Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty'
by detaro on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:18PM
(#10965372)
How does your evaluation change if
a) The kid would have been already dead?
b) They didn't get an answer?
c) They got the attribution wrong and tortured an innocent man?
All aside, I don't agree that hiding what they did could be morally right.
In Germany we had a case where during a kidnapping a very high-ranking police official threatened the suspect with torture, which actually got the location of the child (that had already been killed). He put a note what he did in the protocol and handed that to the DA.
He later was sentenced for it (very mildly), and the courts made clear that even this doesn't fly and cannot be excused. And of course we got a big public debate about it during the trial.
You misuse (legally speaking) your position of power to be morally right, at least face the consequences for it. Don't decide for yourself that you deserve to get away with it.
a) The kid would have been already dead?
b) They didn't get an answer?
c) They got the attribution wrong and tortured an innocent man?
All aside, I don't agree that hiding what they did could be morally right.
In Germany we had a case where during a kidnapping a very high-ranking police official threatened the suspect with torture, which actually got the location of the child (that had already been killed). He put a note what he did in the protocol and handed that to the DA.
He later was sentenced for it (very mildly), and the courts made clear that even this doesn't fly and cannot be excused. And of course we got a big public debate about it during the trial.
You misuse (legally speaking) your position of power to be morally right, at least face the consequences for it. Don't decide for yourself that you deserve to get away with it.