News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:37PM (#10963923)
If you watch almost any superhero show, even the ones that are explicitly for children, you'll see that a huge amount of "investigation" into crimes is done by threatening to kill criminals and often by torturing them. Look at Batman.

The idea that torture works is bedrock in the entertainment world, partially because it's a narrative shortcut and shows how far the "hero" is willing to go.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by colordrops on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:07PM (#10964714)
Even worse is the message towards the end of Dark Knight, where Robin throws his badge in the water, claiming that the system and law enforcement don't work, and the only option is their secretive extra-legal vigilantism. Sounds like an excuse for all the extralegal methods various agencies have been using in the supposed fight against terrorism.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by acqq on Sunday January 24, 2016 @07:42PM (#10964864)
> sounds like an excuse for all the extralegal methods various agencies have been using

...and even for complete extremism, like pure terrorism.

Still, it's also true that the premise "the system and law enforcement don't work" is really the basis of all superhero narratives. That's how the need for the superheros is justified.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by rhizome on Sunday January 24, 2016 @09:40PM (#10965273)
Is your idea that people in the agencies are justifying things because they saw them in a movie once?
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:45PM (#10965442)
S/he was saying that the agencies and the fictional superheroes are using the same rationalization: that legal methods don't work, and a bunch of "good guys" need to use extralegal measures. And, to take that to its extreme, any method is acceptable as long as it's a "good guy" using it against a "bad guy".

Unfortunately, in real life, "good" and "bad" aren't possible to define, nor are they absolute characteristics.

GP was just drawing the parallel, not implying a real connection.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by OvidNaso on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:19AM (#10965723)
Check out the documentary 0.Casino Jack and the United Stats of Money read up on jack Abramoff. It certainly appears that he was living in a fantasy world created from pulp cold war fiction novels and he was not alone.

[0] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1540814/?ref_=nm_flmg_slf_6

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by chillingeffect on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:24PM (#10965554)
It's even more insidious than that. Some people in positions of power are compelled to imitate socially-acceptable behavior as defined by popular media to the point where it requires active resistance to oppose the act of torture. See for example "Normative Social Influence"[1] and "Moral Conviction and Resistance to Social Influence" [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normative_social_influence [2] https://www.uic.edu/labs/skitka/public_html/OppTorture.pdf

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by jessaustin on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:03AM (#10965676)
It's like I always say: the system has been exposed to good people before. It knows what to do with them.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by voltagex_ on Sunday January 24, 2016 @10:24PM (#10965388)
I remember reading http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2008/nov/24/torture..., I hope it's exaggerated.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by hartpuff on Monday January 25, 2016 @12:41AM (#10965787)
From that article:

>"People [in Guantanamo] had already seen the first series, it was hugely popular." Others who were at Guantánamo at the time confirmed her account. Some described to me how the series contributed directly to an environment encouraging those in the interrogation facility to see themselves as being on the front line, and to go further than they otherwise might have

So torturers at Guantanamo had to get lessons on torture from a TV series which, prior to Season 4, was basically torture-free and pro-Muslim?

From Season 4, 24 was fascistic, pro-torture garbage, but it was taking its cue from real life US policy, not directing it.

Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by cturner on Sunday January 24, 2016 @08:41PM (#10965086)
I don't think this was always true. Torture used to be taboo in entertainment. I think that changed after September 11 - you started to see it used extensively by supposed 'good guys'. I remember noting this when the show 24 was coming through - it broke that rule and polite society seemed to have been disarmed to it. And now it's everywhere and we're the poorer for it.
Re:How the CIA Helped Produce 'Zero Dark Thirty' by smt88 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @09:37PM (#10965266)
I guess I was talking about torture in a broader sense.

Yes, in 24 and Zero Dark Thirty it's realistic -- a state military or intelligence agency using torture in a prescribed way. They would actually have received training about effective techniques for torturing people, which is pretty chilling in and of itself.

But you can also watch the 90s Batman cartoon, where Batman holds criminals off of roofs to get them to talk, or the X-men cartoon where Wolverine puts his claws up to someone's chin. It's not strictly "torture", but using fear (of death) to make someone talk is similar to using pain. The person will do whatever is required to end it, whether that involves being truthful or not.

Even worse, you have scenes where James Bond (or some hero) is tortured and doesn't talk. It creates the idea that someone who talks when being tortured is a traitor or is somehow weak. In reality, it's really rare to be able to withstand torture, and the US Dept of Defense doesn't even consider soldiers to have failed their country if they talk.