pressed to find a DA willing to prosecute. I'm OK with that.

Again, I think torture should be illegal. I think programs like the CIA's extraordinary rendition are abhorrent. I think Guantanamo Bay will be rightfully condemned by future generations. I'm certain the post-9/11 institutionalization of torture has caused far more harm than good. But I also think that torture can, in some cases, be morally justified. And I think my example demonstrates that.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by ridgeguy on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:58PM (#10964926)
I'd feel better about the Stanford example you cited if the cops' use of torture had been disclosed - that is, if they had been held accountable for using illegal methods.

The law recognizes extenuating circumstances such as those in the example, and provides reasonable outcomes - the DA/Grand Jury could have declined to charge, a jury could have declined to convict, a judge could have vacated a jury's conviction, and/or the governor could have pardoned them if they were sentenced. Under the circumstances, I think the cops would not have been punished. I'd endorse that outcome, given the facts.

But instead, the cops committed crimes and covered them up. That's bad for us, because it reduces transparency of state conduct. Basically, it's bad for our society if its police use illegal force without accountability.

If the right thing, the moral thing to do in a particular situation involves breaking a law, well ok, but we all (through the law) should know about it and we should all (through the law) hold accountable those who acted illegally. That doesn't mean they'll be punished - but IMO moral conduct must include accountability.

I think a better view of these types of situations is to affirm that torture is never legal, nor is it moral - but it might on rare occasion be an effective tactic to achieve a better outcome. But accountability has to be part of the picture.

I think if we had held that as our standard of conduct following 9/11, we would not have Guantanamo as a national shame today. The law can help when morality drifts due to fear and panic.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jMyles on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:46PM (#10965626)
...as so much media seems to do now.

Standing in contrast, if you are looking for that, is a wonderful two-part episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation called "The Chain of Command."